Which should I choose?
-
I have been looking at a few things, and with a budget of about $20-$40 (plus an $5 Amazon gift card I have) I figured I'd get one of them when these online college courses I've been taking end in early May. So which should I choose?
These are the items I've been looking at:
Spyderco Ladybug Salt serrated hawkbill. (I have been looking for a small knife with a lot of cutting power, as a number of my knives are too small for the work I do on the farm, or too heavy to carry in some pants. Currently, a Case Medium Stockman does the job fine, but I prefer serrated blades for the tough stuff, and hawkbills can pack more cutting power than a straight edge)

Klein Tools (Kutmaster/Utica made) Sheepsfoot Slitting Knife Hawkbill in carbon steel--about $25, but has been marked down to $20 recently (I have one that my grandfather found in the '70s working in the mines and brought home, and had been run over by a piece of equipment, as the blade is bent and won't close all the way, for sentimental reasons, it rarely leaves the house, so I want one I can use heavily, and secondly, it's a bigger and tougher knife than the Spyderco)

Wenger Serrated Highlander--about $23 (I'd like a serrated blade knife with a few tools, and this probably has a longer blade than the Spyderco, but since Wenger's long gone, I'm unsure whether to keep it sealed in box as a collection piece or open and use it)

Wenger Matterhorn--about $35 (I like that it adds a clasp and an in-line driver to the Highlander, but the whistle is a fat layer and wouldn't be as good as putting an Acme 636 on the lanyard ring, so this would likely never be used)

Boker Mini Bar (unlike the smaller one, German made)--about $42. (I've been wanting a tough one-piece pry tool, as the SAK bottle opener and Leatherman drivers aren't made for prying, I also like the pocket clip on this one)

Estwing Tomahawk--about $40 (Don't even know why I want it other than it looking cool, as it isn't made for chopping wood, just defense and forcible entry)

Estwing Sportsman's Axe with rubber handle--about the same price as the tomahawk (This would make much more sense than the tomahawk, in my opinion, as it's made for what I'd actually use it for, plus I don't have the problem of the leather drying out or rotting as on the better looking leather handled one)
Vaughan Carpenter's Half Hatchet--about $20 (Smaller and cheaper than the Estwing, but also US made and also has a dedicated hammer head and the nail pulling notch, features I want--problem is, handle and head are separate unlike on the Estwing, and it doesn't include a sheath like the Estwing does, that I'll have to pay more than $10 extra to get one)

-
Not a real answer as to WHICH of those items you should get more how I decide.
I first figure out am I wanting to try something, need something, want something, or have I been putting something off for whatever reason.
Once Ive narrowed down the answer to the above I flip a coin
.Kidding. Good luck.
-
You mean which of these should you get FIRST, right? ;) I have one of the Klein hawkbills, and the thing is a beast.

-
I'd pick up the Highlander while they are still available at a fair price.
-
Ladybug or Estwing.
Ps: the estwing can chop decently. -
How about a Gerber EAB with some serrated blades? That would be a pretty cheap option.
-
So... longer answer.
The Ladybug is awesome, even if a bit small. It will be a laser.
The thin Wenger is not rare. Feel free to use it.
The fat Wenger is a gimmick, unless you're collecting Wengers skip it.
I was carrying 2 opts with me snd I slwsys used to pry with the sak (i tore apart a cantilever i-beam rack with a sak caplifter. Don't see the appeal.
Estwings are awesome. The axe will be an great chopper, the hawk will be an ok chopper but has the cool factor.Usefulness estwing axe, cool estwing hawk, edc knife dragonfly. First runner up: the thin Wenger.
-
Went with the Spyderco Ladybug. A small folder with full-size knife cutting ability was something I didn't have and needed. I went ahead and bought an Amazon gift card early at the local grocery store this afternoon to get it.
I already have several old axes (one is no newer than 1930s, most are '50s-70s), and those old axes are likely of better steel than what's produced today and I don't have any sharpening stones made for axes, so I'll use the remainder of that Amazon gift card I bought today to get the Spyderco with that $5 card to get a Lansky Puck to properly sharpen them, plus I might find a used Estwing much cheaper at the flea market after college is out. The old Klein hawkbill is still usable though worn out (and cheap used ones should be easy to find at flea markets and such, since Pittston Coal gave all employees these knives, and they were a big employer at one time here). I really don't see why I should over $40 on that Boker tool, it just doesn't seem worth it for one piece of 440 steel.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login