Rusting leathermans
-
Stainless steel does stain less if you leave it in the pickle jar but it will rust if not looked after. The way to stop it rusting is to keep the air away from the steel by it having a coating. Coatings such as Teflon and such work well but can scratch in use. On a plain stainless finish a coating of oil works the best. Get a routine of cleaning, turn the tap full on and rinse the tool in the jet of water making sure the joints get a good rinse out. Dry thoroughly nothing fancy I just use kitchen roll, then oil the joints, axles and then wipe all over the whole tool. Do it once a week or so and emediatly you get the tool home after a days use were you think it may rust.
I find webbing pouches useful because every once in a while I can spread some oil round the inside of the pouch. They seem to repel water better than leather pouch's anyway. I wonder how many would clean a leather pouch as you would a pair of boots?Dave
-
- type of leatherman tool you owned (and whether it was black oxide coated or not)
- whether it rusted or not
- if it did, how long since you bought it it took to rust
- what kind of conditions you exposed it to (whether it rusted or not)
- how the rusting affected the tool
-
Old Style Wave.
-
Yes, minor.
-
Several months.
-
I used this tool when I was working as a dishwasher. I was exposed to every type of liquid imagineable since it was my primary knife. This included; butter, oil, lemon juice, cream, dish soap, grease, etc. The only upkeep I did was run it through the machine at the end of every shift.
-
Mainly comsmetic. There was rusting around the pivot areas and on the main blade.
-
Black Oxide Charge.
-
Not yet.
-
N/A
-
Mainly pocket carry during the winter time. Not a lot of contact with dirt or liquid. I carried it a lot more than I used it.
-
N/A
-
Black Oxide Blast.
-
Not yet.
-
N/A
-
This tool was my EDC when I was doing construction last summer, it was exposed mostly to dust and dirt with little contact with liquid.
-
N/A
-
New Style Wave.
-
Yes, there is minor surface rust on the handles.
-
More than 1 year.
-
This tool is mainly carried in my EDC bag and is seldom used but I did have to use it one night to cut a lot of butcher's twine off the steaks we were serving at work. I ran it through the dishmachine at the end of the night, oiled the pivots and put it back in my bag, the rust is probably from this one use since I can't really think of another time I really used it.
-
None, rust is purely cosmetic.
So far so good, I work around a liquids a lot and really never see that must rust. I must have a good sweat pH balance.
-
- type of leatherman tool you owned (and whether it was black oxide coated or not)
- whether it rusted or not
- if it did, how long since you bought it it took to rust
- what kind of conditions you exposed it to (whether it rusted or not)
- how the rusting affected the tool
- Leatherman Charge XTi (Not black oxide coated)
- It did rust: spots appeared on the 154cm blade (obviously a different steel to the rest of the tool, but also the most used tool in the time I owned it) and also around the pivots.
- Approx 2 weeks
- The rust did not affect the tool's performance, only my estimation of the tool.
Possible mitigating circumstances: I bought the Charge just before going on a coastal holiday, and also used it to prepare lunches often slicing fruit and veg before often cleaning it with nothing more than water and kitchen towel. Even still I was disappointed to see rust this quickly. I was fairly confident I could clean up the blade when I got home, but the spots in the workings of the tool looked like they'd be tricky to treat.
-
- type of leatherman tool you owned (and whether it was black oxide coated or not)
- whether it rusted or not
- if it did, how long since you bought it it took to rust
- what kind of conditions you exposed it to (whether it rusted or not)
- how the rusting affected the tool
- I own quite a number of Leatherman tools, some of them have black oxide finish.
- The <u>only</u> one to ever show signs of rust was a SideClip with bead blast finish. (I've since come to understand that a bead blast finish is more susceptible to corrosion than a polished finish.)
- Less than one year for the SideClip. However, I've owned an original PST for over twenty years, with nary a speck of rust.
- Here is where we should perhaps discount my results. I rotate many tools through my EDC. The Leathermans in my possession spend 11 months out of every 12 sitting on shelf. Not the typical conditions of usage I suspect.
- The SideClip developed a speckling of rust spots all over the head and handles. The spots were more like tiny brown stains really. (See Def's picture above of the Juice phillips screwdriver.) Absolutely no effect to the tool's strength, but bothersome cosmetically.
-
Once again I'd like to point out that where I live is one of the most corrosive environments in the world. Manufacturers used to test corrosion resistance in cars in this area (and New England) but gave up most of it due to the high failure rate. Any metal items here are susceptible to rust and other corrosion due to the acidic soil and high salt content of the air- remember, my province is sticking out in to the Atlantic Ocean- I have to drive for about 300 kms (200 miles) just to reach the mainland, which in my area, is still farther out in the ocean than any point on the US Eastern Seaboard. Add to that the continuously changing temperature and high humidity, and you have a place where it's not good to be metal.
Here, cars have to be "safety checked" each year to make certain that there is little to no corrosion damage because a hole smaller than a dime in the car's body will be big enough to put your hand through in the next year.
As a result, I have been keeping a fairly close eye on all my tools, especially the Leathermans, which have a reputation for rust. I can honestly say, without a doubt, that the amount of corrosion and rust I have seen, is negligeable. I have seen some surface rust, but no pitting, and no damage resulting from rust or any other corrosion, and I am not overly meticulous about keeping tools clean and oiled, and because I am at heart an evil man, I also store them in their leather sheaths. All in all, I think that the rust issue has been greatly overblown.
I traded SuperTools with a guy at work a few months ago because his was broken, and so I gave him mine and I sent his in for repair for him. His tool, aslo kept in a leather sheath and carried every day by a guy who actually works (he is a printer) and used for everything from on the spot repairs to industrial machines to fishing and hunting, had absolutely no rust on it either.
I personally have yet to see a Leatehrman that is rusted so bad that it wouldn't work. A quick look at SpoonRobot's post in the General forum about that dirty old PST should prove that while they may get ugly, they are still solid.
Def
-
because I am at heart an evil man
LOL

Well, not from what I've seen on these forums, maybe you have some hobbies we don't know about... :P
-
:D
Def
-
Anybody else own a Leatherman? Did it rust, or did it not?
-
I am the original owner of a PST, SuperTool, and an early Micra. I also have a 1999-vintage Crunch. I lubricate them periodically and none of them have rusted. My few month old Fuse has not rusted, but it has been used only indoors.
However, I bought a batch of used, plastic covered Micras which were newer vintage than my Micra and about a third of them arrived with rust inside. I knew they were more recent vintage because they said "Tool" on the scissors instead of "USA."
-
@parnass said:
I am the original owner of a PST, SuperTool, and an early Micra. I also have a 1999-vintage Crunch. I lubricate them periodically and none of them have rusted. My few month old Fuse has not rusted, but it has been used only indoors.However, I bought a batch of used, plastic covered Micras which were newer vintage than my Micra and about a third of them arrived with rust inside. I knew they were more recent vintage because they said "Tool" on the scissors instead of "USA."
Oops, I forgot about the red plastic-covered Micra I have. It has all kinds of dirt and crud and rust spots showing in-between the plastic and the "stainless" steel handles.
I don't think the translucent plastic-covered Micra design was a very good idea.
-
Ok, well I think this thread was successful in giving us a better idea of what exactly people are talking about when they mention 'rust' and 'leathermans'
From what I have gained from this thread it seems that leathermans are prone to rust more than e.g. victorinox tools. However, in all cases the rust seems to be on the surface of the tool easily cleaned, and doesn't affect the tool in any way.
This is not to say that the owner isnt shocked by the very fact rust has appeared on their beloved tool, I suppose the biggest concern is about aesthetics, a tool with rust on doesn't look nice, regardless of how superficial it is.
I think this is an issue leatherman have to try and solve, I am sure there are prospective buyers who in the end go for tools from other companies because they do not even want rust specks on the tool they buy.
However, it is reassuring to learn that even if the tool does rust, it will not eat away at the tool and reduce it to powder.
-
I think you have hit the nail on the head right there. Unfortunately the "rusty Leatherman" reputation is out there, and it's up to us, the finest group of multitool enthusiasts to be found anywhere, to dispel these silly rumors.
Of course, look in any tool box, or on any hardworking professional's tools and you will see rust as well. Unless they are brand new tools, or composite materials, most of our tools are going to exhibit rust and corrosion in some manner or another. It's the nature of tools, and we don't mind it on an old wrench or hacksaw frame, but it supposedly makes all the difference in the world on a Leatherman.
Seems kind of silly to me.
Def
-
As I understand it the most effective way to stop a metal rusting is to add chrome (reduces edge keeping and makes the steel weaker) to its make up. The better steels have more carbon (makes the steel harder and hold an edge better but is more prone to rust) added.
As a user of tools the lack of rust would make me question the quality of the steel being used for use on a tool. Rust is formed in the area that comes in contact with the air so is always just surface unless it is allowed to penetrate deeper through the owner not doing any maintenance. If you do no maintenance you get what you deserve, it is up to the owner. Just do as the manufacturer asks on the leaflet that comes with whatever tool you buy.
IMO shiny polished tools can be dangerously slippy in the work environment were hands can get oil, grease or even water on them so I am not too fond of those either. Especially when people round me are using them.Dave
-
@damota said:
As I understand it the most effective way to stop a metal rusting is to add chrome (reduces edge keeping and makes the steel weaker) to its make up. The better steels have more carbon (makes the steel harder and hold an edge better but is more prone to rust) added.As far as I know, adding chrome (molybdenum maybe? I'm not an expert but I remember this particular metal...) doesn't make the blade "weaker" but more prone to bend if too much force is applied. Which, in my opinion, is better for a multitool. A harder steel may rust a little but it cuts better and keeps an edge better; however, when it reaches the breaking point it'll just break without any warning, leaving you with a useless tool in your hand. A duller blade will withstand harder pressure and before the breaking point it will bend a little. This way you will know when to stop. And since I carry a multitool to avoid having a whole toolbox with me, I like to know how far I can push the limit. This is my experience with Victorinox knives: the steel doesn't rust, no spots, no superficial damage. And its elasticity is a plus, to me. Of course, if having a razor-sharp blade is essential, a harder steel is the one to choose. From my point of view, bigger blades should be made of a harder high-carbon steel. Their weight and dimensions would prevent them from breaking. Smaller blades (as the ones on multitools) should be made of a much softer metal. But it's just my opinion, of course. :)
@damota said:
If you do no maintenance you get what you deserve, it is up to the owner.That's true. It doesn't matter if it's Leatherman, Gerber, Victorinox or SOG: no maintenance means bad news to come.
@damota said:
IMO shiny polished tools can be dangerously slippy in the work environment were hands can get oil, grease or even water on them so I am not too fond of those either. Especially when people round me are using them.It may be true, but a shiny polished tool gives rust no places to "hide". Instead, a raw surface gives a good grip to dirt and rust to hold to.
P.S. I hope what I said makes sense, I have a terrible headache and my already-not-so-good english gets worse in these conditions. ;)
-
What I meant by weaker is that it will loose its edge quicker than a higher carbon steel. I should have added that it also makes it easier to sharpen and get a serviceable edge back on it. As I carry a Spyderco with a S30V blade for any cutting I need to do I only use a multi's blade for jobs I am unwilling to risk my Spyderco on and have found that to work for me.
Dave
-
I had a leather man super tool 7 or 8 years ago (i,m now thirty so the memory plays tricks on me
) and that rusted very quickly, never serious rust just, surface corotion. although it was pitted on the tangs and by the pivots, no matter how well i cleaned them :'(I do look after my tools but it was kinda of excessive the amount of care i was giving the lm supertool, especially as it was suposed to be stainless!
i sold it in the end and went back to saks and then got a swisstool x which i,ve got to say is a vast improvement in every area (I,ll run for cover now before i start a flame war
) -
Hehe, no need for a flame war, as you yourself have admitted (or thats what I have understood from your post anyway, forgive me if Im wrong), you have not sampled a leatherman since your supertool, so you have not been able to compare your swisstool to any of the newer leatherman offerings.
That's not to say you might not find it superior in every way, but right now I think most will take that as an uninformed opinion ;)
I think its healthy for people to be able to express their opinions openly in a forum, or any kind of dialogue without worry of attack, of course as long as they do so in a sensitive way, i.e. not trying to hurt people's feelings deliberately.
-
@Raukodur said:
...Therefore, in this thread, if you own a leatherman of any kind, or did in ther past, could you reply with a concise post where you include the following information (and anything else pertinent I might have forgotten to mention):- type of leatherman tool you owned (and whether it was black oxide coated or not)
- whether it rusted or not
- if it did, how long since you bought it it took to rust
- what kind of conditions you exposed it to (whether it rusted or not)
- how the rusting affected the tool
So micky d, going back to the very first post in this thread, what can you tell us about your Leatherman?
-
I have rusty bloomers :'(
-
...Therefore, in this thread, if you own a leatherman of any kind, or did in ther past, could you reply with a concise post where you include the following information (and anything else pertinent I might have forgotten to mention):
- type of leatherman tool you owned (and whether it was black oxide coated or not)
- whether it rusted or not
- if it did, how long since you bought it it took to rust
- what kind of conditions you exposed it to (whether it rusted or not)
- how the rusting affected the tool
So micky d, going back to the very first post in this thread, what can you tell us about your Leatherman?
Ok i used to carry my lm supertool paired with either a spyderco or cold steel 3inch folder, so i always had a good balance of tools to get me through the day.
at the time i was heavily in motorbikes so the leatherman got a fair bit of use in all weather, pulling fuses, bodging electrics
(good old days when all my bikes were crap!)Having said that i always dryed/cleaned and oiled when neccasary, but the uk,s a damp old place so i guess i can be forgiven for a few odd pitts here and there.
the rusting never inhibbited the working of the tool, what finally got to me in the end was the stupid locking system of pulling one blade out to put the other one away, try doing that in sub zero tempretures in the dark with painfully numb fingers

so in the end i got rid of it and went back to carrying normal pliers and a sak, which served me much better in the end, then a mate of mine showed me his swisstool, (after a long time being put of multi tools by my Leatherman Supertool) and i was sold!

and to this day i still think its the finest all round multi tool for me.
but each to there own and there are a lot of multi tools leatheman included that i,d hapilly own these days

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login