The SAK Whittling Club
-

This makes me happy. Nice job, nice pic.
-
A little mushroom/toadstool I did earlier today. Doesn't look like much but I'm pleased with it!
Very cool.
-
That's a cool project C-Unit
I'm glad you whittled an non-poisonous one. 
-
Thanks all! I painted the little mushroom on the weekend too, quite pleased with how it turned out!
Anyone have any experience with woodcuts/wood printing? I experimented a little on the weekend and got mixed results - and apologies for off-topic discussion - i tried a little with linocuts as well and am fairly happy with how they turned out. At work at the moment but will post pics later!
With more intricate whittling designs, I'm having trouble getting good thin clean cuts, even with a variety of good, sharp knives - there seems to be always splinters and jagged edges. Is this "normal"? Would it be best to leave that stuff for sanding/filing at the very end of the project?
-
@caninesapien said:
Thanks all! I painted the little mushroom on the weekend too, quite pleased with how it turned out!Anyone have any experience with woodcuts/wood printing? I experimented a little on the weekend and got mixed results - and apologies for off-topic discussion - i tried a little with linocuts as well and am fairly happy with how they turned out. At work at the moment but will post pics later!
With more intricate whittling designs, I'm having trouble getting good thin clean cuts, even with a variety of good, sharp knives - there seems to be always splinters and jagged edges. Is this "normal"? Would it be best to leave that stuff for sanding/filing at the very end of the project?
Perhaps it's the choice of wood?
Woodcut printmaking - Letterpress Commons
Woodcut tools and techniques for letterpress printing
Letterpress Commons (letterpresscommons.com)
-
@caninesapien said:
With more intricate whittling designs, I'm having trouble getting good thin clean cuts, even with a variety of good, sharp knives - there seems to be always splinters and jagged edges. Is this "normal"? Would it be best to leave that stuff for sanding/filing at the very end of the project?I'm not entirely sure what you mean and besides I'm hardly an expert whittler but I hope I can offer some insight anyway. First of all it's the material, some woods, will never take very crisp features. This seems to be the natural state of some woods while others become like this due to exposure to the elements. Second factor I would guess on is the edge grind. To make really thin cuts you kind of want to slice of the material, so any grind style that works well for that should work fine, I prefer either a Scandi-grind or a full flat (much like you would see on a kitchen knife). Either will take a micro-bevel since I do honing on a honing steel but they will be extremely small compared to what is normally seen on production knives (you'd be hard pressed to see them with bare eyes).
-
Going in the right direction relative to the grain is important too, I would think. I'm no carver but I know when you plane a board, it will plain smoothly in one direction, but in the opposite direction you get lots of tear-out of the grain. Imagine the wood fibres as a bundle of straws, lying in the direction of the grain lines. If cut as though you're smoothing them down, they will cut smoothly. If you go in the opposite direction, the blade will tend to slide between the fibres and lift them up.
-
Thanks for the replies all. I'm doing my best to carve with the grain, but when I'm getting into more intricate sections (e.g. on the small wood spirit I carved recently, I found I was having trouble with the contours of the face), I find that trying to go with the grain can be difficult and i would end up getting splinters which ruins the finer details. I'm using basswood planks for practice and they have been fine. Maybe I just need more practice! Thanks again all.
-
Has anyone ever whittled a wand? (Like of Harry Potter)
My 5 year old has just decided she loves Harry Potter and I was thinking of giving one a try.
-
Then I guess you did it right

-
@Pattas29 said:
Has anyone ever whittled a wand? (Like of Harry Potter)My 5 year old has just decided she loves Harry Potter and I was thinking of giving one a try.
Yes - my daughter whittled herself a Hermione Granger wand when she was little - it's beautiful and she still has it now at 19.
Just try and find one that is already nice and thin but strong and will fit her hand. Here's a pic of my daughters:
WP_20170223_022 by magpie2112, on Flickr -
I cobbled together a knife from parts and did the sharpened can opener and gouge mod on the can opener. Didn't get much of a curve on the gouge because there's just not enough thickness on the can opener.
My opinion is that it's not worth altering a good knife for. I did manage to carve a spoon bowl using mostly the gouge/cap lifter...didn't care for the sharpened can opener at all, although it did serve OK as a scraper to smooth out the bowl. Carving seasoned Poplar was pretty tedious...might be better using green wood.


-
A few days ago I whittled a spoon using my SAK Climber and an Opinel No.7, but just as I was detailing the handle it snapped in half in my hand

Going to start again soon but trying to do it on the sly as a present for my girlfriend so finding time is difficult!
Also I wanted to ask if anyone has any experience with whittling a wood whistle/recorder (as in an instrument with pitch/tone holes)?
-
@caninesapien said:
A few days ago I whittled a spoon using my SAK Climber and an Opinel No.7, but just as I was detailing the handle it snapped in half in my hand
Going to start again soon but trying to do it on the sly as a present for my girlfriend so finding time is difficult!
Also I wanted to ask if anyone has any experience with whittling a wood whistle/recorder (as in an instrument with pitch/tone holes)?
Armchair "expert" comment here(I have no carving experience or musical instrument making abilities), but something with pitch holes would be an ambitious undertaking to get anything to sound right. You also need a hollow tube all the way through. A fixed pitch whistle "should" be an easier undertaking
-
A few days ago I whittled a spoon using my SAK Climber and an Opinel No.7, but just as I was detailing the handle it snapped in half in my hand

Going to start again soon but trying to do it on the sly as a present for my girlfriend so finding time is difficult!
Also I wanted to ask if anyone has any experience with whittling a wood whistle/recorder (as in an instrument with pitch/tone holes)?
Armchair "expert" comment here(I have no carving experience or musical instrument making abilities), but something with pitch holes would be an ambitious undertaking to get anything to sound right. You also need a hollow tube all the way through. A fixed pitch whistle "should" be an easier undertaking
Yes, I think the whistle might be a more sensible place to start :)
I made good progress with a spoon recently, until my mind wandered a little (after a couple of hours of work) and it snapped in half :( oh well, at least it was good practice.
-
Hopefully the next one goes well and your girlfriend appreciates the thought and work that went into making it

-
I don't know if this counts as whittling per se, but it did include a lot of whittling and was done exclusively with my Vic farmer: https://www.youtube.com/embed/z0G7ok4FJjw
-
@NumberThree said:
I don't know if this counts as whittling per se, but it did include a lot of whittling and was done exclusively with my Vic farmer: https://www.youtube.com/embed/z0G7ok4FJjwFantastic! Love it.

-
@NumberThree said:
I don't know if this counts as whittling per se, but it did include a lot of whittling and was done exclusively with my Vic farmer: http://www.youtube.com/embed/z0G7ok4FJjwWonderful!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
