EPIC FAIL
-
@Aloha007 said:
I know society has got to try but let treat the illness not the just the symptoms.Don't worry, they'll fix themselves. I just hope I'm out of this life by the time they smash everything up. I'm just really hoping there is intelligent life on other planets, and when I reincarnate, I can change stars. See ya, Earthworms!
-
Very very sad to me, and very misguided. The implication is that if you are carrying a weapon (or tool that could be used as a weapon), then you must be a criminal, and therefore a coward.
What about those who carry tools for non-weapon purposes?
What about those who carry weapons for law-abiding purposes?Instead of vilifying a symptom (weapons and potential weapons), how about if we instead chose to teach moral principles and respect for law? I'd rather be in a crowd of law-abiding folks with weapons, than in a room of unarmed criminals!
I truly feel sorrow for those that have lost family members to violent crime. Too often though, the emotions of the victim and family are used as justification to pass unwise and foolish legislation on the rest of society, in a misguided attempt to solve the root problems.
-
:ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh

-
I know a lot of points have been made about how this is a specific program that's trying to prevent kids using common items as weapons for various reasons, and that is all true.
But this group's name is Only Cowards Carry. So forget about screwdrivers and hammers, forget broken bottles or bricks...
The people this group are attempting to shame by parading that name/statement around include, but are not limited to all law enforcement agents, all soldiers, me, my deceased grandpa, quite a few people on this forum, and billions of other individuals, past and present. It's really easy to sit back and call people cowards when you don't know anything about them as a person or why they do what they do or carry what they carry. Some might, in fact, say it's quite cowardly. Like me, I think it's pathetic and cowardly. I could make all kinds of further statements about this, but I fear it would take a turn that very quickly gets my posts deleted and/or the thread locked, because a lot of it deals with prejudice. So it will have to suffice that I say it isn't cool and I don't care why they're doing it. -
PS. I have lost family members to violence, and this probably makes me even more disgusted by this group hiding behind "oh, it's ok because it's all for the children!" while spewing their prejudiced attempt at shaming people they've never met.
-
@WoodsDuck said:
The people this group are attempting to shame by parading that name/statement around include, but are not limited to all law enforcement agents, all soldiers, me, my deceased grandpa, quite a few people on this forum, and billions of other individuals, past and present.No, that isn't who they are attempting to shame. They are attempting to shame children who carry things as weapons.
I think you're taking it all a bit personally. -
The people this group are attempting to shame by parading that name/statement around include, but are not limited to all law enforcement agents, all soldiers, me, my deceased grandpa, quite a few people on this forum, and billions of other individuals, past and present.
No, that isn't who they are attempting to shame. They are attempting to shame children who carry things as weapons.
I think you're taking it all a bit personally.Oh, that's better then. Shame is a great teaching tool. I hope those cowardly children learn not to be such sniveling, craven reprobates.
-
I think what this and other threads over the past few weeks are coming down to is that there are two camps here.
There is the camp which feels that being vilified by the actions by someone else is wrong, and it's insulting. Being deprived of property by the state, or being made second class citizens, or abused, or otherwise punished because someone else did something bad is morally wrong and any attempt to justify it is intellectually dishonest. It is wrong when the distinction is your income, your religion, your skin color, your gender, your sexual orientation, nationality or choosing to be a tool making, tool using, self sufficient member of a tool making and using species. It is bigotry. And we're sick of it. And we're tired of it. And we're speaking up.
And then there is the faction that thinks we are in the wrong to feel this way.
I don't have an answer for it. But if I wanted to be spit on, I'd wear my NRA hat and go down town into the campus district. Someone (undoubtedly with poor hygiene and a huge trust fund) would happily oblige me if that was my wish. But I feel that this forum is, deep down, is slowly shifting to not longer be a friendly, safe and supporting community for multitool and knife owners. On a global level. Too many people are taking stances that sound like "surrender to the inevitable, we can't win".
That bothers me. That bothers me greatly.
If our ancestors wanted to surrender to the inevitable, we'd still be on the menu.
-
I really think that people are getting all bent out of shape over this and without understanding the context.
Teenage knife crime is constantly in the media here in the UK, but the problem is that it's impossible to get to the facts behind the statistics to truly see where the problems lay, age group, region, type of 'weapon' etc. There is also one bit of information that will never be released, ethnic background.
At the end of January '17 the government published the Quarterly crime Statistics Bulletin which reported that knife crime in England and Wales had increased by 11% on the previous year. The NHS reported an increase of 13% in hospital admissions for knife wounds (very carefully worded to not differentiate between accidental and malicious). The conclusion of the report stated that this was due to an improvement in record keeping and 'an actual rise in knife crime'. In February the MET police commissioner indicated that between 2014 and 2016 the number of children carrying knives in schools rose by almost 50% and the number of offences involving a knife in schools rose by 26%.
In October '16, the Sentencing Council published draft guidelines for stiffer sentences for people carrying knives. Chief Constable Alf Hitchcock, who leads the National Police Chiefs Council task force on knife crime, told the London Evening Standard in early March that the “peak age” for carrying knives is “getting younger”, and is currently between 13 and 17. “You’ve got a group of people probably being influenced by their siblings, by their peer group, and carrying, which is not a good trend,” he said. In Manchester, parents of a 14-year-old were ordered to pay £1,000 to a boy their son stabbed several times outside school. During a month-long amnesty in Surrey, police collected 237 knives, which will be used, along with knives collected by police across the country, in a 27ft sculpture called Knife Angel, which may yet adorn the empty fourth plinth in Trafalgar Square.
When politicians and officials seek to pre-empt public indignation by making statements about wake-up calls and warning lights, it is a sign that something unacceptable is unfolding, which they lack either the will or the ability to address.
“How many more of our children have to die before the government act?” – is both damning and complex. Many more children will die from knife-related violence; indeed, four more have been stabbed to death since she posed it. But it is not because the government and related agencies are not acting. Pretty much every week, somewhere in the country, there is some kind of initiative to tackle “knife crime”’ – an amnesty, a new charity in the name of the fallen, an appeal from police, a mayoral statement.
The trouble is that these efforts seem to have little effect. That might be because efforts to make a positive intervention are dwarfed by all the things the government is doing that are making the situation worse. These deaths occur at a moment when the country has made a conscious decision to defund and under-resource its young. When you slash youth services, underfund child mental health services and make swingeing cuts to education and policing, there will be an effect. The most vulnerable will suffer. Austerity didn’t invent knife crime, but it is certainly contributing to the conditions in which it can thrive.[/quote]
The media did not invent “knife crime” either. But, with considerable help from the politicians, it has certainly shaped – or rather distorted – our understanding of it.
These distortions are, in no small part, made possible by the paucity of accessible facts. National data on the number of children and teens killed by knives in any given year is not publicly available. Contact the Home Office and it will tell you that individual police forces collect that information; for the best available data, it suggests that you try the Office for National Statistics. Contact the ONS and it informs you that all the deaths in England and Wales are collated in the Homicide Index, which is maintained by the Home Office. Send a freedom of information request to the Home Office and it refuses on the grounds that it would “be likely to prejudice the prevention or detection of crime or the apprehension or prosecution of offenders”. It also notes that the release of the names of victims could endanger the safety, or physical or mental health of their families.
So, while knife crime, particularly as it affects young people, has been the subject of national debate for a decade, our awareness of its true scale is limited, our grasp of its trajectory is only approximate, and coverage of it is erratic. In short, as a nation we are conscious that there is something out there known as “knife crime”, but as yet we lack any coherent or enduring national response.
Without accessible official data, or well-informed discussion, our understanding of the problem is cobbled together from a mixture of personal assumptions, media representation and political projection. “Our opinions cover a bigger space, a longer reach of time, a greater number of things, than we can directly observe,” wrote Walter Lippmann in his landmark book Public Opinion. “They have, therefore, to be pieced together out of what others have reported.” But what others report when it comes to knife crime is neither neutral nor consistent.
Edited to add - We now have seen a rapid and alarming rise in 'acid' attacks, something that was a very rare occurrence before this year and was mainly limited to one specific culture and motive. The media are having a field day with it at the moment, simply because here, like every other country in the world, the media have become 'The Media' and stopped doing what they had previously done. Investigate and report the news.
-
The thread title is epic fail.
The epic fail is not one little charity working in one little corner of a small island nation to raise awareness of something in their immediate community, but the attempts of people from a different cultural and legal perspective in other lands to "globalise" this and therefore make it about them somehow. It's not. Not even remotely.
Related fails include legal assumptions based not on the laws of the land where the charity works, but on laws of the overseas commentators. The fails there are too epic for me to waste time on. Hardly any of the legal assumptions in this thread are right from what I can see.
It's so...
... it's almost (but still not quite) laughable. -
@50ft-trad said:
The thread title is epic fail.The epic fail is not one little charity working in one little corner of a small island nation to raise awareness of something in their immediate community, but the attempts of people from a different cultural and legal perspective in other lands to "globalise" this and therefore make it about them somehow. It's not. Not even remotely.
Hear hear.

-
The people this group are attempting to shame by parading that name/statement around include, but are not limited to all law enforcement agents, all soldiers, me, my deceased grandpa, quite a few people on this forum, and billions of other individuals, past and present.
No, that isn't who they are attempting to shame. They are attempting to shame children who carry things as weapons.
I think you're taking it all a bit personally.Agree with that. I think it's very obvious that the campaign is against carrying tools as weapons. The knee jerk reaction of 'they are saying tools are weapons' is far out of proportion to the message IMO. Weapons carry in the UK is illegal full stop. The legitimacy of that can be debated but not the illegal carry of tools as weapons. It is against the law.
I'm not sure I agree with the campaign. I don't think cowardice is the motivation for carrying weapons. Outside of psycho babble. Using bad arguments does not advance a cause, however worthy. I also find the laws against self defence outmoded in a country which blatantly cannot begin to protect its citizens using the police force. I agree with the concept but it has to be backed up with protection for the citizenry. I am worried about the situation (I'm a Brit and the vast majority of my family live there) because I do not see an answer. The 'band aid' type solutions are trying to hide a reality where the underlying problems are probably far beyond repair at this point and only getting worse.
-
IMO there are two reasons why anyone would carry a knife or a gun.
- Neccesity.
- Macho or criminal behaviour.
The second reason is one we should not condone and that's where education and law (enforcement) come in.
Raising awareness is not a bad thing but some methods may be questionable for people with different cultural backgrounds. (And questionable doesn't neccesarily mean wrong).
-
@50ft-trad said:
The thread title is epic fail.The epic fail is not one little charity working in one little corner of a small island nation to raise awareness of something in their immediate community, but the attempts of people from a different cultural and legal perspective in other lands to "globalise" this and therefore make it about them somehow. It's not. Not even remotely.
Related fails include legal assumptions based not on the laws of the land where the charity works, but on laws of the overseas commentators. The fails there are too epic for me to waste time on. Hardly any of the legal assumptions in this thread are right from what I can see.
It's so...
... it's almost (but still not quite) laughable.The problem is that those things tend to spill over the borders of one little corner of a small island. I wouldn't exactly call Britain small, but that is a landmass vs cultural significance debate. And regardless of the Brexit, Britain is a big player in the EU.
Since you're keen on hitting that cultural perspective, tell me is there a legitimate reason a teen could carry a tool in Essex?
As far as legality goes - criminals don't adhere to laws anyway so either that point is moot or we're just starring at a very huge can of worms.
-
@50ft-trad said:
The thread title is epic fail.
The epic fail is not one little charity working in one little corner of a small island nation to raise awareness of something in their immediate community, but the attempts of people from a different cultural and legal perspective in other lands to "globalise" this and therefore make it about them somehow. It's not. Not even remotely.
Related fails include legal assumptions based not on the laws of the land where the charity works, but on laws of the overseas commentators. The fails there are too epic for me to waste time on. Hardly any of the legal assumptions in this thread are right from what I can see.
It's so...
... it's almost (but still not quite) laughable.The problem is that those things tend to spill over the borders of one little corner of a small island. I wouldn't exactly call Britain small, but that is a landmass vs cultural significance debate. And regardless of the Brexit, Britain is a big player in the EU.
**
Since you're keen on hitting that cultural perspective, tell me is there a legitimate reason a teen could carry a tool in Essex?**As far as legality goes - criminals don't adhere to laws anyway so either that point is moot or we're just starring at a very huge can of worms.
Of course. A teen just like any other person in the UK is allowed to carry whatever they need to carry out their daily lives. It's only the act of carrying for the purposes of causing harm that they are trying to change, not carrying of household items under any circumstances whatsoever. If the teen in question is on his way to fix his Gran's garden gate, no problem.
-
@50ft-trad said:
@50ft-trad said:
The thread title is epic fail.
The epic fail is not one little charity working in one little corner of a small island nation to raise awareness of something in their immediate community, but the attempts of people from a different cultural and legal perspective in other lands to "globalise" this and therefore make it about them somehow. It's not. Not even remotely.
Related fails include legal assumptions based not on the laws of the land where the charity works, but on laws of the overseas commentators. The fails there are too epic for me to waste time on. Hardly any of the legal assumptions in this thread are right from what I can see.
It's so...
... it's almost (but still not quite) laughable.The problem is that those things tend to spill over the borders of one little corner of a small island. I wouldn't exactly call Britain small, but that is a landmass vs cultural significance debate. And regardless of the Brexit, Britain is a big player in the EU.
**
Since you're keen on hitting that cultural perspective, tell me is there a legitimate reason a teen could carry a tool in Essex?**As far as legality goes - criminals don't adhere to laws anyway so either that point is moot or we're just starring at a very huge can of worms.
Of course. A teen just like any other person in the UK is allowed to carry whatever they need to carry out their daily lives. It's only the act of carrying for the purposes of causing harm that they are trying to change, not carrying of household items under any circumstances whatsoever. If the teen in question is on his way to fix his Gran's garden gate, no problem.
And if said teen wants to EDC a tool?
Thats a similar situation to the one I find myself in here in the ROI. There is no provision for carrying a multi for daily EDC purposes under the law here, and I doubt that "Its my daily EDC" would fly as a "reasonable excuse". :-
But I'm going off topic now....
-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@50ft-trad said:
@50ft-trad said:
The thread title is epic fail.
The epic fail is not one little charity working in one little corner of a small island nation to raise awareness of something in their immediate community, but the attempts of people from a different cultural and legal perspective in other lands to "globalise" this and therefore make it about them somehow. It's not. Not even remotely.
Related fails include legal assumptions based not on the laws of the land where the charity works, but on laws of the overseas commentators. The fails there are too epic for me to waste time on. Hardly any of the legal assumptions in this thread are right from what I can see.
It's so...
... it's almost (but still not quite) laughable.The problem is that those things tend to spill over the borders of one little corner of a small island. I wouldn't exactly call Britain small, but that is a landmass vs cultural significance debate. And regardless of the Brexit, Britain is a big player in the EU.
**
Since you're keen on hitting that cultural perspective, tell me is there a legitimate reason a teen could carry a tool in Essex?**As far as legality goes - criminals don't adhere to laws anyway so either that point is moot or we're just starring at a very huge can of worms.
Of course. A teen just like any other person in the UK is allowed to carry whatever they need to carry out their daily lives. It's only the act of carrying for the purposes of causing harm that they are trying to change, not carrying of household items under any circumstances whatsoever. If the teen in question is on his way to fix his Gran's garden gate, no problem.
And if said teen wants to EDC a tool?
Thats a similar situation to the one I find myself in here in the ROI. There is no provision for carrying a multi for daily EDC purposes under the law here, and I doubt that "Its my daily EDC" would fly as a "reasonable excuse". :-
But I'm going off topic now....
The object only becomes a problem under certain conditions. I do not believe that age alone is enough to trigger legal intervention. The officer in question would have to be able to demonstrate in a court of law that said item was being carried for nefarious purposes. A teen with a LM Juice in his pocket or a Vic Classic on his keys is not automatically up to no good (unless being carried in a blade free environment such as schools, airports etc). Questions may be asked, but for legal intervention there has to be cause to believe that the individual intends to use it to break a law. This is purely my interpretation, and ultimately it would be a charge officer's/magistrate's/jury's interpretation of the situation that matters.
Again this is not what they are trying to change. They are trying to stop youths carrying items as weapons, not to stop them engaging in productive activities.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

