EPIC FAIL
-
@50ft-trad said:
The thread title is epic fail.The epic fail is not one little charity working in one little corner of a small island nation to raise awareness of something in their immediate community, but the attempts of people from a different cultural and legal perspective in other lands to "globalise" this and therefore make it about them somehow. It's not. Not even remotely.
Related fails include legal assumptions based not on the laws of the land where the charity works, but on laws of the overseas commentators. The fails there are too epic for me to waste time on. Hardly any of the legal assumptions in this thread are right from what I can see.
It's so...
... it's almost (but still not quite) laughable.The problem is that those things tend to spill over the borders of one little corner of a small island. I wouldn't exactly call Britain small, but that is a landmass vs cultural significance debate. And regardless of the Brexit, Britain is a big player in the EU.
Since you're keen on hitting that cultural perspective, tell me is there a legitimate reason a teen could carry a tool in Essex?
As far as legality goes - criminals don't adhere to laws anyway so either that point is moot or we're just starring at a very huge can of worms.
-
@50ft-trad said:
The thread title is epic fail.
The epic fail is not one little charity working in one little corner of a small island nation to raise awareness of something in their immediate community, but the attempts of people from a different cultural and legal perspective in other lands to "globalise" this and therefore make it about them somehow. It's not. Not even remotely.
Related fails include legal assumptions based not on the laws of the land where the charity works, but on laws of the overseas commentators. The fails there are too epic for me to waste time on. Hardly any of the legal assumptions in this thread are right from what I can see.
It's so...
... it's almost (but still not quite) laughable.The problem is that those things tend to spill over the borders of one little corner of a small island. I wouldn't exactly call Britain small, but that is a landmass vs cultural significance debate. And regardless of the Brexit, Britain is a big player in the EU.
**
Since you're keen on hitting that cultural perspective, tell me is there a legitimate reason a teen could carry a tool in Essex?**As far as legality goes - criminals don't adhere to laws anyway so either that point is moot or we're just starring at a very huge can of worms.
Of course. A teen just like any other person in the UK is allowed to carry whatever they need to carry out their daily lives. It's only the act of carrying for the purposes of causing harm that they are trying to change, not carrying of household items under any circumstances whatsoever. If the teen in question is on his way to fix his Gran's garden gate, no problem.
-
@50ft-trad said:
@50ft-trad said:
The thread title is epic fail.
The epic fail is not one little charity working in one little corner of a small island nation to raise awareness of something in their immediate community, but the attempts of people from a different cultural and legal perspective in other lands to "globalise" this and therefore make it about them somehow. It's not. Not even remotely.
Related fails include legal assumptions based not on the laws of the land where the charity works, but on laws of the overseas commentators. The fails there are too epic for me to waste time on. Hardly any of the legal assumptions in this thread are right from what I can see.
It's so...
... it's almost (but still not quite) laughable.The problem is that those things tend to spill over the borders of one little corner of a small island. I wouldn't exactly call Britain small, but that is a landmass vs cultural significance debate. And regardless of the Brexit, Britain is a big player in the EU.
**
Since you're keen on hitting that cultural perspective, tell me is there a legitimate reason a teen could carry a tool in Essex?**As far as legality goes - criminals don't adhere to laws anyway so either that point is moot or we're just starring at a very huge can of worms.
Of course. A teen just like any other person in the UK is allowed to carry whatever they need to carry out their daily lives. It's only the act of carrying for the purposes of causing harm that they are trying to change, not carrying of household items under any circumstances whatsoever. If the teen in question is on his way to fix his Gran's garden gate, no problem.
And if said teen wants to EDC a tool?
Thats a similar situation to the one I find myself in here in the ROI. There is no provision for carrying a multi for daily EDC purposes under the law here, and I doubt that "Its my daily EDC" would fly as a "reasonable excuse". :-
But I'm going off topic now....
-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@50ft-trad said:
@50ft-trad said:
The thread title is epic fail.
The epic fail is not one little charity working in one little corner of a small island nation to raise awareness of something in their immediate community, but the attempts of people from a different cultural and legal perspective in other lands to "globalise" this and therefore make it about them somehow. It's not. Not even remotely.
Related fails include legal assumptions based not on the laws of the land where the charity works, but on laws of the overseas commentators. The fails there are too epic for me to waste time on. Hardly any of the legal assumptions in this thread are right from what I can see.
It's so...
... it's almost (but still not quite) laughable.The problem is that those things tend to spill over the borders of one little corner of a small island. I wouldn't exactly call Britain small, but that is a landmass vs cultural significance debate. And regardless of the Brexit, Britain is a big player in the EU.
**
Since you're keen on hitting that cultural perspective, tell me is there a legitimate reason a teen could carry a tool in Essex?**As far as legality goes - criminals don't adhere to laws anyway so either that point is moot or we're just starring at a very huge can of worms.
Of course. A teen just like any other person in the UK is allowed to carry whatever they need to carry out their daily lives. It's only the act of carrying for the purposes of causing harm that they are trying to change, not carrying of household items under any circumstances whatsoever. If the teen in question is on his way to fix his Gran's garden gate, no problem.
And if said teen wants to EDC a tool?
Thats a similar situation to the one I find myself in here in the ROI. There is no provision for carrying a multi for daily EDC purposes under the law here, and I doubt that "Its my daily EDC" would fly as a "reasonable excuse". :-
But I'm going off topic now....
The object only becomes a problem under certain conditions. I do not believe that age alone is enough to trigger legal intervention. The officer in question would have to be able to demonstrate in a court of law that said item was being carried for nefarious purposes. A teen with a LM Juice in his pocket or a Vic Classic on his keys is not automatically up to no good (unless being carried in a blade free environment such as schools, airports etc). Questions may be asked, but for legal intervention there has to be cause to believe that the individual intends to use it to break a law. This is purely my interpretation, and ultimately it would be a charge officer's/magistrate's/jury's interpretation of the situation that matters.
Again this is not what they are trying to change. They are trying to stop youths carrying items as weapons, not to stop them engaging in productive activities.
-
To be fair our local law says that umbrellas can be considered dangerous weapons in crowded places like public gatherings, concerts, etc.
Most here agree on the point that they want to accomplish - stop youths carrying items as weapons. But they are going by vilifying the items because of the actions, not the actions regardless of items used.
I oddly took the time to look into some practices that are pretty much standard in Europe and if personal experience is any gauge then I can pinpoint why the campaign is the way it is. In developing such projects, experts (very loose term for any smurf willing to lose way too much time) have to cerate a cause effect relationship. Often it is done in a tree form, but my suspicion is that it is just one visual approach to a general way of doing it. Now the cause is the hilariously dumb problem because of a cutoff point that has to be imposed.
The cutoff point serves because the root of every problem is deeper and usually comes down to local laws, economy and similar things that organizations can't influence. And that is when it comes to the zealotic prerogative of one individual -
@50ft-trad said:
The thread title is epic fail.The epic fail is not one little charity working in one little corner of a small island nation to raise awareness of something in their immediate community, but the attempts of people from a different cultural and legal perspective in other lands to "globalise" this and therefore make it about them somehow. It's not. Not even remotely.
Related fails include legal assumptions based not on the laws of the land where the charity works, but on laws of the overseas commentators. The fails there are too epic for me to waste time on. Hardly any of the legal assumptions in this thread are right from what I can see.
It's so...
... it's almost (but still not quite) laughable.I didn't personally say anything about laws, so I have to assume that bit isn't directed at me. However the bolded bit seems to be, and I have to take issue with the assertion that because something takes place in another country, or is being done by a relatively small group, that makes it none of my business. Since I'm an American I should just shut up about anything that happens anywhere else in the world, because my cultural background prohibits me from understanding it? That's a really ignorant idea, and I'm disappointed to see this kind of close-mindedness on MTo.
I have no problems with the people of the United Kingdom, whether I agree with all the laws in place there or relate to every facet of the culture, or not. In fact, the harshest sentiment I've ever even posted about knife restrictions specifically can be summed up as "hey, that's a bummer." Not because I think my culture is superior, or my laws are more just. But because I assume that everyone posting on this forum is a tool/knife enthusiast of some description, and find it to be kind of a downer that some of my fellow hobbyists have stricter laws to contend with, which may hinder their enjoyment of said hobby.When people from other nations comment on United States politics or anything else, my response isn't "look at that foreigner trying to butt in on my glorious nation's culture, he should mind his own business." I try to understand his point of view, and consider how his specific background (which may include nationality, ethnicity, religion, etc, etc) might color his perspective, and attempt to have a civil discourse wherein we might compare and contrast our viewpoints and gain a greater understanding of one another.
But when it comes to the issue of an organization that chooses to basically slander all who carry weapons with even the naming of their group, I don't care where they are or what they're doing. Whatever good intentions there are behind it, they're leading with an insulting generalization that is a textbook example of demonizing the opposition. I'm not going to take the stance that says "oh, these guys are a small group from another nation, so they're allowed to defame me and billions of others."
What is it about the size and location of both the nation and organization that should inspire me to give them a free pass? I'm not calling for them to be dismantled or their ideas silenced, I am just expressing my opinion on their chosen tactic.I've tried to make this post as clear as I can, and get my points across, though I sometimes struggle to capture exactly what I want to say in text. I'm not a good writer by any stretch. I know a lot of people, including some on this forum, like to argue points. I generally prefer to discuss them. This case is especially silly since, if they had named the group almost anything else, I wouldn't have even bothered to comment. But they did, and so I have responded to it in the only way I feel it should be responded to.
-
Im a biggest coward :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
-
Come on guys let's cool down on this one a bit
It seems to be drifting toward political and we don't want that ;)It all started with a pic that the majority of us had no clue about and went from there
So let's agree to disagree and move on 
-
-
I have to object to the only cowards carry tools line. They should rephrase that. Boyscouts are cowards? I'm in the always be prepared camp as is my son and wife.
A sharpened stick is equally dangerous ad a screwdriver so let's drop the naming of objects more used as tools then weapons and think of a better slogan.
It needs to target the youth violence itself not the method as to how it's carried out or nothing is going to be solved. Why do they want to attack each other? Do they need more positive things to do with their time? Probably but I don't know.
Kids should want to be like macgyver still even though it's not the 80s.
-
We don't have to agree. We also don't have to like our own law or anyones else laws. I enjoy a good discussion but as of late it gets too personal. Come on guys, on both side chill the F out.
That being said, I along with others were just reacting to the picture of the Cookie Monster with the slogan without any context as to political, social, cultural, regional or otherwise.
I had no clue nor did I look up what the reason for the picture was as I believe others didn't or wouldn't do. I didnt care where it was targeted as it could have been here in the city I live and my reaction would be the same. I never took the time to look up why this picture created. My reaction is based solely on the picture and text.
Having clearly stated the picture with slogan was directed at a specific area then it all made sense. While I still stand by my reaction to the picture and text only, I understand better and am sad this is needed anywhere.
Guys, its really simple. I understand as do most of you that this familys grief was channeled in a way they felt was right. Hell I can fully respect that and I know many of you can. Whether we agree on how they went about their LOGO is really where I and others I believe were taking issue. We dont have to agree but as with the other thread we shouldnt take jabs, from either side. Clearly we have some passionate folks and passionate about their homelands.
Thank you all for posting I do appreciate it. I read thru every post with a clear perspective.
Guys please stop bickering back an forth about anything remotely political. This is never going to go well and we all know that. At that same time lets not get to sensitive that we cannot have a feisty debate about things. I do really enjoy when we can have a lively conversation but a fair one.
-
Whose turn is it to buy a round?

-
double post
-
I'm a little confused as to the extent that the charities' and my comments seem to have been taken out of context.
If a small charity was set up in another country (with a legal system I am not familiar with) for issues local and specific to them, I wouldn't relate them to UK law and then get upset about them. Even if I didn't understand them and asked genuine questions about them, if someone tried to explain them from a local perspective , I'd try to understand it purely from their perspective and leave it at that. I don't see why people should get upset and take personal offence at something that doesn't affect them or isn't aimed at them in any way. To claim it's libelous ... seriously? Who to? Based on whose laws?
This is a logo that folks didn't initially understand. Fair enough, out of context it can look very perplexing and potentially inflammatory if that was used elsewhere. I ***completely ***understand that. So, I've looked into it and tried to share some context and clarity as to what it's actually about, and who it's actually aimed at etc. People have then asked specific questions about the way a teen in the UK would be judged at the scene, and I've tried to answer those too.
This is not a cause I am championing or anything I am affiliated to in any way.
However, taking offence when a slogan, name, logo or any other aspect is taken outside of the context and locality and placed into another environment or judged from a completely different perspective from where it was intended and used is simply ridiculous. There is absolutely nothing to be achieved there aside from feeding persecutory delusions, and justifying personal crusades... but that's only possible if you misinterpret what is actually happening with this charity/logo. In it's original setting and context, and without reading other stuff into it that isn't actually there, there is nothing whatsoever for a wider audience to get upset about. You have to intentionally remove it from it's original context and measure it against things that don't apply here for it to be inflammatory.
If someone wants more clarity on something, and if I can answer the question, I'm happy to assist where I can - but I'm not interested in some out of context pissing contest when it is judged against standards from a different system, or viewed from a totally different perspective to which it actually relates. That's just nonsense. That is why I facepalmed.
-
-
I'll buy.

Meet at The Stone Pony in Asbury Park, NJ?
If in a hurry, tonight at The Saint in Asbury Park. :D -
I'll meet you there, I just need to get Concord back into service in less than 3 hours.
-
Mine's a Guinness.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
