The Humble Utility Knife.
-
Mastercraft Utility Knife
Another Canadian Tire branded utility knife with a very different feature, much like the others in this series. This one is very unique in having a ratchet mechanism controlled by a sliding button. One way for forward movement, center to lock, and the other for backward movement. Like a real ratchet, you can lock the blade in many degrees. The annoying thing about this mechanism however, is that you have to constantly play with the sliding master button...but once you get used to this, there is no going back.
Pros:
- all metal textured body
- wheel blade exchanging mechanism
- ratchet mechanism
- included carabiner
Cons:
- no pocket clip
- ratchet mechanism
Overall, another good utility knife with a unique twist. The ratchet mechanism isn't as simple to use as most others, but it offers you blade angle locking flexibility that no other utility knife on the market can.
-
Stanley Fat Max Utility Knife.
Stanley's folder in the Fat Max lineup, this utility knife is fat for its size. This makes the knife comfortable for my big paws. Hidden inside is an extra blade storage compartment. This is good. What isn't so good however is the open design of said storage compartment. This is problematic seeing that these blades usually have a thin coating of oil which if you are cutting chip rock, will gunk up these blades before you can use them. On the other hand, you can tell how many you have stored away with a quick glance. There is an added feature to this knife...and that is the included flat driver/bottle opener seen pocking out of the blade pivot point when the knife is closed. Pocket clip is narrow...argh!
Pros:
- good blade swapping mechanism
- extra blade storage
- bottle opener/flat driver
- positive liner lock
- fat ergonomics
Cons:
- pocket clip is of the narrow variant
- extra blade storage compartment open to the environment
Overall, a nice folder with a few design flaws.
-
Irwin Utility Knife.
Here is a nice compact utility knife from Irwin which is owned by Stanley Black & Decker. The liner lock is a good one with a positive lock. There is an included wire cutter feature, the pocket clip, although has a narrow tip, splays out nice and wide to better hold the knife in place. The one let down of this knife is the blade retention mechanism. It is a bit fiddly to press the button to disengage the blade retention mechanism. I really like the shape of this knife...but for me, if I have to struggle to exchange a blade, it sort of ruins it for me. The Irwin Utility knife does this for me.
Pros:
- ergonomic and compact shape
- pocket clip does a good job of keeping the knife in place
- positive liner lock done right
Cons:
- blade exchange mechanism
Overall, a great little knife with a poorly designed blade exchanging mechanism.
-
Unknown Brand Utility Knife.
Here is another unknown brand utility knife. The rounded shape of this knife makes it very comfortable for extended use. The paint is bright and makes the tool easy to find. The blade exchange mechanism is one of the good designs. Press down on the metal stud lifts a bar which disengages with the grooves on the utility blade. Simple and positive every time. The pocket clip is narrow, which is a common lament of mine.
Pros:
- all metal construction with ergonomic rounded edges
- excellent blade swapping mechanism
- easy to find paint colour
Cons:
- Paint won't last hard use
- pocket clip is narrow
Overall, a nice little utility knife that is fairly well thought out. The blade exchange system is a winner, as is the body shape of this knife.
-
Unknown Brand Utility Knife.
If I thought the above knife offers ergonomics, this one is so much better. That body shape fits my pawns to perfection with its rounded edges. Furthermore, there is a sliding button locking mechanism that will prevent the blade from opening in your pocket. This sliding button is silky smooth and give me more feedback than a button seen on many other utility knives. In other aspects, this knife is very similar to the one mentioned in the previous post. Both have that winner type blade swapping mechanism. Both are painted a bright reddish colour. Both offer the same type of pocket clip.
Pros:
- all metal construction with ergonomic rounded edges
- excellent blade swapping mechanism
- easy to find paint colour
Cons:
- Paint won't last hard use
- pocket clip is narrow
Overall, I like this one a little better than the previous utility knife for its rounded shape and locking mechanism.
-
COAST Utility Knife.
I must say, this is a rather largish utility knife that does offer extra blade storage in the handle. How it gets there is problematic. Much like that slider utility knife that hinged and made the whole knife rather a hand full, this one does the same. The handle hinges, making the knife awkward to juggle. I have dumped all those blades on the floor twice...not a good thing especially when bare foot. Mind you, on the job site with proper footwear, this won't be as dangerous, but still annoying as all get out. The handles are of a textured plastic which is ok. It does make the knife feel super cheap however. The pocket clip is of the worst design being all narrow. There is a liner lock for the main blade section. Interestingly enough, there is also a small lever found on the upper section of the knife pivot point that will double lock the knife blade open...for those that feel a liner lock can be easily disengaged...so that is an added safety feature. There is an include Thumb ring for added control of the knife.
Pros:
- extra blade storage
- grippy textured plastic
- extra safety lock
- blade exchange mechanism works very good for this type of design
Cons:
- hinged access door to blade storage
- bad pocket clip design
Overall, this utility knife offers both good and bad design elements. That hinged door is an accident causer in my opinion. Worst pocket clip design I have see. Oh it will keep the knife there, but it will travel around with any movement of the user.
-
Foldable Knife Utility Knife.
Umm, where do I start with this one. Let's just say, when I saw this hanging on some store's peg board, I just had to have it for the name. This is like selling a knife with "knife" written on it. With that said, this knife follows the generic utility knife formula...which is oddly superior to many name branded and more expensive utility knives. You get a lock back combined with a good blade exchanging mechanism. Once again a crappy second thought pocket clip, but the body on these tend to be comfortable.
Pros:
- all metal construction
- blade swapping mechanism
- lock back
Cons:
- pocket clip could be better
Overall, a good generic utility knife. I have to wonder why more expensive branded knives do not use this type of easy blade exchange mechanism. It seems most of the cheap generic knives use them, meaning there should't be big royalties in its implementation. Just food for thought.
-
Sears Craftsman Utility Knife.
Here is another Sears branded utility knife. Much like Canadian Tire, sears never makes their own products other than just branding them from the OEM. This folding knife offers a nicely textured all metal construction with a kick ass pocket clip featured that wide spatula tip I like so much. The let down with this knife is the sub par blade exchanging mechanism.
Pros:
- all metal textured body
- pocket clip done right
- lock back
Cons:
- blade swapping mechanism
Overall, this is a rather nice knife let down with a blade exchanging mechanism that isn't the smoothest and easiest to use.
-
Unknown Brand Utility Knife.
Here is another utility knife that features an ergonomic rubber/plastic grip. At least there is a metal foundation underneath which is better than an all plastic construction. The blade exchange mechanism works good, but the shape of the button allows the fingers to slip off of it.
Pros:
- good grip and ergonomics
- blade exchange mechanism works good and is consistent
Cons:
- no pocket clip
- blade exchange button shape allows the fingers to slip off of it at times.
Overall, an average utility knife that lacks a pocket clip.
-
Mastercraft Utility Knife Set.
These came in pairs and are made for Canadian Tire. I really like these because they are very slim. Combine that with a great pocket clip, a good blade exchange system, and a lock back, makes this one a great utility knife.
Pros:
- slim and ergonomic
- lock back
- good blade swapping mechanism
- pocket clip
Cons:
- I can't think of any
Overall, this is one sleek thin pocket knife with all the right features.
-
Mastercraft Safety Utility Knife.
This atrocity is what happens when folks take the safety thing to extremes. You get something that is less than ideal and a major PITA to use. The idea behind this travesty is that management can't trust their employees ending up in accidents which results in the invariable time off and possible compensation down the road. So someone somewhere decided to make an idiot proof knife. This knife has the whole blade covered up. To pop it out, you have to press down and make that angled front straight. This will automatically show some sharp blade. However, the amount that is shown is laughable. To change a blade, you have to pop up a small hatch door using a screwdriver, as my nails weren't strong enough to open it. The body is shaped like a mouse, and the whole thing is bonkers crazy. I just had to have it for the collection though because it is nuts.
Pros:
- I can't think of any
Cons:
- everything
Overall, a knife designed to take safety to its extremes where the safety features get in the way ending up with something that has no soul, and can barely do the job of cutting boxes.
-
Stanley 99E Sliding Utility Knife.
Here is something for the more traditional user. The Stanley 99E has been around for ages, and is the type of knife many people think of when they think of a utility knife. Made from all metal construction with room to store extra blades in the handle, this knife is heavy duty. The sliding mechanism is smooth and the thumb button won't snag because it doesn't stick out from the body much. The biggest issue with this knife, is you will need a screw driver to do blade exchanges as the body is held together by a single screw.
Pros:
- all metal construction
- heavy duty
Cons:
- need a screw driver to open the knife up
Overall, it is knives like the Stanley 99E that has been around forever that are the foundations for many people calling a utility knife, a "Stanley". You can't go wrong with this knife. It doesn't offer many fancy features, but what it does offer is rock solid.
-
Stanley No 199 Utility Knife.
Another heavy duty knife from Stanley. This one harkening even further back in time than the 99E, and still sold to this day. This is a no frills knife that features a fixed blade with room to store extra blades in the body. My main issue with this knife is its over-simplicity. How do you store this knife safely away with a naked blade always present? I didn't bother to show the knife with blade present because I didn't feel like rummaging for a screwdriver for a simple photo.
Pros:
- simple design.
Cons:
- naked blade always present (sort of the antithesis of the Mastercraft Safety Utility Knife mentioned a few post up)
- requires a screw driver to change blades
Overall, a nice looking classical knife lacking any safety features other than a textured handle to prevent hand slippage.
-
Fix It! Rotary Utility Knife.
Here is something ultra strange, or at least in my books. The Fix It! Rotary utility knife is an odd duck. This utility knife has a fat rear end because that is where the rotary knife blade cartridge goes. Rotary cartridges are supposed to eliminate the chances of cutting yourself because you do not come into contact with any sharp edges. Used ones just back into storage, and new ones are dialed in. Yeah, this is another safety feature that sounds great on paper, but when implemented is a terrible idea. The knife looks awkward and ungainly because it is. The knife comes with a cheap vinyl holster.
Pros:
- comes with 15 blades in a rotary cartridge
Cons:
- awkward handling with all the weight aft of the hand
- cartridge blade system is hard to find
- vinyl holster wouldn't last a season on the job site
Overall, another knife hampered by a safety issue.
-
Unknown Brand Utility Knife.
Here is something so basic that it is dangerous to use. This one does not use standard utility knife blades, but razor blades. The concept is starkly simply. Have a metal sleeve slide up and down a body to expose and protect the blade. Problem is, the sliding isn't all that smooth, and it is quite easy to cut yourself on the razor blade if not careful. It is a simple and effective tool for box cutting as well as finger lacerating.
Pros:
- I can't think of any
Cons:
- everything
Overall, if I absolutely had to cut something and this is all I had, I would use it. Otherwise, I would search for anything else to do the job.
-
Kobalt Utility Knife.
Here is a very nice utility knife from Kobalt. This one features both a utility knife as well as a plain edge blade and a serrated blade. The quick blade exchange mechanism on the utility knife is well done and executed. This knife also comes with a belt sheath.
Pros:
- good ergonomics and textured handle
- includes a utility, plain edge, and a serrated knife blade
- compact for having 3 blades
Cons:
- no pocket clip...but with the addition of a belt sheath, is this even necessary?
Overall, the Kobalt utility knife brings a lot of functionality in a well designed package.
-
RONA Utility Knife.
Here is another sheath supplied utility knife, but this one is from RONA, a hardware store chain. Unlike the much better Kobalt in the previous post, this one is all plastic and cheap feeling. The quick blade exchange mechanism does work, albeit it is of the push inwards design. At least the part you push in isn't some sculpted crappy plastic oval button. The pocket clip is a great design.
Pros:
- ok blade swapping mechanism
- included sheath
- awesome pocket clip
Cons:
- plastic cheapness
Overall, this is a very lightweight utility knife due to the materials used in its construction. At least the blade carrier is all metal. That pocket clip should be on more utility knife models out there.
-
Kobalt Utility Knife Kit.
Every now and then, I come across these hard case kits. This one is from Kobalt. This kit includes one utility knife and a lot of different blade types. Much like the Kobalt utility knife mentioned in a few post upwards, this one shares the same great ergonomic body but without the added knife blades.
Pros:
- the kit adds to the functionality of the knife
- nice ergonomic body
- good quick blade swapping mechanism
- good pocket clip design
Cons:
- can't think of any
Overall, these type of kits are a great way to store extra blades of different types. The kit is a bit bulky, but that is a small price to pay for convenience.
-
Tooltech Utility Knife Kit.
Similar kit to the Cobalt kit mentioned in the previous kit, except with a different utility knife. This one doesn't have the best quick blade swapping mechanism. Likewise, the tool clip is of the narrow design. Thus this kits utility knife isn't as good as the Kobalt Kit's offering.
Pros:
- the kit adds to the functionality of the knife
Cons:
- Poor blade exchange mechanism
- pocket clip
Overall, the kit does add functionality and keeps all of your blades in one spot.
-
Mastercraft Utility Knife Kits.
Here are two offerings from Canadian Tire. Both kits are mostly the same, except the first having the now discontinued utility knifes and the second being the one that you can still find on sale.
Pros:
- Kits add extra functionality
- a standard and key chain utility knife are included
- newest knife kit offers a wheel blade exchange mechanism
- older knife kit offers a lock back
Cons:
- older knife kit has a poorly designed blade exchange mechanism
- newest kit offers a liner lock...albeit these are solid
- both kits only offer a limited range of blade styles
Overall, both kits are fairly similar as far as blade and knife options go. Both kits have pros and cons to their included knives.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
























































