Drawer queens.
-
Drawer Queens, shelf Queens, closet Queens, they all mean the same thing, tools and knives that are looked at but never used. Now people that have actually read any of my previous posts (that won't be many of you :P) will know that I just don't "do" drawer Queens as I get no enjoyment out of simply owning something for the sake of owning it and then just putting it in a drawer never to be used again. In my opinion (and this is just my opinion) if you are doing that, a picture of it does the same thing.
Now I know this opinion is pretty unpopular with most members here, but after being a member here for over a year now my thoughts on the subject haven't changed. I simply cannot enjoy anything that was designed as a tool by just looking at it. I do however see one case where a drawer Queen is understandable to me and that is if a tool has sentimental value where there value of the tool itself isn't anything to do with the fact of what it is, but what it represents.
In my collection there are currently 5 tools/SAK's that see very little use because they are rare and I either have a newer version or a better option. Before I part with them I thought I'd see what you guys thought and whether or not anyone could convince me that drawer Queens are indeed a good idea.
Looking forward to hearing your thoughts. :)
Ben
-
I agree with you, however...
A collection of MTs is like any other collection, it is the enjoyment of gathering, possibly cataloging, comparing, history, etc. I do agree that tools are meant to be used, but this does not mean someone should not collect items meant for use.
I also think that one may wish to hang on to older tools as newer ones are procured in the event that one finds the newest latest greatest to be less than stellar after all. I know I was glad to still have my ST200 after I got the Diesel.
I do not keep tools I do not use for the most part. And I do not collect. To me the utility is key, and if I have one that is useful and does what I need it to do, I am satisfied. I tend to give my old tools away.
I would see the desire to have an extra of a tool that you like a lot, in case of loss or theft or discontinuation of the design.
I also admit to a new found desire to have certain tools back that I loved even though I now EDC a different one that I feel is better.
For me, having a Surge, my old ST200, and maybe a stashed away extra Surge is more or less ideal. If a newer model comes along that I find to be good enough to replace my EDC, then I will reconsider that.
Right now I still have my Gerber Pro Scout, but it is broken such that giving it away would not really work out. I hate to just toss it though. Same with the Diesel.
My Micra so far has seen zero use at all, and my wife has expressed interest in carrying it, so it will go to her. Otherwise it would be passed to a friend.
If I don't use it, then I don't need it.
G.
-
well i dunno about convincing you, i do have a drawer queen well more of a desk queen the reason is how difficult will be to get another one if something happen to it other than that i try to put in good use all my MT that's why i carry almost all of them with me(some in my bag, some in my car) all tho i recon it will be kinda difficult to do that if you have a 100+ collection and in that case i think the drawer queens "just happen" cuz when you have so many tools is difficult to use them all as you may even forget which ones you've used and which ones you haven't....
that's what i think
-
Yeah I've got a few, most are for sentimental reasons like my first Swisschamp and Mauser which my parent's bought me :), then there's my Camper that hardly get's used at all now because it was the knife responsible for returning me to the true Swiss faith :)
There really is only a few tool's that I've bought from new and won't be used outside the home and that's the Wenger Tool Chest, and that's really only because it's too big to be edc-able imo :), and a Wenger SI and Vic Soldier because of there retired status :)
-
Oh and my 100 year Vic Spartan :)
-
Is future sale value a contributing factor?
-
@Micky d said:
Is future sale value a contributing factor?
Not for me it isn't as I plan to keep them and pass them on :), but I can see it being a contributing factor to other people :)
My new 57 Soldiers will doubtless go up in value given the pedigree of prior ownership :D
Those were 2 of the 5 actually. I have carried them, but TBH I will always chose my SI over them for EDC.
-
@Micky d said:
Is future sale value a contributing factor?
Not for me it isn't as I plan to keep them and pass them on :), but I can see it being a contributing factor to other people :)
My new 57 Soldiers will doubtless go up in value given the pedigree of prior ownership :D
Those were 2 of the 5 actually. I have carried them, but TBH I will always chose my SI over them for EDC.
Well something like retired oldtime Sak's should be draw queens imo as there irreplacable :'(
-
@Micky d said:
@Micky d said:
Is future sale value a contributing factor?
Not for me it isn't as I plan to keep them and pass them on :), but I can see it being a contributing factor to other people :)
My new 57 Soldiers will doubtless go up in value given the pedigree of prior ownership :D
Those were 2 of the 5 actually. I have carried them, but TBH I will always chose my SI over them for EDC.
Well something like retired oldtime Sak's should be draw queens imo as there irreplacable :'(
Well, they are, but if you aren't using them what's the point of having them? That's what I just don't get.
-
@Micky d said:
@Micky d said:
[quote author=Benner link=topic=8382.msg153240#msg153240 date=1230658455]
Is future sale value a contributing factor?Not for me it isn't as I plan to keep them and pass them on :), but I can see it being a contributing factor to other people :)
My new 57 Soldiers will doubtless go up in value given the pedigree of prior ownership :D
Those were 2 of the 5 actually. I have carried them, but TBH I will always chose my SI over them for EDC.
Well something like retired oldtime Sak's should be draw queens imo as there irreplacable :'(
Well, they are, but if you aren't using them what's the point of having them? That's what I just don't get.
[/quote]Well that's where you and I differ, because I really would hate to see them lost, damaged or otherwise harmed knowing that that's it, it's gone and there's no chance of replacement :-\Looking at it another way, Spitfire's, Mustangs et al are wonderful things that we all like to see in our sky's, but if there was just a few of them left in the world, would you fly yours ???
-
Well that is slightly different as we are only talking a few £££'s here and a Spitfire etc would be many many thousands and means so much more to many people. I can't compare those.
Don't get me wrong, I do see loss of these things as a real shame, but almost equally, I see it a shame to not use something which has been designed to be used as a tool.
-
@Benner said:
Well that is slightly different as we are only talking a few £££'s here and a Spitfire etc would be many many thousands and means so much more to many people. I can't compare those.Don't get me wrong, I do see loss of these things as a real shame, but almost equally, I see it a shame to not use something which has been designed to be used as a tool.
But it could be argued that they've seen there service, and have somehow managed to survive the rigours of several 'careful' owners, and now it's there time in the sun, to rest in the hands of a devoted collecter, rather than be thrust back into the malestrome despite there being newer, cheaper more easily replaced tools being available :)
-
@Micky d said:
Well that is slightly different as we are only talking a few £££'s here and a Spitfire etc would be many many thousands and means so much more to many people. I can't compare those.
Don't get me wrong, I do see loss of these things as a real shame, but almost equally, I see it a shame to not use something which has been designed to be used as a tool.
But it could be argued that they've seen there service, and have somehow managed to survive the rigours of several 'careful' owners, and now it's there time in the sun, to rest in the hands of a devoted collecter, rather than be thrust back into the malestrome despite there being newer, cheaper more easily replaced tools being available :)
But some are kept mint in box from new. How have they done their "service"?
-
Well I guess I'm guilty of that too :D
I think that sometimes a tool simply is too nice to use :). When I started out using knives and tools, I was just as confused/horrified as you are at them not being used as there manufactures intended, but now I can see room for both and can quite happily buy something in the sure and certain knowlege that I won't actually use it :)
But it took me a loooong time to reach that conclusion :D
-
@Micky d said:
Well I guess I'm guilty of that too :DI think that sometimes a tool simply is too nice to use :). When I started out using knives and tools, I was just as confused/horrified as you are at them not being used as there manufactures intended, but now I can see room for both and can quite happily buy something in the sure and certain knowlege that I won't actually use it :)
But it took me a loooong time to reach that conclusion :D
Perhaps I'll understand when I am older. A LOT older. :P :D
-
That you will my very young apprentice :D
-
I have many queens but I do understand your point Ben. SAKs are the the only thing I've collected in my adult life. I guess I got here by accident and the whole act of collecting I still find strange.
I suppose the argument is similar to the collection of art, it has no practical purpose so why own it. I find SAKs to be nice objects in and of themselves. This probably explains why I'm drawn to fancier "pretty" SAKs. :)
Yes I could just enjoy looking at photos but these are very tactile objects and I think they really do need to be held. Along those lines sometimes I will buy a knife and six months down the line sell it, it was nice to appreciate it for a bit, have a play but I don't always feel the need to hang on to every SAK I get.
Perhaps at the end of the day I collect because I'm a bit nuts, I can live with that :D
Neil
-
Sound reasons to me mate :)
-
@NKB said:
...I'm a bit nuts, I can live with that :DNeil
Now I can understand that. :D
The way I see it though, art is what it is - art, and therefore has been "created" to be looked at and displayed. Therefore collecting art is only really doing what it was intended to do. Doing this with SAK's is going against everything they were intended to do IMO.
I suppose I can understand retiring oldies (although that isn't for me) and I can even understand having a spare back-up tool or SAK. But buying something which is new just to never use it and leave it BNIB? Unless it's for investment purposes, I just don't get that.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login