Are AMEFA (KL marked) Dutch Army 93mm Knives comparable to Vic soldiers?
-
Knife in Question is a nice KL 75 marked knife, it is, as most of you know, quite similar to the Vic Soldier and Wenger SI, except it has a Bail and a claw style can opener.
I like it pretty much, as 1975 is my birth year. BUT I do want to carry it and I liek the Vic style can opener much better.
Are the knifes of comparable value, i.e. do I stand a chance to find someone who would trade me a `75 stamped Vic or Wenger for my AMEFA?
-
You are a snobby bunch of picture addicts.... ;)
Not even a single "I don´t know".Let´s see if someone bothers to answer if I show some Alox.
I did not have a Soldier of similar vintage at hand (in fact - I am still looking for one, see initial post ;)) , so a modern Pioneer had to do for comparison.
Nice, beefy tools like on early Soldiers. Sharpened , very thick cap lifter, half stop, no wire bender. The Can opener is impressive in size.
Enormous snap on all tools, thick brass liner - and a nice bail!You can see the knife is a fair bit thicker than a contemporary Pioneer.
So? What do you think about it? Anybody wants to trade his `75 Soldier/SI?

-
Ohhhh! Pictures!
I've got a couple of those pattern AMEFAs,but,TBH,I wouldn't swap a 75 Soldier for one.
By the way,I think 75 was a Wenger year
-
I don't know.
-
@kirk13 said:
Ohhhh! Pictures!I've got a couple of those pattern AMEFAs,but,TBH,I wouldn't swap a 75 Soldier for one.
By the way,I think 75 was a Wenger year
Have there been years that were exclusive to one maker? I am not that well informed on the older ALOX stuff, but I did like the idea of a birth year SAK.
Maybe someone knows if the AMEFA springs are compatible to VIC ones and I dare commision a nice EDC-knife mod? -
I've been looking at AMEFA knives for the last two or three months, since I can't seem to find a '77 Soldier :'(.
And I couldn't find a '77 AMEFA either, one seller had a '74, '75, '76, ... , '78, '79 ... :ahhh.
Anyway, I do get the feeling they are not up to par with the Victorinox/Wenger Soldiers, but that's only based on the pics I've seen, I haven't seen one in real life, so my opinion is not really valid ::).
Maybe you can compare them once you have used the AMEFA for a couple of weeks
.:)
-
The Can opener is unable to handle Phillips screws, but I´ll try to carry I for a while.
-
I know 72 was Wenger,and they were a small run(typical,because that's my birth year
)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login





