leatherman vs. the rest...
-
@Micky d said:
I think the thing that puts me off plastic the most is that it's somewhere for moisture to collect and turn to rust (regardless of the manufacturer!) :-\I too prefer a multitool to be made from all-metal.
That being said however, why is it that Leatherman is thought poorly of for using plastic in non-load-bearing areas, but Victorinox and Wenger are not criticized for having plastic scales on their SAK's? What is the difference? ???
-
That being said however, why is it that Leatherman is thought poorly of for using plastic in non-load-bearing areas, but Victorinox and Wenger are not criticized for having plastic scales on their SAK's? What is the difference? Huh
Wow, that is so true! :o
-
@Micky d said:
I think the thing that puts me off plastic the most is that it's somewhere for moisture to collect and turn to rust (regardless of the manufacturer!) :-\
I too prefer a multitool to be made from all-metal.
That being said however, why is it that Leatherman is thought poorly of for using plastic in non-load-bearing areas, but Victorinox and Wenger are not criticized for having plastic scales on their SAK's? What is the difference? ???
Double standard. BTW are alox scales scratch resistant or are they like Squirt scales?
-
They are extremely durable. Plus, the LM plastic is zytel which is basically impervious to the elements...
-
I used to have a MAC-11 and it had clips made of zytel and they were pieces of crap.
-
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zytel
Apparently not all Zytel formulations are the same. Calling a nylon Zytel is kinda like saying that a metal is steel.
It looks like SOG and Gerber use Zytel as well (according to Wikipedia anyway).
G.
-
@J-sews said:
That being said however, why is it that Leatherman is thought poorly of for using plastic in non-load-bearing areas, but Victorinox and Wenger are not criticized for having plastic scales on their SAK's? What is the difference? ???It's not that I mind LM using plastic - I just really dislike the design of those specific zytel handles. I think people would have complained just as much if the Spirit or SwissTool had the exact same inserts.
To be fair, I have gotten used to the zytel handles. Now, it's just when I am feeling "nitpicky" that they bug me... :ahhh :D
-
@Micky d said:
I think the thing that puts me off plastic the most is that it's somewhere for moisture to collect and turn to rust (regardless of the manufacturer!) :-\
I too prefer a multitool to be made from all-metal.
That being said however, why is it that Leatherman is thought poorly of for using plastic in non-load-bearing areas, but Victorinox and Wenger are not criticized for having plastic scales on their SAK's? What is the difference? ???
I actually prefere Alox tbh :)
Plus the scales have been around since the year dot, and carry additional tool as well, so there's no prejudice against them as they've always been there in one form or other :)
-
@american lockpicker said:
@Micky d said:
I used to have one of those, it's now residing with Banner :)
It is in my car as we speak. :)
So Benner what do you think of it? I have one and the only thing I don't like is the handles a bit short.
It does seem a bit short, but I like the compactness because of it.
I am yet to actually use it as it is really just a tool I keep in the car in case of emergencies, but I like the build quality of it. I think it would work well when needed.
-
That being said however, why is it that Leatherman is thought poorly of for using plastic in non-load-bearing areas, but Victorinox and Wenger are not criticized for having plastic scales on their SAK's? What is the difference? Huh
Wow, that is so true! :o
I've asked this question before, the subject normally gets changed quite quickly after..... :P
-
That being said however, why is it that Leatherman is thought poorly of for using plastic in non-load-bearing areas, but Victorinox and Wenger are not criticized for having plastic scales on their SAK's? What is the difference? Huh
Wow, that is so true! :o
I've asked this question before, the subject normally gets changed quite quickly after..... :P
:D
-
Maybe it's because just about everyone has encountered a SAK that's been beat to pieces with busted scales but still functioning, while the plastic inserts in the LM models is internal and so doesn't break easily. When you never encounter a broken one, you never really realize how much breakage affects function?
What we need to do is get one of the modders to pull apart a Fuse and replace the plastic inserts with g-10 or micarta! :D
Def
-
That being said however, why is it that Leatherman is thought poorly of for using plastic in non-load-bearing areas, but Victorinox and Wenger are not criticized for having plastic scales on their SAK's? What is the difference? Huh
Wow, that is so true! :o
I've asked this question before, the subject normally gets changed quite quickly after..... :P
I believe I did answer :P
:D
-
I have damaged a metal leatherman and sog. but I have never had any problems with the zytel on a leatherman. I don't belive it is an issue. considering I have abused and damaged a wave and powerlock it shows I am rough on tools but the zytel on the leatherman is either as tough as steel or located so it is not an issue. I have the core on me at work today and it is as reliable as any other tool.
-
I've never owned a Vic MT so I can't comment on those at all.
The Leatherman tools I've owned have all been solid. The one exception to this is when the wave first came out and the tools didn't lock. I was PO'd big time when I opened the package. I lost the tool a year later while fishing and was not unhappy in the slightlest. I guess this isn't a quality knock so much as a WTF were they thinking in the design phase knock.
The only SOG I have is a Powerlock. To be honest I only purchased it because of the brown sheath it came with. Overall the tool is nice, with the pliers being the best of any MT I've used. The inner handle tools were horrid, they seemed too thin and flimsy to inspire confidence. Also the locking system was a pain to use. I would have to fiddle with the other tools to get the one I wanted to lock. I'm guessing the new Piano Locking System would fix this, but it doesn't help my SOG work better. The brown leather sheath however is GREAT and my SuperTool likes riding in it.
I've owned two Gerber 600's. All have random broken tools on them. I did like the removable grit saws though - cool idea.
-
I has very similar thoughts over the Original Wave. I am glad that the Wave wasn't my first LM buy.
-
I haven't found another multi tool yet that just feels as right to me as a leatherman.
Was given a SOG by an ex colleague, black oxide one, unsure of model, and I've had a a swisstool, a sheffield and countless Gerbers, but I just, for whatever reason, like the way leatherman feel in use.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



