Swiza D03
-
@Corwyn said:
1 - the tip of the canopener breaking
Honestly we meet the same problem on Victorinox knives if the tool is forced. So it's not a defect.
Thats kind of a cop out. Just because the competition has the same issue doesnt mean Swiza can pretend it isnt a poblem, and neither should you.
NO, we don't. Under the conditions the Swiza breaks, none of the Victorinox even showed wear.
Victorinox will take a lot more force to show similar damage.I tested it twice with two brand new Swizas. I tested it with a well worn Spartan / CT29 and a Pioneer.
The test was steel screws into an aluminium frame until the thread in the aluminium breaks. In order for this to happen you need moderate force.-
Victorinox 91/93mm line made it without even showing the slightest wear

-
Victorinox 58mm I could not exert enough force (it collapsed on me several times) YET despite my effort there was NO SIGN OF WEAR.
-
Both Swizas showed significant wear (chipping and bending)

HONESTLY, we DON'T have the same problem on Victorinox!!!
-
-
I was kind of assuming the "not for important work" was some sort of mistranslation, possibly meant to say "not for heavy duty work" but no, the French original is the same (at least according to my abysmal school French).
-
The can opener :
I could show you Victorinox can openers with broken tips... So visually the problem is the same... You can say "I need to moderate my force to not brake the can opener of a swiza knife", but without scientist test with a real force measurement this statement is irrelevant.
You have also to considerate that Victorinox and Swiza use differents stainless steel. It is possible that the Swiza steel is more breakable.
But... The steel of Swiza is also planned to go to the dishwasher... Each person can bring arguments...
I do not like the can opener of Victorinox nor the can opener of Swiza, but I prefer the former model used by Wenger, because IMO if this kind of can opener is effective to open a can of food the screwdriver will always have a weakness due of the conception.
New knife, new concept (more "urban use"), thus new context of use. In every cases, if you break it, the guarantee for life will offer you a solution (like Victorinox) !"When the Phillips driver is opened, the spring also opens the blade just enough that the blade point is exposed" :
Yes it's true ! Just a precision: it exists only on the models of Swiza "1 layer". On Wenger and Victorinox, it occurred on all models but the blade got up less so it was less dangerous and less visible.
I understand it is a problem for lot of persons, you should contact Swiza to indicate it.The screwdriver Philips N°1 :
I'm sorry but every body can say "I don't buy this idea" or "it's a cop out"... But... If you buy a city-car you don't buy an all-terrain vehicle and if you use your city-car like an all-terrain vehicle, you will have problems !In conclusion, My objective is not to convince people nor to make change their opinion, but to present a new brand of Swiss army knives. This approach cannot be completelly neutral, it's necessarily accompanied with enthusiasm, "to present" is also "to promote" with own sensibilities and affinities.
On a new knife with with a new production, each knows that little problems can exist.
Before shouting, it is advised to read the indications of use and to respect them.
Exists also an after-sales service and each can also contact the company to expose the problems he met (an email, photos, a text, etc.).
And each can also express his wishes to the company! -
@Fortytwo said:
I was kind of assuming the "not for important work" was some sort of mistranslation, possibly meant to say "not for heavy duty work" but no, the French original is the same (at least according to my abysmal school French).Yes, you are true... The exact translation is "not for heavy duty work".
Sorry, English is not my mother tong an translators are not still precise with nuances.
-
@jcfiguet said:
The can opener :
I could show you Victorinox can openers with broken tips... So visually the problem is the same... You can say "I need to moderate my force to not brake the can opener of a swiza knife", but without scientist test with a real force measurement this statement is irrelevant.
You have also to considerate that Victorinox and Swiza use differents stainless steel. It is possible that the Swiza steel is more breakable.
But... The steel of Swiza is also planned to go to the dishwasher... Each person can bring arguments...First, I'm a bonafide scientist (with all the credentials including title and publications in well placed journals) :D
It is not about "if it breaks" (everything can be broken) but "at what point it breaks". I did not turn the screw until the tool broke and judge the strength arbitrarily. The test limits the max power and answers a simple question. At this rather consistent force level, does the tool take damage or not.
So, how relevant is this test? Very much so!- Force limit is so low, now tool should break at that.
- Force limit is consistent between tools
- I used 2 Swizas, both brand new ( that is one knife more than most reviews ;))
@jcfiguet said:
You have also to considerate that Victorinox and Swiza use differents stainless steel. It is possible that the Swiza steel is more breakable.
But... The steel of Swiza is also planned to go to the dishwasher... Each person can bring arguments...Exactly and that is what the test shows, the steel is not up to the task.
My Vics have all (exception the cellulose scales and those with electronics) been in the dishwasher with no ill effect.@jcfiguet said:
I do not like the can opener of Victorinox nor the can opener of Swiza, but I prefer the former model used by Wenger, because IMO if this kind of can opener is effective to open a can of food the screwdriver will always have a weakness due of the conception.I prefer the small electrician screwdriver over the can-opener because what is the point of a can-opener on an urban-knife?
@jcfiguet said:
New knife, new concept (more "urban use"), thus new context of use. In every cases, if you break it, the guarantee for life will offer you a solution (like Victorinox) !What does "more urban use" mean if not tightening a screw on a computer?
-
Did you take acceleration/deceleration into consideration? Maybe you spun the swiza faster so the force to get the screw rotating, as well as the force when it stopped was larger

:) :)
Have you had your 2nd replacement yet?
-
@Etherealicer said:
I prefer the small electrician screwdriver over the can-opener because what is the point of a can-opener on an urban-knife?Ask a clochard about that ;)
@Etherealicer said:
What does "more urban use" mean if not tightening a screw on a computer?You mean Swiss chalets aren't yet equipped with (state of the art) informatics machinery? :o
-
If the screwdriver of the can opener breaks by screwing or by unscrewing a screw of computer, knives seem to have a real problem!
I made harder works (without trying to break the screwdriver) and I had no problem, the screwdriver was not even scratched !
I am not the only one to have made the similar tests with the same good results.I suggest you to ask simply for the replacement and to redo this test with new knives. It is possible that your series of knives was defective.
-
I confess, I had to use an online translator :D Nice reports, and some good information

Regarding the driver on the can opener, I agree that inconsistencies are very possible at this stage, and I hope to see more consistent reports later once we've moved beyond the initial batches of knives.
The Phillips #1 vs #2:
We have two conflicting opinions here. One is that Swiza have attempted to make the knife more robust, with larger pins and stainless liners. The other is that the driver was not designed for heavier use. However, the Victorinox drivers work well in #2 screws, providing you don't overdrive it or sprian the tool on a stuck screw. Also, Phillips #2 are very common, and the knife would be far more useful to a lot of people if the drivers could handle more types of screw, even if it couldn't handle high torque.Having briefly handled a Swiza, I can say that the ergonomics are better than I thought they would have been, and I can see why some would like it and others would not. I haven't done any "testing" as the tool wasn't mine, but I did spot a couple of areas for concern in terms of long term durability. It will be interesting to see how they evolve in terms of design, quality, consistency and value.
-
@50ft-trad said:
I confess, I had to use an online translator :D Nice reports, and some good information
Regarding the driver on the can opener, I agree that inconsistencies are very possible at this stage, and I hope to see more consistent reports later once we've moved beyond the initial batches of knives.
The Phillips #1 vs #2:
We have two conflicting opinions here. One is that Swiza have attempted to make the knife more robust, with larger pins and stainless liners. The other is that the driver was not designed for heavier use. However, the Victorinox drivers work well in #2 screws, providing you don't overdrive it or sprian the tool on a stuck screw. Also, Phillips #2 are very common, and the knife would be far more useful to a lot of people if the drivers could handle more types of screw, even if it couldn't handle high torque.Having briefly handled a Swiza, I can say that the ergonomics are better than I thought they would have been, and I can see why some would like it and others would not. I haven't done any "testing" as the tool wasn't mine, but I did spot a couple of areas for concern in terms of long term durability. It will be interesting to see how they evolve in terms of design, quality, consistency and value.
Good summary !
Conflicting opinions are "human" when a new brand arrives on the market.
The main references about Swiss knifes (for a majority of persons) are Victorinox and Wenger. So, some would like to find the same tools, same use, same philosophy, etc.
With 2 similar brands born in 1890's in Switzerland, it's easy to make comparaisons and to say, <u>for example</u>, I prefere the can opener of Victorinox or I prefere the magnifier of Wenger. But these comparaisons will not be really possible between a Mercator or a Laguiole and a Swiss knife.
With a new brand like Swiza this kind of comparisons are more difficult: Swiza is also a Swiss knife, but its design is recent. Some tools also exist on Victorinox, but operate differently on Swiza, other tools like Phillips N°1 appear, etc...
And we must not forget that Swiza started from a "white sheet" and nobody said that Swiza knives are made for same people, same activities, same use that Wenger or Victorinox knives are made for.
IMO, the Swiza knives are on another market place. The Victorinox market and Swiza market are complementary, not competitors. -
@50ft-trad said:
I confess, I had to use an online translator :D Nice reports, and some good information

Regarding the driver on the can opener, I agree that inconsistencies are very possible at this stage, and I hope to see more consistent reports later once we've moved beyond the initial batches of knives.
The Phillips #1 vs #2:
We have two conflicting opinions here. One is that Swiza have attempted to make the knife more robust, with larger pins and stainless liners. The other is that the driver was not designed for heavier use. However, the Victorinox drivers work well in #2 screws, providing you don't overdrive it or sprian the tool on a stuck screw. Also, Phillips #2 are very common, and the knife would be far more useful to a lot of people if the drivers could handle more types of screw, even if it couldn't handle high torque.Having briefly handled a Swiza, I can say that the ergonomics are better than I thought they would have been, and I can see why some would like it and others would not. I haven't done any "testing" as the tool wasn't mine, but I did spot a couple of areas for concern in terms of long term durability. It will be interesting to see how they evolve in terms of design, quality, consistency and value.
Good summary !
Conflicting opinions are "human" when a new brand arrives on the market.
The main references about Swiss knifes (for a majority of persons) are Victorinox and Wenger. So, some would like to find the same tools, same use, same philosophy, etc.
With 2 similar brands born in 1890's in Switzerland, it's easy to make comparaisons and to say, <u>for example</u>, I prefere the can opener of Victorinox or I prefere the magnifier of Wenger. But these comparaisons will not be really possible between a Mercator or a Laguiole and a Swiss knife.
**With a new brand like Swiza this kind of comparisons are more difficult: Swiza is also a Swiss knife, but its design is recent. Some tools also exist on Victorinox, but operate differently on Swiza, other tools like Phillips N°1 appear, etc...
And we must not forget that Swiza started from a "white sheet" and nobody said that Swiza knives are made for same people, same activities, same use that Wenger or Victorinox knives are made for. **
IMO, the Swiza knives are on another market place. The Victorinox market and Swiza market are complementary, not competitors.Then why kick off the initial ad campaign comparing themselves to the two well established Swiss brands?
"Delémont, October 21, 2015 – The legendary Swiss Knife has been given a redesign for the first time in decades."
*"The SWIZA Swiss Knife represents a revolutionary redesign of the legendary Swiss Knife"
"This new Swiss Knife is destined to become the new standard in Pocket Knives and a useful, versatile and must-have accessory for anyone that wants to be prepared for the challenges and adventures that everyday life offers."* That sorta parallels Vic's "Your Companion For Life" theme.... ::)
Swiza themselves invited the comparisons IMO.
-
You oldtimers, always remembering the past.......

-
:bdh:
Interesting how the people at SWIZA thought about putting a display and anti-theft attachement point for their knives but couldn't come up a better design for the awl... or a new design for a can opener...
Sounds like a conspiracy theory: "We'll discredit the SAK so much that eventually Victorinox will go bankrupt". :D
-
@SAK Guy said:
Then why kick off the initial ad campaign comparing themselves to the two well established Swiss brands?"Delémont, October 21, 2015 – The legendary Swiss Knife has been given a redesign for the first time in decades."
*"The SWIZA Swiss Knife represents a revolutionary redesign of the legendary Swiss Knife"
"This new Swiss Knife is destined to become the new standard in Pocket Knives and a useful, versatile and must-have accessory for anyone that wants to be prepared for the challenges and adventures that everyday life offers."* That sorta parallels Vic's "Your Companion For Life" theme.... ::)
Swiza themselves invited the comparisons IMO.
I'm not sure that Swiza themselves invited the comparisons... I think lot of "bla bla bla" of journalists in newspapers or at the TV made comparisons.
Also members/collectors on forums (me too ! LOL) because naturally we used comparisons between Victorinox and Wenger, so why not between Swiza and Victorinox...
But Swiza, never really committed to the comparison, either on its website or on FaceBook.After 3 months of Swiza life, a visit to the factory, the contact with employees Swiza, etc. My opinion has also changed in some areas and the idea of competing against Victorinox I imagined is now much less than I thought.
**<u>However you raise an interesting point : </u>**On the website of Swiza, you can change the language... In French, the text "This new Swiss Knife is destined to become..." does not really exists ! The French text is softer...
So I think that communication is suitable for the supposed cultural backgrounds...
I think it's not a good idea, I'd prefer a standard text, only translated correctly, this would avoid problems of understanding. -
So I thought that the obtained (and authorized) documents could interest some people on this forum.
Please feel free to share the information here at MTo and not via links to a site that you administrate.

Sorry but this post is very long and I have not enough time to translale it.
-
Used the can opener.
It worked very well. There seems to be some minor damage on the edge, barely visible rolling/chipping at 2 places (1/10th of a mm), but this may have been there from before.The bamboo shoots were really awful - never buy them.


Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
