UK Legal Carry Thread!
-
@jzmtl said:
Heh, those prohibited weapon sounds like Canada's, you know those ninja stars are really leathal!Can you guys carry opinel with lock ring popped off?
There's also the smaller opinels that have no lock, I think No.5 and below. Any 58mm, 74mm, 84mm, 91mm, 93mm Vic. is OK. Technically the 108mm is legal as well but as its over 76mm with the tang its probably not wise. Obviously the larger 111mm Vics. are a no no. Most of the 85mm and smaller Wengers are OK but any with the padloc system are a no go.
What about plier based MTs? The LM Juice range are OK but what about others? I'm always slightly concerned about tools like the Mini or the PT-510 as whilst there is no lock on the blade once the blade is out and the tool closed back up the blade can't be folded back into the handle, how would this be viewed?

Neil
-
Heh, those prohibited weapon sounds like Canada's, you know those ninja stars are really leathal!
Can you guys carry opinel with lock ring popped off?
There's also the smaller opinels that have no lock, I think No.5 and below. Any 58mm, 74mm, 84mm, 91mm, 93mm Vic. is OK. Technically the 108mm is legal as well but as its over 76mm with the tang its probably not wise. Obviously the larger 111mm Vics. are a no no. Most of the 85mm and smaller Wengers are OK but any with the padloc system are a no go.
What about plier based MTs? The LM Juice range are OK but what about others? I'm always slightly concerned about tools like the Mini or the PT-510 as whilst there is no lock on the blade once the blade is out and the tool closed back up the blade can't be folded back into the handle, how would this be viewed?

Neil
I think strictly speaking those aren't legal either, however, I am sure I have seen discussions where that is just regarded as being a little OTT.
Also, strictly speaking, saw's that lock and/or are over 3" and aren't legal EDC either. Again though I think that is being a bit OTT.
I'd be interested in hearing Flash's take on it though. :)
(Juice's added)
-
Also, strictly speaking, saw's aren't legal EDC either. Again though I think that is being a bit OTT.
I would imagine saws come into the sharp and or pointy category, so if under 76mm and non-locking would still be OK.
Neil
Sorry I meant that, so will edit my post above to avoid confusion.
-
eeeeeeeeeeer OK well um this is where the "Black and white" of the judicious system gets a little "grey"
Officer discretion applies here as well as this summary (written by someone else):
The Act specifies a number of reasonable excuses for having custody of a knife. This does not limit any other reasonable excuse that a person might have although self defence or defence of another person is not a reasonable excuse for having custody of a knife.
Under the Act it is a reasonable excuse for a person to have custody of a knife, if the custody is reasonably necessary in all circumstances for any of the following:-o lawful pursuit of the person's occupation o preparation or consumption of food or drink o participation in a lawful entertainment, recreation or sport o exhibition of knives for retail or other trade purposes o organised exhibition by knife collectors o wearing of an official uniform o genuine relgious purposes or during travel to or from or incidental to any of these activitiesSo its a strange one with regards to the Locking MT's...To not tempt fate why not stick with a juice or a Pocket Power thingy.

-
But what about the fact that when closed (say on a PST) the blade can't close as it will hit the other handle?
-
So where can I buy a lightsabre...
Benner....would the PP be viewed as a form of frame lock? I honestly don't know and reckon it would take a stated case at a court to decide it.
As a mod why don't you sacrifice yourself for the greater good

-
@Flash said:
So where can I buy a lightsabre...Benner....would the PP be viewed as a form of frame lock? I honestly don't know and reckon it would take a stated case at a court to decide it.
As a mod why don't you sacrifice yourself for the greater good

Although I love this place, I don't love it that much. :D
I'm torn now whether to add the PST for example to the list now. :-\ I can't say I would ever be worried about carrying one.
-
Gerber Shortcut - http://www.gerbergear.com/index.php/product/id/89 and Gerber Clutch - http://www.gerbergear.com/index.php/product/id/97 added as I am safe with those. :D
-
Given the present climate perhaps it would be wise to keep the list to those we know to be legal rather than think are. Then again, given the reaction of people to any size or shape of blade we could just give up now and just presume they'll be grief if we dare to use a Classic in a public place :-\
It might also be an idea to mention that vehicles are also considered public spaces and that all bets are off as to what you can or can't carry on the public transport system :ahhh
Isn't the law so much fun :P :P
Neil
-
@NKB said:
Given the present climate perhaps it would be wise to keep the list to those we know to be legal rather than think are. Then again, given the reaction of people to any size or shape of blade we could just give up now and just presume they'll be grief if we dare to use a Classic in a public place :-\It might also be an idea to mention that vehicles are also considered public spaces and that all bets are off as to what you can or can't carry on the public transport system :ahhh
Isn't the law so much fun :P :P
Neil
I think you are right, this list should be definites only.

The Knifeless Fuse http://leatherman.com/multi-tools/full-size-tools/knifeless-fuse.aspx is a safe one as it has no saw or knife.
-
@Benner said:
...
The Knifeless Fuse http://leatherman.com/multi-tools/full-size-tools/knifeless-fuse.aspx is a safe one as it has no saw or knife.Does have a few pointy bits though :P
Neil
-
...
The Knifeless Fuse http://leatherman.com/multi-tools/full-size-tools/knifeless-fuse.aspx is a safe one as it has no saw or knife.Does have a few pointy bits though :P
Neil
Very true that.
I wonder what would happen if I waved around a blade of grass a bit too vigourously? :D
-
...
The Knifeless Fuse http://leatherman.com/multi-tools/full-size-tools/knifeless-fuse.aspx is a safe one as it has no saw or knife.Does have a few pointy bits though :P
Neil
Very true that.
I wonder what would happen if I waved around a blade of grass a bit too vigourously? :D
Are you maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaad? :ahhh
Didn't you ever blow a grass reed at school and get cut :'(
-
You'd be carted off for sure but not for breaking the law ;)

Neil
-
Good work so far fella's

-
One of my personel favourite that I just can't justify owning coz of the price :o Falkniven U1 http://fallkniven.com/u1/us-u1.htm :)
-
Are they <u>that much</u> more than a UKPK? Not really, now go buy one so I can play with it ;)
"The blade is instead held in place with an springsteel key, a technique which has been in use for more than 100 years and which <u>ensures</u> that the blade does not fold." They seem very confident of that ::)
Anyone own one of these?
Neil
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login