A call to all those interested in sending Leatherman a message.
-
@Fortytwo said:
I mostly agree with 50ft and Chako. Surely we're not here to replace the Leatherman R&D department? There must be better ways to get across to the producers than a hidden group designing the entire tool. Never mind that most don't have enough knowledge of production design to make anything that would be feasible to produce.How about contacting the big producers and ask how they would like to receive comments and critique? Maybe a single, more strictly moderated, topic for each producer would mean that the, for the producers, relevant comments wont get swamped in the, even more important for us users, banter? Maybe setting up a group of people who could relay the gist of our impressions to the relevant companies, MT.O ambassadors basically. The three big American brands seem to be quite open to this type of communication. Maybe some other way altogether.
Wonderful. Lets not ask, lets produce a specimen for their consideration. Surely they have seen some of MTOs modded tools. Why some ideas are picked up and other not, I wish I knew.
-
We have some very creative and knowledgeable people here. I for one am tired of them dictating to us what we want. We have seen some pretty awesome mods done here. I think many people come to MTO to learn from us. Why not us?
Why them?
Would I be wrong in saying LM tools are in more hands than the others? It doesn't have to be just them. I only picked them because in all honesty I pretty much only have LM tools and quite frankly I didn't think the Spirit needed much improvement.
Why bother?
I am not one to complain and be content. IMO we have relevant ideas and we bring a lot ( collectively ) to the table. We all want the same thing right? We want better tools and we want tools that are more refined. We spend a lot of time discussing tools and evaluating them. We have such opinionated views of every tool that hits the market. We have members who have years of experience and so why not take that huge perspective and see if we can effect change.
Why not bother?Now as far as disappointment or whatever else I hope everyone can keep things into perspective. Is LM going to change the way they do business because a few yahoos say so? Has anyone ever heard of a group of like minded individuals taking it upon themselves to help improve a brand?
To you 50ft, I value your view points and really enjoy reading what you post. Your insights are well regarded and respected. We may not agree on everything however I can always find some common ground with you. I think you would bring a lot to the "table". Lets see how it starts and then decide if you don't want part.
Lastly let me leave you with a quote from Theodor Roosevelt,
It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat.

I think I understand your perspective, though I still feel a little confused as to the objectives and benefits. Are we trying to get the manufacturers to improve designs or manufacturing quality? In other words nudge them towards fixing themselves. Or are we trying to come up with a MT.O design, acknowledging that it may not be commercially viable to a wider audience on a mass production basis?
Who benefits? Is this just for the thrill of the chase, or do we want to achieve an in-hand tool at the end of this? Who owns it? Who picks up tooling costs and commercial risk? What does MT.O and it's members actually gain for this, aside from a "bit of fun".
If this is just a bit of fun, and a nudge to the manufacturers in terms of design criteria rather than a rigid design, how about taking one tool from a number of manufacturers - ideally tools that we have a shared negativity about, and exploring what design changes would take this from an unpopular tool, and turn it into a popular one. This may be helpful to more than one manufacturer, and also doesn't tie us down to one toolset which we can't even agree on ourselves. In effect, we'd be establishing a range of design tickboxes, or sub-criteria that should be factored in.
To agree on the solution, we must first agree on the problem that we are trying to overcome
-
@50ft-trad said:
Why us?
We have some very creative and knowledgeable people here. I for one am tired of them dictating to us what we want. We have seen some pretty awesome mods done here. I think many people come to MTO to learn from us. Why not us?
Why them?
Would I be wrong in saying LM tools are in more hands than the others? It doesn't have to be just them. I only picked them because in all honesty I pretty much only have LM tools and quite frankly I didn't think the Spirit needed much improvement.
Why bother?
I am not one to complain and be content. IMO we have relevant ideas and we bring a lot ( collectively ) to the table. We all want the same thing right? We want better tools and we want tools that are more refined. We spend a lot of time discussing tools and evaluating them. We have such opinionated views of every tool that hits the market. We have members who have years of experience and so why not take that huge perspective and see if we can effect change.
Why not bother?Now as far as disappointment or whatever else I hope everyone can keep things into perspective. Is LM going to change the way they do business because a few yahoos say so? Has anyone ever heard of a group of like minded individuals taking it upon themselves to help improve a brand?
To you 50ft, I value your view points and really enjoy reading what you post. Your insights are well regarded and respected. We may not agree on everything however I can always find some common ground with you. I think you would bring a lot to the "table". Lets see how it starts and then decide if you don't want part.
Lastly let me leave you with a quote from Theodor Roosevelt,
It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat.

I think I understand your perspective, though I still feel a little confused as to the objectives and benefits. Are we trying to get the manufacturers to improve designs or manufacturing quality? In other words nudge them towards fixing themselves. Or are we trying to come up with a MT.O design, acknowledging that it may not be commercially viable to a wider audience on a mass production basis?
Who benefits? Is this just for the thrill of the chase, or do we want to achieve an in-hand tool at the end of this? Who owns it? Who picks up tooling costs and commercial risk? What does MT.O and it's members actually gain for this, aside from a "bit of fun".
If this is just a bit of fun, and a nudge to the manufacturers in terms of design criteria rather than a rigid design, how about taking one tool from a number of manufacturers - ideally tools that we have a shared negativity about, and exploring what design changes would take this from an unpopular tool, and turn it into a popular one. This may be helpful to more than one manufacturer, and also doesn't tie us down to one toolset which we can't even agree on ourselves. In effect, we'd be establishing a range of design tickboxes, or sub-criteria that should be factored in.
To agree on the solution, we must first agree on the problem that we are trying to overcome
Thank you 50.
There is no doubt that LM is slipping when it comes to QC. You sir have very well had your share of issues. It really saddens me to read a new members first post regarding an issue with a LM tool :(. They post asking if its "normal" and we all sadly tell them yes, in so many words. We also tend to "justify" it by telling them "It doesn't effect usability". This really shouldn't happen.
Side story.
When I bought my first Wave the edges were very sharp. I looked online to see if this was a fluke or "normal". I found a video of a lady who took an emory cloth to hers and smoothed down the edges. When I came to MTO sad to read this being the rule and not the exception.
"Are we trying to get the manufacturers to improve designs or manufacturing quality? In other words nudge them towards fixing themselves. Or are we trying to come up with a MT.O design, acknowledging that it may not be commercially viable to a wider audience on a mass production basis?"
I'd hope we are trying to help them fix what is glaringly wrong. Thats my premise at least.
A MTO design? That would be awesome. I have said many times that Evil should be paid by LM for his Skeletool. This is not a simple mod. This is a re-designed tool.
The Tread doesn't appeal to the wider audience IMO either and they ( LM ) went full bore into it. That was IMO a knee jerk reaction to TSA. Another example of the "market" dictating product.
So, honestly I don't exactly know what tool if any we can come up with. If a re-designed tool was accepted by LM and they decided to offer it awesome.
"If this is just a bit of fun, and a nudge to the manufacturers in terms of design criteria rather than a rigid design, how about taking one tool from a number of manufacturers - ideally tools that we have a shared negativity about, and exploring what design changes would take this from an unpopular tool, and turn it into a popular one. This may be helpful to more than one manufacturer, and also doesn't tie us down to one toolset which we can't even agree on ourselves. In effect, we'd be establishing a range of design tickboxes, or sub-criteria that should be factored in."
It was alway meant to be fun
. I'm a fun guy. Hard to tell from letters on a screen tho
.Nudge YES. I really didn't think we'd be making a tool from scratch. Ether likes the Signal, well he wants some changes but still :D.
50ft that last quote is precisely the marching orders I so sadly wasn't able to convey. Let start there and it doesn't just have to be LM. I figured why not start with the big guy.
-
So what tools do we think need our intervention? Nice ideas which just don't deliver as they could/should?
Juice line?
Strata?
PowerDuo?
Bivy? -
@50ft-trad said:
So what tools do we think need our intervention? Nice ideas which just don't deliver as they could/should?Juice line?
Strata?
PowerDuo?
Bivy?I VOTE JUICE.
I dont have the others.
Thank you 50ft. You views and input are greatly appreciated, by me!

We just had a new member post about not being able to close her Juice
. I have all models and would love to carry but one to many cuts and I'm done.Suggestions of implements that would be excellent additions to any Med or Large MT are also more than needed and certainly welcomed.
-
Let the market dictate the business decision at Leatherman. I do not think our opinions matter to them much, as it is obvious that they are catering the cost-conscious audience. In a sense, they are bringing more products to the Wingman/ Sidekick/ Rev price range. Personally, I dislike the color option on the Skele KB than the knife itself. They make the cheap design look cheaper.
-
Like when coke brought back coke classic, I would love to see the pst and mini brougut back! Remember more and more places don't allow lockblades and they are great tools.
-
-
Like when coke brought back coke classic, I would love to see the pst and mini brougut back! Remember more and more places don't allow lockblades and they are great tools.

Id buy a PST Classic. :D They are so much smaller than the wave/surge style, much more pocket friendly.
-
I'd love to see a Skeletool with added scissors and a hammer feature. We've seen it can be done.
-
Am I interested in sending LM a message?
About as much as sending one to VW... about EPA related software issues...
They'll both go belly up and be remembered for their "once" greatness...then forgotten.
-

I would like another mini
-
...

-
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:

I would like another mini
That kind of sums it up right there. We would likely come up with a tool made of a Carbon Fiber/titanium hybrid with diamond edged one handed opening blades and built in solar powered GPS, then complain when the MSRP is $80,000.

Def
Oh Grant...
Price has nothing to do with it... it's about QUALITY...
Or any other adjectives i could come up with... i'll pay any amount of money, that is not the point.
-
Sure.
But what happens when you drop it in the woods and lose it?
I think I'd rather have an F Type Jag for $80k than a fancy plier tool. :P
Def
-
Good one Boss...
-
...but really, people in the collecting or serious MT obtaining world do not really care about price/ Heck I do not... I only care about the hole in my collection or pocket.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login