No new Leathermans in 2016?
-
@Mercury said:
The biggest problem with the Multitool market is the consumers need to have a NEW design every year. If people would accept the limitations of the design and be happier with compromise(which is what a multitool essentially is), then we might have a smaller line of better tools from each manufacturer.This.
Victorinox has been making the Swisstool (with minor tweaks) since 1998. The Spirit since 2004. Most people love these tools, and Victorinox seems to be a relatively conservative company, so they just keep the ship on course. Contrast that with Gerber, they put out so many different things that mostly aren't that good; what people really like is the old MP600 (at least they're still making them).
I like the Victorinox approach more, which focuses on incremental improvements. And frankly, it's better for me as a consumer to have a limit to my choices. In a world of instant access to reviews on any brand and product, it's easy to get paralyzed by the huge amount of options out there. It was hard to pick out a new coffee maker because there were so many options, and of course I was concerned about getting the "best" one.
The drive to churn out new stuff is the same almost everywhere. The lumen race is getting silly (manufacturers want you to pay $75 to get another 100 lumens from the 2016 edition of whatever flashlight, which you probably won't even be able to see). Kershaw is putting out a zillion new knives this year that are mostly nothing new. The improvements are unnecessary at best, random variety with unproven track records at worst.
Unfortunately, the gear community is more about what you buy than about the adventures you have or problems you solve with it. I've been eaten away by the consumerism for a while; it's easy to get caught in that and hard to break out of it. It's tempting to think that next purchase will fix some minor limitation in what you currently have. But it's a lie, because like you said, you're never going to get rid of that compromise on some level, there's no perfection to be had.
And actually, that's one of the reasons I like MTO is because people here seem more sensible than average. Helps keep me more sensible too.
Thus endeth the rant. :-)
You hit the nail on the head. I'm still very new to the game, but usually when I want to buy something new it is out of need. Not just to have the next tacticool gadget. I wish companies spent more time perfecting their bread and butter line rather than chasing the newest trend. Gerber is still a top contender imo, if you ONLY consider their main tool line (mp600, 400, diesel, etc) I recently acquired an octane and I like it more than the 400. It's a shame they discontinued it. But they have a hundred other products they could've cut. If Gerber spent more time perfecting what they do best instead of watering down their name with BG tools, who knows. SOG is moving in the right direction. I want to get their new tools in hand before I make any judgments, but they seem like they are starting to figure it out....where was i going with all this
Anyways I agree with you. The market is saturated. I see it and I just joined the party 
-
@metasyntax said:
And actually, that's one of the reasons I like MTO is because people here seem more sensible than average.
ha! Us, sensible. Good one. 
-
I feel like improving on what you do make before releasing something new is necessary in most if now all walks of life. How does a company expect their new designs from other makers built the same as existing products to generate that many more sales and get much more admiration? I feel like let's say Kershaw should have expanded or improved on things like the Cryo, perhaps a KVT bearing Kershaw-Hinderer or the like verses adding more SKUs. Quite honestly I could care less about the 100th stainless scaled speed safe design without any improvements over the other. In short I'm not opposed to Leatherman's decisions this year, I'm satisfied with what they have the last thing I want from them is to discontinue good products for the sake of producing new products.
-
And actually, that's one of the reasons I like MTO is because people here seem more sensible than average.
ha! Us, sensible. Good one. 
The operative phrase here is "more sensible than average." Doesn't mean y'all ain't crazy, just less crazy than half of them out there.

-
@metasyntax said:
And actually, that's one of the reasons I like MTO is because people here seem more sensible than average. Helps keep me more sensible too.you were doing well up to this. Anyone who asks what to get, or whether even to get something, is told "DO IT . . . get TWO !"


-
@Mercury said:
The biggest problem with the Multitool market is the consumers need to have a NEW design every year. If people would accept the limitations of the design and be happier with compromise(which is what a multitool essentially is), then we might have a smaller line of better tools from each manufacturer.This.
Victorinox has been making the Swisstool (with minor tweaks) since 1998. The Spirit since 2004. Most people love these tools, and Victorinox seems to be a relatively conservative company, so they just keep the ship on course. Contrast that with Gerber, they put out so many different things that mostly aren't that good; what people really like is the old MP600 (at least they're still making them).
I like the Victorinox approach more, which focuses on incremental improvements. And frankly, it's better for me as a consumer to have a limit to my choices. In a world of instant access to reviews on any brand and product, it's easy to get paralyzed by the huge amount of options out there. It was hard to pick out a new coffee maker because there were so many options, and of course I was concerned about getting the "best" one.
The drive to churn out new stuff is the same almost everywhere. The lumen race is getting silly (manufacturers want you to pay $75 to get another 100 lumens from the 2016 edition of whatever flashlight, which you probably won't even be able to see). Kershaw is putting out a zillion new knives this year that are mostly nothing new. The improvements are unnecessary at best, random variety with unproven track records at worst.
Unfortunately, the gear community is more about what you buy than about the adventures you have or problems you solve with it. I've been eaten away by the consumerism for a while; it's easy to get caught in that and hard to break out of it. It's tempting to think that next purchase will fix some minor limitation in what you currently have. But it's a lie, because like you said, you're never going to get rid of that compromise on some level, there's no perfection to be had.
And actually, that's one of the reasons I like MTO is because people here seem more sensible than average. Helps keep me more sensible too.
Thus endeth the rant. :-)
Victorinox is a prime example of what works. They largely keep their bread and butter items for a LONG period of time, and make relatively few core adjustments. Leatherman would do well to follow the example of the classic red SAK. Make a range of implements that form a system, and design tools that follow a format. A Spartan and a Swisschamp are vastly different in their capabilities and appeal, yet a view from the side shows them to be nearly identical.
The swisstool line is another perfect example, and mirrors Leatherman's early years. For over ten years they made fewer than 5 products. And it worked.
-
Rebar IS PST 3. Like people, MTs get fatter too when they grow up. :)
-
Agree that no need to bring set of new tools every year. What would be good though to bring some sets or sheats. So could do small upgrades to existing tools example in form of carry set. As example bit adapter for st is for normal hex, would like slim sheath that would store bit adapter and some bits. And croc set is for wave, could have ST / surge upgrade set for croc type of tool plus sheath which would carry both tools. Though one way to go is to learn to do sheaths..
-
I think the Kick or Fuse was PST 3. Rebar is more like, mini super tool.
-
I totally understand what has been said.
Personally, I don't see much difference between SAK and LM strategies. Both brands have kept some of their lines quite similar over the years and have created many totally different models too.
I don't really see a problem with a brand launching disrupting products. Different people has totally different needs, and the manufacturers give us all the versatility it the variety we claim as costumers. Both companies play the game of leaving pendant each time some details so we keep waiting for, searching and buying new products. Most of their products are good & interesting enough as to review and acquire them but perhaps no one of them is totally satisfying.I agree in the fact that these companies have left some unsolved issues, like better sheaths, and others, and they have proposed solutions as well. IMHO both brands have done a pretty good job keeping our attention and willingness to buy and, what's more important, use their products, which means that they have launched quite a few good things.
Just like Metasyntax so remarkably pointed out, our gear communities are focusing more on products we buy than in what we do with them.
Of course. Instead of just talking about things we buy or only superficially describing them, our attention, wants and decision as customers will regulate market more efficiently and provide more vision for these large companies to re-define their strategies in an even better way, if we share and speak more about the jobs we do, problems we solve using their products, as well as the challenges we were not able overcome with them.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I'll just leave this here http://toolguyd.com/leatherman-knifeless-rebar-skeletool-rx-rescue-tool-2016-multi-tools/
-
They're variations really. The Skeletool RX failed, no O2 wrench...
-
@Wanimator said:
They're variations really. The Skeletool RX failed, no O2 wrench...I think pliers probably make a pretty decent O2 wrench in a pinch...
-
They're variations really. The Skeletool RX failed, no O2 wrench...
I think pliers probably make a pretty decent O2 wrench in a pinch...
That's unacceptable for somebody who probably carries it on them daily and uses it for that every now and then. Especially when there's those dang holes everywhere in the handle, you can't tell me they couldn't have found a way to put an O2 wrench in there.
-
@Wanimator said:
They're variations really. The Skeletool RX failed, no O2 wrench...Why would you need an O2 wrench when you have pliers? I would imagine they could accomplish the task in a pinch.
-
They're variations really. The Skeletool RX failed, no O2 wrench...
Why would you need an O2 wrench when you have pliers? I would imagine they could accomplish the task in a pinch.
I asked a friend that is an EMT, he said pliers tend to scar the valve whereas a dedicated O2 wrench is smooth and designed for turning that valve so it doesn't scar it.
-
They're variations really. The Skeletool RX failed, no O2 wrench...
Why would you need an O2 wrench when you have pliers? I would imagine they could accomplish the task in a pinch.
I asked a friend that is an EMT, he said pliers tend to scar the valve whereas a dedicated O2 wrench is smooth and designed for turning that valve so it doesn't scar it.
Insider info!

Makes sense if you're going to make it a regular thing. In a pinch, I'd not hesitate to use the pliers though.
-
They're variations really. The Skeletool RX failed, no O2 wrench...
Why would you need an O2 wrench when you have pliers? I would imagine they could accomplish the task in a pinch.
I asked a friend that is an EMT, he said pliers tend to scar the valve whereas a dedicated O2 wrench is smooth and designed for turning that valve so it doesn't scar it.
Beat me too it.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
