The Humble Utility Knife.
-
Stanley 10-788 Utility Knife.
If the above Stanley didn't float your boat, and you want something that looks very modern, then the 10-788 should fit the bill. Basically the same features but with different aesthetics. The 10-788 does have more plastic in it, making it a bit lighter.
Pros:
- ergonomic
- added wire cutter feature
- extra blade storage
- good quick blade exchange mechanism
Cons:
- more plastic in body
Overall, another nice Stanley utility knife.
-
Stanley Fatmax Sliding Utility Knife.
Another iteration of the Fatmax family. This one is rather nice with rubber grips at all the good spots. The sliding mechanism is silky smooth, and the blade exchange mechanism works good. There is even a place to store extra blades. Best part, you won't have to press or pull on a small plastic hard to reach piece...as access is super easy via a nice big round red rear button.
Pros:
- good ergonomics
- easy to access blade storage
- thumb button will not catch on stuff
Cons:
- can't think of one.
Overall, this is a very good utility knife. Easy access to extra blades, and the blade exchange mechanics works like a charm.
-
Stanley Fatmax combo utility knife.
One of the strangest in my collection. If memory serves me right, it was sent to me from a fellow member who hails from the UK. This Fatmax features a built in interchangeable bit driver and pliers. Each rotate and lock separately via that big rear yellow round button. There is storage room for an extra driver bit built into the handle. Surprisingly, there appears to be enough room to throw in an extra blade storage compartment, but there is non to be found on this model.
Pros:
- driver and pliers are thrown in for good measure
- good blade exchange mechanism
- sliding thumb button won't snag on stuff
Cons:
- Big and clunky
Overall, this odd duck is an interesting concept.
-
Mastercraft Utility Knife.
Another Canadian Tire offering. This time with an upgraded exchange blade mechanism. This one is a winner as it gives you plenty of purchase to push upwards to replace the blade.
Pros:
- all metal construction
- excellent blade exchange mechanism
- pocket clip is good
- rubber thumb rest aids in fine control
Cons:
- uses a handle button to lock the main blade open or closed
Overall, this one is a good utility knife. It has a lot of good pluses going for it. I must admit, although I am not a fan of the handle buttons, they are more positive than some of the liner locks out there.
-
Mastercraft Maximum Auto Utility Knife.
Now here is something special, or at least I think so. This is a much smaller svelte auto loader from the folks at Canadian Tire. Not only is this the most compact auto loader I have yet to see, that texture which covers the whole tool is a winner. The good stuff doesn't stop there. The pocket clip is excellent being wide and well designed. The extra blade storage compartment is easily accessed via a well executed pull tab and hinged door under the pocket clip. Furthermore, the blade exchange mechanism is also good. like all auto loaders, remove the spent blade, and slide the blade holder all the way back. This will automatically pick the next blade in the storage well. Repeat until you have to refill the storage well with blades.
Pros:
- auto loader
- super small size compared to the other auto loaders in my collection
- pocket clip
- quick blade exchange mechanism
- textured surface
- included attachment ring
Cons:
- I can't think of any
Overall, this compact auto is a great utility knife. Probably one of my favorites.
-
Paper Knife E.D.C. Utility knife.
Very compact and light weight, the Paper Knife E.D.C is a sub compact utility knife designed to use standard utility blades. There is also an included bottle cap opener and pry-bar/flat screwdriver. The operation of this knife is simple, but also can be dangerous. You can stow the blade completely inside the knife by pulling and pressing the top part. This disengages and engages the metal locks into the top grooves of the utility blade. By doing this, you can extract and retract the blade. This is somewhat dangerous as it is somewhat easy to cut yourself as you are busy yanking on that top piece of the knife handle. My copy arrived in good working condition. I have heard others had difficulties with the blade not being retained and falling out.
Pros:
- compact
- bottle open and pry-bar/flat driver
- if you get a good copy, the blade can be retracted into the knife blade for safety
Cons:
- fiddly blade locking mechanism
- you may get a not so good copy
Overall, not a bad little design...if it works properly. Just about the maximum size I would consider attaching to my key-chain.
-
That is about it for my collection. These type of threads are time consuming to make, but I think they are also great fun and hopefully somewhat informative. You might disagree with my opinions, and that is ok. I hope that at least the photos won't steer you onto looming shoals, and you can learn much from them.
Here are two bonus photos of my two overflowing collection drawers devoted to the humble utility knife.
I am sure I may have missed a knife or two in this thread wrangling. With that said, it still amazes me at how many different utility knives there are out there. You could group them on their similarities such as the type of blade exchange mechanism used, or if the knife is full sized or folding type. You could further break down the folders by sliding or fixed blade holders. There are even those with added features such as extra blade storage, or an included extra knife blade, or even a driver, pliers, and wire stripper. Add to this mix the auto loaders and safety knives, and this all adds up to a shocking amount of variety. So the next time you are at the hardware store, go check out what is available. Maybe just maybe, you might bring one home with you.
Hope you enjoyed this trip through my collection of humble utility knives.

-
Impressive as alway Chako

-
Thanks SteveC.

-
Great thread and I enjoyed it very much. A wonderful collection of items most people wouldn´t collect.

I´m hoping I´ll run into that three blade Kobalt sometime (or something similar). -
It's over already? :'( :'( :'( :'(
-
Sorry styx. I worked long and hard to post the majority of my collection as quickly as I could. I know I wouldn't have the patience to post a knife a day. :ahhh
-
It was interesting, exciting and a very nice piece of Chako's collection.

I love your threads, this one was no exception.
Read through all of it and wanted more
As many types of utility knives as there might be, I think that's not too many compared to the types and styles of folding knives we have today.
Especially considering that this utility blades are older, and probably wider available and more used, sold and carried around the world than modern folding knives -
Thanks for taking the time Chako! So interesting to read about all those utility knives.
I love that black one with the auto-loading feature and the texturing that looks like truck bed "rhino-liner"!

I Love the idea of that Fatmax one with the bit driver and the pliers. It looks like it just needs a redesign. The pliers don't look small or wimpy in the picture. Are they about the size of LM Juice or Skeletool? or do they just look big in the picture?Is there one that you would say is your absolute favorite?
-
King_Gorilla, that same compact auto loader that looks like a truck bed liner.
I did find a few more in my collection...
-
Fuller Sliding Utility Knife.
This type of one piece metal utility knife tends to be heavy duty in construction, and this Fuller does not disappoint. Like the majority of this type of knife, there is a hidden blade storage inside the handle. The handle in this case, requires a flat screw driver to access. As with many other similar models, the sliding mechanism has several stops allowing for blade depth adjustments. Nothing fancy about this Fuller, but I must say, the handle ergonomics are very good, with a shape that will prevent your hand from sliding on the body which is good considering there is no texturing to the metallic body whatsoever. Of interest, the extra blades are packaged in some anti-rust paper.
Pros:
- all metal body
- good ergonomics
- good sliding mechanism
- screw held in position by a C washer, meaning it won't get lost during a blade swap
Cons:
- need a screw driver to open the knife up
Overall, this is a nice basic knife of this type that offers no extra features.
-
HDX Utility Knife.
Here is another no frills sliding type utility knife. The biggest exception with this model is the lack of extra utility blades. I do believe the knife will hold a few extras, but you will have to include them yourself instead of relying on a few extras at the time of purchase.
Pros:
- sturdy all metal design with grippy side panels
- Sliding mechanism offers several blade depth stops
Cons:
- A Phillips or a flat screwdriver is required to gain entry
- no extra blades included although there is space for some inside the handle
Overall, a no frills utility knife with excellent grip due to those side panels.
-
Milwaukee Safety Utility Knife.
Here is a great tool for those who need quick and safe access to a box cutter. This utility knife is considered "safety" because of an internal spring which pulls the blade back inside when the user releases pressure on the thumb slider button. There are several good design features at play here. There is no need for a tool to access the interior of the knife. Likewise, an include wire cutter function adds versatility. There is extra blade storage inside the handle with included extra blades. The spring mechanism is easy to use and doesn't get in the way unlike some of the other safety monstrosities seen in this thread.
Pros:
- all metal heavy duty construction
- no tools required to access the extra blade storage compartment
- wire cutter
- thumb slider button angled to ensure thumb will not slide off of the sliding mechanism
- internal spring hides the blade without user input
- C washer used to prevent the loss of the handle screw
Cons:
- I can't think of any other than the constant force needed to deploy and re-deploy the blade during a job may get tiring over time
Overall, here is a nice safety utility knife that works well. The ergonomics are excellent, and the included feature set makes this one a winner in my books.
-
Stanley FATMAX Utility Knife.
Here is an other Stanley FATMAX utility knife, but with a difference. Like all FATMAX Stanley's this one is very wide. I tend to like the FATMAX family because this extra width does translate into more comfort for my big paws. This model does not require any tools to gain access to the internal extra blade storage. Simply twist the big black locking mechanism and the whole knife scissors out via a spring mechanism. So far so good. However, this is where things get a little negative. The blade storage is angled outwards, and held in place by a strong spring. Pulling one out isn't an option as the whole glued together due to the oil blade clump resists the removal of a single blade, or they will all come out together. Loading the extra blade storage compartment is a bit tricky due to that strong retention spring.
Pros:
- no tools required
- very comfortable ergonomics
- extra blade storage in handle
Cons:
- strong retention spring and angled blade storage makes this one dangerous knife to add or remove blades from the storage compartment
Overall, not a bad knife if you don't mind being extra careful in adding or removing blades from the storage compartment. The whole knife springs open which took me by surprise the first time I opened the knife to gain access to the interior. Other than that, the ergonomics on this knife are excellent. The extra width and sculpted rubber finger panels make this one an easy knife to work with for long extended periods of time.
-
I think you might have an issue. You'll need more space to store all those utility knives
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


































