The problem with having experience
-
Though I agree with the gripes relating to car layout (I'm affected by LHD, RHD, and various other vehicle layouts (like having lights and wipers controlled by toggles and dials on the dash)
Generally fine when I'm "paying attention", but often enough my "Native" instincts take over, and I'll indicate with wipers, or throw the emergency brake on in an Auto when going to down-gear

Try getting into two different brands of Crane with the yoke set up for different controls :ahhh
HOWEVER - I don't agree with the conclusion - Without introducing new methods and ideas, how do we move forward?
It's essentially the design version of Evolution - Any mutations that work will continue, any that don't will be bred out :)
All that said, I love my high beams on the floor, the option of foot & hand throttle.
You also get a fuel cut off and an isolator switch, the wipers, lights and horn are worked from the dash, oh and the exhaust brake, not to mention low range, diff locks and winch controls :D(Plus all the fun gauges - pyro, pitch, roll, & a dash mounted compass...)
Edit: Added a picture for S & G
There's only one "wand" on the steering column, and it's not even indicators :P - It's a brake lever.

-
It is the big discussion on why cars still have/need steering wheels.
Most games, equipment , even ships are controlled by joysticks. The steering wheel has been described as an anachronism by many, for years. I remember an article by Setright in Car saying that about 20, 30 years ago..
A suitably weighted joystick could control the power steering and the wheels just as well as a steering wheel, but it is still there, taking a huge amount of space, because people are used to it.
Imagine how much more space you will have, how less likely tit would be for the driver to be injures, without a steering wheel (the airbag can go somewhere else). -
@dks said:
It is the big discussion on why cars still have/need steering wheels.Most games, equipment , even ships are controlled by joysticks. The steering wheel has been described as an anachronism by many, for years. I remember an article by Setright in Car saying that about 20, 30 years ago..
A suitably weighted joystick could control the power steering and the wheels just as well as a steering wheel, but it is still there, taking a huge amount of space, because people are used to it.
Imagine how much more space you will have, how less likely tit would be for the driver to be injures, without a steering wheel (the airbag can go somewhere else).And growing up on video games the trigger and missile launch buttons will be second nature too :D
-
I often use the handbreak button, Reverse gear lever/button as a missile launcher.... :)
-
-
@dks said:
It is the big discussion on why cars still have/need steering wheels.Most games, equipment , even ships are controlled by joysticks. The steering wheel has been described as an anachronism by many, for years. I remember an article by Setright in Car saying that about 20, 30 years ago..
A suitably weighted joystick could control the power steering and the wheels just as well as a steering wheel, but it is still there, taking a huge amount of space, because people are used to it.
Imagine how much more space you will have, how less likely tit would be for the driver to be injures, without a steering wheel (the airbag can go somewhere else).::) :D
I think a joystick would require much more precision than a steering wheel and this could cause problems?

-
I remember a few decades? ago when there was a gadget with buttons and rocket sounds that you were supposed to put in your car and use to "dispose off" any annoying drivers.
You can get similar functions on your phone these days, but at the time that gadget was a popular gift for men,
Mad max was in 1979, but you also had James bond and mainly Knight Rider influencing you.
-
It is the big discussion on why cars still have/need steering wheels.
I'm a big proponent of fluid (and to a lesser extent electrical) power systems - and yes, a joystick could easily be used to steer a vehicle.
Much like the electronic controlled gears, brakes, and, hell, windows, that are fairly common now.
I like my steering wheel same reason I like all my other mechanical input systems - I like the "direct" control, and the "feedback"
When the aliens come and rain down EMPs, I'll be fine (albeit in the dark) while you lot with your keyless ignitions, electronically controlled throttles and gearboxes, and fancy steering joysticks will be smurf out of lack :)
I think a joystick would require much more precision than a steering wheel and this could cause problems?
Not really, whether through hydraulics or electronics, it's not too hard to get the hang of it.
But with driverless cars so close on the horizon, it doesn't seem like it's a "step" we need to take. Maybe they'll put them in as the "override" for Driverless cars, more leg room without the wheel and column....
-
you could use a sliding lever, or as i said, an appropriately weighted joystick.. Once you get used to it then you will have the necessary precision.
Think of a good quality, well designed system, not an arcade/toy grade one.
-
most cars now have electronic steering assistance, so the wheel, to a large extend is just a big variable resistor (or other similar system)
Driving a non power assisted car is a big shock to the system.
I used to drive a pickup truck, with no power assistance in the early nineties and it was hard...
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
That is the beauty of it. Different Strokes for Different Folks.
Our MT carry preferences aren't just based on functional use.
Keep up the good work! :D
Absolutely, and that is the issue with my wiper/headlight argument. How do we decide which placement to go with, and if it was standardised, how many people would be complaining that their usual location wasn't used?
For multitools, I believe that a person's first multitool dictates what they like and don't like, and future multitools that they like are all based on that initial tool. For example, my first SAK was a Camper, and at the same time my father got a Champion. While I was always amazed at all of the other stuff he had on his, the one thing I really wished I had on mine was scissors.
Fast forward a few years, my first non-SAK multitool was a Leatherman Micra, a scissor based tool. I was so impressed with it, I gave it to my girlfriend and went back the next day to buy a PST II, which has scissors.
To this day, I still consider a lack of scissors to be a drawback to any multitool, and you will likely have heard me complain about the lack of scissors on the CenterDrive, MUT, SuperTool series and many, may other tools, because I personally think scissors are one of the most important options on a multitool. However, for every time I have complained about not having scissors, someone else has seen them as a waste of space.
Def
My first non-SAK multi was also a Micra, and I also greatly prefer a tool with scissors.

-
The Micra is a great tool, and I have no interest in the Squirt or Style series because I believe the Micra ruined me for just about all other keychain tools.
As for why we have steering wheels instead of joysticks, you can blame much of that on inertia and control. A joystick is overkill for a car as cars only turn left and right. The forward and back movement of a joystick is unnecessary. The suggestion then becomes using forward and back as brake and accelerator, which is a bad idea. If pushing forward on the stick is forward then you will have trouble stopping by pulling back. Imagine you are at a reasonable speed and need to panic brake- you pull the stick back and get pushed forward by your momentum, causing the car to try and accelerate.
Flip the controls around so pushing forward stops the car and you have the same problem in reverse.
Also, the steering wheel might seem awkward, but it allows for more precise, minute changes that a stick wouldn't allow for. It is because of this that you automatically (visually and by feel) don't crank the wheel too hard to one side or the other at speed. You wouldn't have that sensation with a joystick. Ditto for the gas pedal.
Def
-
you can have a joystick that just goes left and right.
-
I did suggest lever as an option in a previous post.... nobody reads anymore
-
The joystick would need to be centre mounted. You don't want to be limited to only being able to use a single hand to steer with a side mounted joystick just as we can steer with either hand using a steering wheel while we itch our nose or tap a tune or whatever. A centre mounted joystick would make getting in and out of the car far more difficult (think about it). I still think a steering wheel is a better overall solution.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


you could use a sliding lever, or as i said, an appropriately weighted joystick.. Once you get used to it then you will have the necessary precision.