SAK's - Corkscrew or Phillips?
-
@50ft-trad said:
Logic path:I like SAKs
SAK pliers can't handle what I need pliers to do
I need to carry a pliers tool
The pliers tool will usually have a Phillips and assorted flat drivers
The pliers tool is unlikely to have a corkscrew
The pliers tool is unlikely to have scissors as good as a SAK
My SAK should have scissors and a corkscrewThis formula works very well for me indeed
That said, I have found that a Gerber Dime is sometimes all I need on the pliers front, and as such have been considering a DofE with a blade modification. If I do this, it will be the only SAK with backspring Phillips I carry (except for the Mega84 which has both backspring Phillips AND corkscrew)
This does make sense to me too. If I'm carrying a Rebar, for example, then it is complimented by carrying the SAK with a cork crew and scissors.
Then Victorinox went and blew that whole line of logic to hell by putting out the Spirit which has their excellent scissors, and an optional accessory cork screw.

-
@cody6268 said:
Phillips driver. It can handle No. 1 and No. 2 Phillips, unlike the inline model which can only handle No. 2. The can opener can handle No. 2s on models that do not have a Phillips, (i.e. Soldier '61, Spartan), but is limited by the fact it can't reach recessed screws.Sure, I often carry a pliers based tool, but almost as often as I carry it, I usually leave it behind. I only have two models with corkscrew out of my almost one dozen SAK collection--German Army Knife and Explorer. GAK I usually carry because it's so light and thin, and the Explorer because I do occasionally use the mag lens.
**The Duke of Edinburgh Award Tool I've considered getting myself--problem is the darn idiot-proofed blunt tip blade, **and since I don't think I have the skills to reprofile it, guess I'm stuck with that blade. At least that blade would be better for emergency situations and when I'm in extremely close quarters to others.
I've been playing around with how to reprofile it. It seems a 2p coin makes a reasonable template for marking out a kind of sheepsfoot style (see pics below)




-
I thought I'd weighed in last time this thread surfaced
But I've changed my mind since then anyway...I used to be 100% in the phillips camp, then came to realize when you need a corkscrew, you NEED a corkscrew. Whereas the phillips can be managed with the can opener.So if I have a second tool with me, the SAK needs a corkscrew/mini SD. All of my kit/bag/car SAKs are CS models. However, around the house, I usually carry a SAK by itself, and it needs to have a phillips (Super Tinker/Evo 16). I have a corkscrew in the kitchen, and the back side phillips is great for replacing kids' toy batteries.
Also, that sheepsfoot looks like a great idea

-
Both are important but I did choose philips. Mostly because corkscrew often mess the use and carry a bit. I would rather have a bit bigger tool where corkscrew is inside scales. Or seperately carried in sheath like in swisstool. Tool itself is good still. And like mentioned, when you need it, you need it.
-
I only arry saks with the inline philips like SC, Champ Plus or Explorerso I get the best of both worlds. I get to use the cork screw to hold the mini screwdriver. :)
-
I prefer the corkscrew. I put a mini screwdriver in the corkscrew of most of my knives because I find the mini screwdriver handy for opening toys and remotes that need new batteries as well as tightening various doodads around the house. And like Humppa, I often use the mini screwdriver when my hands are too cold, or my thumbnails are too short to get a good hold on the nail nick.
Dave
-
One argument is missing in all of the above - yet I don't know whether it's true. In Europe, it seems to me, corkscrews are the default. Walk into any shop dealing in Victorinox and they'll have a zillion models with corkscrew, and only a few with backside Phillips.
BTW, I rarely use screwdrivers of any kind. OTOH, I never go to a party without my Waiter.
-
I love both corkscrew and Phillips.
I carried and used my Tinker many times back when:
a) I had solid quality eyeglasses whose screws didn't need fixing (now I have modernly crappy ones, I need to tighten the screws every month or so)
b) I didn't have the SwissTool, so the Tinker's Phillips was the only real Phillips screwdriver I had in my EDC (OK, I do EDC a Classic SD and the "Quattro" screwdriver too, but we are talking about the full-profile PH screwdrivers now).Later on, I bought the Climber and now I EDC it more often than the Tinker:
a) I actually used the corkscrew quite a few times for opening wine bottles (AA, here I come
)
b) I use the tiny screwdriver often on my new eyeglasses
c) I started using the "Quattro" screwdriver and the Classic SD tip on the PH screws.I just love the profile of the backspring Phillips, it looks like a nice, fair, full-sized, well-profiled PH2 screwdriver. I've used it many times successfully, especially on the recessed PH screws. About 90% of time its position wasn't a problem and I could use it without problems.
The profile of the inline/SwissTool Phillips looks weird, almost stubby and sort of hybrid-ish. But actually, I've used it successfully on both the PH1 and PH2 screw heads. PH0 screws can be a bit problematic with that hybrid inline/SwissTool screwdriver - I prefer to use the "Quattro" screwdriver for those screws.
-
I just realized this thread has been necrobumped - but hey, I am a necrobumper :P
What 50ft-trad said - I absolutely agree about carrying both - a pliers based MT for the screwdrivers etc. as a real work tool + a classic SAK with scissors and corkscrew as a pocket knife.
-
My logic path hasn't altered from higher up this page, though I have found myself carrying a SAK with a Phillips more frequently. Aside from carrying the Mega84 when I the mood to, I also modified a DofE as descrbed above (I call it The Sheepsfoot Duke) and that little knife has been an excellent companion through much of this year. There's been several times when I've ventured out without a pliers tool, and the Duke and the Dime on my house keys have dealt with everything that needed doing.
Edit: Typical! I type "higher up this page", and this becomes the first post on a new page!
oh well, you get the idea :D -
Hummmm....I still feel that SAKs "should" have a corkscrew, and I still don't use the back Phillips to turn screws very often. However given how much I like carrying the Grand Prix at the moment I have to concede they must have their place. I suspect this is due to the fact that the Phillips makes a four layer SAK just that little more streamlined and pocket friendly. Not that I haven't pocket carried a four layered corkscrew SAK, but a Phillips based one feels better. Three layer SAKs sit just fine in my pocket, Phillips or corkscrew, 5 layers and up I normally carry in a belt pouch where the issue is mute. Perhaps I'd be OK pocket carrying the Master Craftsman?

-
I'm actually that biased towards corkscrew adourned SAKs, and have such little knowledge of back Phillips SAKs that I'm going to have to visit SAK Wiki to see what a Grand Prix and Master Craftsman are

-
@50ft-trad said:
I'm actually that biased towards corkscrew adourned SAKs, and have such little knowledge of back Phillips SAKs that I'm going to have to visit SAK Wiki to see what a Grand Prix and Master Craftsman are
Grand Prix=Mountaineer
Master Craftsman=Ranger
At least I hope that's right or else I'm going to look very foolish. :-[
-
IMO Spartans should have corkscrews and Tinkers should have phillips drivers.

-
@50ft-trad said:
I'm actually that biased towards corkscrew adourned SAKs, and have such little knowledge of back Phillips SAKs that I'm going to have to visit SAK Wiki to see what a Grand Prix and Master Craftsman are

Grand Prix=Mountaineer
Master Craftsman=Ranger
At least I hope that's right or else I'm going to look very foolish. :-[
Don't worry mate, you nailed it ;)
I'll probably still have to look again in future though......
-
A SAK without a corkscrew is like a dog without a nose.
-
I sell modded super tinkers at a 9:1 ratio to climbers. My preference for the phillips is now actually mostly based on ethetics since I rarely use a backside phillips or corkscrew. IF the corkscrew had the same O.D. as the phillips I would actually have no preference for one over the other, but right now I strongly prefer the phillips as it sits flush with the scales and the corkscrew sticks out alot.
-
A SAK without a corkscrew is like an odor without a source.
-
For all you Tinker owners, are there screws/situations where you use the backside screwdriver, while others where you use the can opener? Or do you use just one most of the time regardless?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

