I need a new kayak knife
-
Both Mora and Hultafors do stainless rope knives. Cheap and with good reputation, what's not to like?
-
I'm certainly hard pressed to find something I don't like about them, but I'm not really sold on the configuration for kayaking.
Def
-
Never having kayaked.... is that a word? .....I don't understand what does make for an appropriate knife. On the canal boat, it was all about rope cutting. What are the three primary features you need for it to be a decent kayakable.... I'm doing it again :ahhh ...... knife?
-
Three main things huh? Simple enough:
1- Easily and securely attaches to a PFD or can be hung around your neck without worry of losing it.
2- Safe tip and serrated blade for cutting rope or webbing that may get tangled.
3- Easily oriented in the hand from any angle so you can be sure that the rounded tip and serrated blade are pointed the right way.
Much of this is oriented towards whitewater and I don't (usually) just go for whitewater, but the kind of kayaking I do, you can encounter just about anything, including whitewater. When you are paddling on the ocean or flasmurfer (lakes etc) there really isn't any need for a knife. When you stop for lunch or to make camp you can use the kayak knife or you can bring a secondary knife, especially since weight doesn't matter as much in a boat as when you are climbing or hiking.
But, when you hit whitewater you don't know what is under you so if you roll and get snagged you want to get out quickly since you may not have had there ability or wherewithal to have taken a breath on the way down. A couple of years ago Megan got snagged on a rock, right next to a submerged telephone pole which also had the steel climbing pegs in it. Since everything is tied to the boat, there are lots of ropes to get snagged on something like that, plus the straps on your PFD, and the rigging on your boat.... plus there can be old ropes, fishing lines, nets, weeds etc, all capable of grabbing you. If you can't quickly get yourself free, someone else may get a free boat. :ahhh
Def
-
-
Nice knife, but it looks a little big, a little darkly colored and a lot too expensive for a kayak knife. I'm not sure how comfortable I'd be watching $270 sink to the bottom of a lake or river! :ahhh
Plus if I get tangled in something and need to cut myself free I'm a bit worried about what that tip and the sawback teeth are likely to do to my precious flesh and organs. :ahhh
Def
-
I'm not sure how comfortable I'd be watching $270 sink to the bottom of a lake or river!
It's got a lanyard hole ;)
Plus if I get tangled in something and need to cut myself free I'm a bit worried about what that tip and the sawback teeth are likely to do to my precious flesh and organs.
It just needs a little cover for the saw, a-la GAK.
(FWIW - I don't really like HHA stuff (although I've only ever used one of their D2 knives....)
I discovered this bad boy whilst reading a Hatchet review listicle, that, aside from being a bunch of random words strung together to pass as an article - They managed to review the same HHA hatchet TWICE, in different colours, without apparently noticing.
(I'm guessing the "article" was written by doing an image search for "tactical hatchet" , picking 10 images, and writing some stuff that made it look like they'd ever actually be in the same room as a hatchet (much less the ones they were "reviewing" )
-
Grant, any success with this ?
-
-
any reason you go for a fixed over a folder ? i can think of a few obvious reasons, but i'd be curious to hear yours.
I carry the palm equipment folding knife, only used it for maintenance tasks and thankfully so far haven't needed it in an emergency. In ireland (and i think the UK) fixed blades unfortunately are frowned on due to the "rambo" phenomenon/public perception :( :(
i think i asked you before, few months back, have you ever looked at the NRS co pilot knife ? it's a bit pricey but looks a nice knife if fixed is what you need. but, i have never played with one.
-
As someone who has been upside down in a whitewater boat I am surprised that you would ask why I prefer a fixed blade! :D
When your kayak/paddler ratio inverts it can be very disorienting and the fewer complications you have while trying to learn to breathe underwater the better.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
As someone who has been upside down in a whitewater boat I am surprised that you would ask why I prefer a fixed blade! :Dthere is this thing called inexperience :D - yeah, i get the easy to deploy, but then theres the risk of it snagging on something, etc.
one of the things drilled into us from day one is "trees are not your friend" when it comes to rivers and kayaking. a lot comes back to advice you gave me a few months back, make sure i can access and open my knife with either hand, and eyes closed etc. And the rapids i've been playing on so far are only grade 2 so not particularly hazardous. -
You are right of course, but the reality is that moving water can always put you places you don't want to go, and bump you into things you don't want to bump into. Megan had a couple of experiences that made her quickly realise how dangerous a current can be. One was when she was in a fairy fast but shallow current and her boat fetched up on a rock and started to turn. She quickly jammed her paddle in and pushed herself up on the rock for more stability and used her paddle to keep from turning.
Another time was further up the same waterway when the water was only a few inches deep on a sandbar. The current was rushing out for the day (the Shubie Canal ends at the Bay of Fundy, home of the highest tides in the world, and the tide was going out) and dragging us along with it. Unfortunately there were some shallow spots, and the water was rushing so fast that it only took a second or two to fetch up, turn sideways and roll. Luckily it was only soft sand and extremely shallow, so no real danger, but that's not what you are thinking about when you are being almost forcefully ejected from the boat.
In the first scenario if she had rolled she would have hit many rocks, and it would have resulted in many broken bones a long way from help. The second situation wasn't as grave, but happened much faster.
Don't underestimate what can happen in a current, even a relatively slow and safe one. The areas we were in were Class 2.
Admittedly in either case a knife wasn't going to do a damned bit of good, but it's more to give you an idea of how quickly things can change, and I wouldn't want something underneath or any of my rigging keeping me from the oxygen I have been addicted to for years.
As for it snagging, I haven't found that was a serious problem yet. The Benchmade rides quite flat on my PFD, and the other knives I have had were hung around my neck and tucked inside my PFD. Anything is possible, but I'll take the chance of having them snag over not having them at all. Especially with a neck knife, as if I did get hung up by it, it means I still have it with me, and can find it easily enough to free myself.
I still haven't tried the CoPilot knife. I have been looking at them and I'm not sure I want to take the plunge (so to speak) on it. I think I prefer the larger Pilot's knife and I recall thinking I preferred the titanium version (for some reason) and decided to write it off as I have no interest in dropping $200 for it.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
You are right of course, but the reality is that moving water can always put you places you don't want to go, and bump you into things you don't want to bump into. Megan had a couple of experiences that made her quickly realise how dangerous a current can be. One was when she was in a fairy fast but shallow current and her boat fetched up on a rock and started to turn. She quickly jammed her paddle in and pushed herself up on the rock for more stability and used her paddle to keep from turning.Another time was further up the same waterway when the water was only a few inches deep on a sandbar. The current was rushing out for the day (the Shubie Canal ends at the Bay of Fundy, home of the highest tides in the world, and the tide was going out) and dragging us along with it. Unfortunately there were some shallow spots, and the water was rushing so fast that it only took a second or two to fetch up, turn sideways and roll. Luckily it was only soft sand and extremely shallow, so no real danger, but that's not what you are thinking about when you are being almost forcefully ejected from the boat.
In the first scenario if she had rolled she would have hit many rocks, and it would have resulted in many broken bones a long way from help. The second situation wasn't as grave, but happened much faster.
Don't underestimate what can happen in a current, even a relatively slow and safe one. The areas we were in were Class 2.
Admittedly in either case a knife wasn't going to do a damned bit of good, but it's more to give you an idea of how quickly things can change, and I wouldn't want something underneath or any of my rigging keeping me from the oxygen I have been addicted to for years.
As for it snagging, I haven't found that was a serious problem yet. The Benchmade rides quite flat on my PFD, and the other knives I have had were hung around my neck and tucked inside my PFD. Anything is possible, but I'll take the chance of having them snag over not having them at all. Especially with a neck knife, as if I did get hung up by it, it means I still have it with me, and can find it easily enough to free myself.
I still haven't tried the CoPilot knife. I have been looking at them and I'm not sure I want to take the plunge (so to speak) on it. I think I prefer the larger Pilot's knife and I recall thinking I preferred the titanium version (for some reason) and decided to write it off as I have no interest in dropping $200 for it.
Def
again, you're right, i have always treated water be it sea or river with a VERY healthy respect. Some good advice there Grant

One thing to mention is I am always on the river with instructors who are very very good at what they do.
and yeah, titanium is crazy money, for me anyway. -
Found this... looks like a good knife for the job
Edelrid RESCUE CANYONING KNIFE
Not really much information
-
Since I don't whitewater per se, I have been winging it with regards to the knife I carry when kayaking. If anyone happens have a CRKT Neckolace for sale, I would love to try one. Looks pretty good but they don't seem to make them anymore.
That Benchmade is crazy expensive for something that may find its way into the drink and lost to the elements the first time I have to use it, but that's just me. Otherwise seems nice.
Anyone had any experience with the Gear Aid Akua? I have not, but found it while researching. 420 steel, Titanium coated. Serrated and plain edge. The blunt end is flat enough to be used to pry clams. Bright green yellow handle. Drainholes in sheath. Removable side clip. I think it is under $30 USD.
-
@Etherealicer said:
Found this... looks like a good knife for the jobEdelrid RESCUE CANYONING KNIFE
Not really much informationInteresting, but the handle looks a little slick and awkward? Of course, so did the Neckolas, but now it is hands down the best kayak knife I have owned.
I don't see any pricing info on that page- in fact the whole website seems a little wonky, like they just threw in a bunch of features and never looked to see if any of them were working.

Def
-
@ThundahBeagle said:
Since I don't whitewater per se, I have been winging it with regards to the knife I carry when kayaking. If anyone happens have a CRKT Neckolace for sale, I would love to try one. Looks pretty good but they don't seem to make them anymore.That Benchmade is crazy expensive for something that may find its way into the drink and lost to the elements the first time I have to use it, but that's just me. Otherwise seems nice.
Anyone had any experience with the Gear Aid Akua? I have not, but found it while researching. 420 steel, Titanium coated. Serrated and plain edge. The blunt end is flat enough to be used to pry clams. Bright green yellow handle. Drainholes in sheath. Removable side clip. I think it is under $30 USD.
Rule #1 of kayaking is "If it's not secured, it's not yours."
Rule # 2 is "Always have a knife."
You are right though, the Benchmade is quite expensive for a knife that is used around water, and that is usually against the rules. However, that having been said, I am liking the Benchmade very much, although it is also discontinued, so if it goes, I won't be able to get another.

That Gear Aid one you posted looks like a potentially useful blade for the water, and I may have to get one and try it out. Unfortunately the season is pretty well over here, so I'll probably wait till closer to spring to pick one up. The concern I have with it is the image of the guy using it as a screwdriver. As a knife guy it makes me cringe as it means either the blade isn't properly hardened meaning it won't take a decent edge, or it is properly hardened and they are encouraging people to break their knives, since screwdrivers are usually much softer. Still, it looks like a good alternative to the Benchmade, with a very similar blade style.
Thanks for the heads up!
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Found this... looks like a good knife for the job
Edelrid RESCUE CANYONING KNIFE
Not really much informationInteresting, but the handle looks a little slick and awkward? Of course, so did the Neckolas, but now it is hands down the best kayak knife I have owned.
I don't see any pricing info on that page- in fact the whole website seems a little wonky, like they just threw in a bunch of features and never looked to see if any of them were working.

Def
Edelrid has a good reputation in the climbing world... so I'm a bit surprised that the knife costs less than 40$ (canyonstore.eu)
-
That's not a bad price either. I think I may try that one out too for that price.
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
