Mod material resources
-
Hello. Long time lurker and admirer, first time caller.
I have built one previous SAK, which was a Huntsman that I turned into a micarta scaled "Bushcrafter" by removing the opener tools, relocating the awl under the blades and peened the pins flush into countersinks in the micarta. I made the micarta right on the outer liner plates and molded the Vic emblem right into it. It all worked pretty well except the countersunk pins were hard to get really tight.
So now I have taken an interest in the Cadet and 84mm and 85mm source knives. Questions and thougts:
-
Has anyone shown exactly what the difference in hole placement between 84 and 85 is? In some cases, moving a hole a little bit wouldn't affect function. It would be cool to use an 85mm lockblade with alox scales. If not, I'll just have to do micarta again.
-
One thing that occurred to me is that if using a Wenger saw with Alox Cadet scales, that you could substitute a Small Tinker opener backspring and awl for the usual Recruit. This wouldn't normally work because you only have 3 pins, but if you are using a lopped off bottle opener on one end, the fact that you have omitted the 4th pin isn't going to matter because the backspring is trapped between the immobile opener and the awl and saw. Agree or disagree?
-
For pins, I've seen 1/8" standoffs with torx screws and peened solid pins. What I haven't seen is using brass 0-80 standoffs and turning them down to 2.25mm instead of drilling everything out. The other possibility is using 3/32 brass tubestock, and flaring the ends with a point and ball to make a tube rivet. Anyone tried either? I also heard of a guy using tubestock and tapping it for screws.
One thing that really puzzles me is doing much of anything with the 93mm knives, short of just removing a layer. They appear to have such different hole locations that there are no 91mm backsprings that really adapt to use with 93mm scales to bring scissors, saws or other tools to them. Are custom backsprings the only option?
-
-
No idea on numbers 1 & 3.
As for #2... I suspect that you will run into issues with the awl retention, as well as losing "snap" on the remaining opener. Victorinox included that fourth pin for a reason, and I dont think it was aesthetics
As for your last point, custom backsprings are pretty close to necessary for Alox modding. Modified Solo backsprings will work for scissors, and saw spring will work for the metal file. Other combinations of Opener, blade, Solo and saw layers work for other tools to a limited extent, but that information is beyond my knowledge.
-
The 4th pin doesnt add tension - it usually is in an open slot. It is there to retain the spring so it can't creep away from the back tool when the can opener is folded shut. If the can opener is used as a spacer it's shoulder retains the spring.
-
huh. I always thought it helped tension the backtool, as well as prevent spring shift.Whelp, if you are right then it should work just fine with the opener cut off like that.
I know its a long shot, but is it possible to sqeeze a 93mm awl in place of the nail file, and then swap the nail file with one of the openers?
-
@sLaughterMed said:
huh. I always thought it helped tension the backtool, as well as prevent spring shift.Whelp, if you are right then it should work just fine with the opener cut off like that.I know its a long shot, but is it possible to sqeeze a 93mm awl in place of the nail file, and then swap the nail file with one of the openers?
Putting the nail file in place of the opener is probably possible with an washer or spacer. It seems like most of the tools have a similar enough base shape.
The 93 awl may be too long and thick for the backspring, and it has a 3mm pivot hole. It could certainly be ground to shape and the pivot filled in and re-bored - but it is not going to come out pretty considering the thinner 84mm scales. Plus, some 93mm knife is going to lack the coolest and most unique tool of the 93mm line.
-
huh. I always thought it helped tension the backtool, as well as prevent spring shift.Whelp, if you are right then it should work just fine with the opener cut off like that.
I know its a long shot, but is it possible to sqeeze a 93mm awl in place of the nail file, and then swap the nail file with one of the openers?
Putting the nail file in place of the opener is probably possible with an washer or spacer. It seems like most of the tools have a similar enough base shape.
The 93 awl may be too long and thick for the backspring, and it has a 3mm pivot hole. It could certainly be ground to shape and the pivot filled in and re-bored - but it is not going to come out pretty considering the thinner 84mm scales. Plus, some 93mm knife is going to lack the coolest and most unique tool of the 93mm line.
I intentionally ignored the fact that the nail file would need a spacer, as I couldnt seem to phrase it in a way that made sense.
As for the 93mm awl on the 84mm frame, it does fit, it just needs some pivot grinding. 50ft-trad put one on his Mega 84 mod here: /topic/61654
If you use the older (2.3mm tang) blade, you need a .5mm spacer to make room for the awl. The newer (2mm tang) blade requires a .8mm spacer.
Stock the awl sits too high, leaving the tip exposed. I believe he ground off a bit of the bottom inside corner of the awl pivot, forcing the tip to sit in the knife. the "butt" of the awl sticks up a little, but it dosent affect the function or pocketability.
I dont see the hole being too big as much of an issue. I doubt it will affect function, or form.
-
There is almost no force applied to the 4th pin, its sole purpose is to prevent springs that have no way to hold themselves in from moving end to end. Example if I make a 91mm mod with out a blade and opener layer, the 4th pin isnt even needed as its only those 2 springs that even need it there. All other spring have the center or end pin passing through the spring. You can assemble a blade layer without that pin, adn it will work fine for a few cycles, then the spring walks itself out one end eventually.
Mixing and matching parts between 84/85 would be a nightmare unless you just want to take tools from wengers and put on vics, but use vic backsprings. The layers themselves arent compatible and the few times Ive worked with the wengers have been a nightmare that I would never ever bother with again. I still will transplant tools onto Vics, but building the wengers is a total pain.
-
This is the thread where I came up with some of this stuff:
/topic/41486
He uses Wenger tools in a 84 Vic format - using Recruit backsprings and cut up tools as end backspring extensions. That got me thinking about how the extensions could also take the function of the 4th pin.What's the problem with all Wenger mods? I wouldn't use their plastic scales, so I thought the construction isn't much different than alox with a 4th pin.
-
@Syph007 said:
There is almost no force applied to the 4th pin, its sole purpose is to prevent springs that have no way to hold themselves in from moving end to end. Example if I make a 91mm mod with out a blade and opener layer, the 4th pin isnt even needed as its only those 2 springs that even need it there. All other spring have the center or end pin passing through the spring. You can assemble a blade layer without that pin, adn it will work fine for a few cycles, then the spring walks itself out one end eventually.Mixing and matching parts between 84/85 would be a nightmare unless you just want to take tools from wengers and put on vics, but use vic backsprings. The layers themselves arent compatible and the few times Ive worked with the wengers have been a nightmare that I would never ever bother with again. I still will transplant tools onto Vics, but building the wengers is a total pain.
Is there anything extra nightmarish working with the Wengers or is it just while trying to get things to work together with Victorinox parts? Otherwise I would have though that the 85mm would open up some great opportunities for you compared to the 84mm. Considering that you're making liners and scales yourself it should be easy to build them closer to the "standard" SAK look instead of the Evo-style (that I know some people dislike). I'm considering something like that for my own "perfect" SAK.
My findings (what little I've been able to achieve so far) is that while (at least for Metric use) it should be easier to source the pin-stock since it's all 2.5 mm. On the other hand, one side of the bushings are part of the pin (but that's not really a problem for you since you're screwing them together anyway!).
-
The wengers (by this Im referring to the current delemont line and the last generation of wengers) dont use standard bushing sizes like the vics do, and one side of the pin head is formed into a bushing shape to fit the scale, so only one side has a bushing.
Its a total pain to salvage that bushing and since the bushing is part of the pin on the other side its lost and cant be reused unless you are making a thinner SAK. The last one I worked on I got so annoyed I just made some round DIY bushings the right size to fit in the scale (but no lip on them) and glued them into the scales. That was the last modern wenger / delemont I will work on.
Oh and the last treat and slap in the face was the bushings werent even the same size each side of the SAK, on the same pin. That might have been a curiosity just on the rangergrip size though, I dont remember that on the 85s.
Here is the point in my modding thread when I made the discovery.
/post/1042751
-
So, if using custom scales and fresh pinstock or standoffs, is there any real problem modding Wengers?
For making bushings, have you tried brass tubestock? I'm seeing a lot of useful items on McMaster-Carr.
-
@RX-79G said:
So, if using custom scales and fresh pinstock or standoffs, is there any real problem modding Wengers?For making bushings, have you tried brass tubestock? I'm seeing a lot of useful items on McMaster-Carr.
Ah yes if you are doing custom scales then you dont need bushings anyhow so that problem is solved.
I'll admit Im not a fan of any of the wenger parts, and if I was I might have tried to find more solutions. But for me its easier just to skip working on them. The delemonts are particulary odd. They made the keyring piece out of aluminum.
-
So, if using custom scales and fresh pinstock or standoffs, is there any real problem modding Wengers?
For making bushings, have you tried brass tubestock? I'm seeing a lot of useful items on McMaster-Carr.
Ah yes if you are doing custom scales then you dont need bushings anyhow so that problem is solved.
I'll admit Im not a fan of any of the wenger parts, and if I was I might have tried to find more solutions. But for me its easier just to skip working on them. The delemonts are particulary odd. They made the keyring piece out of aluminum.
I guess I just like the smaller size with a full complement of tool choices. I also like the blade lock and springless scissors.
-
So, if using custom scales and fresh pinstock or standoffs, is there any real problem modding Wengers?
For making bushings, have you tried brass tubestock? I'm seeing a lot of useful items on McMaster-Carr.
Ah yes if you are doing custom scales then you dont need bushings anyhow so that problem is solved.
I'll admit Im not a fan of any of the wenger parts, and if I was I might have tried to find more solutions. But for me its easier just to skip working on them. The delemonts are particulary odd. They made the keyring piece out of aluminum.
I guess I just like the smaller size with a full complement of tool choices. I also like the blade lock and springless scissors.
I never heard of wengers growing up and they only existed for a few years after I found them as an adult. I bought up a few models to tinker with and see whats what, but they just werent for me.
If you need a lockblade, then yep I see the appeal there and its a good option on a small knife. I really dislike the scissors on wengers though. I will take replacing the scissors return spring every decade or so over the bobbing up and down action of wengers any day. The champion I bought in 84 the scissors spring broke in 94. :D
I do like their pliers design though. Im not trying to discourage you from modding them, I just wanted to point out what I discovered and why I wont work on them again. If I preferred them to Vic I would probably go through effort to make the bushing and custom scales / liners etc etc. But seeing as how maybe 2% of the mod requests Ive had in the last 5 years have been wenger, its an easy case for me to just say no thanks for work on those from now on. I much prefer the original wengers to the delemonts too, and those are now dead and gone.
-
I appreciate your comments.
I'm a bottom feeder, using cheaply purchased TSA and similar knives off ebay. All the old LLBean SAKs were Wenger, which is how I first noticed them.
Thanks.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login