Tactical folder definition?
-
So, is this HK Ally a tactical knife?
What do you think?

-
Though my initial impression is HK may want to advertise or want people regard this as a 'tactical' knife, but thinking about how the big thumb hole weaken the blade, I would probably think this is most suited for utility.
-
apart from the black colour, it also helps if it is made of "Supersteel", or at least "Surgical Steel", made from a special "Alloy", especially the handle and, hardened to over HRC60.

-
Thanks for the opinions!
The knife is actually very usefull as a utility knife. :) -
What about the Spyderco Tenacious Black?


-
HK Ally: IMO not tactical. It's shiny and silver. Also the due to the holes it lacks a certain ruggedness.
Spyderco Tenacious Black: TACTICAL! The all black look makes it tactical despite it's ergonomics and functional design. -
@Etherealicer said:
HK Ally: IMO not tactical. It's shiny and silver. Also the due to the holes it lacks a certain ruggedness.
Spyderco Tenacious Black: TACTICAL! The all black look makes it tactical despite it's ergonomics and functional design.+1!!!!! Elicits flight response in fearful types!!!!
However in green/satin: builds community, fosters goodwill, ends world hunger and the chicks dig it..... ;)
(which kinda sux because I'm all about eliciting flight responses in the fearful....)adjusted pic..
-
I've been thinking a bit more on the definition. Tactical as used to describe a knife IMO still remains a marketing term. That being said, in response to your HK and Blacked out Tenacious, I'd say to the average man/woman on the street the black looks Tactical vs the HK.
Here's where I'm at tho, if joe/jane public sees a guy with all the other gears with any knife they'd assume Tactical as I'm sure many would. Example would be a guy with head to toe in camo gear or even to an extent a T-Shirt with certain logos/depictions etc emblazoned. Yeah I know this sounds really judgmental but lets contrast.
A guy in yuppy clothes hopping out a mini van full of toddlers whipping out the blacked out Tenacious.
Tactical looking may be interpreted as part of the whole appearance of the individual not just the knife alone.
-
@Aloha007 said:
I've been thinking a bit more on the definition. Tactical as used to describe a knife IMO still remains a marketing term. That being said, in response to your HK and Blacked out Tenacious, I'd say to the average man/woman on the street the black looks Tactical vs the HK.Here's where I'm at tho, if joe/jane public sees a guy with all the other gears with any knife they'd assume Tactical as I'm sure many would. Example would be a guy with head to toe in camo gear or even to an extent a T-Shirt with certain logos/depictions etc emblazoned. Yeah I know this sounds really judgmental but lets contrast.
A guy in yuppy clothes hopping out a mini van full of toddlers whipping out the blacked out Tenacious.
Tactical looking may be interpreted as part of the whole appearance of the individual not just the knife alone.
i agree - i think it is about perception more then anything else.
-
How about this one?
It's black. Exceptionally traumatizing, if it goes thru a body(even more than a blade), and even disguise itself as a bottle opener...

:D -
I've been thinking a bit more on the definition. Tactical as used to describe a knife IMO still remains a marketing term. That being said, in response to your HK and Blacked out Tenacious, I'd say to the average man/woman on the street the black looks Tactical vs the HK.
Here's where I'm at tho, if joe/jane public sees a guy with all the other gears with any knife they'd assume Tactical as I'm sure many would. Example would be a guy with head to toe in camo gear or even to an extent a T-Shirt with certain logos/depictions etc emblazoned. Yeah I know this sounds really judgmental but lets contrast.
A guy in yuppy clothes hopping out a mini van full of toddlers whipping out the blacked out Tenacious.
Tactical looking may be interpreted as part of the whole appearance of the individual not just the knife alone.
i agree - i think it is about perception more then anything else.
I think you are on to something here

-
How about this one?
It's black. Exceptionally traumatizing, if it goes thru a body(even more than a blade), and even disguise itself as a bottle opener...

:DEvery mall ninja and couch commando needs one :D
I think under the "right" circumstances YES. Imagine a guy who "appears" a certain way whipping that out. I think the "mall ninja" description is a response from the real so called tactical people ( I very well may be wrong in this ). They saw/see and read about civilians carrying high powered guns and beefy blades dressed to the 9's in tactical gears and think
.I imagine as a result the average joe/jane also began to notice this all well. Being an average civilian these beefy blades being whipped out in the most flagrant of ways. Average joe/jane get either annoyed or scared and so when a non "mall ninja" type whips out a knife that same average joe/jane doesn't make a distinction.
This is all my loosely mangled thoughts on the idea of Tactical but hopefully I've conveyed my thoughts.
I live in a military town and I can imagine the real life tactical -
@pfrsantos said:
http://bearingarms.com/10-things-that-make-a-tactical-knife/Might help... or just add to the confusion.

IMHO, OHO, locking blade, ergonomic grip, easy to carry/conceal/deploy, task-specific, strong.
So any good modern folder is by default tactical?
Kind of an all-encompassing standard, isn't it?
Surely workers and outdoorsmen want cutting-edge features in their tools as well.
Sent from my Z750C using Tapatalk
-
@NG VI said:
http://bearingarms.com/10-things-that-make-a-tactical-knife/
Might help... or just add to the confusion.

IMHO, OHO, locking blade, ergonomic grip, easy to carry/conceal/deploy, task-specific, strong.
So any good modern folder is by default tactical?
Kind of an all-encompassing standard, isn't it?
Surely workers and outdoorsmen want cutting-edge features in their tools as well.
Sent from my Z750C using Tapatalk
Weel, we seem to have more and more tactical workers and tactical
outdoorsmenoutdoorspersons every day...
-
@NG VI said:
http://bearingarms.com/10-things-that-make-a-tactical-knife/
Might help... or just add to the confusion.

IMHO, OHO, locking blade, ergonomic grip, easy to carry/conceal/deploy, task-specific, strong.
So any good modern folder is by default tactical?
Kind of an all-encompassing standard, isn't it?
Surely workers and outdoorsmen want cutting-edge features in their tools as well.
Sent from my Z750C using Tapatalk
Weel, we seem to have more and more tactical workers and tactical
outdoorsmenoutdoorspersons every day...
What's 'tactical' about one-handed opening and closing?
Isn't 'versatile' or 'safe' a more appropriate term for it?
To me it isn't a 'tactical' knife until performance as a cutting tool takes the backseat in favor of features that someone without a toolbox, just a vest, might want.
The DPx HEST for instance, I think of as a tactical knife because of clear design choices that make it well suited as a soldier's knife.
The ESEE 3/4, a very similar knife in construction, is not 'tactical' to me because the design focus is clearly not combat use like wedging things open, manipulating machinery, or bashing things into place, it's just a generalist fixed blade knife designed to be a comfortable and capable tool.
Do you think a knife like the Sage 3 is 'tactical'?
Based on those criteria it is, though anyone with a working noodle can see that it's not at all designed or sold as a weapon or harsh-environment oriented general tool. It's a nice, civil knife, designed to excel at civil knife things.
Sent from my Z750C using Tapatalk
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login