The HOOK brings you back
-
[quote author=Pablo O'Brien link=topic=71139.msg1534601#msg1534601 date=1502289639]
I see what you're saying ThundahBeagle, and I understand, despite being a hook lover.
Question, what would you put in the place of the hook?
Don't say awl, fine screwdriver, etc, because Victorinox seems to like pairing tools. So the Awl goes on the Can/Bottle opener layer, the hook on the scissors layer, etc. And I don't see them changing that anytime soon.

Is the hook so bad that you would rather have no tool in that location, instead of the hook? We ran a poll a while back I think, and I got the impression that lots of people would rather have no tool on the scissors layer than have the hook, which I thought was kinda weird.

Because it takes up no space and doesn't compromise the integrity of the SAK.
Oh, and some trivia. The hook was introduced in 1991, so it came along a bit late for carrying parcels wrapped in brown paper and string.

Hi Pablo,
I would rather it had been left well enough alone. No tool necessary there. Just nice clean flat back spring.
Yes, the hook was introduced in 1991 as a parcel carrier. That is what is insane about it. When in 1991 did anyone think that then, or in the future,packages would be bound in twine, and that it was mission critical that SAK s assist in carrying them.
The hook may not take up much space, but it does bulge out a bit - more than the awl or Philips- and ruins the lines of the tool. But my biggest gripe is...how did a corporate committee decide that humanity could not do without a tool that has no specific purpose. And they would have had to vote that in, design it, cost it out and alter the production process to do add it. That takes a lot of time effort and expense to add a tool that has no specific purpose assigned to it.
Actually, please allow me to amend this statement. While I would have liked for them to leave this hook out of it and have a nice clean backstrap, I also would not mind seeing the awl moved to the center of the back, with a Philips AND a corkscrew, one on either side of the awl. If there had to be three tools down there, I think that would have been a better layout with much more use.
Humm...
while it would be more usable, it would also require to have a cut out on the front and on the back of the Sak, and that would ruin the look of the Sak...

At least for me it would... :-\Mac, do you feel that the corkscrew/Phillips side of the SAK is unsightly? While the other side is elegant I it's simplicity, I like the cutout and would be fine with one on each side...wouldnt mind a SAK with 2 blades, 2 openers, saw, and scissors, awl, corkscrew and Phillips. And that's it.
[/quote]Well i guess is just a matter of personal taste here. I love the current look of the 84/91mm sak's and wouldn't change a thing as far as asthetics go. I would however improve on some tools maybe, and definitely bring back the 84mm scissors and expand on the 84mm line. A 84mm golfer with a awl shaped nail file in the back and choice between CS/SD would be great for example, and quite doable, even shape the end of that file to a small SD :D
-
The Spirit has one.

to me that awl/hook is the single most precious and unique implement on the Spirit. I've found 101 uses for it, and it's the best Victorinox hook ever devised, IMO...it locks too!

An awesome tool, no doubt about it.

-
@Mactire404 said:
The Multipurpose Hook, a highly underestimated tool indeed...The hook has a very satisfying element of surprise to it. And it saved my day on more than one occasion.Once I was riding my bike to school, it was exam day! Halfway my chain got derailed and got stuck, really stuck, between the rear gears. It was impossible to budge. I tried sticks, my hands. I was a oily mess and nothing worked. Then I recalled my Handymand an opened the hook. One tug and the chain was free! I quickly replaced it and raced to school. Just shy of 20 minutes late, the deadline for entry.
I wouldn't want to miss the hook!
This has got to be one of the BEST uses of the hook that I've heard so far!
All the stuff the OP mentioned such as tightening small brass hooks or pulling guitar strings I always do with my fingers. But the bike chain. Hey hey! Good idea!@MacGyver said:
<u>Always think outside of the box and keep a loose and open mind</u>I think most people do, actually. How many times have you seen someone use a kitchen knife as a pry bar, screwdriver, an even a hammer?
What's odd to me is how many "unprepared" type people who are quick to abuse a kitchen utensil and would never think to buy a SAK, think of using a knife blade for everything. But the type of people who buy a SAK seem more resourceful and prepared, in general, but we often struggle to think of using a tool for an "off label" use.
I think we're all resourceful under the right conditions. As the saying goes, "Necessity is the mother of Invention". I think our problem is focusing on the labels. I like what another poster said about the hook. (Paraphrasing) It's not a "parcel hook"; it's just a metal hook.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Not to say my position on this issue is softening at all but, I saw an earlier post where a lady uses the hook to tighten corset laces...um...how does one say "no" to THAT? So I decided to give this thing another look.
I saw the bike chain use but that did not peak my interest as much as the bike wheel spoke wrench use. That did get my attention (though still not as much as the corset).
I ride an old Mongoose Hill Topper. Sometimes on trails, sometimes the 18 miles to and from work. I can see the spoke wrench aspect being very helpful, but again, I already carry a Park Tool with spoke wrench and all the necessary Allen wrench sizes, so again, I say that whatever the hook can do, seems to be able to be done by something else. Even the corset. Think outside the box.
-
The Multipurpose Hook, a highly underestimated tool indeed...The hook has a very satisfying element of surprise to it. And it saved my day on more than one occasion.
Once I was riding my bike to school, it was exam day! Halfway my chain got derailed and got stuck, really stuck, between the rear gears. It was impossible to budge. I tried sticks, my hands. I was a oily mess and nothing worked. Then I recalled my Handymand an opened the hook. One tug and the chain was free! I quickly replaced it and raced to school. Just shy of 20 minutes late, the deadline for entry.
I wouldn't want to miss the hook!
This has got to be one of the BEST uses of the hook that I've heard so far!
All the stuff the OP mentioned such as tightening small brass hooks or pulling guitar strings I always do with my fingers. But the bike chain. Hey hey! Good idea!@MacGyver said:
<u>Always think outside of the box and keep a loose and open mind</u>I think most people do, actually. How many times have you seen someone use a kitchen knife as a pry bar, screwdriver, an even a hammer?
What's odd to me is how many "unprepared" type people who are quick to abuse a kitchen utensil and would never think to buy a SAK, think of using a knife blade for everything. But the type of people who buy a SAK seem more resourceful and prepared, in general, but we often struggle to think of using a tool for an "off label" use.
I think we're all resourceful under the right conditions. As the saying goes, "Necessity is the mother of Invention". I think our problem is focusing on the labels. I like what another poster said about the hook. (Paraphrasing) It's not a "parcel hook"; it's just a metal hook.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
One has to know the tool as well. We all know that prying with blade tips is BAD, due to the way they are made, and the the SAK screwdrivers are better for the job.
Think outside the box, like MacGyver, but know the theoretical stuff, such as reasons why it might(will)/might not (will not) work, like MacGyver.
-
@ThundahBeagle said:
..so again, I say that whatever the hook can do, seems to be able to be done by something else...Well that is true. It's also true of every tool on every SAK. The only thing a SAK can do, that some other tool can't do, is look like a real SAK. Your line of reasoning would seem to suggest that you should put your SAK's in storage...or gulp...sell them all and invest in task specific tools.

Let's say you were not out riding and didn't have your bicycling tool kit, but encountered a damsel in distress who need a spoke tightened on her bicycle while wearing a loose corset. Would you render assistance if you could with your trusty SAK and extensive knowledge?
Prepared is prepared. Just sayin'.....

-
..so again, I say that whatever the hook can do, seems to be able to be done by something else...
Well that is true. It's also true of every tool on every SAK. The only thing a SAK can do, that some other tool can't do, is look like a real SAK. Your line of reasoning would seem to suggest that you should put your SAK's in storage...or gulp...sell them all and invest in task specific tools.

Let's say you were not out riding and didn't have your bicycling tool kit, but encountered a damsel in distress who need a spoke tightened on her bicycle while wearing a loose corset. Would you render assistance if you could with your trusty SAK and extensive knowledge?
Prepared is prepared. Just sayin'.....

TWICE if possible!
But seriously...all of the other tools on the SAK have at least one dedicated purpose. Some are even named after that purpose. Screwdriver. Bottle opener. The hook is just such a wide net to cast.
I have a 30 year old Super Tinker with no hook and I love it. Then again, I have a newer Tinker Deluxe with a hook, and I haven't tossed that out as junk
-
@carboncopy101 said:
I use the hook to pull open the zippers of my backpack. When i ride the train or in public im pretty sure that no one would bother trying to open my pack sneakily.So have you removed the zipper pulls for added security and just used your SAK to open them?
If that's the case, I have to say that's a pretty clever idea.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I use the hook to pull open the zippers of my backpack. When i ride the train or in public im pretty sure that no one would bother trying to open my pack sneakily.
So have you removed the zipper pulls for added security and just used your SAK to open them?
If that's the case, I have to say that's a pretty clever idea.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
CARBON COPY... genius in its simplicity. Remove the pull tab from the zipper slider to make it difficult for someone to open your pack...so using the hook on my Deluxe Tinker, I just tested it on my day pack and it works. It won't stop a determined thief who has time, but most people would look at it and move on in favor of an easier "get."
Now back to normal programming: I ALSO tested this using the hook of my bottle cap opener (cap lifter). I placed it inside the eyelet of the slider, and THAT works, too. Actually better because it gets into that little eyelet easier. As does the can opener. And the awl. And the toothpick. The plyers of the Deluxe Tinker and other models can be used to grab the outside surface of the zipper slider and move it that way.
It's clever, but I'm just reinforcing my position that the hook is a superfluous addition to the SAK.
-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
The Multipurpose Hook, a highly underestimated tool indeed...The hook has a very satisfying element of surprise to it. And it saved my day on more than one occasion.
Once I was riding my bike to school, it was exam day! Halfway my chain got derailed and got stuck, really stuck, between the rear gears. It was impossible to budge. I tried sticks, my hands. I was a oily mess and nothing worked. Then I recalled my Handymand an opened the hook. One tug and the chain was free! I quickly replaced it and raced to school. Just shy of 20 minutes late, the deadline for entry.
I wouldn't want to miss the hook!
This has got to be one of the BEST uses of the hook that I've heard so far!
All the stuff the OP mentioned such as tightening small brass hooks or pulling guitar strings I always do with my fingers. But the bike chain. Hey hey! Good idea!@MacGyver said:
<u>Always think outside of the box and keep a loose and open mind</u>I think most people do, actually. How many times have you seen someone use a kitchen knife as a pry bar, screwdriver, an even a hammer?
What's odd to me is how many "unprepared" type people who are quick to abuse a kitchen utensil and would never think to buy a SAK, think of using a knife blade for everything. But the type of people who buy a SAK seem more resourceful and prepared, in general, but we often struggle to think of using a tool for an "off label" use.
I think we're all resourceful under the right conditions. As the saying goes, "Necessity is the mother of Invention". I think our problem is focusing on the labels. I like what another poster said about the hook. (Paraphrasing) It's not a "parcel hook"; it's just a metal hook.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
One has to know the tool as well. We all know that prying with blade tips is BAD, due to the way they are made, and the the SAK screwdrivers are better for the job.
Think outside the box, like MacGyver, but know the theoretical stuff, such as reasons why it might(will)/might not (will not) work, like MacGyver.
Of course, when i say "think outside the box", i'm assuming people are aware of the physical limitations of the tools and what kind of use (or abuse) would damage them in order to stay away from that danger area. I'm also assuming that people (at least Sak and MT lovers) are aware that prying (anything) with any of the blades is an absolute NO-NO


-
..so again, I say that whatever the hook can do, seems to be able to be done by something else...
Well that is true. It's also true of every tool on every SAK. The only thing a SAK can do, that some other tool can't do, is look like a real SAK. Your line of reasoning would seem to suggest that you should put your SAK's in storage...or gulp...sell them all and invest in task specific tools.

Let's say you were not out riding and didn't have your bicycling tool kit, but encountered a damsel in distress who need a spoke tightened on her bicycle while wearing a loose corset. Would you render assistance if you could with your trusty SAK and extensive knowledge?
Prepared is prepared. Just sayin'.....

TWICE if possible!
But seriously...all of the other tools on the SAK have at least one dedicated purpose. Some are even named after that purpose. Screwdriver. Bottle opener. The hook is just such a wide net to cast.
I have a 30 year old Super Tinker with no hook and I love it. Then again, I have a newer Tinker Deluxe with a hook, and I haven't tossed that out as junk
I'm with you, I really do like the pre-hook SuperTinkers! -
I prefer my newer Climber-with-hook to my Pre-hook Climber. I just love that hook.

-
Right on Nix!!!

-
And I'm not sure that I'll ever be totally happy with my bladeless Woodsman until I get new scales, buff up the tools, and oh yeah, add a hook. :-\



The back is looking unsymmetrical without a tool on the opposite side as the corkscrew, and the scissors go on that layer, so the only thing that fits is the hook.
-
Pablo, is it time to change your screen name to "Cap'n Hook"?

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
