Which folding saw?
-
If you're clumsy take the Bahco. Japanese saws tend to run harder so they are more prone to breaking if you for what ever reason twist 'em. Bahco has a higher chance of bending so you can pound it out with a hammer and keep using it (heard people have done that)
I actually remember seeing Dave Canterbury twisting his Bahco to remove a chip from a notch he was making which is debatable use, but illustrates my point
-
The silky saw I have cuts awesome but as its all I've used I have nothing to compare it to.
-
@Syph007 said:
The silky saw I have cuts awesome but as its all I've used I have nothing to compare it to.- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
Katanaboy :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
-
The silky saw I have cuts awesome but as its all I've used I have nothing to compare it to.
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
Katanaboy :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
Dammit I do want that. If only it also had scissors....
-
@firiki said:
I've tried (not extensively) on amazon UK, Italy, Germany... none would ship to Greece. Now I've forgotten the login info
I got mine on ebay from a German seller - you couldn't get much further away from Germany than New Zealand. With shipping included it was still cheaper than the Bahco folding saws at the hardware stores here.
-
Why a folding saw? I've honestly been reading threads such as this one for years and All this time I have wondered why anyone would choose a folding saw over a fixed blade saw. I mean you can get a fixed blade saw that fits in its own scabbard which can be lashed to a pack or hung from your belt, so it will be just as safe and easy to carry as a folder, but a fixed blade saw is going to cut better and have fewer parts. So, I ask again, why a folding saw?
-
Ease of carrying, fits in the glove compartment of a car, cuts well. The Laplander has a following for good reason.
-
@Alan K. said:
Why a folding saw? I've honestly been reading threads such as this one for years and All this time I have wondered why anyone would choose a folding saw over a fixed blade saw. I mean you can get a fixed blade saw that fits in its own scabbard which can be lashed to a pack or hung from your belt, so it will be just as safe and easy to carry as a folder, but a fixed blade saw is going to cut better and have fewer parts. So, I ask again, why a folding saw?It often boils down to convenience. Easier to carry than than most fixed saws, lighter than most bucksaws and bowsaws and can generally process the same wood as a smaller buck or bow saw which tends to be larger than one would go after with a SAK or an MT.
I think a good bit of those saws started to gain momentum with the popularization of bushcraft, especially the Ray Mears approach. Folding buck and bow saws can get fiddly to assemble or have parts that can be lost, carrying just a bow saw blade means you'll have to spend time making the frame which isn't always ideal for a short stay (how 20ish minutes is too much for a tool you might use for days is beyond me though).
In the end hose are pruning saws that have become an interesting alternative in the outdoors community -
@SteveC said:
How about Friskars, I used to have one that was pretty good.
This one actually seems quite good, at a tempting price, too. Locks both open and closed, cuts on both push and pull stroke, handle seems comfortable. Not sure what they'd charge for shipping tho'.
Fiskars.gr only lists this one, called Xtract, and it's smaller brother. I don't like the locking mechanism nor the handle!

-
How about Friskars, I used to have one that was pretty good.

This one actually seems quite good, at a tempting price, too. Locks both open and closed, cuts on both push and pull stroke, handle seems comfortable. Not sure what they'd charge for shipping tho'.
Fiskars.gr only lists this one, called Xtract, and it's smaller brother. I don't like the locking mechanism nor the handle!

I tried both of them at the shop, they were easily available until recently, the Laplander feels a lot better in the hand and looks more solid.
-
The Bahco is nice indeed, but if you live in Europe shipping usually kills the deal.
I've found the Fiskars sliding saw and Silky Gomboy to perform as nicely or even better, at a cheaper price, at least here outside of the US.just my two cents
And then there's shipping fees, you're right.
I've noticed you work around plants and gardens a lot so I take your word for the Fiskars and the Silky. Thanks for bringing them up

That's why I linked you to that one on ebay, it's 26 quid shipped, 24,50 for the tools, 1,50 for shipping to Greece. I should stop checking this thread, I'll seriously buy another one. :ahhh
I caved
It should be here in a few days.If I like it, I'll probably want to get a spare one, too. This tends to happen with things I like

-
Mission accomplished. :D
Looking forward to hearing your thoughts once you get it.

-
The silky saw I have cuts awesome but as its all I've used I have nothing to compare it to.
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
Katanaboy :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
Dammit I do want that. If only it also had scissors....
WANT
But what would you do with scissors that big?! And what size teeth do you use?@Obi: Tease

-
@styx said:
If you're clumsy take the Bahco. Japanese saws tend to run harder so they are more prone to breaking if you for what ever reason twist 'em. Bahco has a higher chance of bending so you can pound it out with a hammer and keep using it (heard people have done that)I actually remember seeing Dave Canterbury twisting his Bahco to remove a chip from a notch he was making which is debatable use, but illustrates my point
You raise a good point there. My sawing technique needs refinement, I can tell you that. In a outdoors setting I'll probably be doing things a little roughly so I think a springy steel might be a better choice than something harder and more brittle. No idea as to the Laplander's metal composition though.
Suddenly, I'm terribly tempted to check out the Silky boy and compare it to the Tajima and the Laplander...

-
I've tried (not extensively) on amazon UK, Italy, Germany... none would ship to Greece. Now I've forgotten the login info

I got mine on ebay from a German seller - you couldn't get much further away from Germany than New Zealand. With shipping included it was still cheaper than the Bahco folding saws at the hardware stores here.
That's both impressive and scary at the same time. :o
Spoiler:
Still, I think I need to stay away from E-bay!
I'm almost certain one of the Bahco folding saws is identical to the Laplander, I just don't know which one and for 5€ more I get a decent knife, so I went for that value pack. How do you like the Laplander?

-
The canadian site I buy alot from carries the katanaboy. Im close to an impulse purchase... just because I want to try it!
http://www.workwearcanada.com/products/detail.cfm?product=606
-
@Alan K. said:
Why a folding saw? I've honestly been reading threads such as this one for years and All this time I have wondered why anyone would choose a folding saw over a fixed blade saw. I mean you can get a fixed blade saw that fits in its own scabbard which can be lashed to a pack or hung from your belt, so it will be just as safe and easy to carry as a folder, but a fixed blade saw is going to cut better and have fewer parts. So, I ask again, why a folding saw?dks and styx have said it much better than I could. For my part, I'll say I think I don't need a bigger, wider saw for camping around or trimming down the occasional branch. :)
-
@Syph007 said:
The canadian site I buy alot from carries the katanaboy. Im close to an impulse purchase... just because I want to try it!http://www.workwearcanada.com/products/detail.cfm?product=606
That's a pricey impluse if you ask me. ::) I sure would be interested to hear your thoughts, nevertheless. :angel:
-
@Alan K. said:
Why a folding saw? I've honestly been reading threads such as this one for years and All this time I have wondered why anyone would choose a folding saw over a fixed blade saw. I mean you can get a fixed blade saw that fits in its own scabbard which can be lashed to a pack or hung from your belt, so it will be just as safe and easy to carry as a folder, but a fixed blade saw is going to cut better and have fewer parts. So, I ask again, why a folding saw?
dks and styx have said it much better than I could. For my part, I'll say I think I don't need a bigger, wider saw for camping around or trimming down the occasional branch. :)
I've taken down trees of more than 20cm diameter with it so I'd say it can handle more than just branches. ;)
-
@Alan K. said:
Why a folding saw? I've honestly been reading threads such as this one for years and All this time I have wondered why anyone would choose a folding saw over a fixed blade saw. I mean you can get a fixed blade saw that fits in its own scabbard which can be lashed to a pack or hung from your belt, so it will be just as safe and easy to carry as a folder, but a fixed blade saw is going to cut better and have fewer parts. So, I ask again, why a folding saw?
dks and styx have said it much better than I could. For my part, I'll say I think I don't need a bigger, wider saw for camping around or trimming down the occasional branch. :)
I've taken down trees of more than 20cm diameter with it so I'd say it can handle more than just branches. ;)
That's good to know. 8)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login