Signal owner's club
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
Here's where I stand on the Signal ...When I first saw it I liked the looks of it, but thought my Wave/Charge or Spirit could kick its *ss when it came to functionality.
Then this topic appeared, and more and more MTO'ers started buying and using the Signal for EDC.
Then there was a giveaway last month where you could win a Signal, and this got me thinking about the Signal again.
After I didn't win the giveaway Signal ( :'() I checked the local outdoorstore and noticed that the Signal had gone down in price (still more expensive than in the U.S., but at least it's about the same price as a Wave now ::)).
So I started looking at youtube reviews of the Signal (again ::)), searched this place and found this topic (again ::)), looked at the pics here (yes Zoidberg, your pics ...
).And ...
Now I want a Signal
.So once again I've been "tricked" into buying a tool thanks to a giveaway here and/or pics of a fellow MTO member, same thing happened to me with the Leatherman OHT, and with the Charge AL (after seeing daily Charge pics for a month during the Midlman Challenge) and probably a couple of other tools I don't recall at the moment ...
What can I say, "the flesh is weak" I suppose ...
Hey buddy.....

[emoji48]Proud SAKMC member :)
-
Mine has the file ;)

Proud SAKMC member :)
-
Glad to see the Signal has surprised many
It still remains one of my favorites.Proud SAKMC member :)
-
Ka-blam!



-
Nice one RP
I am still trying to find one on the cheap
:D -
Me too Poncho!!
-
Me too, guys [emoji23]
-
I would love to see a Signal Vs MUT comparison...
-

Any thoughts?

-
Great comparison pics
Thanks for that Pete

-
My ticket to this club

-
Congrats Chrono
I just bought that same REI Signal for my best friend for Christmas. My girl keeps looking at it asking me if I'm sure I wouldn't rather keep it and give him something else. So far I'm holding fast
-
I can see there is a lot of reversal taking place - opinions now compared to prior to the Signal' s release. And I would tend to take more to heart reviews and comments made after handling the tool. Some folks who previously balled at the design may now have one and like it.
However, we can like something while not exactly using it for the intended purpose. Like an old cardbodrd box zip tied to the grill of an 18-wheeler in the winter...it definitely serves a purpose, but it sure isn't the one intended when designed.
Or more like a store bought frozen Boston Creme Pie. Pretty tasty dessert but as a Boston Creme Pie, it actually sucks.
I don't own one nor have I so much as committed frottage with a Signal outside of the package, so maybe I'm all wet...
But I look at what and who this was geared towards, and scratch my head at so many design choices.
- it should be stainless or otherwise brightly colored. You will need to find it, if you need it. Maybe even use a highly polished surface as a...signal...
- whistle should be integral to one of the handles and made of SS. Never lose it.
- Ferro rod should screw in somewhere or be secured by cable lanyard. Again, never lose it.
- replace loose bit with dedicated driver. So. You. Don't...lose...it.
- sharpening file should also screw into its storage. See the end of #'s 2, 3, & 4.
- 420 HC is fine. Harder steel is harder to sharpen. But a spill over rocks with the knife blade open will do in even a much "nicer" blade. Besides, a better blade steel would up the price, and this is already...
- over priced.
-8- hex tools (3 of them) seem to serve little purpose other than cheaply bumping up the tool count, just to try and justify this thing and its price, try to make it seem close to SURGE in tool count.
There. I said it.
But if I get one for Christmas I sure wouldn't complain...
-
Good points TB.

-
The only point I would agree with is number 7, it is overpriced.
-
I agree this tool is overpriced. I got the standard one before, and sold it. I do not like the plastic pieces. I think it offers less for money, compared to the reliable Wave.
But... don't the dark green and the topo paint jobs look cool? My price point for a new Signal is about $60. I need to be extremely lucky to get that. And I don't want to pay $110 + tax that REI want. Then came eBay with one at $85. I just had to do it. :P Now only if I could score a TTC Damascus blade for cheap
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
