What Traditional Knife are you toting today?
-

Hayn' Helper again. -
Still agonizing with terminology. A knife selling site lists Case as "traditional" and Opinel & Svord (and similars I guess) as "primitive".
-
@kkokkolis said:
Still agonizing with terminology. A knife selling site lists Case as "traditional" and Opinel & Svord (and similars I guess) as "primitive".I've found that on an international forum it helps to not to over think it.
The problem with the term traditional is there is no official definition of a traditional knife. It will vary from forum to forum and continent to continent. To muddy the waters even more this is an international forum so what might be considered traditional in Europe may not be considered traditional in the U.S. Which explains why Opinel is considered traditional by many here. Before the internet I had never heard of a Opinel.
If this was a U.S. Based site then by the strictest definition of the term, a traditional would have pinned construction. With the blade pivot pinned to a bolster & handles pinned to the liners. Like a stockman, barlow, trapper, whittlers etc. The strictest definition is not often used.
Another way to look at it is the pattern is a very large part of what defines "Traditional". Any steel can be used to make the blade. Looking at it that way an Opinel NO.3 looks just like an Opinel NO.12
Miller Bros made a Surveyor pattern with screwed on handles. Once you use a screw in the pivot it becomes a modern design. A modernized traditional maybe but still in a different class.
As a general rule a traditional is a two hand opener, no assist, thumb studs, filppers or belt clips are allowed. Liner locks like the TL-29 and lock backs like the Buck 501 are considered traditional. The designs have been around for a hundred years more or less.
The SAK Pioneer has the same tool load out as a Camillus boy scout knife. I don't believe many would consider a Swiss Champ a traditional, it's more of a tool than a knife. So SAK's tend to get their own thread. Multitool.org has a very large SAK forum so it would confuse things to see them posted as a traditional in the traditional thread as well.
-
The traditional forum in Bladeforums tends to accept as traditional any knife that would have been carried by someone 40, 50 years
From their guide:
"If a regular knife user of the mid 1960's would find nothing out of the ordinary about the design, then it's traditional.That means large Buck 110-ish lockbacks are in.
SAKs date to the late 1800's. If they are not one hand opening, they are in. (See comments on materials of construction.)
Modern locking mechanisms such as Walker liner locks, pocket clips, holes / studs to allow one hand opening are all out. (Traditional liner locks, such as the lock on a TL29, are in.) Add a clip to a stockman, and it needs to be posted elsewhere. By the same token, if it is traditional except for a clip and you remove the clip, feel free to post it here.
We tend to have some tolerance when it comes to fixed blades. But, new designs with features such as glass breakers, are not included in this forum.
We give leeway on materials of construction. So if you have a nice stockman with G10 covers, it's traditional enough for us. After all, plastics have been used on knife handles since the 1800's. Stainless steel has been used in cutlery since the 1920's, so stainless is considered traditional. And even though PM alloys are new developments, that fella in the mid-1960's would never know the difference if he were looking at the knife, so they are OK, too."
So, for Europe (and elsewhere - higonokami in Japan for example) and especially the mediterranean region, a basic friction folder, that is a folding knife with no spring to hold it open, is THE traditional knife.
This was the most basic knife and it was easy for everybody to make. This was the type of knife I remember people using as it was cheap and easily available. I can make one in 20 minutes, using an old blade.
Fixed blades were also commonly carried by many working people, especially in th countryside.In the new world there is a lot of influence from the UK, as there were many knives being exported, slipjoins, from there to the colonies. So, what they call traditional tends to be what Sheffield makers were/are producing. Multiple blade slipjoints are a US characteristic knife.
So, just because a US seller did not see his father carry an opinel type knife it does not automatically mean that the whole world has to accept that this type of knife is not traditional. The buck 110 is considered, in the US to be a traditional knife but most Europeans will put it in the same group as a locking spyderco, sebenza atc.Notice that the bladeforums definition ignores friction folders, being a US forum.
-
Great great knives. I especially like the hayn helper design and that babinga opinel. Geez that rough riders nice too!
-
I dont carry traditional pocket knives much any more. Carried them most of my life. I still like them very much just dont carry them very often. I've been using a Laguiole some lately as I really like that design. If this is traditional enough for Robert I post up a pic shortly. :) I do carry on occasion a Western 657 a traditional much to my liking.
-
@David said:
I dont carry traditional pocket knives much any more. Carried them most of my life. I still like them very much just dont carry them very often. I've been using a Laguiole some lately as I really like that design. If this is traditional enough for Robert I post up a pic shortly. :) I do carry on occasion a Western 657 a traditional much to my liking.That's an awesome Western!!!!! Laguiole's are very cool!!! I just never found the right one at the right price or I would already have one!
Dang David, I gotta go look now!

-
Thanks for clarifying the term "traditional" guys.
Since a little boy I remember Swiss Army knives and Opinels (and our Cretan similar knives) and some Italian Stilettos, which are my tradition. American knives were total strangers until MTO.
Calling Opinel, Svord, Douk-Douk, Merkator and Hayns' Helpers (which I saw here for the first time) primitive is a big mistake.
Take my Opinel Jardin for example. How primitive it is, a knife that uses the same steel as Skandinavian knives, is fully flat ground, lightweight, opens with one hand, completely silently, locks in both open and closed position with one hand, has a spearblade that can be reconfigured by the user any way he wants, a handle that can be engraved or sculpted by the user himself (thinning and making a convienient for one hand opening form included), is sharp and strong enough for every task, has a spine for scratching anything from fire rods to paint drops, has a reknown logo on the blade, can be tarnished and costs so little you can buy ten for the price of a mid class tactical folder, while it is as much a weapon without screaming it aloud, with that archetype tool format it has?
I wouldn't call that primitive, since it does more than any other folder knife I know.
My Helle Skala needs two hands to be opened, my Endura clicks with a noise that's music in the ears of a mall ninja but not a guy who served in a Special Forces camp, and all simple blade modern folders I see around can do less than the Opinel, which comes in any size you might want. And the format can be explored further, as Opinel does now with Outdoor, DIY and Explore.
Simple would be a better word than primitive, but even that is wrong since it's simple in concept but not in functionality, as it does more (for less). It's like calling a shark primitive, following a cognitive mistake of seeing evolution as a ladder. No, sharks were functional from the beginning and they stayed that way because they were almost perfect at such an early stage.
I would call Opinel an "evolved archetype". And a Neolithic obsidian knife "primitive". -
-
A knife purportedly used by Davy Crockett during the Battle of the Alamo

The difference from the knife Jim Bowie was carrying at the same site/day would be striking.
-
@David said:
I dont carry traditional pocket knives much any more. Carried them most of my life. I still like them very much just dont carry them very often. I've been using a Laguiole some lately as I really like that design. If this is traditional enough for Robert I post up a pic shortly. :) I do carry on occasion a Western 657 a traditional much to my liking.

-
Queen Railsplitter

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




Thanks buddy!!
Yours has really nice chestnut bone.