How to sharpen
-
The question is, Lansky or Sharpmaker?
-
I still use sticks and stones... =(
I spent all the money on new knives and tools! I can't afford to maintenance then, are you crazy?!
-
Sharpmaker (sorry Nick)
-
I've read more testimonials for the Sharpmaker! but if it works he's covered ;)
I personally am getting back to stones, I like being able to do it "the old fashion way"
and I have a belt sander too, but stones you can use anywhere. I'm getting better. -
I tried DMT's "Magna-Guide" system which IMO is pretty much the same setup as Lansky's. I honestly wanted it to work. It did. :P However, I didn't like the amount of play in the whole guide/clamp-and-rod setup so I returned it. I've been using a belt sander now and getting very, very satisfactory results. If the Lansky system works for you then that's very cool. You definitely should feel confident in your sharpening system/setup.
-
I have got to get a sharpening system soon. I have looked into the Lansky as although it can be fiddly, it seems that there is less chance of messing the edge up than on the Sharpmaker. The Lansky appears to be able to sharpen duller knives to.
Anyone used a Gatco sharpener? They work the same way as a Lansky, but have larger stones.
-
@Flash said:
Ladies and gents,If like me you are fed up of fighting the old sharpening stones can I recommend to you the Lansky sharpening system.
Got mine about two days ago and have used it on several knives and got them shaving sharp.
This is a VERY good bit of kit considering I got mine on hellbay for less then £30.
With it came the oil, knife clamp and extra coarse, coarse, medium, fine and ceramic ultra fine stones with their holders in a convenient plastic carry case the size of an old walkman.
Get one, you wont regret it,

Flash
Flash how does the lansky work with bigger blades 10 inches and above if it's ok you may have just saved me from the added expense of a sharpmaker
-
I've got a Sharpmaker and it works just fine. I haven't tried any of the others to do a comparison, but it does seem to take care of everything I need at least.
-
Jock,
I don't know is the answer...I have used it mainly on 6-8". I will try it tonight on an old machete and get back to you ASAP

Take care,
Flash
-
I went the other direction. Started with a Lansky, went to an EdgePro, then went to just stones. I like not having to rely on anything other than my hands and some stones to sharpen my knives. I like to "simplify" my life when possible.
This is no slam on folks who like Sharpmakers, Lansky, EdgePro's, etc, etc, etc. Just my personal preference is all.
Mike
-
Mike,
No probs mate, I am happy to use a stone but for "defining" a blade , or repairing a badly damaged one I need some help and the lansky does just that. :D
Jock,
The lansky managed a 11" machete OK. Any bigger than that and you may need to doe the blade bit by bit...but for my largest blade it worked a treat.

Hope this helps,
Nick
-
I love the Lansky system. I use it all the time.
-
@Flash said:
Mike,No probs mate, I am happy to use a stone but for "defining" a blade , or repairing a badly damaged one I need some help and the lansky does just that. :D
Jock,
The lansky managed a 11" machete OK. Any bigger than that and you may need to doe the blade bit by bit...but for my largest blade it worked a treat.

Hope this helps,
Nick
Cheers man am looking at a KA-BAR KUKRI this should be fine for my purpose .
-
The trouble I found with the Lansky was the blade kept moving in the clamp when sharpening a heavy Multitool like a Swisstool or Supertool . I find the sharpmaker so easy to use . Ben you cant mess the edge up mate . Just be carefull when you sharpen near the tip as you can round off the point if your careless . If you get one I'll go into depth over the phone with you if you like .
Dunc
-
@dunc5 said:
The trouble I found with the Lansky was the blade kept moving in the clamp when sharpening a heavy Multitool like a Swisstool or Supertool . I find the sharpmaker so easy to use . Ben you cant mess the edge up mate . Just be carefull when you sharpen near the tip as you can round off the point if your careless . If you get one I'll go into depth over the phone with you if you like .Dunc
I was thinking we could meet up for a demo actually. ;)
-
What's this...meeting without the rest of the gang

-
Has there been anything further on the date...I know this may hijack the thread, but its my thread so its OK :D
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login