HD MT
-
This one isn't really that heavily built but it shows one idea as to how it could be made (picture in bottom, the format of my post didn't really work out with a mix of uploaded and linked pictures). Fixed blade knife (probably the single most useful tool on a multitool) and then a few other implements. Yes, the blade might be a bit awkward while using the other tools (OSHA would probably not approve) but it's hard to find a tougher blade solution.
To speculate in how it could be done, how about starting with a fixed blade and then adding a bit driver like some of the Wenger/Vic Ranger models have (plus a bit holder in one scale) and a set of pliers, again either the way the Rangers handles them or possibly similar to the SOG toolclip.

(first picture from the SAK-Wiki and the second picture from Chako's excellent SOG series)

-
If you are looking for a large knife on a multi-tool...then take a look at a Buck X-Tract. It does have a liner lock however.
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
Hi AllAre there any heavily overbuilt multitools out there? I'm thinking something like a Skeletool (low tool count and OHO) with a monster blade and something stronger that a liner/frame lock.
Do you think there would be a market?
The Alone thread and Justin's choice of a multitool over a knife (and my opinion on the matter) raised the question for me.
Do you mean something like the MUT? That is a big, heavy duty version of the Skeletool. It still has a liner lock, but it's quite sturdy.
If that's not big enough for you, there's always the Paladin (SOG) PT525 or the SOG Blacktip, both of which dwarf the MUT. The Gerber Freehand also comes to mind.
Def
-
opinel 10 corkscrew (it has 2 different tools :D)
-
Wenger Mike Horn Ranger
LM Mut -
Refering to Alone again, I thought about Justin maybe having to pry something from a rock.......
There are several folding knives (and brands) that can take serious abuse, build that into a MT and give it a few tools.I had a thought - What would it look like if Medford built a multitool.....?
I know the MUT and googled the other suggestions, but as far as I know none of these have a very substantial blade, nothing I couldn't easily envision snapping or bending during hard use
Fortytwo - your fixed blade suggestion is nearest to the spirit of what I had in mind.......
-
Oh... that is what you are looking for... well you know Mother Russia, right? :D
-
Kilimanjaro Magnus.
Seriously though, if I have already have an axe, then I am good with a small knife. -
Ok, here are some more suggestions:
From Fox cutlery FX-211, not really an MT but it has a saftey cutter / pry-bar / Phillips / flat screwdriver / glass-breaker. Well, I guess that would make it an MT.

Maybe don't look at bigger but at better :P
Victorinox Spirit has a kick ass pry-bar. I have abused several Victorinox they can take it (also search for Jothras challenge threads) -
@Etherealicer said:
Oh... that is what you are looking for... well you know Mother Russia, right? :DThat's what I'm talking about!
Not exactly what I envisaged because I had pliers in mind,but robust enough!
Replied before I checked that thread.......and thanks, never seen it before!

-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
Oh... that is what you are looking for... well you know Mother Russia, right? :D
That's what I'm talking about!
Not exactly what I envisaged because I had pliers in mind, but robust enough!
First one got pliers


Second one got a wire-cutter that should count as half of pliers 8)
-
Fixed that......replied based on the 2 pics and before looking at the thread.
Awesome tools & designs.

@zoidberg said:
Kilimanjaro Magnus.
Seriously though, if I have already have an axe, then I am good with a small knife.As we've established I'm not a proficient axe user, but I would agree with you if that small knife is a Mora or such-like.
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
Oh... that is what you are looking for... well you know Mother Russia, right? :D
That's what I'm talking about!
Not exactly what I envisaged because I had pliers in mind, but robust enough!
First one got pliers


Second one got a wire-cutter that should count as half of pliers 8)
@Gerhard Gerber said:
Oh... that is what you are looking for... well you know Mother Russia, right? :D
That's what I'm talking about!
Not exactly what I envisaged because I had pliers in mind, but robust enough!
First one got pliers


Second one got a wire-cutter that should count as half of pliers 8)
I would love one of those Noks Professional's... too bad they are seriously difficult to find, and expensive to boot
-
There's "HD Multi" and "HD"
Even a beefy Folder won't have the strength of an (equivalently beefy) fixed blade, and off hand, I can't think of a Multi that comes close.
Obviously some of those mentioned - MUT, or designs that are primarily Folding Knife, with extra features jammed in the handle (ie Ranger) are as close as you'll get.
Also remember knives are meant to be used in a specific direction.
I can use SAK to cut through a car tyre, however I can put that same SAK into a soft apple, change my force 90 deg (ie across the narrow cross section) and hey-presto-snapo.
In the above instance I'm imagining it snapping above the tang, but it could as easily go through the rivet, or where the hole is drilled for the rivet.
So sure, you can get a HD Multi, but don't expect to use it as a prybar.
-
Everytime I have halfway forgotten abut NOKS Tools, someone brings them up.

Either stop it or reveal a source! :ahhhI do liketeh looks of those.
-
The Emerson/Multitasker EDC tools might fit your description. Mostly an Emerson folder with a couple extra tools on board.
-
For me, it's a 111mm Vic and/or Buck 110 and dedicated pliers. The Super Tool 300 might be heavy duty, but even its pliers are too weak for my uses--they've flexed, but never broke, because I know when to stop.
-
@clown said:
The Emerson/Multitasker EDC tools might fit your description. Mostly an Emerson folder with a couple extra tools on board.I was just coming in here to mention Multitasker. I don't know from experience. But I do know that they create the pliers on their tools differently than those found on SOGs, Leathermans, and most Gerber (MP1 has a different method as well) so that they are much more robust. Also, the knife on those Multitaskers are highly regarded, and in general looked at as the same level quality-wise as a high end folder
-
@cody6268 said:
For me, it's a 111mm Vic and/or Buck 110 and dedicated pliers. The Super Tool 300 might be heavy duty, but even its pliers are too weak for my uses--they've flexed, but never broke, because I know when to stop.Even comparing the best suggestions I agree.
We camped out this weekend, nothing wild about it, but my big knife made some kindling, the Mora Bushcraft did nothing but strike a ferro rod, CS Finn Wolf opened some food packaging and trimmed a pesky finger nail.....
My buddy's Wave was never opened, came out of the sheath few times to open beers using the top edge of the handle.....guess his finger nails were okay

:DTo each his own I guess, but I would take a fixed blade if I went Alone

-
I haven't seen mine yet, but I am reliably informed that the Kilamanjaro Magnus is "MASSIVE".
http://www.gearinstitute.com/hiking/multitools/item/kilimanjaro-gear-magnus-910056
/post/1124488
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

