leatherman vs. the rest...
-
@pocketgecko said:
Sorry, but SOG destroys Leatherman. SOG has a lot higher quality and function.Could you tell us why you think that ??? Besides compound leverage I don't see anything that great about them :-\ I have seen there knife blade and I get a MT for the pliers and the knife mainly so for the pliers there probably great but the knife blade I just can't quite understand (not to good of a design for a knife company as was already said)
-
Well, for me, the compound leverage alone makes them better if nothing else. The tools, etc all appear similar in quality/function but I have had too many Leathermans snap shut on me while cutting wire. The SOG just wont do that.
-
Heh.
Leatherman lead - the rest followed. Some other manufacturers have refined certain aspects of the original "Leatherman" design, (e.g. SOG's compound leverage) but across the board, Leatherman won't be "caught" for a long time IMO.
As far as quality is concerned, they are one of a few manufacturers where quality is king. Anyone who gurantees their product for 25 years is pretty confident in their quality!
Every now and then, I like to look at another manufacturer's tool, but it's rare that I see anything that is significantly better than something LM have already done, probably in a variety of sizes and colours!
-
Leatherman leads.... 100 years later! :D
Def
-
@Defender said:
Leatherman leads.... 100 years later! :DDef
Not quite the same though....
-
I think Bob has a butterfly folding plier tool from the 1800's... that's about as much the same as any butterfly opening plier tool that followed the PST.
I won't argue that Leatherman is indeed 100% responsible for every multitool (with the notable exceptions of SAKs) since 1983 though.
Def
-
Leatherman vs. the rest??
It all depends in what you are looking for in a MT, I guess. I want OHO and all locking implements, so it looks like I'm stuck with Leatherman. And it never let me down so I'm all for Leatherman (btw no rust here). But if you want just a high quality tool you can go for Vic as well so I'm told. The SOG I have no experience with those but they seem to have there share of fans. It is the compound leverage thing I guess. Most of bad things I hear are about Gerber, but no I've no experience with those myself either. And these are just the major companies if I'm not mistaken

All in all it looks like Leahterman offers the best tool for my needs. But he, that just me :D
-
Hello All,
I'm afraid that I have to question all the stuff (you decide what stuff is) about Leatherman and rust. I've got around 200 Leatherman tools and knives. Yes, I wipe them down with a gun cleaning cloth - no, I don't have any rust. I think those who complain about rust either don't have any Leatherman tools or don't treat their tools properly.
I'm sure daggers will be launched against me, but I'm a bit tired of this "stuff".
Cheers - Joe
-
That has been my experience with them too Joe.
-
No rust problems here either.
-
I have Leatherman tools that have rust on them, however, it's all harmless surface rust. Some of it was so minor that I didn't even notice it until I posted large pictures on the main site. You can see the rust on the orange S2 in this pic:

I got this S2 second hand and I couldn't say if the rust was on it when I got it or since it got here, but where I live is extremely corrosive. The fender I bent on my Jeep last week is already showing signs of rust where the paint has flaked off.
I also had a second hand BO ST200 with some surface rust in the pivots. It was only noticeable because the oil in the pivots spread the rust around, so it looked worse than it was.
I also have a Leatherman C300 with spots on the blade, similar to the ones on the S2.
The myth that Leathermans rust is true, but it is blown WAY out of proportion, and I have yet to see any evidence of a Leatherman tool failing in any way due to corrosion. In fact, I have never seen any significant rust on any Leathermans, other than occasional spots, and almost always on bead blasted or satin finished parts.
This isn't meant as an attack on what Joe says, just my own observations. It's entirely possible that I simply do not treat my tools properly. It wouldn't be the first time I've abused something!
Def
-
I think the bottom line is that any tool can rust if not regularly maintained.
I personally have found more rust on second hand SAK's than I have with my Leatherman's.
-
I am on my second EDC Leatherman, and it sees a lot of use and adverse conditions.. and it has no rust.
The only time I ever saw rust on my LM was with the ST200, and that was under what I would consider abuse. I had used the saw to cut both plaster and drywall, and also got quite a bit of wet spackle on it in the course of the day. I let all of that dust and gunk just sit on the saw blade, along with the spackle residue. The next day I was working around water, and the tool got good and damp. I did not use the saw again for a week or so.
When I opened the saw to use it, the spackle had dried and all the drywall and plaster dust was still on there, but in addition to that there were little rust spots over the entire saw blade. I figured I had at least marred the saw a bit, but.. I rinsed off the blade, dried it, got out some steel wool and polished it up with nary a blemish. I mean, it looked brand new.
Other than that, the only thing I have had "appear" on my LM tools is dirt, grease, and blood. Your results may vary. I wonder if the folks that see them rust maybe have them in a toolbox? Mine is always with me, so perhaps that is the difference?
-
I didn't even bother reading the replies, but I'm going to state my opinion. They are ALL great, any of the names you know are good tools, or they wouldnt still be in buisness after this long. Leatherman makes a great tool, so you won't be disappointed.
-
My observations from owning 3 leatherman's, 1 SOG, and 1 Gerber.
Leatherman VS. Gerber is no contest. After carrying the gerber tool for about 2 days I put it in a drawer.
Leatherman VS. SOG
I have EDC'd a Leatherman for the past 6 years. I also have a SOG Powerlock that stays on my tool belt at work. The compound leverage and large size make it great as it pretty much replaces a full size set of pliers. Most of the tools are good, but I think Leatherman tools are better in design and finish. The knife blows chunks and the scissors aren't much better. When I first got it I wished Leatherman manufactured the SOG design with leatherman tools inside.
The SOG is truly a badass tool, and my only complaints are more or less nitpicking.
-
I find that LM tools are the most well rounded for my needs.. I have given Vic, SOG, and Gerber a chance, but I always go back to LM tools.. If the SURGE was a SOG tool, I still think I would be a LM fan though.. I like their one handed opening tools the best... I have the Powerassist, but IMO it is a gimmick..it is extremely awkward IMO.. (but only time will tell) The Gerber 800 legend is a great MT but it doesn't have a lot of implements.. Oh, and about the rusting; I have never had a LM tool rust. I have had a SURGE on my belt in extremely wet conditions and not a single speck of rust.. I keep all my multis well maintained with tuf glide and a nice tuf cloth..
-
I have at least 12 sog tools and a handful of their knives. the scissors are the worst I have used. cutting paper, leather, and thread I found them to fold the material more than others. I also bought some hard wood and tested saws. my favorite was a the vic, next the leatherman and bear. the sog tool was the least efficient of the group. for years I prefered my swiss tool. I carried both the swiss tool and charge for a while and found that for my needs the charge was a better tool. the eye glass screw driver, neddle nose plier, pocket clip and most of all the wider opening pliers on the charge better suit my needs. I now edc the charge and have since it was realesed.
-
Every MT company has their pros and cons. SOG's biggest selling points are the compound leverage and the option to add and remove components. LM has more MT variety and their flagship models - Wave and Charge - have the ability to open blades with one hand. LM also has nicer-looking components.
It's hard to say that one brand is better than the rest because I think each brand has something positive and unique. I love my SOG but there are things that it can't do that a LM Wave or Charge can. I love the Wave/Charge but again, there are some things they can't do that a SOG can.
-
Leatherman set the standard,the rest followed!!!

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



