Victorinox Factory 93mm ALOX w/ scissors!!!!! [UPDATE]
-
I have the new one and one made by syph.
Syphs Spring is firmer, and to beats alox for me. -
@user24 said:
Got mine today. Can't quite work out a nice way of opening the scissors that's not cack-handed ???Super strong snap which is nice.
It's super heavy too; 10g heavier than the farmer.
How does the spring compare to your design Syph?
The spring shapes at the scissors pivot end is the same as mine, there really is only one way to do it. at the other end where the scissors rest is fully enclosed though where mine was open since I modeled it off a solo spring and that is how they were designed.
Im not a fan of the nail nick and Im not sure I understand the reasoning they provided. If they only did it to have workers not mix them up at the factory that seems wrong to me to compromise the way users are accustomed to opening the tool, when they could have distinguished them another way. My theory is they wanted them easily distinguished as vic factory ones vs modded ones.
-
Got mine today. Can't quite work out a nice way of opening the scissors that's not cack-handed ???
Super strong snap which is nice.
It's super heavy too; 10g heavier than the farmer.
How does the spring compare to your design Syph?
The spring shapes at the scissors pivot end is the same as mine, there really is only one way to do it. at the other end where the scissors rest is fully enclosed though where mine was open since I modeled it off a solo spring and that is how they were designed.
Im not a fan of the nail nick and Im not sure I understand the reasoning they provided. If they only did it to have workers not mix them up at the factory that seems wrong to me to compromise the way users are accustomed to opening the tool, when they could have distinguished them another way. My theory is they wanted them easily distinguished as vic factory ones vs modded ones.
But WHY does the nick have to go across the grind? That's just bad sight on the part of whoever signed it off.
Might as well get a Pioneer X and have Syph install PROPER scissors...

On an (even) more serious note, is the nick harder to reach on the side it is now?
-
Got mine today. Can't quite work out a nice way of opening the scissors that's not cack-handed ???
Super strong snap which is nice.
It's super heavy too; 10g heavier than the farmer.
How does the spring compare to your design Syph?
The spring shapes at the scissors pivot end is the same as mine, there really is only one way to do it. at the other end where the scissors rest is fully enclosed though where mine was open since I modeled it off a solo spring and that is how they were designed.
Im not a fan of the nail nick and Im not sure I understand the reasoning they provided. If they only did it to have workers not mix them up at the factory that seems wrong to me to compromise the way users are accustomed to opening the tool, when they could have distinguished them another way. My theory is they wanted them easily distinguished as vic factory ones vs modded ones.
But WHY does the nick have to go across the grind? That's just bad sight on the part of whoever signed it off.
Might as well get a Pioneer X and have Syph install PROPER scissors...

On an (even) more serious note, is the nick harder to reach on the side it is now?
Yes I just looked at that, there is a wee bit less space on the side they did it.
Like I said before though Im happy to have a set of scissors with the nail nick on this side so I can put scissors on my OHO trekker... My theory was they were intending a factory version of that mod too.... so maybe. Its seems very weird to me to retool to make this new set of scissors just to have the nick moved with the normal standard 91mm scissors they already make would be fine.
-
I preordered 2 via cutlery shoppe but they said it had been delayed a bit to the USA (for later delivery to me in Asia). I do have a TI Syph Urban P model that I was lucky enough to win. However, I have babied it and not carried it much. Now that a stock model is out, I may have to carry Syphs more normal like.
I wonder if the X is in Asia yet?
-
The X just got today to Romania... in no hurry to get one though... they should pop up soon from TSA >:D
-
@Syph007 said:
Yes I just looked at that, there is a wee bit less space on the side they did it.Like I said before though Im happy to have a set of scissors with the nail nick on this side so I can put scissors on my OHO trekker... My theory was they were intending a factory version of that mod too.... so maybe. Its seems very weird to me to retool to make this new set of scissors just to have the nick moved with the normal standard 91mm scissors they already make would be fine.
I finally got a Pioneer X and I really don't like the moved nail nick. As a right-handed person, I find that whether I open the scissors with my thumbnail or index fingernail, I have to be careful to avoid catching the opposite digit with the points of the scissors. That's never a problem with the normal 91mm sissors.
-
Yes I just looked at that, there is a wee bit less space on the side they did it.
Like I said before though Im happy to have a set of scissors with the nail nick on this side so I can put scissors on my OHO trekker... My theory was they were intending a factory version of that mod too.... so maybe. Its seems very weird to me to retool to make this new set of scissors just to have the nick moved with the normal standard 91mm scissors they already make would be fine.
I finally got a Pioneer X and I really don't like the moved nail nick. As a right-handed person, I find that whether I open the scissors with my thumbnail or index fingernail, I have to be careful to avoid catching the opposite digit with the points of the scissors. That's never a problem with the normal 91mm sissors.
Yep its annoying. I am so used to opening scissors the other way I dont like this style. I know Im not the target market though so its fine. I will just be using these for OHO trekker mods as its a dream for that purpose.
-
Yes I just looked at that, there is a wee bit less space on the side they did it.
Like I said before though Im happy to have a set of scissors with the nail nick on this side so I can put scissors on my OHO trekker... My theory was they were intending a factory version of that mod too.... so maybe. Its seems very weird to me to retool to make this new set of scissors just to have the nick moved with the normal standard 91mm scissors they already make would be fine.
I finally got a Pioneer X and I really don't like the moved nail nick. As a right-handed person, I find that whether I open the scissors with my thumbnail or index fingernail, I have to be careful to avoid catching the opposite digit with the points of the scissors. That's never a problem with the normal 91mm sissors.
Yep its annoying. I am so used to opening scissors the other way I dont like this style. I know Im not the target market though so its fine. I will just be using these for OHO trekker mods as its a dream for that purpose.
It just feels wrong I know what I prefer ... and it came from Canada :)
-
I'm used to carrying a compact or climber and find myself trying 2-3 times before I realise there is no nick on that side.
But a good solid piece of kit, -
COMING TO THE U.S. If you're in the U.S. and haven't got yours yet (or want more) I will have them available in May. You can pre-order now:http://www.edcsource.com/listing/victorinox-pioneer-x-swiss-army-knife-new-issue/119675
-
My first thoughts were that the nail nick would not be an issue, but after using it I think it's one of Vic's biggest design mistakes in a while. Putting it on the wrong side is not only counter-intuitive for regular SAK users, but it puts the nick very close to the can opener and partially hidden by it. If they would have left it on the traditional side, the width of the lower jaw spaces it away from the main blade nicely, making it more accessible (which is obviously right on the customs). So if manufacturing scissors with the nick on the wrong side was what delayed the introduction of this otherwise fine tool, then I would say it's a big OOPS! for Vic.



-
I agree that I like the nail nick on the back of the 91mm scissors better. There is more space to access it, and it would have created a consistent user experience across the 91mm and 93mm knives.
But, it is not a deal breaker IMO. I've been using my Pioneer X for the last 3 weeks. I like it, and I am used to it now. It's great to have scissors on the alox frame. If Victorinox move these new scissors to the 111mm linerlocks, I will forgive their
completely. -
Perhaps the nailnick is uncomfortable but is the price you have to pay as an alternative to a custom Pioneer X

-
You can always open the can opener to access easier to the scissors

-
I keep my nails very short and I have no problem opening the X scissors, and the standard size, precise, and durable Vic scissors I regard as the best ever made. But I still think it was a rather unfortunate error on Vic's part.

-
Ya the nail nick bugs me, but its awsome to have a factory made spring for scissors.
This is my path to use the new parts for now and I will do it a few times to end up with some 'backups'
Buy...
- Pioneer X
- 111mm OHO Trekker
- 111mm outrider
Do...
- Take scissors / phillips layer from outrider
- Reassemble to now have a new 111mm rucksak to sell or use
- Replace pioneer x scissors with scissors from outrider, put on my black scales and brass liners.
- Add Scissors backspring and phillips from outrider, and scissors from pioneer x to OHO trekker. The layer will go between saw layer and blade layer.
This gives me...
- A nice pioneer x with nail nick on proper side and factory made backspring.
- A OHO with scissors! The only spot to add a scissors layer on a OHO is in this spot and the normal scissors have the nail nick on the wrong side, so the pioneer x scissors are perfect!
Be happy. :D :D :D
-
A bright side for sure Syph, looking forward to a liner lock with scissors, I've been thinking that would be great for a while! Also, comparing the springs, your custom ones look better to me, esp. since I know the QC guy was there that day. ;)
-
I built an electrician with scissors today and I made an interesting observation. The electrician blade is bent much more towards the center than the can opener and it also sticks up higher. With the nail nick on the wrong side on the pioneer x, I dont think we will see an electrician x as it would be very difficult to open.
*note this is my wifes hand not mine.. lol
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
