SAK scales
-
Welcome to the forums.
Aluminium liners are rather soft so they'll probably bend if you squeeze them hard enough. I say don't do it.
You may want to consider the alox line

-
-
If the knife is the only tool you really need, maybe check out Opinel. They're super light, dirt cheap, and have been carried in the Alps for many years.
-
It'll be very uncomfortable to use without scales, the thin liners and exposed rivets will dig into your hand. And as firiki says they will probably bend. If you can do without the backside Phillips driver on yor hike, then a Pioneer or Cadet is thinner than a Tinker. A Cadet is also lighter.
I concur with hiraethus' answer to the question of having two pocket knives :)
-
I think the backsprings provide enough rigidity to the structure so the alu liners wouldn't flex under normal use.
Anyone up for some torture testing? >:D
-
You wont save much weight and it will be very uncomfortable to use. You get a blister, it gets infected, you have to amputate with a sharpened rock, a bear smells blood and its all over for you... Why risk it!

-
Find the weight/bulk savings somewhere else......
Welcome to the forum.

-
Seriously, they're just two thin pieces of plastic, how much space and weight does that waste? A lot of pocketknives and multitools have excessively fat handles (i.e. Opinel), but they are for comfort. SAKs have some of the thinnest folding knife handles on the market.
No, they make the tool comfortable to use and give a space for a toothpick, tweezers, and on some models, they also manage to cram a straight pin and pen in there. I always add the straight pin (off the shelf dressmaker's pin) to the newer scales.
-
@shibafu said:
It'll be very uncomfortable to use without scales, the thin liners and exposed rivets will dig into your hand. And as firiki says they will probably bend. If you can do without the backside Phillips driver on yor hike, then a Pioneer or Cadet is thinner than a Tinker. A Cadet is also lighter.I concur with hiraethus' answer to the question of having two pocket knives :)
Just slap some duct tape on there and you're good to go!
-
I'm impressed by the number of responses, also the civility of them all, I am after all suggesting butchering something that you're fond of.
In answer to you all, instead of quoting individually:
Bulk does matter, at least to me, in hard terrain both weight and bulk matter equally, if I can remove 50% of the bulk from any item I carry it is worthy of the effort presuming I don't lose efficiency from that item.
I never said weight, I said bulk :) though losing a little weight from a rucksack can't be a bad thing.
I always carry a needle in my first aid kit, it serves all the purposes as a pin and it sews.
A toothpick can be fashioned from any non poisonous twig.
Tweezers are good but you can, and would, take them in your first aid kit.I tend to use my knife to open packets and to slice food, (two blades, the tin opener and the awl are all worth their weight in gold too) those are the main uses but I still want a knife that can cope with harder tasks in the bush otherwise I'd just bring a razor blade hence I'm concerned about weakening it.
A knife breaking in an emergency situation isn't a good scenario.As for discomfort, for minimal tasks there simply wouldn't be any, I'm not that much of a princess. I could either wrap it in material or just grin and bear it in more serious circumstances.
I think it will probably be strong enough, I guess I'll just have to experiment. I'll order some of those deluxe scales with the pen and then test the knife and see how it copes with different tasks, if I cant trust it then the scales will go on.
One last point, I could have got a smaller knife but this was given to me and I've grown attached to it.
I don't see the point in having numerous multitools, one is all it takes.
I can see the point in a hunter or stockman having a fixed blade knife and a multitool, but why multiple multitools? -
Sorry to say the same thing as everyone else, but the main reason for keeping the scales is grippiness. Or, more to the point, you are less likely to injure or hurt your cold/wet/numb fingers if they are squeezing on rounded plastic rather than hard metal edges. If it's really cold, metal will suck heat from you and be miserable to handle.
The scales occupy a pretty trivial amount of space; if things are that tight you might just want to get a larger rucksack!
-
First, welcome to MT.o. There's no shortage of opinions here, all usually based on personal experiences and preferences.
With that said, go for it Cabbage and see what works for you. SAKs are strong enough to use without scales. -
Cabbage - Welcome to the forum. Obviously you are Oscar Mike, going somewhere? whats your mission? terrain? weather? group size? time?
Then I could be of help...
Note...I like the trigger finger control... now head and eyes front... :)
-
Alox all the way

-
@cabbage said:
I can see the point in a hunter or stockman having a fixed blade knife and a multitool, but why multiple multitools?Two is one and one is none.
Also, when tightening a nut and bolt, you'll need two tools.
The scales don't strengthen the Tinker, they just hold the tweezers etc and make it more comfortable to grip. -
Another point to consider, is that the scales protect your pocket from the sharp edges of the liners and rivet heads, not something you want abrading your clothes on the trail. Sure, you could wrap something around it, but, as you say, you're trying to cut down on bulk, which would be counterproductive if you have to protectively wrap it.
I'd almost suggest the Colin Fletcher minimalist combo of a Classic SAK and a P-38 can opener.
Sent from my SM-N910T using Tapatalk
-
I'll take the scales off and see, will report back with results :)
I do like the look of the alox knives but am hoping to make do with what I have.
@Mattexian said:
Another point to consider, is that the scales protect your pocket from the sharp edges of the liners and rivet heads, not something you want abrading your clothes on the trail. Sure, you could wrap something around it, but, as you say, you're trying to cut down on bulk, which would be counterproductive if you have to protectively wrap it.I'd almost suggest the Colin Fletcher minimalist combo of a Classic SAK and a P-38 can opener.
I don't tend to carry it in my pocket but time will tell if there's abrasion anywhere.
I think FREDs or p38's are a pain, SAK can opener is actually pretty good. Not that I use it much... still.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login