SAK's - Corkscrew or Phillips?
-
@50ft-trad said:
I can't believe that nobody has given the standard MTO response to this thread yet...... get both!
I did! I said "Both, carry a Yeoman or Explorer
" - these have an inline Phillips (where it's more useful) and a corkscrew on the back...And let us not forget about the venerated Woodsman which carried the Explorer to the next level, errr, ummm, layer too, I suppose.

John
-
Sex is as unnatural than using SAK corkscrew.
-
Awesome mod and tools, but the rambler has a tiny cute philips for electronics work!

-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
Awesome mod and tools, but the rambler has a tiny cute philips for electronics work!
This is one of the reasons why it can be a good idea to carry both a Rambler and a larger SAK with a #2 Phillips, then you've got the majority of commonly-encountered Phillips screw sizes coverd!
-
Just found this thread after searching for this very topic. I was a little surprised that the corkscrew was not beating the phillips by more. But maybe that's just me being corkscrewcentric. Definitely wins for me, especially when carrying a SAK with the opener layer. The Explorer is the answer for many but with a Rambler/Manager on the keychain I usually feel adequately equipped with a 2-layer.
-
@El Corkscrew said:
Just found this thread after searching for this very topic. I was a little surprised that the corkscrew was not beating the phillips by more. But maybe that's just me being corkscrewcentric. Definitely wins for me, especially when carrying a SAK with the opener layer. The Explorer is the answer for many but with a Rambler/Manager on the keychain I usually feel adequately equipped with a 2-layer.You like the corkscrew?
No way!? -
The corkscrew dates back to 1897, the Phillips to 1952. I don't consider the Phillips an improvement, but rather a falsification. The resulting knife is not an officer's knife, but a mechanic's. :D
-
@El Corkscrew said:
Just found this thread after searching for this very topic. I was a little surprised that the corkscrew was not beating the phillips by more. But maybe that's just me being corkscrewcentric. Definitely wins for me, especially when carrying a SAK with the opener layer. The Explorer is the answer for many but with a Rambler/Manager on the keychain I usually feel adequately equipped with a 2-layer.
You like the corkscrew?
No way!?
Now you know... Hope this doesn't change anything.... -
I'll translate for those of you who don't speak German.
According to Captain Cork, I'm telling the truth, for sure. I don't mean to offend any mechanics among you, but to me an officer's knife needs a corkscrew to deserve the name. Looking beyond Victorinox, it appears that no other European manufacturer implements Phillips screwdrivers, the corkscrew is a must on this type of knife.
-
If I was carrying two SAKs, one would have Philips and the other would have Corkscrew. The end. :D
-
@Ronald Schröder said:
I'll translate for those of you who don't speak German.According to Captain Cork, I'm telling the truth, for sure. I don't mean to offend any mechanics among you, but to me an officer's knife needs a corkscrew to deserve the name. Looking beyond Victorinox, it appears that no other European manufacturer implements Phillips screwdrivers, the corkscrew is a must on this type of knife.
C'mon RS, *everyone * speaks German. Duh
in a video I heard someone pronounce rostfrei "roastery"

-
@El Corkscrew said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
I'll translate for those of you who don't speak German.
According to Captain Cork, I'm telling the truth, for sure. I don't mean to offend any mechanics among you, but to me an officer's knife needs a corkscrew to deserve the name. Looking beyond Victorinox, it appears that no other European manufacturer implements Phillips screwdrivers, the corkscrew is a must on this type of knife.
C'mon RS, *everyone * speaks German. Duh
in a video I heard someone pronounce rostfrei "roastery"

Try the Dutch roestvrij.
-
Anyway, if you need a Phillips, go get a SwissChamp or another one with the inline tool. I've heard that the backside Phillips is no good to begin with.
-
@Ronald Schröder said:
Anyway, if you need a Phillips, go get a SwissChamp or another one with the inline tool. I've heard that the backside Phillips is no good to begin with.You've "heard" lol! You are a true-blue corkscrew! Even with my moniker, I do have several SAKs with the backside phillips. One of my favs is a 60's super tinker w/ the file on the driver, at least the driver got some use that way. :P
And I do love the Fisherman, still looking for the old Fisherman (Or is it Angler?) w/ corkscrew.
-
@El Corkscrew said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
Anyway, if you need a Phillips, go get a SwissChamp or another one with the inline tool. I've heard that the backside Phillips is no good to begin with.
You've "heard" lol! You are a true-blue corkscrew! Even with my moniker, I do have several SAKs with the backside phillips. One of my favs is a 60's super tinker w/ the file on the driver, at least the driver got some use that way. :P
And I do love the Fisherman, still looking for the old Fisherman (Or is it Angler?) w/ corkscrew.
There's one Phillips Fisherman in my collection ...

-
@Ronald Schröder said:
@El Corkscrew said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
Anyway, if you need a Phillips, go get a SwissChamp or another one with the inline tool. I've heard that the backside Phillips is no good to begin with.
You've "heard" lol! You are a true-blue corkscrew! Even with my moniker, I do have several SAKs with the backside phillips. One of my favs is a 60's super tinker w/ the file on the driver, at least the driver got some use that way. :P
And I do love the Fisherman, still looking for the old Fisherman (Or is it Angler?) w/ corkscrew.
There's one Phillips Fisherman in my collection ...
Well, at least it's still in mint condition.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login