What Traditional Knife are you toting today?
-
Thanks guys

That is a beauty Dean

-
Thanks all.

-
My first traditional. Case Sodbuster Jr. I EDC'd this for 6 months as my main blade. Rough, tough and with a very strong spring. I had to smooth out a bunch of edges too. I gave up on it for regular carry due to a combination of the 'Tru-Steel' metal which was way too soft, the complete lack of point for any kind of pierce cut on packaging or bread and the hollow grind. It does still get some pouch time. The blade gets razor sharp easily on the strop and it's a very comfortable hand filling handle. Goofing off at home right now so this one will be cutting up lunch for me. I'm currently testing my new Vic Pruner and specifically the edge holding of what is known to be a soft metal so I'm testing it out against a blade I found just too soft for EDC. The Vic so far has been rather surprising me with it's edge holding, a lot better than I'd been led to believe.

-
I had a sod buster as a shop knife for a short while. The son in law used it to scrape dirt out of a couple axle nuts.
So I gave it to him with a gentle comment, that now you don't have to borrow my knife.Case's Tru Sharp is 420HC --- 54-56 HRC --- Carbon .46
Victorinox uses x55CrMo14 -- 56 HRC ------- Carbon .48-.60
Both are fairly soft compared to GEC's 1095 at 57-59 HRCSo there's a little more carbon in your Vic Pruner & I believe Vic has a more consistent heat treat than Case.
The Victorinox has a thinner profile, so that alone will make it seem sharper when it gets worn a bit. -
@pomsbz said:
My first traditional. Case Sodbuster Jr. I EDC'd this for 6 months as my main blade. Rough, tough and with a very strong spring. I had to smooth out a bunch of edges too. I gave up on it for regular carry due to a combination of the 'Tru-Steel' metal which was way too soft, the complete lack of point for any kind of pierce cut on packaging or bread and the hollow grind. It does still get some pouch time. The blade gets razor sharp easily on the strop and it's a very comfortable hand filling handle. Goofing off at home right now so this one will be cutting up lunch for me. I'm currently testing my new Vic Pruner and specifically the edge holding of what is known to be a soft metal so I'm testing it out against a blade I found just too soft for EDC. The Vic so far has been rather surprising me with it's edge holding, a lot better than I'd been led to believe.

-
The Cammie again!!! Love this knife!!!

-
Peachseed IRJ again.

-
Nice ones today all !

-
Back to the Remi today.

-
Thanks buddy

-
[quote author=kaput link=topic=68477.msg1419826#msg1419826 date=1485797472]
Anyone have any medium stockmans? How do you like them? Is it handy to have the threee blades?The 4 1/4" were just to long for me to pocket carry.
I'm thinking the mediums are 3 7/8 to 4", they were my primary carry for 25 years or so. They are a true jack of all trades knife, from cardboard to small game.
I carried a 3 1/4" as a second quite often, a little more pocket friendly.Just bought one. Thanks for the information Dean. Sounds like it'll be a fun useful knife to have in my pockets. Pictures to come!!

Does that mean if you don't like it, it's my fault. :ahhhI think it'll all be quite ok. ;) I've been reading a little more after the fact. It seems to be quite a tried and true design that's been around for ages. Why not give it a go. I'm stoked :ahhh
[/quote]I'm another who strongly recommends that size, and the knife period I carry the most. Large is too big for everyday carry (can be uncomfortable in some pants), but it's what I've got the most of. Medium is big enough for large, tough cutting chores, but fits nice in about all my pants, including sweatpants, which I wear around the house, and even do farm chores in. I've got three of them, maybe four . Small feels like a toy--I borrowed a Case Small Stockman from my grandfather to try the pattern, and hated it. Honestly, with small Stockmen, I'm surprised there isn't a little bail to hook it to your keys.
Here's the Case 63087 in Boy Scout clothes, which I coincidentally carried today. I got it as a Christmas gift years ago from my folks when I joined the BSA, but if it was up to me to pick it out, it would have been the 3318, which has the traditional arrangement of sheepsfoot, clip, and spey blades. This one (the 63087 pattern) moves the spey to the middle, and trades the sheepsfoot for a pen blade. I dislike that arrangement, but it's a sold knife. Oh, and by the way, get the knife in CV, Tru-Sharp, and 420HC in general is a pain to sharpen, but if you don't think you're up to maintaining CV, Tru-Sharp ain't bad.
I lost the shield a decade ago, but I just got a reply back from the warranty form I filled out on the Case website this past weekend--should get a new shield sent to me in a month or less.
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/QqSF2x" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://c1.staticflickr.com/1/337/31786607653_6bc8490f16_c.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>2017-01-29_06-35-26 by cody6268, on Flickr
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



