Victorinox Quality?
-
Alright my first post, glad I found this forum. I hope this is not too offensive a question to start off but ...
I used to own a SAK that I carried every day for 10+ years. I don't know the model but looking at the web site I think it was equivalent to the Climber. Anyway I loved this knife, until one day I lost it in a move and it was gone forever. I replaced with a Leatherman which I never really loved for a number of reasons, mostly size and weight. I have had this thing for another 10+ years.
I wanted to go back to a lighter knife again, so I ordered a Camper II. Here's the thing - the Camper II does not "feel" like my old knife. Frankly it feels a little more cheaply made. Maybe it's because the weight is less or something which may or may not be the same as lower quality.
Anyway what I'm wondering about - I have my eye on the new Evolution Grip 14, for the locking blade and scissors. Will these have the old "feel" from the knife I used 20 years ago? I do realize they all carry the same lifetime warranty which is nice. Or is this pretty much all in my mind.
Thanks much,
Greg. -
Welcome

I think the Camper II has economy scales which may feel cheaper but the tool quality shoud be the same. You could always replace the scales with normal ones.
-
Welcome aboard! No I don't think it's your imagination. I really think there's a difference in the feel between the older and newer versions, but the new versions seem to hold up just as well. On a different note, you can always find earlier versions on Ebay, etc. for a pretty reasonable price. Either way you can't go wrong!
-
If you buy one of these, I believe it will remind you of your former Camper or Climber.
I bought two from him and I like the quality of these....essentially they're new-old-stock.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/NEW-VICTORINOX-SWISS-ARMY-1-3613-71-KNIFE-MINT-IN-BOX-/172435158831? -
@FolderBeholder said:
If you buy one of these, I believe it will remind you of your former Camper or Climber.
I bought two from him and I like the quality of these....essentially they're new-old-stock.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/NEW-VICTORINOX-SWISS-ARMY-1-3613-71-KNIFE-MINT-IN-BOX-/172435158831?Alright thanks I'll carry on with the newer models no big deal. Just trying to set my expectation level. I have come to find that I need two tools. I like the Leatherman for around the house stuff, especially for the screwdrivers and pliers. I like the SAK for actually carrying with me. I expect to get another 10 years from this new one as well before I lose it. I'll keep the little Camper in my truck.
Greg
-
I've got a few older SAKs. First before I get to that, Welcome.
Ok so those older SAKs, they do "feel" different. I have a one from the early 60s and it feels awesome. The nylon scales will be more scratch resistant than the celidor but that SAK shine on the celidor is pretty sweet. Ever thought to go with Alox? The new Pioneer X has scissors and the scales will develop great character with time. The Alox will also add weight but its a good weight IMO.
-
OK thanks this is good to know. I did look at the Alox they look great. None of them however has a locking blade or corkscrew. I know corkcrew is an afterthought for most, but I live in Washington wine country and my wife works at a winery. So it is important here!
@Aloha007 said:
I've got a few older SAKs. First before I get to that, Welcome.Ok so those older SAKs, they do "feel" different. I have a one from the early 60s and it feels awesome. The nylon scales will be more scratch resistant than the celidor but that SAK shine on the celidor is pretty sweet. Ever thought to go with Alox? The new Pioneer X has scissors and the scales will develop great character with time. The Alox will also add weight but its a good weight IMO.
-
Is there a particular use that you would need a locking blade? Just curious, as that will limit the models available to you. I own a couple Wenger knives with locking blades and they are nice, but for my day to day use it isn't necessary.
-
A locking blade is mostly a nice-to-have for a small knife but, in general I prefer it to lock. I agree that's it's not strictly necessary for this type of tool.
@Roc said:
Is there a particular use that you would need a locking blade? Just curious, as that will limit the models available to you. I own a couple Wenger knives with locking blades and they are nice, but for my day to day use it isn't necessary. -
The only difference between the Climber and Climber II are the nylon scales on the Climber II. Nylon is more durable and doesn't show scratches like cellidor. I have an old Huntsman and except for the grooved corkscrew and beat up scales without toothpick or tweezer slot it feels just like my year old Huntsman.
Sent from my XT1254 using Tapatalk
-
@Inlaw Biker said:
A locking blade is mostly a nice-to-have for a small knife but, in general I prefer it to lock. I agree that's it's not strictly necessary for this type of tool.Is there a particular use that you would need a locking blade? Just curious, as that will limit the models available to you. I own a couple Wenger knives with locking blades and they are nice, but for my day to day use it isn't necessary.
Heart wants what the heart wants. Good luck finding the one for you. I've been at it for years and I've found I like all of them. :(
-
@Inlaw Biker said:
A locking blade is mostly a nice-to-have for a small knife but, in general I prefer it to lock. I agree that's it's not strictly necessary for this type of tool.
Is there a particular use that you would need a locking blade? Just curious, as that will limit the models available to you. I own a couple Wenger knives with locking blades and they are nice, but for my day to day use it isn't necessary.
Heart wants what the heart wants. Good luck finding the one for you. I've been at it for years and I've found I like all of them. :(
So true.

-
Seems like those I own with the old, "Crossbow" stamp opposite the normal one are of slightly higher quality, and have better snap, and seem easier to resharpen (as if they may use a different steel), but modern ones are still excellent quality, unlike many makers have done, by either using inferior materials, outsourcing, or outright sloppy craftsmanship (i.e. Bear and Sons).
Don't go for the locks on the EvoGrips--they're always in the way, hang on my pockets, and make use of the whole knife uncomfortable. To me, personally, a small knife doesn't need a lock at all.
-
Welcome to
and congrats on the new SAK
If you don't like the feeling check Ebay and find either NOS or just a second hand good user
but as others said it may just be the economy scales and the quality of the tools should still be there

-
Many good points again in this forum :) Maybe older models are more man made. So quality does not come only from calculations or facts. But from feeling. Earlier worked with mobiles and there were same issues. Toy like plastic was most durable but that did not feel like good quality. At least mobiles were tested by dropping over and over again. Quite sure mt's has similar quality controls (with biggest brands).
Also locking blades have similar points. When using "correctly" lock is not needed. But again multitools can be used in many tasks. I as well like locking blades. But as well screw drivers. Sadly that means often bigger size as well.
-
You should know that the Evolution series is really the Wenger knife. Actually, its kind of a mix of Wenger and Victorinox.
There are differences in feel and design.- The Wenger's generally have less "snap" on the tools.
- The design of the scissors is different, some prefer the Vic design, others the Wenger.
I find that the Evolution scales add some unnecessary bulk to an otherwise slimmer SAK.
-
OK this is good advice, along with the other responses. Thank you very much for helping me out with this.
I watched some videos of the Evo grips and I agree the locking latch could get in the way of things. I went ahead and ordered a Climber after all, just like my old one! Should be here Monday from Amazon. I have a good Gerber knife that locks so no big deal with this one.
Now that I think of it, I believe my old knife also had the pliers but otherwise was just like the Climber. I distinctly remember never once using the pliers and being kind of annoyed that they were there. So I consider the Climber the perfect knife for what I want to do.
Thanks again,
Greg.@cody6268 said:
Don't go for the locks on the EvoGrips--they're always in the way, hang on my pockets, and make use of the whole knife uncomfortable. To me, personally, a small knife doesn't need a lock at all. -
Amici,
This is a very interesting topic, since this is exactly what I was pondering just the other day due to my latest acquisition.That being a mint or NOS Victorinox Champion that must have been made in the 1980's. Reason I say this, is due to the corkscrew which is profoundly flouted. Besides this, the entire knife does seem to feel more solid overall. the scales I am pretty sure are solid as well, unlike the current runs which no longer are. This Champion feels like a beast in the hand, and despite my opposition to the corkscrew as part of my EDC, I plan on keeping this "as is" and using it as it was meant to be.
Speaking of the flouted corkscrew, the corresponding layer has a pronounced "groove" cut into it, as well as it does not include the package hook.
But going back to the original post, I would definitely agree that you can definitely feel the difference between this Champion of old, as compared to those that are relatively new.
Cheers,
Serge -
This are just my feelings exactly, the new Vic's feel somehow lighter and just not as rock solid as the 80's and 90's ones. The only "vintage" ones i currently have are two small tinkers, one with early 80's awl with the big nail groove, the other late 80's/early 90's with the same awl but smaller nail groove. Everything on them just "feels" more solid and flawless, down to the scales. I polished them and they kept some of the scratches and dings to add character, but feel's real smooth. I have a lot of new 84mm scales but i'll never replace the ones on my vintage sak's. I think the earlier scales where just a solid block of cellidor, only with pockets for the T&T. The newer scales are as we all know hollow'd out inside, so no wonder they feel hollow... :-\
Even the steel just "feels" different, the early ones are a more clear "silver" color. My first Vic, a late 80's spartan with grooved corkscrew (unfortunatly lost :'() felt different than my new ones too. Even the first Vic i ever saw and used when i was a kid, my grandpa's 70's Princess (no T&T) felt rock solid, really indestructible. My classics feel very different from that one.
While still of premium quality i think Victorinox is no different than any other company these days, they have to cut some corners on some areas to keep themselves competitive on the market. It's just the way it is... :-\ -
Amici,
I would agree.. For those of you who recall "my case against the corkscrew" regarding the despised "nick" that occurs on both the liner and back side of the cellidor scale from the placement and use of corkscrew on SAKS which utilize this tool. well this doesn't appear to be an issue at all on this vintage tool since again, both tools and scales seem to be made from a different and tougher standard.Cheers,
Serge
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login