Mod compact or huntsman?
-
-
Plus the opener layer is miles better than the combo tool... the two screwdrivers and the prybar function make all the difference.
-
I know, you want to save up on wight. But have you looked into the 111mm line?
The blade is big enough for serious food preparation and maybe even big enough that you can leave the fixed blade home. I knolw for me a 111 of some sort replaced a fixed blade and 91mm on my scouting trips. The saw is actually useful for making fire wood and setting up camp.
There are versions with scissors, but maybe a 3 layer (Forester or Rucksack) combined with a classic for the scissors might be a good combo, too?Might even save some weight over the 91 + fixed blade?! Just a thought.
-
Based on the difference between a compact and a climber, the weight saving from not having the full openers layer is 18g or 0.6oz. To me, not a big saving, but I know every ounce matters to some backpacking folks.
There must be some worthwhile benefit to replacing the openers layer with the combo tool, or there wouldn't be so many Yeomen in the mod squad forum ;)
-
Get a Farmer and an Alox Classic.

-
Thanks for all the suggestions.
The 111mm suggestion is very good. But I can't find a SAK with only the three main tools I want.
I already have a Hercules. Which is the tool I take when traveling or luxurious camping. Littlebit of camping functionality and a littlebit of technical capability (screwdrivers and pliers)When wildcamping and weight is less of an issue (motorcycle) I carry a large fixed blade and woodsaw for camping, and my LM charge tti for technical capability.
Now I'm trying to get a setup for hiking. (Where technical capability is not important). That's why I want the foodknife, small woodsaw and scissors. In as small and lightweight package as possible.
I realize the weight reduction with modding the Huntsman are negligible, but I'm kind of doing this for fun :)
The fieldmaster suggestion is awesome! I don't need the corkscrew nor the hook. A Philips is better. This is probably the way I'd go if I decide not to mod.
Can you guys suggest me two SAKs I should purchase and mod to get the functionality I want, but nothing more?
(Backtools: I only want an awl, nothing else)Ideally I'd like to be able to put the remaining parts together to get a second SAK... Just for fun :)
Eg a fieldmaster and a bantam. And end up with my dreamknife and a bantam with small blade and can&bottle opener layer. But I'm not sure about the back tools in this example...
Regards
-
3rd option:
Purchase Lumberjack. Purchase X SAK and take its scissor+awl layer, and add this entire layer to the Lumberjack. -
@Rebelgium said:
3rd option:
Purchase Lumberjack. Purchase X SAK and take its scissor+awl layer, and add this entire layer to the Lumberjack.If you want an awl, the alox in-line awl is far superior to the back side version. I echo Hiraethus in recommending a Farmer and a Classic. The Farmer is a fantastic SAK and the Classic is.... well....Classic!
-
3rd option:
Purchase Lumberjack. Purchase X SAK and take its scissor+awl layer, and add this entire layer to the Lumberjack.If you want an awl, the alox in-line awl is far superior to the back side version. I echo Hiraethus in recommending a Farmer and a Classic. The Farmer is a fantastic SAK and the Classic is.... well....Classic!
Or wait until the Farmer X comes out ;)
-
An alox model would meet your needs well, though it doesnt factory exist.
- awl / blade
- saw
- scissors
I made something similar, but with combo tool where the awl would go.

-
3rd option:
Purchase Lumberjack. Purchase X SAK and take its scissor+awl layer, and add this entire layer to the Lumberjack.If you want an awl, the alox in-line awl is far superior to the back side version. I echo Hiraethus in recommending a Farmer and a Classic. The Farmer is a fantastic SAK and the Classic is.... well....Classic!
The alox farmer looks amazing! But I really want (big) scissors.
Also the inline reamer being superior to the back reamer sounds good. But it takes the space the combo tool would sit, and using that combo tool is how I could get rid of an entire layer. -
@Syph007 said:
An alox model would meet your needs well, though it doesnt factory exist.- awl / blade
- saw
- scissors
I made something similar, but with combo tool where the awl would go.

What a beauty <3
So option 4:
Get a Farmer and a Compact. Take the opener layer out of the farmer. Replace with scissors from Compact. Also replace awl with combo tool.This way I get the (small) disadvantage of not having an awl, but the advantage of having alox.
I suppose there's no way a back-awl could be added?
-
Since there is now a model of the Pioneer with added scissors (Pioneer X), there is also the chance the Farmer will have a model with scissors added as well, probably within a few months.
I also agree on the Fieldmaster, it has everything I need. I also suggest the Victorinox Evo S18, which is the old Wenger Handyman with Victorinox's superior awl and can opener replacing the somewhat inferior Wenger tools, and also different handles. The S18 is a bit smaller, a bit lighter, and has rubber grip panels. Also, being bright yellow, it should be a bit easier to find if lost.
-
If you want bigger scissors than on the classic and are still with me on the 111 track...:
http://www.sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Outrider
I might even have one flating around that I could weigh.And you might want to look into 85mm Wengers, there are 4 layer knives that meet your criteria, but are smaller and lighter than the 91mm Vic models with the same tools.
Without wanting to shamelessly promote my sale thread, here are a few pics of Wengers:
/topic/64798
But, if you want to ake and carry a mod, do so! There are tutorials and helpful members all around.
-
The 111m outrider (and ditch my 4" fixed blade) is probably the more sensible solution for the weight-conscious hiker who still wants decent wood processing capabilities.
However I'm still in love with my fixed blade and not willing to give it up... Yet.
Plus the Farmer X sounds just about perfect, and looks the part.
I guess I'll wait for it to be released... I can't decide if this is very good timing or very bad timing :p
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
