Sharpening - Please educate me!
-
@Magic Bus said:
@Micky d said:
Yep it's a bit of an art sharpening blades :), a sharpmaker is pretty foolproof, but it is expensive, and lets face it learning to do it yourself is a pretty useful skill :)
Here's the best online tutorial I've found, and it's by the man himself :)
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=bQN4jcXDjbE
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=0a2Jm3pkXqk&feature=relatedHope this helps mate :)
Thanks Micky, that's good stuff. Just as a matter of interest, I scrubbed the stone, and tried again with much better results. By the way Trueways Survival School seem to sell the combi. stone that Ray uses.
Yeah it's a decent little stone the DC4, I've got one that goes with me everywhere :)
-
I now just use 6"x2" diamond stones I have for woodworking. Probably not sharp enough to fillet paper but good enough.
-
Yeah it's a decent little stone the DC4, I've got one that goes with me everywhere :)
[/quote]Got one coming :)
-
I agree with mickyd, learning to sharpen on a sharpning stone is a very useful skill.
I feel like a cheater everytime I use my sharpmaker......... Have to take a long shower just to wash away the guilt! :D -
@duckman1975 said:
I agree with mickyd, learning to sharpen on a sharpning stone is a very useful skill.
I feel like a cheater everytime I use my sharpmaker......... Have to take a long shower just to wash away the guilt! :D:D
Yeah stone sharpening is a good skill I am slowly learning but I have one of those little ceramic sharpeners and I can get very good results with it
The links do show very well how to sharpen though

-
@duckman1975 said:
I agree with mickyd, learning to sharpen on a sharpning stone is a very useful skill.
I feel like a cheater everytime I use my sharpmaker......... Have to take a long shower just to wash away the guilt! :D:D LOL
-
I agree with mickyd, learning to sharpen on a sharpning stone is a very useful skill.
I feel like a cheater everytime I use my sharpmaker......... Have to take a long shower just to wash away the guilt! :D:D
Yeah stone sharpening is a good skill I am slowly learning but I have one of those little ceramic sharpeners and I can get very good results with it
The links do show very well how to sharpen though

Have to find a cheap knife to practice at, I have ruined 2 good knives the last time I tried to learn.
-
even though he's usually right, try not to agree to much with Mikey guys,
the other mods say it makes him really smurfy! :D -
@WhichDawg said:
even though he's usually right, try not to agree to much with Mikey guys,
the other mods say it makes him really smurfy! :DOh that has a whole different meaning this side of the pond :D
-
it does! :o please don't tell me what it is :ahhh
-
@WhichDawg said:
it does! :o please don't tell me what it is :ahhhMike are you feeling smurfy today ? :D

Dunc
-
The good news is, if you can dull your knife trying to sharpen it freehand ........ then you can also sharpen your knife freehand. Takes practice and patience, but once learned it's good skill to have.
Mike
-
@WhichDawg said:
it does! :o please don't tell me what it is :ahhhWell, it's a bit like this................... :D
-
Did someone mention sharpening?

For practical purposes you are better off with a diamond stone. They don't clog as easily and are easier to clean out either with soap, water and a brush or a rubber pencil eraser. Please don't ask for a rubber on this side of the pond. Has a whole different meaning here. >:D
What sharpeners like the sharpmaker do is provide a jig for a flat bevel. Free hand you can get the bevel pretty flat with a little practice. You shouldn't need too many strokes unless you are using a rubber instead of an erasure, lol.
For practical sharpening a 600 grit is ok. For a finer edge use above 1000 grit. Use straight strokes or is that when you have the rubber.
For a polished edge use a strop with stropping compound. I use Yellow Stone compound. You can make a strop by gluing some leather to a block of wood or buy one commercially. Stropping like this will put a razor sharp mirror polished edge on the blade.
I also recommend using a 10x loupe magnifier to check that you are getting the bevel right.
-
it does! :o please don't tell me what it is :ahhh
Mike are you feeling smurfy today ? :D

Dunc
I always feel smurfy :D
-
@Micky d said:
it does! :o please don't tell me what it is :ahhh
Mike are you feeling smurfy today ? :D

Dunc
I always feel smurfy :D
Just remember on this side of the big pond ask for a pencil eraser instead of a rubber to clean out your diamond stone unless you are smurfy.
-
@Micky d said:
Here's the best online tutorial I've found, and it's by the man himself :)Okay, I'm a wet blanket and a master of anal retention. And Ray Mears could probably kill me with a matchstick and a clover leaf.
However, that said, I think his sharpening technique sucks. I don't like the drag on the pullback. Yes, he claims only pressure on the forward stroke, but I still think the edge should be lifted completely off the stone on the pullback. Otherwise, the drag back raises a burr. :P
I admit to being no expert on knife sharpening. I am, however, a fair machinist, and can sharpen drill bits by hand. And just like a metal file, most folks saw back and forth. It's natural and much easier. However, I was taught that the correct method is to lift the file completely off the workpiece on the pullback stroke. Saves the file cutting edges, prevents clogging, and works the piece faster. I have to believe the same is true for a blade edge.

I'm also aware that Ray was describing a field technique. Perhaps his shop technique is different ... but I suspect not by much. ???
Anyhow [/rant=off] I would like to learn the finer details of knife sharpening myself. I am open to discussion and even criticism... :D
best-
-steve
-
I don't like the way he drags the blade either, but it probably does no harm :)
-
Good ol' Ray mears :D I hadn't seen them vids, very informative, cheers Mike.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login