Dullish blade. How to sharpen it and not ruin the edge?
-
In my opinion freehand sharpening is the way to go...it is a lifetime skill that should be cultivated. It might take a while to gain the muscle memory to hold proper angles, but it is worth the effort. Once learned, there is no need for special fixtures or jigs and you will be able to sharpen just about any edged tool...from axes to scissors...
The easiest method to start with is sandpaper sharpening. I do not like using a mousepad even for convex edges...I use a fairly stiff sheet of rubber glued to a board. There are plenty of instructions and videos on the web for sandpaper or mousepad sharpening.
Learn to keep your edges touched up between uses and it will be a long time before you actually need to sharpen.
-
@Spork, Lord of Lime Jello! said:
In my opinion freehand sharpening is the way to go...it is a lifetime skill that should be cultivated. It might take a while to gain the muscle memory to hold proper angles, but it is worth the effort. Once learned, there is no need for special fixtures or jigs and you will be able to sharpen just about any edged tool...from axes to scissors...But…then how will all those marketers of the special fixtures and jigs make money?????
And make no mistake, it's all about the money. People have been sharpening knives and swords since biblical days, with no special fixtures and gizmos. But the marketers have turned knife sharpening into some sort of mythical hyped procedure to intimidate the new comer into thinking it's more complicated than it really is. And they can sell some whiz bang gizmo to you. Think about this; some Roman legionnaire about to fight the Carthaginians, some Crusader camped outside Jerusalem in the third crusade, or some mountain man in the 1830's in the Rocky Mountains after beaver skins, didn't have anything but a smooth rock. Yet they did well with primitive stones. A little leather with some goose oil to strop it on and they were good to go.
Knife sharpening is easier than you think. If you can walk, you can sharpen on a stone.
-
@glenfiddich1983 said:
This is what I use
If you want to be creative and save money just buy a small sharpening stone like the fallkniven DC4 and use an old leather belt for stropping. Also you can use the bottom of a coffee mug and then use a leather belt for stropping. On youtube you can find tips and howtos.
Sharpened the blade of my 1947 Soldier today. The shape of the blade isn't perfect but to make it look perfectly straight and free of chips I would have to remove too much of the blade.
It is shaving sharp though.

While I was busy I also sharpened the kitchen cutlery :D
Nice knife, nice advice. One more thing, you can sharpen the blade on the DC4 or DC3 and then use the stones' pouch/sheath as a strop. Works like a charm

-
@BleaKrytE said:
That would indeed be perfect but the thing is: I got no money, plus parents don't like my SAK (yeah I'm a teenager) so buying a sharpener is a no go.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
How 'bout ..............
Black sharpie marker - to color the edge so you can VISUALLY see what and where you are actually sharpening.
& the "Ol' Bottom of a Porcelain/Ceramic Coffee Cup Trick" :D ? link to many vids: https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=coffee+cup+knife+sharpening
IF you dont have a whetstone of the correct courseness - there are some that are too course and will RUIN your blade(not all stone are the same or good for knives :) ) - the bottom of the cup if FINE in courseness.
-
Favorite knife sharpener;
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/gq2euJ" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://c7.staticflickr.com/8/7429/10117187934_a1b70bcc95_c.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a> -
@Spork, Lord of Lime Jello! said:
The easiest method to start with is sandpaper sharpening. I do not like using a mousepad even for convex edges...I use a fairly stiff sheet of rubber glued to a board. There are plenty of instructions and videos on the web for sandpaper or mousepad sharpening.Learn to keep your edges touched up between uses and it will be a long time before you actually need to sharpen.
^^^ This.
You dont need expensive gear to get a really nice edge on a SAK. If you have chips then you'll need to address those first. I agree with using sand paper if you cannot get your hands on anything else. It will work well when you use a sharpie to mark your cutting edge.
You can also finish the edge on your belt. Use your belt as a strop. You can also strop on cardboard. Look up stopping on cardboard.
-
Thanks guys! I still haven't done it because I don't have the time (and I need to get the mug hidden because people wouldn't like the idea of 'ruining' the mug) but I will post the results as soon as I do it ^^
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
A Spyderco Sharpmaker makes sharpening a consistent angle relatively easy and doesn't mess up the blade: https://www.spyderco.com/catalog/details.php?product=77

-
@BleaKrytE said:
Thanks guys! I still haven't done it because I don't have the time (and I need to get the mug hidden because people wouldn't like the idea of 'ruining' the mug) but I will post the results as soon as I do it ^^Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Beware the Mug Police :ahhh
Good luck

-
So um... Sorry for the late reply! I sharpened it. Kinda... I went the old mug way and I mean, it's better... Not by a lot, but it is considerably sharper. Enough for my daily uses I guess, what do you need a razor sharp blade for sharpening pencils, cutting fruit and the occasional little tree branch?

-
The more blunt the knife was before, the longer you have to spend getting it back sharp. You've proved it was working, you just stopped before you'd finished ;)
-
@50ft-trad said:
The more blunt the knife was before, the longer you have to spend getting it back sharp. You've proved it was working, you just stopped before you'd finished ;)It was working sometimes... I mean, I can't hold the angle steady so sometimes I would just go ten steps backwards and 9 forwards most of the time
Enviado do meu iPhone usando Tapatalk
-
Good work!!! If there's an improvement, you're on the right track. Like with any new skill, it takes time and practice while our brains adjust by making new neuron pathways (or something scientific like that). It'll get easier and more efficient each time until you're a pro eventually.
-
Did you use any marker on the edge to see how your angle is doing?
That's one of the biggest aids, marking the edge to see if you're holding too much of an angle or too shallow an angle. If it's better, then your probably doing pretty good. Just keep at it.
-
I'm a great fan of the Edge Pro. Well, I have a Chinese version, like to one below.

It's great and will sharpen anything from large kitchen knives to small SAK blades. The chinese versions are really cheap and will set you back around $15-$20 (€15,-).
There is a little learning curve but when you get the hang of it... you will have scary sharp blades!
Sharpening stones for this system are really cheap and available in a various grits, as well as diamond plates in various grits. This system will sharpen virtually any knife (except concave blades).But such a system at home is worthless in the field. So I would recommend learning freehand sharpening. When out in the field the Fallkniven DC4 and DC3 stones are a fantastic way to sharpen your knives. I carry a DC3 daily, just in case. They also come in a really nice leather pouch :D
-
Or, you can just carry a cut down Eze-Lap model L in your wallet and sharpen up your knife anytime you need to, anywhere, in a few minutes. SAK's respond to diamond hones very well.
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/nRcmdS" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://c1.staticflickr.com/6/5585/14340214690_20437aa481_c.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>Learning to free hand sharpen gives you total freedom from homebound gizmos that are overly complicated. Sharpening a knife is not rocket science. It's an easy to learn skill if you don't over think it. The problem is, too many merchants like to over complicate it so they can sell you thier over complicated and over priced gizmos that are over hyped.
-
It is definitely worth learning how to sharpen instinctively like cbl51 says in his video.
I basically learned the same way. I used to take one knife and sharpen it and then dull it and sharpen it again, etc. to get better.
You will eventually be able to feel when the knife is at the right angle. Also as you sharpen, start out with firm pressure on the knife and then, once you have established the edge, lighten up on the pressure until the final strokes are done using only the weight of the knife. This will give you a hair shaving edge once you get the feel of it.
Keep practicing.
-
The bevel looks decent enough. I mean you didn't leave it looking uneven or higher than normal. Getting the cutting edge fine tuned is exactly that, fine tuning. After you went the mug route a follow up on your leather belt ( inside ) would have made that edge pop. You can also strop in on the edge of a cardboard box. Slow and easy. Also some people like their edges "toothy" which basically means tiny micro serrations imagine this ^^^^^^ on the cutting edge. No problem with that. Other prefer a razor blade edge which simple put is without the micro serration.
-
Thanks guys! I might try it again and see if I can do any better. Maybe dull and sharpen my classic as I don't use the blade on it anymore, so it wouldn't be a issue if the blade went dull and I could not sharpen it again. As for the marker, I forgot about it! I'll make sure to remember to use it next time :)
Enviado do meu iPhone usando Tapatalk
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login