Why a Spirit?
-
Maybe someone should bury it for a year as was done with the wave and gerber somewhere around here
-
So what do you guys think about this list?
Swisstool cons:
No lanyard ring
No pocket clip
No OHO knives or tools (other than pliers)
No operation with gloves (other than pliers)
Damage to fingernails
Not user modifiable
Not user repairable -
@aluminated said:
So what do you guys think about this list?Swisstool cons:
No lanyard ring
No pocket clip
No OHO knives or tools (other than pliers)
No operation with gloves (other than pliers)
Damage to fingernails
Not user modifiable
Not user repairableexcept it:
does have a lanyard attachment hole
knives and tools can be one hand opened
knives and tools can be used with gloves
doesn't have to trash your nails
can be modified
can be repaired -
So what do you guys think about this list?
Swisstool cons:
No lanyard ring
No pocket clip
No OHO knives or tools (other than pliers)
No operation with gloves (other than pliers)
Damage to fingernails
Not user modifiable
Not user repairableexcept it:
does have a lanyard attachment hole
knives and tools can be one hand opened
knives and tools can be used with gloves
doesn't have to trash your nails
can be modified
can be repairedI think we have different definitions or at least different perspectives for some of those terms. :D
Don't get me wrong - I am not nagging on the Victorinox products. I love my Swisstool and check the repair status of my Spirit at least twice daily. However, some of the design choices such as the location of the lanyard hole (is that the strange slot/hole thing?) have me befuddled.
I'm sure I CAN open all the tools with a tooth too, but I'm not about to call the Spirit "OTO."
Same for the glove comment. Latex or nitrile, maybe. How about a cowhide work gauntlets?
Doesn't have to trash your nails...but probably will do some damage. I'd rather not have nail nicks for every tool, but that's personal preference, largely because I had a Swisstool with tools so hard to open that I broke a couple nails with almost every tool selection. Btw, I'm old(er.) I have very hard and strong nails.
There's nothing I could do to change that tool other than to send it away for repair so I resold it to a friend to be a user/beater. -
So what do you guys think about this list?
Swisstool cons:
No lanyard ring
No pocket clip
No OHO knives or tools (other than pliers)
No operation with gloves (other than pliers)
Damage to fingernails
Not user modifiable
Not user repairableexcept it:
does have a lanyard attachment hole
knives and tools can be one hand opened
knives and tools can be used with gloves
doesn't have to trash your nails
can be modified
can be repairedI think we have different definitions or at least different perspectives for some of those terms. :D
Don't get me wrong - I am not nagging on the Victorinox products. I love my Swisstool and check the repair status of my Spirit at least twice daily. However, some of the design choices such as the location of the lanyard hole (is that the strange slot/hole thing?) have me befuddled.
I'm sure I CAN open all the tools with a tooth too, but I'm not about to call the Spirit "OTO."
Same for the glove comment. Latex or nitrile, maybe. How about a cowhide work gauntlets?
Doesn't have to trash your nails...but probably will do some damage. I'd rather not have nail nicks for every tool, but that's personal preference, largely because I had a Swisstool with tools so hard to open that I broke a couple nails with almost every tool selection. Btw, I'm old(er.) I have very hard and strong nails.
There's nothing I could do to change that tool other than to send it away for repair so I resold it to a friend to be a user/beater.Yeah for sure. :D You didn't define the type of gloves, mods or repairs etc so I was cheeky. :kirky:
-
Again, I'm a fan of the Vics. All of the "cons" listed are far outweighed by the quality and features.

-
USE It Every Day for 6 weeks, then tell me about cons.
What most are calling cons are not even noticed if they actulay cary and use the tool consistantly. -
So it appears the Vic pliers-MT is slippery in comparison to a Charge TTi. CTTi I've not once had an issue with the tool being slippery nor hot when left out in the sun. So, wondering, is the blacked out version of the Spirit any less slippery?
Was going to purchase the phillips/standard MUT bits (2) and put on in the K503x and other in with the CTTi to get past that, but LM only sells those in a set of 3 bits for $11 ... which seems a lot for wanting one bit (times 2).What seems cool about the Spirit is the screwdrivers are long and slim enough to be used in some things, however lack the large bit driver that LM has. Although has an awl there's no hole for emergency sewing. and yes, I've used the awl w/ thread-loop before for emergency fabrication and repairs. There is a Vic tool called a Sailing Needle that I'd like to acquire and put into something. Unsure if that could be retrofitted into a Spirit X or not.
And trying to cut an elongated hole in the awl might be very difficult unless someone has a precision cutting laser on hand.Pocket clip, meh. I've maybe used a pocket clip a few times, but have one on the CTTi but it's there cause it was given to me. What the CTTi has is the ability to use a Charge Saw, although I don't see any more Charge Saws on MTO's Store anymore. :( Think the clip was a reminder that I had a saw that can clip in there. And for the lanyard loop, had removed the one in the CTTi before sending it in for final repairs, and LM stuck the thing back in there. /argh Tried to use one with a PST II when fly fishing ... bad mistake. Did better with curved forceps and grinding a groove on the outer edge. :D
OHO tools are nice, though if a LM blade gets the slightest grime in there it is difficult to open. However broken nails ARE NOT FUN. The Wenger S557 broke many a nail; nut tool & phillips drive being the most notorious for that.
Vic Climber has an awl with a thread-loop. Why not the STool or Spirit too? Climber's Hook was another nail breaking SOB too.
I'd trade a Wenger EvoWood S557 for a Vis SwissTool if I had the chance. :D Would miss the walnut scales. - Never used the slip-joint pliers, but the self-sharpening scissors work well. Some don't like the rocking motion but I had no issues with that. Sure beats have that loose spring wire in there. :P
-
I forget the member but theres a video here on MTO showing him opening his Spirit with leather gloves on.
He was real serious about the Spirit and bought them for his team IIRC. I believe while the tool can be OHO lets not compare it to the OHO of say a Wave. I'd imagine most people naturally will open the Wave one handed while use two with the Spirit.
The only real issue I have with the Sprit is those scissors. I am directly comparing them to my 91mm SAK. In my use those scissors are ok but certainly not anywhere near 91mm SAK scissors.
Other than that the butter blade is pretty darn nice. I cannot speak to slippery cause I did polish my Wave
. I will say tho its certainly not going to be grippy in some circumstance. If in fact they would be used in those circumstance so its probably a moot point. -
I love the Spirit, it has been with me for about 8 years (I think) and has held up through all kinds of dumbsmurfery. The scissors can be modified to make them open wider (main complaint in regards to 'em).
The slippery part does come into play if you have sweaty paws. But I've had that some issue with the LM Rebar BO and SOG Switchplier 2. For me it does carry better in the pocket than the other 2. Often to the degree that I even forget I have it in my EDC until I put my hand on it (again lucky thing that my first response is to pat my pockets and see if anything on hand can solve the issue) -
I forgot to mention the tool I am most looking forward to using: the package opener! Though some use the butter knife tip to open packages and some call the package opener a "chisel/scraper," I know that I'll be using the package opener a whole lot...if I ever get my Spirit back from the repair center.
-
@aluminated said:
I forgot to mention the tool I am most looking forward to using: the package opener! Though some use the butter knife tip to open packages and some call the package opener a "chisel/scraper," I know that I'll be using the package opener a whole lot...if I ever get my Spirit back from the repair center.Why did you send it in for repair? Guessing that the American repair facility was the previous Wenger repair center? Took me over a month to get the S557 repaired ... it had the most horrendous pliers ever. Think took 6 weeks and numerous email to get one back.
Not found any local stores that carry anything past Vic Classics. Might try Big 5 if I remember, but am on limited funds for a while yet.
-
@Outback in Idaho said:
I forgot to mention the tool I am most looking forward to using: the package opener! Though some use the butter knife tip to open packages and some call the package opener a "chisel/scraper," I know that I'll be using the package opener a whole lot...if I ever get my Spirit back from the repair center.
Why did you send it in for repair? Guessing that the American repair facility was the previous Wenger repair center? Took me over a month to get the S557 repaired ... it had the most horrendous pliers ever. Think took 6 weeks and numerous email to get one back.
Not found any local stores that carry anything past Vic Classics. Might try Big 5 if I remember, but am on limited funds for a while yet.
TBH this is one of the main reasons I stick with LM, I've only sent 2 tools in and turn around was 4-5 days, was doing maintenance job then so needed it back asap,for me another pro for LM ;)
-
The outside access of tools is the big sell for me. The whole package just works. I think you need to fidget around and handle one to get it. Let me put it this way..I have almost carried a Spirit almost everyday sans for a day here or there due to not being able to take it somewhere. The only other MT w/pliers I own is an LM Crunch.
-
@Outback in Idaho said:
I forgot to mention the tool I am most looking forward to using: the package opener! Though some use the butter knife tip to open packages and some call the package opener a "chisel/scraper," I know that I'll be using the package opener a whole lot...if I ever get my Spirit back from the repair center.
Why did you send it in for repair? Guessing that the American repair facility was the previous Wenger repair center? Took me over a month to get the S557 repaired ... it had the most horrendous pliers ever. Think took 6 weeks and numerous email to get one back.
Not found any local stores that carry anything past Vic Classics. Might try Big 5 if I remember, but am on limited funds for a while yet.
TBH this is one of the main reasons I stick with LM, I've only sent 2 tools in and turn around was 4-5 days, was doing maintenance job then so needed it back asap,for me another pro for LM ;)
Well over here it's the other way around...
I don't even know how to begin sending in a LM for repairs over here in Europe :ahhh
They're mostly sold through LARGE outdoor stores that aren't known for handling stuff like that.
I do have a client that sells them in his own store... should ask him how he handles repairs next time I'm there.For Vic: I hand them in at a retailer so I don't need to send it to Germany (9 friggin €) and just wait for them to hand it along with their supplier.
This means it'll be gone for anywhere between 1-3 months but I've got plenty of backups.
I'm sure if I send it to Vic directly I'd get it back around 2 weeks later. -
How about this...pm coming your way 😉
-
@Outback in Idaho said:
I forgot to mention the tool I am most looking forward to using: the package opener! Though some use the butter knife tip to open packages and some call the package opener a "chisel/scraper," I know that I'll be using the package opener a whole lot...if I ever get my Spirit back from the repair center.
Why did you send it in for repair? Guessing that the American repair facility was the previous Wenger repair center? Took me over a month to get the S557 repaired ... it had the most horrendous pliers ever. Think took 6 weeks and numerous email to get one back.
Not found any local stores that carry anything past Vic Classics. Might try Big 5 if I remember, but am on limited funds for a while yet.
I sent the used tool to the Repair Center in Connecticut but I don't know where the Wenger place was/is. The pliers pivot was very sloppy, causing pliers tip misalignment, and one of the handle pivots was much looser than its mate. This, even though the tools were sharp and mostly unused and there was no evidence of abuse or damage other than the above-described symptoms.
-
It's not entirely non-clumping. Every time I open the scissors the small screw driver comes with it, but nothing else clumps. Also, if I don't notice the screw driver is out, I can still use the scissors without the screw driver causing any interference because it lines right up with the solid part of the scissors. It's still the best pliers based tool I own. :D
-
The Spirit is like Multitool Enlightenment, you will have to try one to see why.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login