Power Access Owners BEWARE
-
@dks said:
Of course, we did see how much the powerduo improved after the initial run........... Right? Have they ever even admitted that it had issues? As far as they are concerned it was exactly what they ordered.If sog is not happy with it they should recall it, like LM did with the leap. Otherwise, this is the quality they want.
I think you nailed it the first time. SOG are perfectly happy to sell us poor quality tools. Simple as that. Having now inspected a PowerAccess and both Syncs, I am not convinced that SOG have any intentions of raising their standards of manufacture.
The PA clumping can compromise the lock up, and the drivers were badly formed (one was ground at an angle, and one was almost semi-circular at the tip). I stopped paying close attention after that, so there could well be other issues that I overlooked. It's a shame, because it could have been a really nice tool, and it wouldn't take much refining to sort the issues out (or at least the ones I noticed). I do not expect any refinement to take place.
The Sync were to my mind, truly awful, but that was mainly due to the design. I was so repulsed with the frail laticework, arse backwards choices of what locks and what doesn't, and dreadful ergos, that I didn't waste much time looking at build quality. They're novelty "dad gifts", not tools, and even if they were well built, they'd still be bloody awful.
-
As much as I would want to love this tool, I find myself bumping this thread as the Power Access I got today shows the symptoms that's mentioned in this thread. The worst offender of the flipping back of the tool is the flat screwdriver. Something about closing the tool to the folded position is causing the lock to move half a millimeter. So when you deploy a tool on the blade-side of the handle, there's a chance it will go beyond the correct limit. Ironically, there's no problem in the file/philips side of the tool.
There's something terribly, terribly wrong with the tolerances between the parts. Unfortunately I'm stuck with this tool as 1) I got it off a private seller 2) no such thing as international warranty here 3) I've filled here and there trying to shave away metal to fix the tolerance issue.
I really really wanted to give it a chance but now unless I find what's wrong with this, I'm just ranting and regretting away that I should have bought something else....
I'll post pics tomorrow.
-
SOG's QC is really letting some people down... again

-
Every manufacturer throws out a lemon every now and then. My last one was a gerber
-
As promised, here are the pictures of what's driving me nuts about his tool.
picture 1:
Picture with the circles show the tool at rest. It's when you pick it up, or stow in your sheath or pocket or just hold it up to the light. Circle to the left shows the gap between the handles. Circle to the right shows how the locks should be -- the should sit low and as close as possible to the handles. Deploying the tools with the lock in this position would create an audible "click" but nothing as loud as a SAK's click.picture 2:
Picture with the rectangle shows the tool with pressure applied to the handles. It's when you grip the tool tightly to get some work done with the tool. Rectangle shows no gap between the handles compared the the first picture. It also shows how the lock has raised itself higher compared to the first picture. I don't even think it traveled the distance of half a millimeter. Maybe 1/3 a mm at most. But something is forcing the lock to open up when the handles are brought together.picture 3:
Picture with the circles show the tool at rest. Notice the gap between the handles. Push the lock up, use nail nick to lift out flathead, use other fingers to put back clumping tools, swing flathead to position. click. All sounds good, right?picture 4:
Picture with the rectangle show the tool when actually griped to get some work done. Rectangle shows no gap between the handles. Rectangle shows the lock mechanism has actually risen.The frustrating thing about this is it only happens to the pocket-clip side of the tool -- the other side is perfectly file with matching click of the tool lock.
-
Picture 1:
With that said, it takes no effort at all to make the outer tools of the pocket clip side to do this. All you have to do is clamp your 2 handles together and fail happens.Picture 2:
Those with Rebar or Micra (in my case) may have used their tool this way. The flathead and knife do not fold back when the handles are positioned this way. Unfortunately, due to design, this is a dangerous way to use the SOG.Picture 3:
Those with MP600/MP400 would be used to this configuration. It would work with this tool. The flathead and knife do not fold back when used in this position. Using it this way totally, totally defeats the original design of outward-accessible tools.When in folded position, something in the poweraccess is hitting the inner portion of the lock on the pocket clip side. It's either the lock on the opposite end hitting the clip-side lock causing the other end to pivot up to cause the fail OR it could be a hair of either plier head hitting the clip-side's lock causing the lock to pivot upward. Wish more traditional back springs would have been used and this would have been a really beautiful tool.
-
I own several of the old SOG tools, like the Power Assist and the Power Lock. I also over the past year or so purchased a Reactor, Power Duo, and a Power Play. They were never my favorite brand, and I never cared for the design of the older tools, but they were made very well. The newer ones I have purchased, from a design standpoint, are better, but SOG seems to be more concerned with making a tool lightweight, than making one that will hold up. Reviews of the newer tools I own seem to reflect my thoughts on them. As far as where they are manufactured, I agree that the blame should be put on SOG, and that also goes for where they decide to make them. The reason why companies outsource labor is cost, nothing else. A lot of these manufacturing plants in China are sweatshops, and the work conditions in them would be illegal here. Items manufactured in bad conditions are going to suffer quality wise. I am not saying they all are, but it is a known fact that some are. Apple got caught several years ago with the working conditions in one of their plants. I also do not like when companies outsource for cheaper labor, but their prices go up. It is a shame too, because some of SOG's newer designs seem pretty innovative and different, but if they cannot make them with the same quality they did on their older tools, I will pass on them.
-
Every manufacturer puts out Gems, Turds, and a lot of stuff inbetween

-
I'm not really one to place the blame on being so lucky that we got a lemon -- that's a lemon for me, for Grant, for Kevin and one for another guy who posted in SOG's Power Access review page. Hopefully 800 other people have Power Access tools they can actually work with.
As for China, yeah, they get a bad rap on manufacturing especially on stuff they copy. If there's one thing the iPhone I have taught me, it's that quality products can be produced (and copied
). For all I know, Gerber and Leatherman implements might be produced in some undisclosed China factory, shipped to the US and mixed with USA made implements like blade, scissors, etc and just assembled there and we wouldn't even know which came from where. (Can you know which Lego bricks came from where but you can easily blame a bad brick as "Made in China" haha!) Oh, how about SOG do what Hasbro did to their Transformers line -- everyone got fed up with parts that don't fit or are too loose or mis-aligned rivets so they moved production to Vietnam. And I think it actually helped!Maybe I'm just frustrated coz
- it's my first SOG. I heard things about Gerber but fell in love with the MP600 despite of all the noise. I was holding that kind of expectation from SOG.
- given MTO's relationship with SOG, I set a really, really high bar for them -- as in MP600 levels of expectation. I wanted a competitor for the MP600/MP400.
- I can't return it as I've tampered with it already and there's no such thing as warranty from individual sellers here.
It's ironic that yes, the blade won't fold down on your fingers, but it'll fold up!
-- and I was using the knife to open a box of Swiss Miss powdered chocolate drink for my little kid before bedtime and the blade folded up on me. Blade folds up while going between the box cover tabs of a Swiss Miss pack!Anyway, I'm going to continue grinding away at the inside hinges of the locks to try to prevent whatever from catching on to whatever. Worst case is for me to realize that the lock hinge on the pocket-clip side is off by 0.1mm compared to the other side.

edit:
hahaha I just realized that I now have a small pair of compound leverage pliers which I've never had before. If I needed a blade or flathead, might as well 1) pull out the SAK in my profile pic 2) reach into my pocket for the Micra. -
@Zephon said:
I'm not really one to place the blame on being so lucky that we got a lemon -- that's a lemon for me, for Grant, for Kevin and one for another guy who posted in SOG's Power Access review page. Hopefully 800 other people have Power Access tools they can actually work with.As for China, yeah, they get a bad rap on manufacturing especially on stuff they copy. If there's one thing the iPhone I have taught me, it's that quality products can be produced (and copied
). For all I know, Gerber and Leatherman implements might be produced in some undisclosed China factory, shipped to the US and mixed with USA made implements like blade, scissors, etc and just assembled there and we wouldn't even know which came from where. (Can you know which Lego bricks came from where but you can easily blame a bad brick as "Made in China" haha!) Oh, how about SOG do what Hasbro did to their Transformers line -- everyone got fed up with parts that don't fit or are too loose or mis-aligned rivets so they moved production to Vietnam. And I think it actually helped!Maybe I'm just frustrated coz
- it's my first SOG. I heard things about Gerber but fell in love with the MP600 despite of all the noise. I was holding that kind of expectation from SOG.
- given MTO's relationship with SOG, I set a really, really high bar for them -- as in MP600 levels of expectation. I wanted a competitor for the MP600/MP400.
- I can't return it as I've tampered with it already and there's no such thing as warranty from individual sellers here.
It's ironic that yes, the blade won't fold down on your fingers, but it'll fold up!
-- and I was using the knife to open a box of Swiss Miss powdered chocolate drink for my little kid before bedtime and the blade folded up on me. Blade folds up while going between the box cover tabs of a Swiss Miss pack!Anyway, I'm going to continue grinding away at the inside hinges of the locks to try to prevent whatever from catching on to whatever. Worst case is for me to realize that the lock hinge on the pocket-clip side is off by 0.1mm compared to the other side.

edit:
hahaha I just realized that I now have a small pair of compound leverage pliers which I've never had before. If I needed a blade or flathead, might as well 1) pull out the SAK in my profile pic 2) reach into my pocket for the Micra.You could always pull the guts out and have a lightweight set of compound leverage pliers :D
PS. Is that a Midnite Minichamp?
-
What a bizarre anomaly. Thanks for the insights on that.
I hope you can find and eliminate the route cause

-
Stupid comment alert. But, are y'all sure this isn't a feature but a defect?
-
That's what they say in software development -- if you can't find a way to clean out a bug, you can always document it as a feature 
It's actually a hidden feature to make you use your Gerber, Leatherman, Spirit MT's to see whose metal file can shave off more material and can get into smaller areas 
Will let you guys know what I find out when after I get home from work later.
I'm not sure what the encircled part does on the PowerPlay, but on the PowerAccess, those are the tool locks. Unless someone tells me otherwise, my opinion is that the PowerAccess' problem is due to that part going beyond the level of the handles. By design, it's flushed to the handle -- make any part of it a fraction of a millimeter off or, a pivot point that's not 100% on target, would cause the pivot locks on either handle to hit each other raising either 1 lock or both by a fraction of a millimeter. If the lock hinges of the tools were below the handle line like the encircled part in the picture, then this tool would lock with a click properly and tools won't bend back. At least that's my opinion.
ps. yes, it's a midnight minichamp.

-
Again, blame the brand, not the factory - The reason you are getting bad SOG products is because SOG is happy selling you these products, not because the evil Chinese are cheating the poor, honest US company. Is SOG run by incompetent morons?
You can get crappy quality in all countries, if you want to.Has there been a recall? If not then SOG is selling you the product they ordered, based on the requirements they placed on the manufacturer. Remember the Powerduo?
Why do people assume that only US companies can produce good products? Is Sal Glesser getting many complaints about the Byrd and Chinese Spyderco lines? Do you think he inspects each knife? Are Bear and Son products superior to all other products made out of the US?
-
Hey, guess what? I think that picture of the Power Play helped solve the problem. Yeah, it's a tolerance issue, all right. Bad design? Bad execution? Bad part selection? Hard to say. What's important right now is I think I now have a fully working tool.
My take away from all this:
- Rebar has a very aggressive 3-sided metal file. Just has an odd shape.
- Spirit has a darn good 3-sided metal file that can get inside nooks and crannies because of the size and shape.
- Gerber MP600 and MP800 metal files are no match for the 2 above.
- MP600 (and MP400) are still king of OHO pliers.
- why doesn't LM put washers between the Rebar tools to prevent clumping?
- I was using a Rebar, MP600, MP800, then Power Access til my armpits were sweaty, then I switch to a Spirit. That is when you'll know the meaning of ergonomics in a tool.
-
@dks said:
Again, blame the brand, not the factory - The reason you are getting bad SOG products is because SOG is happy selling you these products, not because the evil Chinese are cheating the poor, honest US company. Is SOG run by incompetent morons?
You can get crappy quality in all countries, if you want to.Has there been a recall? If not then SOG is selling you the product they ordered, based on the requirements they placed on the manufacturer. Remember the Powerduo?
Why do people assume that only US companies can produce good products? Is Sal Glesser getting many complaints about the Byrd and Chinese Spyderco lines? Do you think he inspects each knife? Are Bear and Son products superior to all other products made out of the US?
You're absolutely right here. The more time and money a company invests in quality control, the fewer lemons will make it to the customers. This includes outsourced production.
Just off the top of my head, I have owned/used good quality tools/knives/firearms from China, Taiwan, Canada, Malaysia, South Africa, Japan, Brazil, Mexico, Spain, Germany, England, Sweden, Switzerland, Vietnam, Russia, and probably some I'm forgetting.USA made products aren't guaranteed to be good, and products made in other countries (including China) aren't guaranteed to be bad. But I think most posters here know all that, honestly.
-
I think in the West, here included, we have not yet realised that there are good Chinese products and bad Chinese products - The term "Chinese" is used here to describe lower quality products, usually by salesmen trying to convince you that their product is better - in many cases their product is actually made in china too, but has a western brand name on it - I got a very German freezer a few years ago, with the salesman telling me how good a company it was and so on because it was German, only for me to point out that the actual compressor, the heart of the whole freezer was made in China.
The freezer has not missed a beat in 2/3 years and it is operating in temperatures reaching 45 Celsius.
There is a lot of rubbish coming from China too, but we are the ones buying it, knowingly, so they keep making it. When I pay 2 Euros in total to have a light sent to me from China, I am not expecting miracles...
There are also political issues, as there were with Japan after the 2nd World War.
-
How about the other guys who have the same defect? Did you guys send it for replacement? How was the replacement piece?
What I honestly can't figure out here is why the problem is isolated to the knife and flat head side of the tool. The file side was healthy enough to give a click when deploying a tool.
-
sigh the awl just folded back on me when I was applying downward force when trying to make a hole at the handle end of a plastic knife.
I guess it's just a half baked solution I came up with.
-
i had the large flathead driver fold on my when applying light-moderate force the other night.
does SOG read this forum?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
