Mora Club
-
Nice idea. No way you'll get choked by snagging a branch now
-
2 more to the club,think a older stamped 511 ss and possibly a older stamped #3? It's longer than my 1

-
[quote author=styx link=topic=67811.msg1512742#msg1512742 date=1499889257]
Nice idea. No way you'll get choked by snagging a branch nowNot to death anyway :D
Well that death part can be a bit of a downer
Yeah. That can really ruin your day.
Nobody likes a dirt nap.
[/quote]Tell me about it. And when you wake up dazed and confused, everyone just keeps gawking at you like they've seen a ghost
-
[quote author=Kevin Davey link=topic=67811.msg1513198#msg1513198 date=1499955244]
[quote author=styx link=topic=67811.msg1512742#msg1512742 date=1499889257]
Nice idea. No way you'll get choked by snagging a branch nowNot to death anyway :D
Well that death part can be a bit of a downer
Yeah. That can really ruin your day.
Nobody likes a dirt nap.
[/quote]Tell me about it. And when you wake up dazed and confused, everyone just keeps gawking at you like they've seen a ghost
[/quote]
Or a zombie. -
[quote author=styx link=topic=67811.msg1513243#msg1513243 date=1499961543]
[quote author=Kevin Davey link=topic=67811.msg1513198#msg1513198 date=1499955244]
[quote author=styx link=topic=67811.msg1512742#msg1512742 date=1499889257]
Nice idea. No way you'll get choked by snagging a branch nowNot to death anyway :D
Well that death part can be a bit of a downer
Yeah. That can really ruin your day.
Nobody likes a dirt nap.
[/quote]Tell me about it. And when you wake up dazed and confused, everyone just keeps gawking at you like they've seen a ghost
[/quote]
Or a zombie.
[/quote]Yup. Lucky for me, I don't live in a part of the world where Twinkies are popular
-
[quote author=Grathr link=topic=67811.msg1513247#msg1513247 date=1499962227]
[quote author=styx link=topic=67811.msg1513243#msg1513243 date=1499961543]
[quote author=Kevin Davey link=topic=67811.msg1513198#msg1513198 date=1499955244]
[quote author=styx link=topic=67811.msg1512742#msg1512742 date=1499889257]
Nice idea. No way you'll get choked by snagging a branch nowNot to death anyway :D
Well that death part can be a bit of a downer
Yeah. That can really ruin your day.
Nobody likes a dirt nap.
[/quote]Tell me about it. And when you wake up dazed and confused, everyone just keeps gawking at you like they've seen a ghost
[/quote]
Or a zombie.
[/quote]Yup. Lucky for me, I don't live in a part of the world where Twinkies are popular
[/quote]

-
Nice!

-
Cool pic Spartan

-
+1
On another note I've been reading and researching more on scandi grind and me thinks I'll be doing something that a lot of folks will find as heresy - knock off the shoulders of the Mora Classic. There has been a lot of debate over the years over why the Mora is so effective and some suggest that it would be even better once we actually finished the product we buy (the low cost implying they are unfinished) and sharpened it properly. Now that properly for some means going scandivex, for some full convex, and for me it sure seems like an interesting way to go.
What sparked this is that I found some old documents where I was noting my thoughts on performance between the Classic #1 and an Opinel No.8 -
Cool pic Spartan

+1
On another note I've been reading and researching more on scandi grind and me thinks I'll be doing something that a lot of folks will find as heresy - knock off the shoulders of the Mora Classic. There has been a lot of debate over the years over why the Mora is so effective and some suggest that it would be even better once we actually finished the product we buy (the low cost implying they are unfinished) and sharpened it properly. Now that properly for some means going scandivex, for some full convex, and for me it sure seems like an interesting way to go.
What sparked this is that I found some old documents where I was noting my thoughts on performance between the Classic #1 and an Opinel No.8
I watched a video some time ago by an american knifemaker (was it you that posted it?) that claimed that the scandi grind on the moras originally was ment as a half finished grind, so that the buyer could put their own grind on it after buying it.
-
Cool pic Spartan

+1
On another note I've been reading and researching more on scandi grind and me thinks I'll be doing something that a lot of folks will find as heresy - knock off the shoulders of the Mora Classic. There has been a lot of debate over the years over why the Mora is so effective and some suggest that it would be even better once we actually finished the product we buy (the low cost implying they are unfinished) and sharpened it properly. Now that properly for some means going scandivex, for some full convex, and for me it sure seems like an interesting way to go.
What sparked this is that I found some old documents where I was noting my thoughts on performance between the Classic #1 and an Opinel No.8
I watched a video some time ago by an american knifemaker (was it you that posted it?) that claimed that the scandi grind on the moras originally was ment as a half finished grind, so that the buyer could put their own grind on it after buying it.
Could be. I think it might have been Murray Carter.
When I looked at my old notes and thought about the last couple of weeks (since I'm home now, I do most of the cooking and prefer my knives over the kitchen knives) Opinel and SAKs did perform better in pure cutting performance due to a lack of wedging. Moras cut extremely well with their thin stock and holy smurf angle (about 11° per side if I recall correctly) but I have to wonder if I might be missing out on peak performance as an all around knife.
Now the Scandi grind or single bevel saber or what ever one wishes to call it has a reputation for being an excellent grind for woodworking and ease of sharpening. Oddly enough most of my knives end up with a slight convex due to rather quick sharpening in hand and no longer using jigs, systems or even setting down the stone (might even put up a Spyderco Sharpmaker up for a trade). It could be argued that convex is harder to maintain or that scandi requires more time since more metal needs to be taken off and I won't go into that as I can't prove either one.
What really has the gears in my head turning is the uproar of scandivex. Can't question the durability of it, but the logic sounds plausible. Biggest issue with it is the logical fallacies (read: pure garbage) that many of the largest proponents of it have said (read: spewed out) in regards to other knife related topics. -
Cool pic Spartan

+1
On another note I've been reading and researching more on scandi grind and me thinks I'll be doing something that a lot of folks will find as heresy - knock off the shoulders of the Mora Classic. There has been a lot of debate over the years over why the Mora is so effective and some suggest that it would be even better once we actually finished the product we buy (the low cost implying they are unfinished) and sharpened it properly. Now that properly for some means going scandivex, for some full convex, and for me it sure seems like an interesting way to go.
What sparked this is that I found some old documents where I was noting my thoughts on performance between the Classic #1 and an Opinel No.8
I watched a video some time ago by an american knifemaker (was it you that posted it?) that claimed that the scandi grind on the moras originally was ment as a half finished grind, so that the buyer could put their own grind on it after buying it.
Could be. I think it might have been Murray Carter.
When I looked at my old notes and thought about the last couple of weeks (since I'm home now, I do most of the cooking and prefer my knives over the kitchen knives) Opinel and SAKs did perform better in pure cutting performance due to a lack of wedging. Moras cut extremely well with their thin stock and holy smurf angle (about 11° per side if I recall correctly) but I have to wonder if I might be missing out on peak performance as an all around knife.
Now the Scandi grind or single bevel saber or what ever one wishes to call it has a reputation for being an excellent grind for woodworking and ease of sharpening. Oddly enough most of my knives end up with a slight convex due to rather quick sharpening in hand and no longer using jigs, systems or even setting down the stone (might even put up a Spyderco Sharpmaker up for a trade). It could be argued that convex is harder to maintain or that scandi requires more time since more metal needs to be taken off and I won't go into that as I can't prove either one.
What really has the gears in my head turning is the uproar of scandivex. Can't question the durability of it, but the logic sounds plausible. Biggest issue with it is the logical fallacies (read: pure garbage) that many of the largest proponents of it have said (read: spewed out) in regards to other knife related topics.Im not familiar with the scandivex grind. Is it a flat convex grind or just a rounding of the shoulders of a scandi grind?
A picture/figure would be great. 😊 -
I am curious also. But I am thinking, if you rounded the shoulders or curved the grind itself or both, wouldn't it be a saber grind or close to it?
-
Some would already be pulling their hair out because of my terminology.
Technically a Scandi grind is a zero saber grind due to the lack of a secondary bevel at the cutting edge. Spyderco has grinds very well explained so I'll attach a photo of their short and sweet explanations as a reference.
So the scandivex, for lack of a better word, would fall between a full convex and a flat saber grind as it is now commonly done in the industry. A great example of it would be the BRKT Bushcrafter (pic attached), although I'm sure the same people who would pull their hair out would now hit me with large, heavy objects as this can also be described as a flat convex grind, convex saber grind and probably a few more names I'm not aware of.
A lot of this came from differentiating between a full height convex grind and a partial convex grind. Another drop of confusion came when some custom makers started selling proprietary grinds, probably in an effort to get away from the notion of having sharpened prybars with a convex edge which came from many people modifying their BK2s, ESEE-5s and similar knives with a convex edge to the height of the primary bevel (reference pic included).To be perfectly honest I have no idea what I'll get with this experiment or if I'll just ruin a perfectly good knife. Since I won't be touching the edge, my suspicion is that the knife will perform somewhat better on deeper cuts on stiffer materials but will keep its performance in shallow cuts even though the edge might get a bit harder to control in regards of biting too deep.



-
I think it will become a better slicer, but I think you are right about losing some control in wood processing. It might want to bite to much. However, with a little practice, it might be excellent at wood processing. My SOG Vulcan is a hollow grind and it makes feather sticks and carves like it was made for it. Not fine cravings, but spoons, forks, pot hangers and things of that nature. So I guess it is what you are used to using is what I am trying to say.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
