Signal owner's club
-
-
Finally got the chance to have a hands on look at one of these in a shop. First impressions were good (ish). I liked the size and weight, the blade and saw were also good. Still not a fan of modern Leatherman ergonomic on the handle spread when in pliers mode, but it's not as bad as some. The diamond stone is....fine, I guess. At least it's easy enough to remove and use, unlike the whistle.
I'm sorry to say but my thoughts on the whistle haven't changed; it's not even slightly practical and there's no way it's a substitute for a proper whistle and fire starter. First off it's far too fiddly to remove, tricky enough in a nice warm shop, I'd hate to have to try and access it when I'm cold, wet and in trouble. I'm not inspired by the feel of the plastic either. As a ferro rod it's also definitely on the small side, you'd still need to remove it from the main tool as you need to get the rod right down into your tinder so having it sitting half way up on the side of the Signal isn't ideal. I'd never carry this alone and think myself prepared for an emergency. I'd genuinely worry about the safety of someone who did.
The whistle is only one aspect of this tool though and, much as I don't like it, it doesn't make the rest of the tool bad. I can't see myself buying one, but I understand you folks who like it enough to own it. :)
-
Thanks for your thoughts Gareth
It's always interesting to hear others' views on a tool. I agree about the plastic bits. However, I don't have it as an emergency survival tool myself. Much like you, I would likely carry another MT with it if I were going out in the woods or some area where survival would be in question (not likely for me at least). -
It would have been neat to see a ferro rod attached like the MUT punch tool ( screwed in ). That would have been much better IMO. "Survival tool"
naw, I still don't see it either. A whistle, ferro rod, and saw are all great items to have when outdoors but I think we all know on the Signal its salesmanship.I think the tool is a lot neater than I probably originally thought it would be. Glad you got to handle one.
-
Good to have another POV
I have been back and forth about getting one as well
it is a bit high for what it is but it is awesome that it is a beefier Skeletool and it I really
It has several possibilities to mod and I also like that about it 
-
@Poncho65 said:
Good to have another POV
I have been back and forth about getting one as well
it is a bit high for what it is but it is awesome that it is a beefier Skeletool and it I really
It has several possibilities to mod and I also like that about it 
Sounds to me like you want one, but just need to pull the trigger
;) -
Letherman Signal and Wenger Mountaineer


-
Good to have another POV
I have been back and forth about getting one as well
it is a bit high for what it is but it is awesome that it is a beefier Skeletool and it I really
It has several possibilities to mod and I also like that about it 
Sounds to me like you want one, but just need to pull the trigger
;)Perhaps birthday and/or Christmas money will help me get this nice tool ;) I can wait til then :D
-
Bumping in case there are any new Signal owners :)
Sent from my SM-G920R4 using Tapatalk
-
Yea, I'm in too, forgot to update the thread.
Cool tool so far, I like it.
Pete
-
I knew you were one of the recent additions ;)
Welcome to the club Pete
Sent from my SM-G920R4 using Tapatalk
-
Congrats to the newest editions to the club

-
Welcome gdoolittle

Sent from my SM-G920R4 using Tapatalk
-
Yea, welcome mate.
What are your initial thoughts on the tool? I think it is a cool tool and pretty underrated.
Cheers
Pete
-
@pietervn said:
Yea, welcome mate.What are your initial thoughts on the tool? I think it is a cool tool and pretty underrated.
Cheers
Pete
Thanks all, Ive actually had it for about a month or so and just have not posted it here. Overall I would say it is pretty good. Not worth 100 dollars to me, but I got it NIB for 75. When I first got it it was covered in dust (probably sitting in the cardboard box on the shelves for so long), so I cleaned it up and oiled it and it was still a little rough, but it has broken in somewhat now and is much better. The sharpener and fire steel/whistle aren't the best at all, but better than nothing if you weren't planning on being stranded. I would have liked to see a pair of scissors somewhere but its no big deal to carry a classic. The fact that you cant close the tool all the way to use the bit driver kind of sucks, but it would be OK in a pinch or if you prefer to screw with the tool open. I would have honestly liked to have seen either a fully serrated blade or a fully plain blade, but some people only carry one knife/tool, so again, both sides of the combination edge work when you need them to. Pliers and saw are great of course. Tool is very carry able, surprisingly so actually. It has an awl, which is awlsome! And one way to get around the bit driver issues is to just use the hex head if you carry standard bits. I think the hammer was a nice edition. Yeah you could just use a rock, but if you are going to put a carabiner why not put the extra space to use?
Overall, I like it more than I thought I would and would and do carry it outdoors, but there are a lot of compromises that might just be deal-breakers for some folks.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
