The HOOK brings you back
-
Funny stuff
:DLink to the automatic pants buttoner please?
-
I see what you're saying ThundahBeagle, and I understand, despite being a hook lover.

Question, what would you put in the place of the hook?
Don't say awl, fine screwdriver, etc, because Victorinox seems to like pairing tools. So the Awl goes on the Can/Bottle opener layer, the hook on the scissors layer, etc. And I don't see them changing that anytime soon.

Is the hook so bad that you would rather have no tool in that location, instead of the hook? We ran a poll a while back I think, and I got the impression that lots of people would rather have no tool on the scissors layer than have the hook, which I thought was kinda weird.

Because it takes up no space and doesn't compromise the integrity of the SAK.
Oh, and some trivia. The hook was introduced in 1991, so it came along a bit late for carrying parcels wrapped in brown paper and string.

-
You know what, I've changed my mind. The hook is useless...

-
Ya its only a use for the hook, IF you cant tackle the problem with any other standard SAK tool like an opener and blade. I think its ideal for a parcel carrier and if I ever get a twine bound parcel Im set! Most other uses I see could also be solved with the can opener or blade or a finger or tweezers or whatever.
As for what else shoudl be there? On a compact model the awl should be there. On a standard model some type of bit driver or holder.
-
@Syph007 said:
Ya its only a use for the hook, IF you cant tackle the problem with any other standard SAK tool like an opener and blade. I think its ideal for a parcel carrier and if I ever get a twine bound parcel Im set! Most other uses I see could also be solved with the can opener or blade or a finger or tweezers or whatever.As for what else shoudl be there? On a compact model the awl should be there. On a standard model some type of bit driver or holder.
There is the obvious penholder. Have you looked through the other pages of this thread?
the other obvious application is just picking up anything you don't want your skin to touch. The rounded edges make it very ideal for stretching out guitar strings and spare my fingers from being pinched.
I do use it a lot for the toaster oven in the oven at work as there is not a potholder handy and it's faster to grab A knife out of my pocket, then it is to find something to protect my fingers.
It would be pretty useful for getting through a Barbed wire fence as well, I would imagine.
-
@El Corkscrew said:
Ya its only a use for the hook, IF you cant tackle the problem with any other standard SAK tool like an opener and blade. I think its ideal for a parcel carrier and if I ever get a twine bound parcel Im set! Most other uses I see could also be solved with the can opener or blade or a finger or tweezers or whatever.
As for what else shoudl be there? On a compact model the awl should be there. On a standard model some type of bit driver or holder.
There is the obvious penholder. Have you looked through the other pages of this thread?
the other obvious application is just picking up anything you don't want your skin to touch. The rounded edges make it very ideal for stretching out guitar strings and spare my fingers from being pinched.
I do use it a lot for the toaster oven in the oven at work as there is not a potholder handy and it's faster to grab A knife out of my pocket, then it is to find something to protect my fingers.
It would be pretty useful for getting through a Barbed wire fence as well, I would imagine.
Ah ya I have tried the penholder idea and that works. But I can also hold it with my fingers fine. I use the can opener as a puller type tool the same way people use the hook, and I find it more convenient to deploy. I didnt watch that whole video but i suspect its a very many less that 79 things the hook can do that another tool cant.
Ive had people pay me extra to use an old style spring just so they didnt have the hook there. Some people loathe it! lol. Im not that extreme it doesnt bother me to have it there, I just dont use it.
-
@Syph007 said:
Ive had people pay me extra to use an old style spring just so they didnt have the hook there.
Do you still have dozen of hooks and matching springs in a box?If I ever tear apart my bladeless Woodsman again, I'd change the scissors spring to the new style and add the hook. An added fish scaler is an option too.

But that would be months in the future, so nevermind that for now.An idea, maybe you could arrange with Grant to sell a few extra tools and springs in the MTO store?

But theres probably obstacles preventing that, so, just a mad idea then. -
@Pablo O'Brien said:
I see what you're saying ThundahBeagle, and I understand, despite being a hook lover.
Question, what would you put in the place of the hook?
Is the hook so bad that you would rather have no tool in that location, instead of the hook? We ran a poll a while back I think, and I got the impression that lots of people would rather have no tool on the scissors layer than have the hook, which I thought was kinda weird.

While i don't hate the hook and find it useful for certain things, i don't think it's essential by far, so i wouldn't miss it much if it was not there.
As far as aesthetics go, i have to say i like the look of the plain scissors spring flush with the liners better, especially on 3 layers being on the middle layer. To me it just looks good, don't ask me why...

I absolutely love the look of the small climber with that middle spring flush


P.S.: LeaF i borrowed your pic, i hope you don't mind

-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
Ive had people pay me extra to use an old style spring just so they didnt have the hook there.

Do you still have dozen of hooks and matching springs in a box?If I ever tear apart my bladeless Woodsman again, I'd change the scissors spring to the new style and add the hook. An added fish scaler is an option too.

But that would be months in the future, so nevermind that for now.An idea, maybe you could arrange with Grant to sell a few extra tools and springs in the MTO store?

But theres probably obstacles preventing that, so, just a mad idea then.When I used to add scissors to alox mods I bought hundreds of climbers just to take the scissors from so I still have all those backsprings and hooks in a box doing nothing.
-
disregard this post
-
I don't have a hook yet or a saw on a SAK, really want one now.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@Syph007 said:
When I used to add scissors to alox mods I bought hundreds of climbers just to take the scissors from so I still have all those backsprings and hooks in a box doing nothing.Wow Robert, I'd be careful there. The last thing we'd want is for all those hooks to start reproducing...this world doesn't need more SAK Hooks!

-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
I see what you're saying ThundahBeagle, and I understand, despite being a hook lover.
Question, what would you put in the place of the hook?
Don't say awl, fine screwdriver, etc, because Victorinox seems to like pairing tools. So the Awl goes on the Can/Bottle opener layer, the hook on the scissors layer, etc. And I don't see them changing that anytime soon.

Is the hook so bad that you would rather have no tool in that location, instead of the hook? We ran a poll a while back I think, and I got the impression that lots of people would rather have no tool on the scissors layer than have the hook, which I thought was kinda weird.

Because it takes up no space and doesn't compromise the integrity of the SAK.
Oh, and some trivia. The hook was introduced in 1991, so it came along a bit late for carrying parcels wrapped in brown paper and string.

Hi Pablo,
I would rather it had been left well enough alone. No tool necessary there. Just nice clean flat back spring.
Yes, the hook was introduced in 1991 as a parcel carrier. That is what is insane about it. When in 1991 did anyone think that then, or in the future,packages would be bound in twine, and that it was mission critical that SAK s assist in carrying them.
The hook may not take up much space, but it does bulge out a bit - more than the awl or Philips- and ruins the lines of the tool. But my biggest gripe is...how did a corporate committee decide that humanity could not do without a tool that has no specific purpose. And they would have had to vote that in, design it, cost it out and alter the production process to do add it. That takes a lot of time effort and expense to add a tool that has no specific purpose assigned to it.
-
When I used to add scissors to alox mods I bought hundreds of climbers just to take the scissors from so I still have all those backsprings and hooks in a box doing nothing.
Wow Robert, I'd be careful there. The last thing we'd want is for all those hooks to start reproducing...this world doesn't need more SAK Hooks!

I think that it does need more hooks!
:DI'd like to see a SAK with lots of hooks, in the same vein as this one.

</post/970096> -
@Pablo O'Brien said:
Wow Robert, I'd be careful there. The last thing we'd want is for all those hooks to start reproducing...this world doesn't need more SAK Hooks!

I think that it does need more hooks!
:DI'd like to see a SAK with lots of hooks, in the same vein as this one.

</post/970096>I guess that would be a task for some idle hands with absolutely nothing better to do...right?
Or how about giving them to a school trying to raise money so the kids can make Christmas ornaments? Better yet, how about to a jewelry designer who can make dangly earrings to sell at Vx distributors? See, Pablo, there can be a use for hooks with no life.

-
.

-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
When I used to add scissors to alox mods I bought hundreds of climbers just to take the scissors from so I still have all those backsprings and hooks in a box doing nothing.
Wow Robert, I'd be careful there. The last thing we'd want is for all those hooks to start reproducing...this world doesn't need more SAK Hooks!

I think that it does need more hooks!
:DI'd like to see a SAK with lots of hooks, in the same vein as this one.

</post/970096>LOL ok challenge accepted. I'll make a SAK with as many hooks as I can. LOL
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login