MT's as a defensive weapon ...
-
[I agree with your 1st plan of action....but....Part 2 does not sound like you are in immanent danger of death or great bodily harm (bodily harm yes but not GBH). I don't know what state your in but you need to articulate more than your about to be punched in order to shoot someone.
[/quote]wrong if a perp is about to smash in my rolled up window then he is about to do me bodily harm and I do not know if he will stop just because I am hurt. Flying glass is a lethal hazard and I am not about to risk my life on the generosity of some thug. If he is bold and angry enough to knock my window in on me he is angry enough to kill me too. Therefore I do my best to stop the threat dead in its tracks.
-
[quote author=One Lame Frog link=topic=7600.msg145086#msg145086 date=1228165904]
[quote author=cgk link=topic=7600.msg144993#msg144993 date=1228143857]The reality of it is that these situations are so rare, and more often than not the overzealous defender gets slapped with all kinds of charges too. Especially when you're not a cop. :D
for every rare realityof the overzealous defender I guarantee that I can post 3 justifiable shootings that saved a life or lives not counting the perp
-
A couple guys I know have used a knife in a self-defense situation and believe me, carrying a knife for "self defense" doesn't fly. Nor does the much prefered, "I use it to whittle." Explaining why you carry and why you used any kind of weapon will be your problem. Porbably cause is actually hard to come by, don't expect it to call into your lap. Hell, even cops have problems with things like blunt force trauma. If the law enforcement agency can't get away with it, neither can you!
And another thing. If you've never trained with the weapon, don't use it. You're as likely to get hurt as the other guy.
EDIT: Forgot to throw in here that I live in the city, so, you could very likely get away with all kinds of things elsewhere. :D
[/quote]1st of all I am not trying to get away with it I am trying to survive. Then as far as me not using a weapon out of fear that I might get hurt because I have not trained with it. Well duh the guy is about to hurt you if you don't. This is a situation where you have nothing to loose. I choose me over the perp any day.
-
There aren't many situations where you'd get injured without escalating the situation yourself. :D
I'd rather nurse a few bruises and cuts than spend a couple months bored out of my mind in a tiny cell.
-
@ephraim said:
[I agree with your 1st plan of action....but....Part 2 does not sound like you are in immanent danger of death or great bodily harm (bodily harm yes but not GBH). I don't know what state your in but you need to articulate more than your about to be punched in order to shoot someone.wrong if a perp is about to smash in my rolled up window then he is about to do me bodily harm and I do not know if he will stop just because I am hurt. Flying glass is a lethal hazard and I am not about to risk my life on the generosity of some thug. If he is bold and angry enough to knock my window in on me he is angry enough to kill me too. Therefore I do my best to stop the threat dead in its tracks.
[/quote]
" he is about to do me bodily harm"=does not rise to a legally justifiable deadly force situation, must be great bodily harm or death.
"Flying glass is a lethal hazard"=Auto safety glass is not a lethal hazard.
" If he is bold and angry enough to knock my window in on me he is angry enough to kill me too."=What your saying is any one who looks like they are going to punch you justifies your use of deadly force on them....law does not support that.You can not draw too many conclusions what you must say is 1-he had a weapon capable of causing death or GBH 2-he had the means to use it (displaying a knife at me 100 yards away-he has no means to use it) 3-he has the intent to cause death or GBH (my friend has a weapon at the range--no intent to use it on me).
In this situation the weapons are his hands, and you are drawing a big assumption that his intent is to kill you and that he is able to do it with his hands. Look I would like to shoot everyone that takes a poke at me....but I would be a criminal under current laws.
Its up to you whether you agree with me or not but I am telling you I have a great deal of training in this field.
-
Ephraim--I do not mean to come off as argumentative, if I have I am sorry. We are more like minded than not, I support your right to defend yourself 100 percent. We disagree about a situation that is full of what if's. If you lived near me I would offer to discuss this over a beer....I would buy (well the first one anyway).
-
What if you got in a traffic altercation? and the huge guy got down from his car and shouted invectives at you and kicked your car and seemed in a very combative mood? Would pull out the knife in your Mt? or get a pepper spray,or poke a gun in his face, or just say "hi Handsome?" :D
If I am not blocked by traffic, I drive off and get his plates to turn into the police for damage to my vehicle. If I am stuck I grab my pistol but never raise it until he is actually in the process of swinging at my rolled up window and sending glass in on me, then I send two to three hollow points out at him.
I agree with your 1st plan of action....but....Part 2 does not sound like you are in immanent danger of death or great bodily harm (bodily harm yes but not GBH). I don't know what state your in but you need to articulate more than your about to be punched in order to shoot someone.
Yes, that definitely would depend on what state you're in. In Missouri, I would not need more than the fact that he is breaking in attempt to enter my vehicle while I'm occupying it in order to shoot him. In MO, our Castle Doctrine laws are extended to the vehicles we occupy, and anyone who legally owns a handgun can carry one, open or concealed, in his vehicle.
-
What if you got in a traffic altercation? and the huge guy got down from his car and shouted invectives at you and kicked your car and seemed in a very combative mood? Would pull out the knife in your Mt? or get a pepper spray,or poke a gun in his face, or just say "hi Handsome?" :D
If I am not blocked by traffic, I drive off and get his plates to turn into the police for damage to my vehicle. If I am stuck I grab my pistol but never raise it until he is actually in the process of swinging at my rolled up window and sending glass in on me, then I send two to three hollow points out at him.
I agree with your 1st plan of action....but....Part 2 does not sound like you are in immanent danger of death or great bodily harm (bodily harm yes but not GBH). I don't know what state your in but you need to articulate more than your about to be punched in order to shoot someone.
Yes, that definitely would depend on what state you're in. In Missouri, I would not need more than the fact that he is breaking in attempt to enter my vehicle while I'm occupying it in order to shoot him. In MO, our Castle Doctrine laws are extended to the vehicles we occupy, and anyone who legally owns a handgun can carry one, open or concealed, in his vehicle.
I stand (or rather sit) corrected. Thanks for the education. I am in Wisconsin (the courts think we are in California) and use of deadly force is much more restrictive, we do not have the Castle Doctrine even for......our castle. In this situation we would need to show the bad guy was trying to enter the vehicle, not just damage it.....though it would certainly help the defense of force.
-
I agree with your 1st plan of action....but....Part 2 does not sound like you are in immanent danger of death or great bodily harm (bodily harm yes but not GBH). I don't know what state your in but you need to articulate more than your about to be punched in order to shoot someone.
wrong if a perp is about to smash in my rolled up window then he is about to do me bodily harm and I do not know if he will stop just because I am hurt. Flying glass is a lethal hazard and I am not about to risk my life on the generosity of some thug. If he is bold and angry enough to knock my window in on me he is angry enough to kill me too. Therefore I do my best to stop the threat dead in its tracks.
" he is about to do me bodily harm"=does not rise to a legally justifiable deadly force situation, must be great bodily harm or death.
"Flying glass is a lethal hazard"=Auto safety glass is not a lethal hazard.
" If he is bold and angry enough to knock my window in on me he is angry enough to kill me too."=What your saying is any one who looks like they are going to punch you justifies your use of deadly force on them....law does not support that.You can not draw too many conclusions what you must say is 1-he had a weapon capable of causing death or GBH 2-he had the means to use it (displaying a knife at me 100 yards away-he has no means to use it) 3-he has the intent to cause death or GBH (my friend has a weapon at the range--no intent to use it on me).
In this situation the weapons are his hands, and you are drawing a big assumption that his intent is to kill you and that he is able to do it with his hands. Look I would like to shoot everyone that takes a poke at me....but I would be a criminal under current laws.
Its up to you whether you agree with me or not but I am telling you I have a great deal of training in this field.
[/quote]
What I am saying is that not if i just think a person might punch me but if a person is in the process of arm drawn back fist balled up or with a weapon in the hand at my window while within that process he presents threat to me. With glass shards coming in on me and a crazed lunatic hitting me with his weapon or beating me to death comes to mind then he constitutes a grave and immanent threat, of which I have a legal right to shoot. My vehicle unlike in the UK is personal property and I can defend my self if I feel that my life is in danger or to save someone elses. The key is if you feel your life is in danger. I can reasonably assume that my life would be indanger from an assailant who would be willing to in traffic in front of possibly hundreds of witnesses use a weapon or fist to bash in my window to get at me. He is not bashing my window in to get at me to give me a nice big kiss. I have every reason to believe that he intends serious bodily harm or even death which if I have the acess to a firearm I will preserve my life before I worry about his.
-
@cgk said:
Ephraim--I do not mean to come off as argumentative, if I have I am sorry. We are more like minded than not, I support your right to defend yourself 100 percent. We disagree about a situation that is full of what if's. If you lived near me I would offer to discuss this over a beer....I would buy (well the first one anyway).I drink Molson Ice or Labatts :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login