Folding Knives for EDC
-
I seem to recall having read the Okapi was based in a portuguese knife. The mechanism is partly like the lock in the Caneças. Not sure if it was in fact so. I'll try to find out more.

-
@50ft-trad said:
I believe that the Sodbuster is originally a German design. I also have a feeling that the majority of US traditional knives were originally British patterns?
I don't know if the American companies copied the designs that we were already selling them, or if our patterns were influenced by the fact that we were selling heavily into the American market .... or a mixture of both.
There doesn't seem to be a complete mirroring either. Lambsfoot blades and Wharncliffe's seem to be less popular in the States, and such as the Congress seems less popular over here. There seems to be less traditional double-ended penknives (aka sleeveboard) about these days too. My grandfather always carried penknives rather than the larger "farmers knives" that he would consider many traditional slippies to be.Do you mean your grandfather carried something like these Hartkopf knives?

-
Not sure if mentioned? Lockback hunting style knife





-
@Ronald Schröder said:
@50ft-trad said:
I believe that the Sodbuster is originally a German design. I also have a feeling that the majority of US traditional knives were originally British patterns?
I don't know if the American companies copied the designs that we were already selling them, or if our patterns were influenced by the fact that we were selling heavily into the American market .... or a mixture of both.
There doesn't seem to be a complete mirroring either. Lambsfoot blades and Wharncliffe's seem to be less popular in the States, and such as the Congress seems less popular over here. There seems to be less traditional double-ended penknives (aka sleeveboard) about these days too. My grandfather always carried penknives rather than the larger "farmers knives" that he would consider many traditional slippies to be.Do you mean your grandfather carried something like these Hartkopf knives?
Like the top one, yes

-
The Sodbuster, or something I can't discern from a Sodbuster is often called Hippekniep in German and Mineur in French. I think such a basic pattern could easily flow very quickly between Sheffield-Solingen-Thiers making tracking the history somewhat challenging. I've seen it presented as a traditional American pattern on US sites, a traditional French pattern in French stores, and the Germans lay claim to it as well. I suspect they are all correct.
-
@50ft-trad said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
@50ft-trad said:
I believe that the Sodbuster is originally a German design. I also have a feeling that the majority of US traditional knives were originally British patterns?
I don't know if the American companies copied the designs that we were already selling them, or if our patterns were influenced by the fact that we were selling heavily into the American market .... or a mixture of both.
There doesn't seem to be a complete mirroring either. Lambsfoot blades and Wharncliffe's seem to be less popular in the States, and such as the Congress seems less popular over here. There seems to be less traditional double-ended penknives (aka sleeveboard) about these days too. My grandfather always carried penknives rather than the larger "farmers knives" that he would consider many traditional slippies to be.Do you mean your grandfather carried something like these Hartkopf knives?
Like the top one, yes

First time I heard the name sleeveboard. 8)
-
The Sodbuster must be coming from the German Hippekniep
https://www.windmuehlenme...ekniep-small-walnut-wood/
-
A current French Sodbuster

-

There are many variations, like this Papagayo. I find them all appealing.
And a Robert Klaas Mule (Solingen)

The Antonini Lupo

-
I like the looks of that one too. But I went to a shop to see it in real life and found it had a lot of blade play. I asked the salesperson if he had some more, he did, but they were all equally bad. (These were the plastic handle versions)
-
Updated list
In bold the ones I would like to have (with exclamation point the ones I already have).
Nontron, Joker, Antonini and other European makers make some old style knives. Some are far than the early "penny" knives, costing more than 60 euros today.
I guess that all originals are Eurasian designs and were radiated across the world with colonialism and the expanse of western civilisation.
That happened before. The Kukri is similar to the Macedonian Machaira (machaira means knife and it is the same in modern Greek), perhaps a heritage of the Hellenistic expansion to India. America and Oceania were in the stone or chalcolithic age when Sheffield, Thiers, Solingen and Gifu thrived.1. Bursa Arnavut Çakısı (Turkey- Albania)
2. Lierenaar Farmers Knife (Belgium)
3. Manly Knife (Bulgaria)
4. Mikov Fish Knive (Czechia)
5. Opinel Yatagan (France)!
6. (Forge de) Laguiole (France)
7. Douk-Douk (France)!
8. Merkator K55K (Germany)!
9. Szankovits (Hungary)
10. Maskara (Hungary)
11. Stilleto (Italy)
12. Resolza Pattada (Sardinia)
13. MAM Corta e Pica (Portugal)
14. Caneças (Portugal)
15. (Joker) Navaja (Spain)
16. Swiss Army Knives family (Switzerland)!
17. Sheffield knife (England)
18. Higonogami (Japan)
19. Nontron knife (France)
20. Scarperia knives (Italy)
21. Vendetta Corsa (France)
22. Sodbuster (US), Hippekniep, (Germany), Couteau de Pays Terroir (France)
23. SVORD Peasant (NZ)
24. Okapi (Germany, South Africa)!
25. Trattenbacher Zauckerl (Austria)
26. Traditional Slipjoints (Sheffield, US)
26. Buck 110 lockback hunter (US) -
@Ronald Schröder said:
I like the looks of that one too. But I went to a shop to see it in real life and found it had a lot of blade play. I asked the salesperson if he had some more, he did, but they were all equally bad. (These were the plastic handle versions)They are supposed to be primitive!
But the Mercator, the Okapi, the Douk-Douk and the Opinels are all sturdy designs.
-
@Ronald Schröder said:
I like the looks of that one too. But I went to a shop to see it in real life and found it had a lot of blade play. I asked the salesperson if he had some more, he did, but they were all equally bad. (These were the plastic handle versions)
They are supposed to be primitive!
But the Mercator, the Okapi, the Douk-Douk and the Opinels are all sturdy designs.
Primitive, yes, but made in modern factories. The Klaas, Herder, and Windmill knives, I heard, are great.
-
Herder made Sodbuster too! Indeed, it's not an American design it seems.

-
My other Sodbuster has a Homeco tang stamp. It's a labeled Herder probably, for Homeij, a Dutch knife importer and wholesale.

-
I also have a few Sodbusters by Böker with plastic handles and back lock. But it's too dark for pics now.
-
Quite a lot of cutlery companies named Herder over the years... The name literally means "[steel] hardener", just like a lot of blacksmiths were named Smith. ;)
I have (or have had) knives from both Klaas, Otter, and Windmühlenmesser. As with the other old Solingen companies I would recommend inspecting the knife before buying. I ended up giving away my Windmühlenmesser Sodbuster as the blade play was too annoying. Klaas is the one I've had least problems with. (Though the knives in question are hardly a statistically significant sample, just my personal experience.)
-
I always thought the Barlow design originated in Sheffield but later became heavily adopted in the US?
-
Few knives are sold here, most are the big firms', Victorinox, Opinel, Buck, Gerber etc. I have to buy from abroad. But I can start from an Old Bear I saw downtown. I don't know if they have other Antoninis.
-
@Smashie said:
I always thought the Barlow design originated in Sheffield but later became heavily adopted in the US?According to Laurence A. Johnson (1) the Barlow knife was probably first manufactured by Obadiah Barlow at Sheffield, England, around 1670. (2) Obadiah’s grandson, John Barlow, joined the business around 1745 and it was he who was chiefly responsible for developing the exportation of the Barlow knives to America. Another source says the barlow knife was also made by Luke Furnace of Stannington, which in the eighteenth century was a small village on the outskirts of Sheffield. Luke Furnace’s name occurs in the Sheffield directories from 1774 and 1787, but not in the 1797 directory, so he was presumably dead by then. He put the mark “1760” on his knives. The original Barlow, after whom the knives are named, was working in Sheffield at the same time as Luke Furnace.An 1823 directory of Sheffield, England cutlers (knife makers) shows Samuel Barlow on Neepsend (Street). In the Sheffield suburb of Stannington, Barlow Bros. is listed as a cutler.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
