Tactical folder definition?
-
NT
-
Pretty much good marketing to the average buyer IMO. To the "tactical" person I'm sure any knife he/she deemed fit for tactical operations is then classified as a "tactical folder".
On a side note, have you seen the Filipino Escrima "tactical sticks"? Now joking aside I'm of the mind set that the role of the "tool/weapon" makes it tactical rather than the "design". I'm sure a tactical operator is skilled enough to use most things tactically.
-
If I pick up a rock in anger, it's a tactical rock :P
-
Tactical = Any black knife that you can carry at the mall

-
Here is what I believe:
Tactical folder is a marketing term, which suggesting such knife is designed for tactical personal (police, soldier) to use as
a) A Weapon
b) An utility tool
c) BothA weaponized knife is a knife designed to be a weapon first, a tool second, if at all.
It must incorporated features such as pointy, strong tip for stabbing, large blade for good reach, fast deployment (OHO, Wave, Auto etc), strong lock up and construction, good gird and traction. And sometime with features like double edge, hawkbill blade. You may argue the effectiveness of such weapon but that in not in the scope of this discussion.Some examples:
An Emerson folder is a weaponized tactical folder, with a some utility value.
A Victorinox Solider is an utility tactical folder, can not be use as a weapon.
A spike bayonet is a tactical weapon, with no utility value at all. (exception: Mosin Nagant's spike bayonet exactly has a screw driver tip for soldiers to work on the rifle.)
A SAK carry by a soldier is not a tactical folder because it was not designed and marketed as such, even though it is being use in tactical role. -
I think we will have to pull a scrodinger on this one.
A knife in a box can be both tactical, and not tactical at the same time.
Only when the box is opened and the knife is carried, can it be determined if it is tactical or not :D -
@Kampfer said:
Here is what I believe:
Tactical folder is a marketing term, which suggesting such knife is designed for tactical personal (police, soldier) to use as
a) A Weapon
b) An utility tool
c) BothA weaponized knife is a knife designed to be a weapon first, a tool second, if at all.
It must incorporated features such as pointy, strong tip for stabbing, large blade for good reach, fast deployment (OHO, Wave, Auto etc), strong lock up and construction, good gird and traction. And sometime with features like double edge, hawkbill blade. You may argue the effectiveness of such weapon but that in not in the scope of this discussion.Some examples:
An Emerson folder is a weaponized tactical folder, with a some utility value.
A Victorinox Solider is an utility tactical folder, can not be use as a weapon.
A spike bayonet is a tactical weapon, with no utility value at all. (exception: Mosin Nagant's spike bayonet exactly has a screw driver tip for soldiers to work on the rifle.)
A SAK carry by a soldier is not a tactical folder because it was not designed and marketed as such, even though it is being use in tactical role.This is a pretty precise definition that can work.
-
Tactics relate to fighting not utility. A knife designed to give a tactical advantage in a fight. First it must be capable of being used as a weapon; then Perhaps concealed, quickly deployed, kept ready for quick access. But only on a fight context; a SAK may be a military knife but it's not tactical. You don't use tactics to open your can of beans while waiting for battle.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@shark_za said:
Tactics relate to fighting not utility. A knife designed to give a tactical advantage in a fight. First it must be capable of being used as a weapon; then Perhaps concealed, quickly deployed, kept ready for quick access. But only on a fight context; a SAK may be a military knife but it's not tactical. You don't use tactics to open your can of beans while waiting for battle.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Maybe not for eating beans, what about cutting rope to free hostages, or cutting down branches for field camouflage?
Many tactical items are not exactly weapons, like tactical light, tactical gloves, tactical boots. They are designed and marketed to tactical personal or Mall
.
Battering ram is a tactical tool, not a weapon ; so a tactical knife doesn't has to be a fighting knife. -
A battering ram is used in an assault, it provides a tactical advantage in the scenario. So not a weapon but used in the fighting context.
Same with boots, lights and gloves that enable certain options not previously available.Think change, reaction, surprise, diversion, brute force, stealth. These are tactics as opposed to operations and logistics.
-
I think it is fairly simple
If it has any of the following then it's tactical
- fake-tanto blade with straight edges
- blade is painted black
- larger than necessary for its intended purpose
- impractical or weird blade shape
- sacrifices utility for a more aggressive look
- poor design in general like no cross-guard on a stabbing knife
- if it shows up on pinterest under EDC knife
-
This pretty sums up what I see in every advertising... :D

I think the word 'tactical' is definitely one of the most overused term for outdoor/rugged utility gear, and probably 'bushcraft' has became another big advertising term overused.

When something is 'tactical', I would genuinely assume its main purposes is to be used as a weapon(or part of), and it has more 'fighting' value than its 'utility' value. It maybe a little oxymoron that a folding knife can be 'tactical', I would think a fixed blade with pointy double edge is what I consider to be a fighting knife.

-
It is black or some kind of subdued color, and it really super dangerous with that sharp edge. And it scares a whining children of all ages.
-
Just a thought - would it not be easier to define what a tactical folder is not? >:D
If "stag handles"=True, "tactical folder"=False


-
The top left look tacticool... :D
-
@Grathr said:
But what if it is a black tanto with stag handles??
You almost had me, but I asked Google, and I think my point stands!

https://www.google.com.na/search?q=tanto%2Bblade%2Bstag%2Bhandles&espv=2&biw=1366&bih=667&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj39KKH6IPLAhUBvBoKHUL3DMcQsAQIGQ#imgrc=0q2tfg_45OmVwM%3A.....at least as far as stag is concerned

-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
But what if it is a black tanto with stag handles??

You almost had me, but I asked Google, and I think my point stands!

https://www.google.com.na/search?q=tanto%2Bblade%2Bstag%2Bhandles&espv=2&biw=1366&bih=667&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj39KKH6IPLAhUBvBoKHUL3DMcQsAQIGQ#imgrc=0q2tfg_45OmVwM%3A.....at least as far as stag is concerned

This one looks tactical to me... :p

And this one:
http://www.knifecenter.com/item/BO121917DAM/boker-trench-knife-5-5-8-inch-damascus
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login