The problem with having experience
-
In the Multitool Minute thread I was just complaining about an extra hole in the Sidekick/Wingman tools that is a bit confusing during use, but there is a hole (no pun intended) in my logic that I think is also important to point out. As it goes beyond the Sidekick and Wingman issue, I can't think of any other tool examples at the moment, but I am sure I will come up with some later on. In the meantime, I will use another example to illustrate what I am talking about.
A few years ago I rented a car- I had requested a cheap hatchback but by the time I got to the rental office they didn't have any small cheapos left, and they gave me a Chrysler 300, which I was more than happy to have. For those that don't know, the Chrysler 300 is a very nice, full sized luxury sedan.

What you may not know about the 300 is that the rear end swoops in a bit, which means that you actually cannot see where the rear bumper is when you are driving. And, the one I drove didn't have a backup camera. So, the point is, since it was a rental, I didn't know where the rear end was or how far I could back up. But, if it was my car, and if I'd been driving it for a while, I would have gotten used to it and this wouldn't be a problem.
The same goes for multitools, and in the Sidekick/Wingman example, that complaint, the one I would like to kick a designer in the crotch until his kids got headaches over, would be a lot less prevalent if the Sidekick or Wingman was my only tool. I would know how it comes out of my pocket, and it is only because I have so many different tools that I carry and use that I am unable to create that level of familiarity with most of them that I would have if I only had one multitool that I carried and used every day for years on end.
No real question here, just food for thought. Of course I have my go to tools like my Victorinox Compact, that I could use in my sleep, so I guess that I do have that connection, but I wonder how much this actually affects my reviews and thoughts on other tools?
Fascinating to think about, isn't it? :D
Def
-
That's a really long way of writing "I'm rubbish at reversing" :-\
Interesting as your thought is, I feel your assessment is still valid.
I'm not buying 3 years of "getting used to" a product, I'm buying the product.
If I hop in a chair and it's not comfortable, I don't want to hear "you'll get the hang of it" - I want a different chair.
But, I guess this is why so many people are happy with $9.95 "STAINLESS CHINA" knife shaped object, and we demand the pinnacle of engineering - We know how good things could be, and prefer it like that.
As for the Chrysler, I think it's a non-issue. Only Rental places buy the base model without the reversing camera :P - All the owners have never even considered what the back end looks like, they just watch the screen :P
-
"Chrysler 300 is a very nice, full sized luxury sedan" Is that a review? Did you compare it to the jeep or the golf? :)
-
I've got exactly the same issue with my torchlights. Over the years, a nice assortment of Fenixes (P3D, E35 UE, HL5), a Nitecore (MH20GT) and a Thrunite (T10T).
Wonderful lights, but most of them plagued with "Double push, release, gentle push and turn two thirds left to activate"-issues.
If I only operated one of these lights, I'd instantly remember what kind of shi**y phantasy its designer had when thinking up how to operate a complex light with only one button, but since they serve different purposes, I've got that milisecond of sweet remembrance. "Ah, yes, it's THAT light!"
The Thrunite T10T wins here - sturdy light, only useful modes, easy to operate.
Tomcat
-
I think this is an excellent point. We all get used to where tools are located in our favorite MT's and when handling a new one, changes from what we expect makes the new MT seem inconvenient. This is really accentuated when you go from OHO tools to MTs that no longer have that (for example, Charge to Vic Spirit).
-
Interesting as your thought is, I feel your assessment is still valid.
I'm not buying 3 years of "getting used to" a product, I'm buying the product.
Good argument and something to consider, but I second the above.
How many Chrysler 300 owners got used to the dimensions of their cars by bumping into a wall?
Also, experience equates to knowledge, that hole bothered you because you had experienced better.
-
Since the car analogy has gone further than I anticipated I guess I will continue it.
I have long thought that headlight and wiper switches should be in the same location, and function almost identically across all makes and models. It is a safety thing- imagine you are in a rental on a dark highway and you don't know where the high beams are. Or it suddenly starts to rain hard. You go to click on the wipers (or at least where they are in your car) and the trunk opens Or you spend so much time glancing down trying to find the right switch and you run into something.
That's not a mistake you'd make in your own car, but you do it in an unfamiliar machine, which is exactly what I experience with the Sidekick and Wingman. I am not as familiar with it as I would be something I carried constantly.
Then we can switch t my father's example. He carried a Schrade Tough Tool (old USA made one) for years and it was absolutely the best thing ever. I gave him a Victorinox Spirit, and honestly, as much as most of us would consider it a step up from the Tough Tool, he still carries and uses the Tough Tool every day. Or at least he did until I got him a PowerAsssist, which sadly is at the bottom of a lake.
Yes, in MTO fashion, it actually did go over the side of the boat! :ahhh
But I digress- it didn't matter how much better the Spirit was, it was not as good as his old Tough Tool, and only a combination of arthritis and Compound Leverage would change his mind.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Since the car analogy has gone further than I anticipated I guess I will continue it.I have long thought that headlight and wiper switches should be in the same location, and function almost identically across all makes and models. It is a safety thing- imagine you are in a rental on a dark highway and you don't know where the high beams are. Or it suddenly starts to rain hard. You go to click on the wipers (or at least where they are in your car) and the trunk opens Or you spend so much time glancing down trying to find the right switch and you run into something.
That's not a mistake you'd make in your own car, but you do it in an unfamiliar machine, which is exactly what I experience with the Sidekick and Wingman. I am not as familiar with it as I would be something I carried constantly.
I agree wholeheartedly. My particular beef is with RHD cars that have the blinker (turn indicator) wand on the left of the steering wheel.
Yes, I know that all you LHD folks are thinking "What's wrong with that, that is where it should be ? "
But if you drive a RHD vehicle with a manual gearbox your left hand is often busy with changing gears just when you also want to use your blinker. In the past all vehicles sold in Australia ( a RHD country) were required to have the control wand for blinkers on the right and because all cars were the same you didn't have to think about it, you just knew where it was. Unfortunately several manufacturers of (mainly) European cars were able to persuade the govt to relax this requirement, so these days you often see someone switching their wipers on when they obviously wanted to indicate a turn (it took me years to retrain my muscle memory when I got a VW and a Skoda, and very occasionally I still revert to the wrong wand when under stress).
I suppose it is just as well I can't afford a new Ferrari (I believe their turn indicators are actuated by a couple of buttons on the steering wheel, and there are a whole lot of other buttons there as well to add to the confusion).
-
That is the beauty of it. Different Strokes for Different Folks.
Our MT carry preferences aren't just based on functional use.
Keep up the good work! :D
-
Tool bonding. I think it happens at some point when one discovers a tool better than a previous tool used. I certainly bonded with my Wave and know that tool inside and out. My modified Wave was used a lot recently and I had to remember I added an awl and exterior scissors. While we can argue the Spirit is one of the top tools its interesting how many owners of it still carry their favorite instead.
Regarding placing wipers and other vehicle accessories in the same place across all models, I agree. Hazard signal comes to mind as well as fuel latch. I can open mine without pressing any button.
-
@JP said:
That is the beauty of it. Different Strokes for Different Folks.Our MT carry preferences aren't just based on functional use.
Keep up the good work! :D
Absolutely, and that is the issue with my wiper/headlight argument. How do we decide which placement to go with, and if it was standardised, how many people would be complaining that their usual location wasn't used?
For multitools, I believe that a person's first multitool dictates what they like and don't like, and future multitools that they like are all based on that initial tool. For example, my first SAK was a Camper, and at the same time my father got a Champion. While I was always amazed at all of the other stuff he had on his, the one thing I really wished I had on mine was scissors.
Fast forward a few years, my first non-SAK multitool was a Leatherman Micra, a scissor based tool. I was so impressed with it, I gave it to my girlfriend and went back the next day to buy a PST II, which has scissors.
To this day, I still consider a lack of scissors to be a drawback to any multitool, and you will likely have heard me complain about the lack of scissors on the CenterDrive, MUT, SuperTool series and many, may other tools, because I personally think scissors are one of the most important options on a multitool. However, for every time I have complained about not having scissors, someone else has seen them as a waste of space.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
That is the beauty of it. Different Strokes for Different Folks.
Our MT carry preferences aren't just based on functional use.
Keep up the good work! :D
Absolutely, and that is the issue with my wiper/headlight argument. How do we decide which placement to go with, and if it was standardised, how many people would be complaining that their usual location wasn't used?
For multitools, I believe that a person's first multitool dictates what they like and don't like, and future multitools that they like are all based on that initial tool. For example, my first SAK was a Camper, and at the same time my father got a Champion. While I was always amazed at all of the other stuff he had on his, the one thing I really wished I had on mine was scissors.
Fast forward a few years, my first non-SAK multitool was a Leatherman Micra, a scissor based tool. I was so impressed with it, I gave it to my girlfriend and went back the next day to buy a PST II, which has scissors.
To this day, I still consider a lack of scissors to be a drawback to any multitool, and you will likely have heard me complain about the lack of scissors on the CenterDrive, MUT, SuperTool series and many, may other tools, because I personally think scissors are one of the most important options on a multitool. However, for every time I have complained about not having scissors, someone else has seen them as a waste of space.
Def
It's all very well trying to derail this thread with (albeit interesting) remarks about MT's Def, but try and stay on the topic of cars please.
-
Sorry, I'll try to keep my comments in check from now on....

Def
-
as said before, Japanese cars still have the indicators on the rear, but Korean, European etc. seem to have it only on the left.
I switch between cars, often during the same day, and you end up cleaning your windscreen when you want to indicate.
-
The answer to the OP is to have one MT that you always use until it breaks/wears out only to replace it with the same model. Do we want to go there? :D
The horror.
-
I remember hiring a Mercedes people carrier thingy while in France about ten years ago with my wife and some friends. After some paperwork I was handed the keys and pointed in the general direction of the car. Not a problem I think, I've driven a good verity of vehicles; large, small, manual, automatic, right hand drive, left hand drive, it's all the same to me. So I get in and have a look over the basic controls, lights, wipers, that sort of thing, all within the realms of what I expect. I start it up and get ready to move and all I need to do is release the hand break......errr....where the smurf is the hand break? :ahhh After a lot of head scratching from the whole occupancy of the car I finally work out it's actually a "foot" break with a little leaver on the console to release it. So pull the car up, lift your knee up about half a meter, try and find a small extra peddle with your foot that's set way off to one side and is totally black against a black background. At night.

Getting back to Grant's point though; it's not actually a terrible system, and it's one that doesn't take long to get the hang of, but the designer certainly didn't have me and my circumstance in mind when it was conceived. ::)
-
@Gareth said:
I remember hiring a Mercedes people carrier thingy while in France about ten years ago with my wife and some friends. After some paperwork I was handed the keys and pointed in the general direction of the car. Not a problem I think, I've driven a good verity of vehicles; large, small, manual, automatic, right hand drive, left hand drive, it's all the same to me. So I get in and have a look over the basic controls, lights, wipers, that sort of thing, all within the realms of what I expect. I start it up and get ready to move and all I need to do is release the hand break......errr....where the smurf is the hand break? :ahhh After a lot of head scratching from the whole occupancy of the car I finally work out it's actually a "foot" break with a little leaver on the console to release it. So pull the car up, lift your knee up about half a meter, try and find a small extra peddle with your foot that's set way off to one side and is totally black against a black background. At night.
Getting back to Grant's point though; it's not actually a terrible system, and it's one that doesn't take long to get the hang of, but the designer certainly didn't have me and my circumstance in mind when it was conceived. ::)
General Direction!

-
I remember hiring a Mercedes people carrier thingy while in France about ten years ago with my wife and some friends. After some paperwork I was handed the keys and pointed in the general direction of the car. Not a problem I think, I've driven a good verity of vehicles; large, small, manual, automatic, right hand drive, left hand drive, it's all the same to me. So I get in and have a look over the basic controls, lights, wipers, that sort of thing, all within the realms of what I expect. I start it up and get ready to move and all I need to do is release the hand break......errr....where the smurf is the hand break? :ahhh After a lot of head scratching from the whole occupancy of the car I finally work out it's actually a "foot" break with a little leaver on the console to release it. So pull the car up, lift your knee up about half a meter, try and find a small extra peddle with your foot that's set way off to one side and is totally black against a black background. At night.

Getting back to Grant's point though; it's not actually a terrible system, and it's one that doesn't take long to get the hang of, but the designer certainly didn't have me and my circumstance in mind when it was conceived. ::)
General Direction!

General Direction quickly became Major Issue. ;)
-
General Dynamics?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login