Tube Death
-
Teaser... :D

-
Oh man. I need one one of those.
-
Everything on that pic is
WOW! -
Currently charging all those lovelies. I will also throw in the JETBEAM MINI-1 into the pot for comparison and use the OLIGHT I3E EOS (120 lumen) as benchmark.
-
Benchmade!!

-
-
Size Comparison
From left:
OLIGHT I3E EOS, JETBEAM MINI-1, NiteCore (NC) Tube, MecArmy SGN3, NC TIP, NC THUMB, NC T360



-
Overview
From various websites.T360: That should be "Comes with a headband"

-
Not sure anyone is still reading :D. Anyway, found some time so lets kick of with the
NiteCore THUMB
Well, how do I put it? There is really nothing I like about the thumb.Body & Clip: The body is a good deal larger than the thumb and the clip is simply overkill making it even bulkier.
Tiltable Head: At first glance, the tiltable head seems like a good idea, but it feels flimsy. Also, as you can see from the images, you cannot put it all the way to the front
White Light: The Thumb gives a fair amount of light. Because it lacks a reflector the light is primarily good for short distance and mostly to illuminate the path. My major issue is that the LEDs stick out you have to be careful they are not in your field of vision.
Red Light: Ok, that is the major reason I bought the light, As a cyclist and safety concerned citizen I always like to have a clip-on safety light. However, the red light is terrible, it is so weak you can hold it a couple of cm from your eyes without ill effect, seriously it is that weak. You can also see it on the photo with/without flash from my Galaxy Note 3.Conclusion: Don't buy
Tube 1 : 0 Challengers




-
NiteCore T360
Not much to say about this one. The clip is to small to be attached anywhere (to small for the baseball cap) so really, you can only use it with the headband. The base is also curved (to fit on your head) which does not help if you want to attach it anywhere else. As that it does not really need the 360° adjustment. There is a newer version, the T360M with a magnet foot, so you can attach it somewhere and make the light shine wherever you want. Although I think the joint will wear out at some point, after all its just plastic on plastic. Once the joint is worn out you wish you had bought a regular headlamp.
Again the absence of a reflector makes it a short distance light. You also have to be careful with placement, so the light source is not in your field of vision.Conclusion: Don't buy, a real headlamp is the better choice.
Tube 2 : 0 Challengers



-
I'm still reading and, based on what I'm seeing, I'm also going to keep my wallet in my pocket. :D
-
Quick look around suggests the TIP isn't getting much love atm. And yes I know how that sounds. Get out of the gutter.
-
TIP
I have previously compared the SGN3 vs.TubeBody & Construction: Probably the first thing I noted was that the TIP has no cover for the USB port, for a pocket device I think that is a no-go as it will be filled with dust. On mine you can spot a small gap towards the back, like the tow half don't fit perfectly together (I can push a piece of paper in, but only about a millimeter). Despite having a picture of a wet TIP on their website, I cannot find any indication that the TIP is water resistant. The keyring loop is another piece that does not really fit the rest of the TIP design wise, it also creates more holes in the body (in the close up all the way to the right, you can also see that the metal body is not really nicely finished as this edge looks really rough).
Personally, it feels like the parts don't fit together well and the whole body is a long way from the sleek uni-body of the SGN3.**Light & Reflector: **Obviously, the TIP kicks ass in the brightness department, it's color is slightly cooler than the SGN3 but still warmer than the TUBE. The TIPs reflector has tiny bumps resulting in a much fuzzier beam than the SGN3. This makes me highly doubt that the TIP has a throw of over 70m. While the reflector is a clear improvement over the tube, I prefer the smooth reflector of the SGN3 with the much more defined beam (especially, since I use my flashlight to find stuff I have dropped).
Button: The TIP is operated with two buttons, one for ON/OFF and one to cycle through the mode. The buttons stand out quite prominently, which is thanks to a lock-out mode (press and hold both buttons) only a cosmetic problem. The button have a good feel to them, and I would say are the best part about this flashlight.
Conclusion: Buy the SGN3
Tube 3 : 0 Challengers
SGN3 vs. Tube
I would call that a draw, as there is merit to both. The tube has weight and price on its side, whereas the SGN3 offers a reflector (better beam, warmer light) and more function at a significant higher price.Tube 4 : 1 Challengers




-
One more image

-
-
-
Wow thanks for the in depth review of the product line. Very nice of you. Unfortunate too some of those weren't better. I really like the small tube that's like $12, I think that ones of great value.
Thanks again
-
Thanks for the insights, Beat
i'm not being inspired to part with any cash, so I'll stick with the tube I reckon. The Tube has served me well so far, albeit with a few accidental activations. I have one on my house keys, plus two spares in a drawer. Should last me a while 
-
I'll admit I was curious about these lights, but I'll stick with the Olight I3U EOS on my keys or an S1 in the pocket. Not as many lumens, but hey

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

