84mm SAK love
-
To balance the discussion, I never got along with the 74mm line. I recently picked up a used Executive from the MTO store with a view to revisiting and reappraising it, and possibly putting some fance homemade scales on. Since I've got it, I'm remembering why I got rid of my Director, and wondering if it's really worth doing any work to it, as I'm not sure it'll ever get pocket time.
The 65mm line is the largest I would want on keys, the 84mm line is the smallest I would want in the pocket. The 74mm is in a nowhere land. I might possibly wear it in a waistcoat pocket at a formal event if I put some fancy scales on, but otherwise it a solution looking for a problem.
-
@Faddy Daddy said:
Dang you this-is-nascar and MacGuyver!

Just when I thought I was pretty satisfied with my SAK collection. Now you've got me looking at that executive, what? 2 blades and a nail file? Not sure what that orange peeler is about, maybe like the magical hook in that you can find uses for it? ;)
I do like having a bit less weight and smaller size, but curious just how much bigger an executive is compared to a classic (which is a bit to small for me as my only edc). Again, tourist has no scissors, argh... ha ha :ahhhLove my Executives. The best nail file Victorinox makes. The orange peeler does well opening clam shell packages.
If I could only own one, the Executive would be it.
Sorry, I don't want to take this thread off-topic.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
I fear I'm the one who took this thread off topic long ago, sorry!

I have to ask though, the orange peeler then does have a sharp edge? It's hard to tell from photos. Opening clam shells would be a great use though a small blade also works very well for that I've found. -
@Faddy Daddy said:
Dang you this-is-nascar and MacGuyver!

Just when I thought I was pretty satisfied with my SAK collection. Now you've got me looking at that executive, what? 2 blades and a nail file? Not sure what that orange peeler is about, maybe like the magical hook in that you can find uses for it? ;)
I do like having a bit less weight and smaller size, but curious just how much bigger an executive is compared to a classic (which is a bit to small for me as my only edc). Again, tourist has no scissors, argh... ha ha :ahhhSorryy....

The Executive is the only Sak i bought exclusively because of Macgyver i must admit...

It is a great SAK, way bigger than the classic. I carried it for a while as the only Sak, but the lack of the opening layer and good drivers made me decide that it was not for me, and went back to my 84's. Gave the Executive to my wife, it's perfect for her
If you are trying to settle on a more permanent model for regular edc you need to decide what you really need or want in a sak, and what will you be using it for most of the time. I can't get by with a sak without the opening layer and screwdrivers, as apart from cutting task's i'm a natural born tinkerer, always taking stuff apart, fixing stuff, modding,etc...
That opening layer is crucial to me, not because i need to open cans or pop a lot of bottle caps with it, i probably opened one (max. two) cans with a sak and popped a dozen bottle caps or so in 30 years of owning and using sak's. The bottle opener is my main screwdriver/bit driver, prybar, push bar and the can opener is also a great SD, finer prybar, scraper, hook-like tool, box opener, etc...
The awl is also essential to me, as is the small blade. All of this even more than any full sized scissors. I'd rather have the 84mm/classic combo than a 91mm with scissors all the time.As for the Sportsman, it is a great sak and i have one, but hardly use it because like i've said before i don't want to loose the small blade and i like to keep nail files and similar separate from my main Sak. And on the Sportsman the file if facing the main blade and scratches it when ever it's deployed, and i hate that....

Great input MacGyver.
I'd been trying to avoid this but I might just have to go for another few purchases just to see for myself
I don't think any multi tool will be perfect, especially for everyone and so the best will probably be whatever you happen to be carrying that day. But now I'm starting to get hooked trying the different ones, looking at them sitting on my counter, ha ha. Luckily it's not as expensive as a hobby as collecting say cars, or motorcycles or something!
That would be aggravating with the sportsman if it scratches the main blade, though the tool set intrigues me. Yeah, I like looking through the threads at some of the older tools, and like you say, the scissors versions of the 84mm seem like they'd be pretty nice! -
@Faddy Daddy said:
@Faddy Daddy said:
Dang you this-is-nascar and MacGuyver!

Just when I thought I was pretty satisfied with my SAK collection. Now you've got me looking at that executive, what? 2 blades and a nail file? Not sure what that orange peeler is about, maybe like the magical hook in that you can find uses for it? ;)
I do like having a bit less weight and smaller size, but curious just how much bigger an executive is compared to a classic (which is a bit to small for me as my only edc). Again, tourist has no scissors, argh... ha ha :ahhhLove my Executives. The best nail file Victorinox makes. The orange peeler does well opening clam shell packages.
If I could only own one, the Executive would be it.
Sorry, I don't want to take this thread off-topic.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
I fear I'm the one who took this thread off topic long ago, sorry!

I have to ask though, the orange peeler then does have a sharp edge? It's hard to tell from photos. Opening clam shells would be a great use though a small blade also works very well for that I've found.Oh yeah, the orange peeler is bloody sharp, almost as sharp as a regular serrated blade. Sharp enough to easily draw blood in one is not careful... :ahhh
I used to cut my cuticles on my fingers with it sometimes, and cut myself one or two times with it
-
@Faddy Daddy said:
@Faddy Daddy said:
Dang you this-is-nascar and MacGuyver!

Just when I thought I was pretty satisfied with my SAK collection. Now you've got me looking at that executive, what? 2 blades and a nail file? Not sure what that orange peeler is about, maybe like the magical hook in that you can find uses for it? ;)
I do like having a bit less weight and smaller size, but curious just how much bigger an executive is compared to a classic (which is a bit to small for me as my only edc). Again, tourist has no scissors, argh... ha ha :ahhhLove my Executives. The best nail file Victorinox makes. The orange peeler does well opening clam shell packages.
If I could only own one, the Executive would be it.
Sorry, I don't want to take this thread off-topic.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
I fear I'm the one who took this thread off topic long ago, sorry!

I have to ask though, the orange peeler then does have a sharp edge? It's hard to tell from photos. Opening clam shells would be a great use though a small blade also works very well for that I've found.Oh yeah, the orange peeler is bloody sharp, almost as sharp as a regular serrated blade. Sharp enough to easily draw blood in one is not careful... :ahhh
I used to cut my cuticles on my fingers with it sometimes, and cut myself one or two times with it
:ahhhThat's right up there with the Cuticle Pusher found on the MiniChamp...
-
Yep, it's plenty sharp, especially at the corner.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
-
Well that makes it sound like it actually could be useful. I love the idea of opening blister packs, that would be handy if it worked well. Might have to try one of these.
-
Lumberjack lately

-
^^^^^^ Nice! Love those nylon scales too!
-
I was thinking about my walker, coincidence ☺️.
I'm not a fun of combo tool, but I realized that it's the best solution for this knife and what it's made for: a walk. Maybe the Vic with the most correct name.
-
The Walker's a nice little tool. It's the only SAK I saw fit to buy two at once of.
-
well done! -
@Mini said:
I was thinking about my walker, coincidence ☺️.
I'm not a fun of combo tool, but I realized that it's the best solution for this knife and what it's made for: a walk. Maybe the Vic with the most correct name.The Walker is a cool sak, but what's beyond me is why they chosen that tool set instead of making an 84mm Camper or/and Hiker, that would be way cooler IMO, and they had all the parts readily available, not the case unfortunately for scissors models... :-\
-
I was thinking about my walker, coincidence ☺️.
I'm not a fun of combo tool, but I realized that it's the best solution for this knife and what it's made for: a walk. Maybe the Vic with the most correct name.The Walker is a cool sak, but what's beyond me is why they chosen that tool set instead of making an 84mm Camper or/and Hiker, that would be way cooler IMO, and they had all the parts readily available, not the case unfortunately for scissors models... :-\
Right? or at least hook a brutha up with some back layer tools?

I've commissioned one of our members to add the wood saw to an 84mm Golfer. Can't wait. ::)
-
@El Corkscrew said:
I was thinking about my walker, coincidence ☺️.
I'm not a fun of combo tool, but I realized that it's the best solution for this knife and what it's made for: a walk. Maybe the Vic with the most correct name.The Walker is a cool sak, but what's beyond me is why they chosen that tool set instead of making an 84mm Camper or/and Hiker, that would be way cooler IMO, and they had all the parts readily available, not the case unfortunately for scissors models... :-\
Right? or at least hook a brutha up with some back layer tools?

I've commissioned one of our members to add the wood saw to an 84mm Golfer. Can't wait. ::)
Yesh that would be cooler too, since it's a saw they could have put a back fine SD and a corkscrew/philips

-
I agree but cost may be an issue. I picked up a Walker for $17 new. But I imagine that labor is the highest cost component in the making of a SAK and can't really see how using a different spring and adding a corkscrew and back layer fine SD would add much to the labor cost

-
There would be a small weight increase when adding back later tools. Ye olde SAKWiki states that there is a 3.56g difference in weight between a Recruit (48.4g) and a Tourist (51.96g). Perhaps they are marketing to ultralight walkers.
-
Really loving my Tourist, with the new black scales.


Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
-
@this_is_nascar said:
Really loving my Tourist, with the new black scales.


Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
Gorgeous!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login