My Juice
-
Leatherman have no one to blame but themselves for the Juice line not being more popular - they haven't made any meaningful changes to the line. They should add tweezers/toothpick/pin/pen to the scales and offer a pocket clip. Also, offer different tool combos, such as the one Yud created. I really like the Juice, it's well built and a very handy size.
The scales on the juice just cover the skeleton of the tool, there isn't any room for any removable parts without making the tool wider. The Juice Pro however, has a plastic spacer that is used to hold a tweezers. I think there is room for more of these without widening the tool that could hold a stick pin or a tooth pick, a pen however would be a more ambitious mod, but there is some genius modders around here. I have a few other ideas for some cool juice mods, but I would need someone else to do them or have an endless supply of juices to destroy as I learn how
Trust me in comparison to taking the thing apart a scale mod is easy. You just have to have the skills to cut the grooves in the scales, the bigger problem is working out what goes where.
But more to the point there is no reason that LM had to make the scales the way they did. They could of made them bigger to include scale tools or they could of added them other places. Also I don't think adding extra width to a juice is all that horrible.
The advantage of the Juice is that it packs a lot of good sized tools in a small package. Once you get beyond the KF4 size, the advantage of the Juice becomes moot. Might as well get a Rebar once you are going that big.
-
Leatherman have no one to blame but themselves for the Juice line not being more popular - they haven't made any meaningful changes to the line. They should add tweezers/toothpick/pin/pen to the scales and offer a pocket clip. Also, offer different tool combos, such as the one Yud created. I really like the Juice, it's well built and a very handy size.
The scales on the juice just cover the skeleton of the tool, there isn't any room for any removable parts without making the tool wider. The Juice Pro however, has a plastic spacer that is used to hold a tweezers. I think there is room for more of these without widening the tool that could hold a stick pin or a tooth pick, a pen however would be a more ambitious mod, but there is some genius modders around here. I have a few other ideas for some cool juice mods, but I would need someone else to do them or have an endless supply of juices to destroy as I learn how
Trust me in comparison to taking the thing apart a scale mod is easy. You just have to have the skills to cut the grooves in the scales, the bigger problem is working out what goes where.
But more to the point there is no reason that LM had to make the scales the way they did. They could of made them bigger to include scale tools or they could of added them other places. Also I don't think adding extra width to a juice is all that horrible.
The advantage of the Juice is that it packs a lot of good sized tools in a small package. Once you get beyond the KF4 size, the advantage of the Juice becomes moot. Might as well get a Rebar once you are going that big.
I am not talking about adding that much thickness, about 1/8" to either side and you come out with the plus tool set. You might be able to trim that down even farther, with the Wenger tools. Now that does put a kf4 at about 3/4" which is not huge.
Also there is a fair amount of space in juices for the half length tools, enough for a cross cut style toothpick.
-
I suspect it is because the Juice line is leathermans least popular line if tools, because they are trying to compete with the same niche that SAKs already dominate. Plus, I know of only one store in the area (5th largest metropolitan area in the USA) that has any Juices (and they only have two in stock), so availability is probably an issue as well.
Leatherman have no one to blame but themselves for the Juice line not being more popular - they haven't made any meaningful changes to the line. They should add tweezers/toothpick/pin/pen to the scales and offer a pocket clip. Also, offer different tool combos, such as the one Yud created. I really like the Juice, it's well built and a very handy size.
Actually, I'm pretty sure the bigger problem with the Juice line is that there are too many models. There were originally five models, plus a couple of special editions, each available in two scale color variations: that's fourteen SKUs for distributors and retailers to manage. Few stores are gonna take up space in the stockroom / display case for even half of the lineup, so consumer choices are limited.
That said, I do think Leatherman's original line-up was flawed; they had two ultra-minimal models, the S2 and C2; two four-layer models, the CS4 and KF4; and the six-layer XE6, which was so thick it defeated the purpose of a smaller tool.
IMNSHO four layers is the sweet spot, not as bulky as the XE6/Pro, but with room for more functionality than the two-layer models. Yet the two models in that configuration were both poor choices for EDC. The CS4 is schizophrenic; it includes scissors and a corkscrew, typical of "suburban" EDC tools, but also a saw and awl, which are more for outdoor use. Likewise, the KF4 was poorly thought out, with not one but two knife blades, and again, a saw.
Yet for some reason Leatherman declined to make a four-layer model with the sort of implements that are expected for a suburban / office EDC tool: one knife blade, that awesome diamond-coated file, scissors, bottle/can opener. (And of course the screwdrivers, duh.) It wouldn't have been difficult: take the CS4 and replace the saw with scissors; or take the KF4 and replace the saw or serrated blade with scissors and the opener. Worse, they killed off the KF4, rather than modifying it to be more useful.
We'll never know now, of course, but personally I think a model like that would've sold well. After years of waiting for Leatherman to build it, I got tired of waiting, and made my own.
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/G72zt1" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm2.staticflickr.com/1575/26322477386_f5cc9909c8_b.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
Maybe somebody at Leatherman will see the light, and make an actual EDC Juice. Maybe…
-
@Gryffin said:
IMNSHO four layers is the sweet spot, not as bulky as the XE6/Pro, but with room for more functionality than the two-layer models. Yet the two models in that configuration were both poor choices for EDC. The CS4 is schizophrenic; it includes scissors and a corkscrew, typical of "suburban" EDC tools, but also a saw and awl, which are more for outdoor use. Likewise, the KF4 was poorly thought out, with not one but two knife blades, and again, a saw.Yet for some reason Leatherman declined to make a four-layer model with the sort of implements that are expected for a suburban / office EDC tool: one knife blade, that awesome diamond-coated file, scissors, bottle/can opener. (And of course the screwdrivers, duh.) It wouldn't have been difficult: take the CS4 and replace the saw with scissors; or take the KF4 and replace the saw or serrated blade with scissors and the opener. Worse, they killed off the KF4, rather than modifying it to be more useful.
We'll never know now, of course, but personally I think a model like that would've sold well. After years of waiting for Leatherman to build it, I got tired of waiting, and made my own.
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/G72zt1" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm2.staticflickr.com/1575/26322477386_f5cc9909c8_b.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
Maybe somebody at Leatherman will see the light, and make an actual EDC Juice. Maybe…
This is a sadly a very common problem that shows up in far to many models (half the market for OPTs seems to do this, cram in tools that don't compliment eachother). Not falling for this trap might be one of the best parts of models like the MUT and Signal (or the Flair for that matter).
-
@Fortytwo said:
This is a sadly a very common problem that shows up in far to many models (half the market for OPTs seems to do this, cram in tools that don't compliment each other).What's the old saying? "Just because you can doesn't mean you should. ;)
@Fortytwo said:
Not falling for this trap might be one of the best parts of models like the MUT and Signal (or the Flair for that matter).Heh heh, the Flair gets little respect, but there's no denying it was very well focused on the mission. Likewise the MUT and Signal, they have a specific purpose, and just about everything on them is designed to contribute to that mission.
The danger in such focused tools is, they have a limited, specialized market – perhaps even falling into the dreaded "niche" hole.
After posting that, I decided to email a more through version to Leatherman's marketing folks. I described the two four-layer models they should have released:
• A “CF4” optimized for suburban/indoor/office duty; knife blade, scissors, corkscrew/assist/caplifter, and that amazing diamond-coated file – basically a CS4 with the file in place of the wood saw/awl. Bonus points if it also had the lexan insert and Style tweezers from the Juice Pro! (Basically what I did, minus the foil cutter blade.)
• A “WS4” optimized for outdoor/backyard/hiking/camping roles; one knife blade, wood saw/awl, file, scissors/can opener – basically the KF4 with the scissors/can opener in place of the extra knife blade.
I dunno about you, but I would've bought one of each of those. And probably some spares, too.
(I forgot to mention that they really, really need belt pouches for the Juice that don't utterly and thoroughly suck. They've only had, what, fifteen years to come up with a better one, right?)
-
One more entry in the saga of my Juice, bocote scales.
It only took me 9 months to finish them

-
-
Just about to get a s2 so reading up on mods done (why invent the wheel again and so forth). Love your modding technique. Thinking of tweezers and toothpick - you can easily move over from SAK to either buffalo or wooden. The tweezer heads can be of any material tbh. Just thinking out loud
~ if you're not good, be creative ~
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login