EDC Question
-
Seriously though, if the blade is like that, why not just get a Pruner?
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
-
@this_is_nascar said:
Seriously though, if the blade is like that, why not just get a Pruner?Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
It weighs a tiny bit less?
-
Seriously though, if the blade is like that, why not just get a Pruner?
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
It weighs a tiny bit less?
Yeah I was just thinking that too. Also, it would defeat the purpose of what I think I want this knife to be for me.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
-
Seriously though, if the blade is like that, why not just get a Pruner?
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
It weighs a tiny bit less?
Yeah I was just thinking that too. Also, it would defeat the purpose of what I think I want this knife to be for me.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
Less is more. Maybe it's because once you start considering a Pruner it would make sense to have the opener and now you have a Rancher. Oh, and wouldn't a saw be nice? Harvester it is then. Soon enough you'll start coming up with uses for the fish scaler and pharmaceutical spatula.
I carry a Spartan and an Executive. And I'd like to get rid of the Executive if I could only find a solid, nice-looking way to build my own "best of" SwissCard. The bonus with a fixed toolset is that it minimises the often ridiculed tendency for extended fiddling to find any particular tool.
-
Seriously though, if the blade is like that, why not just get a Pruner?
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
It weighs a tiny bit less?
Yeah I was just thinking that too. Also, it would defeat the purpose of what I think I want this knife to be for me.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
Less is more. Maybe it's because once you start considering a Pruner it would make sense to have the opener and now you have a Rancher. Oh, and wouldn't a saw be nice? Harvester it is then. Soon enough you'll start coming up with uses for the fish scaler and pharmaceutical spatula.
I carry a Spartan and an Executive. And I'd like to get rid of the Executive if I could only find a solid, nice-looking way to build my own "best of" SwissCard. The bonus with a fixed toolset is that it minimises the often ridiculed tendency for extended fiddling to find any particular tool.
I love my Executive. I really do. Why have you chosen it to EDC with a Spartan? Why not a Classic or Rambler? Just curious.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
-
[quote author=this_is_nascar link=topic=73612.msg1545575#msg1545575 date=1504043608]
Seriously though, if the blade is like that, why not just get a Pruner?Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
It weighs a tiny bit less?
Yeah I was just thinking that too. Also, it would defeat the purpose of what I think I want this knife to be for me.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
Less is more. Maybe it's because once you start considering a Pruner it would make sense to have the opener and now you have a Rancher. Oh, and wouldn't a saw be nice? Harvester it is then. Soon enough you'll start coming up with uses for the fish scaler and pharmaceutical spatula.
I carry a Spartan and an Executive. And I'd like to get rid of the Executive if I could only find a solid, nice-looking way to build my own "best of" SwissCard. The bonus with a fixed toolset is that it minimises the often ridiculed tendency for extended fiddling to find any particular tool.
I love my Executive. I really do. Why have you chosen it to EDC with a Spartan? Why not a Classic or Rambler? Just curious.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
[/quote]It is basically down to two tools, the small blade and the nail file. I have an older Executive with a double cut file that works even better than the single cut ones. One of the nice things about the nail file on the Executive is that it can be used for other things too. As such I have used it to remove the sharp dents that occurred on the aluminium rim of my phone when I dropped it, among other things.
-
[quote author=GoatDragon link=topic=73612.msg1545580#msg1545580 date=1504044626]
[quote author=this_is_nascar link=topic=73612.msg1545575#msg1545575 date=1504043608]
Seriously though, if the blade is like that, why not just get a Pruner?Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
It weighs a tiny bit less?
Yeah I was just thinking that too. Also, it would defeat the purpose of what I think I want this knife to be for me.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
Less is more. Maybe it's because once you start considering a Pruner it would make sense to have the opener and now you have a Rancher. Oh, and wouldn't a saw be nice? Harvester it is then. Soon enough you'll start coming up with uses for the fish scaler and pharmaceutical spatula.
I carry a Spartan and an Executive. And I'd like to get rid of the Executive if I could only find a solid, nice-looking way to build my own "best of" SwissCard. The bonus with a fixed toolset is that it minimises the often ridiculed tendency for extended fiddling to find any particular tool.
I love my Executive. I really do. Why have you chosen it to EDC with a Spartan? Why not a Classic or Rambler? Just curious.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
[/quote]It is basically down to two tools, the small blade and the nail file. I have an older Executive with a double cut file that works even better than the single cut ones. One of the nice things about the nail file on the Executive is that it can be used for other things too. As such I have used it to remove the sharp dents that occurred on the aluminium rim of my phone when I dropped it, among other things.
[/quote]
Exactly. The file, the larger scissors over the 58mm line and the orange peeler are all reasons it would be tough for me to retire my Executive.Too many choices is the problem.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
-
[quote author=this_is_nascar link=topic=73612.msg1545592#msg1545592 date=1504046068]
[quote author=GoatDragon link=topic=73612.msg1545580#msg1545580 date=1504044626]
[quote author=this_is_nascar link=topic=73612.msg1545575#msg1545575 date=1504043608]
Seriously though, if the blade is like that, why not just get a Pruner?Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
It weighs a tiny bit less?
Yeah I was just thinking that too. Also, it would defeat the purpose of what I think I want this knife to be for me.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
Less is more. Maybe it's because once you start considering a Pruner it would make sense to have the opener and now you have a Rancher. Oh, and wouldn't a saw be nice? Harvester it is then. Soon enough you'll start coming up with uses for the fish scaler and pharmaceutical spatula.
I carry a Spartan and an Executive. And I'd like to get rid of the Executive if I could only find a solid, nice-looking way to build my own "best of" SwissCard. The bonus with a fixed toolset is that it minimises the often ridiculed tendency for extended fiddling to find any particular tool.
I love my Executive. I really do. Why have you chosen it to EDC with a Spartan? Why not a Classic or Rambler? Just curious.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
[/quote]It is basically down to two tools, the small blade and the nail file. I have an older Executive with a double cut file that works even better than the single cut ones. One of the nice things about the nail file on the Executive is that it can be used for other things too. As such I have used it to remove the sharp dents that occurred on the aluminium rim of my phone when I dropped it, among other things.
[/quote]
Exactly. The file, the larger scissors over the 58mm line and the orange peeler are all reasons it would be tough for me to retire my Executive.Too many choices is the problem.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
[/quote]
Sounds like you don't need a classic if you have the executive.So, Manager vs. Executive, ask yourself, do I need a little Philips and a pen? If not, go for executive. 8)
Personally, in this situation, I would carry the Executive modded with the little Philips, and a Fisher bullet.
-
@this_is_nascar said:
Seriously though, if the blade is like that, why not just get a Pruner?Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
Would be my thought. :D
-
Seriously though, if the blade is like that, why not just get a Pruner?
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
Would be my thought. :D
The reason I carry Wenger and Victorinox products is because they address so much more than just being able to cut stuff. Once you remove the files and drivers and scissors and openers and are just talking purely about blades, the product has less of an appeal to me. At that point I start thinking about wood or bone handles, different blade shapes, bolsters, pocket clips, OHO, and suddenly the Swiss offerings are less prominent against the competition. Yes, the blades are still good, and the knives are still well made, but my interest veers towards other knives for the reasons just mentioned.
The one "blade only" Swiss knife I own is a Pioneer Pruner, which was bought as a donor for the pruning blade. I have never been tempted to pocket this if just wanting to add blades to the days carry. I will add a different traditional folder instead. The only reason I would buy a Solo would be as a donor for the spring for putting scissors in another 93mm knife.
As I've mentioned in the past, I don't even tend to carry Swiss knives without scissors. I want scissors in my array, and these guys make the best ones. For me to carry my Tourist, I'd have to carry a pliers tool with bloody good scissors to make up for the lack of scissors on the knife. I won't pair it with another Swiss knife, as that just proves that the Tourist was the wrong knife to pick in the first place. I also like to minimise duplication/redundancy in my tool choices where possible.
Just my £0.02
-
@50ft-trad said:
The reason I carry Wenger and Victorinox products is because they address so much more than just being able to cut stuff. Once you remove the files and drivers and scissors and openers and are just talking purely about blades, the product has less of an appeal to me.I agree with you, 50ft. I have several really nice one blade knives with better steel and handles than a SAK. But a SAK offers so much more in the way of utility, if that SAK has a few features like a driver or scissors. I think the Single blade SAK's are lovely, but then it just makes more sense to carry a 2- or 3-ayer SAK with a couple extra tools.
Still, a Solo is tempting....
-
Thing is, I have a bottle opener on my rambler taking up far less space and also giving me a magnetic phillips screwdriver which can handle anything from tiny screws to ones that I'd use a #2 phillips screwdriver for. I don't open cans on a daily basis or have use for an awl. However much I rethink it, for urban carry I believe my choice of Rambler and Pruner is the combination of useful features and size and retains most of that extra utility if I decide to carry a different knife.
-
Pruner blade doing the dirty work leaving the main blade clean for food use. If the blade is offset anyway on the Solo you might as well add the Pruner blade. At least until the glorious day that they resurrect the Settler. :D

-
Personally I don't see the appeal of a solo. Without any non blade tools the SAK loses it appeal to me. Not saying anything is wrong with a Solo. But there's other single or multiple blade knives I would choose first.
A pioneer, cadet or 2 layer 91mm variation would be my minimum SAK carry as a main knife. Now I suppose if I already had a Solo I may carry it, not often nor woruld I go out of my way to purchase one.
Just my .02 on the matter. -
@4everYoung said:
Personally I don't see the appeal of a solo. Without any non blade tools the SAK loses it appeal to me. Not saying anything is wrong with a Solo. But there's other single or multiple blade knives I would choose first.
A pioneer, cadet or 2 layer 91mm variation would be my minimum SAK carry as a main knife. Now I suppose if I already had a Solo I may carry it, not often nor woruld I go out of my way to purchase one.
Just my .02 on the matter.Like anything else, you have to consider it's intended use. The reason the Solo was even mentioned in this thread is because I said that I had a requirement to carve-up several apples in a daily basis.
For that, a Solo makes perfect sense, since it's a single tooled device making cleanup much easier.
I could carry one of my pocket folders to accomplish this task, but none of them are a lightweight or easy to carry than the Solo.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
-
Personally I don't see the appeal of a solo. Without any non blade tools the SAK loses it appeal to me. Not saying anything is wrong with a Solo. But there's other single or multiple blade knives I would choose first.
A pioneer, cadet or 2 layer 91mm variation would be my minimum SAK carry as a main knife. Now I suppose if I already had a Solo I may carry it, not often nor woruld I go out of my way to purchase one.
Just my .02 on the matter.Like anything else, you have to consider it's intended use. The reason the Solo was even mentioned in this thread is because I said that I had a requirement to carve-up several apples in a daily basis.
For that, a Solo makes perfect sense, since it's a single tooled device making cleanup much easier.
I could carry one of my pocket folders to accomplish this task, but none of them are a lightweight or easy to carry than the Solo.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
I fully understand your point. My point is that when you look at a Solo, it's a folding knife. Nothing more. So compare it to other folding knives. Folders all suck to clean up from juicy fruits.
So if I were looking for a easy clean up folder on the cheap, it would be something like a mini paraframe. It's has a very open design easy to rinse quickly and dry. This why I said the solo doesn't appeal to me.
If I'm going the SAK route with a pioneer for example, your cleaning process is still similar to the solo.Could you carry a small fixed blade for your apple needs? That would be simple to clean.
-
Personally I don't see the appeal of a solo. Without any non blade tools the SAK loses it appeal to me. Not saying anything is wrong with a Solo. But there's other single or multiple blade knives I would choose first.
A pioneer, cadet or 2 layer 91mm variation would be my minimum SAK carry as a main knife. Now I suppose if I already had a Solo I may carry it, not often nor woruld I go out of my way to purchase one.
Just my .02 on the matter.Like anything else, you have to consider it's intended use. The reason the Solo was even mentioned in this thread is because I said that I had a requirement to carve-up several apples in a daily basis.
For that, a Solo makes perfect sense, since it's a single tooled device making cleanup much easier.
I could carry one of my pocket folders to accomplish this task, but none of them are a lightweight or easy to carry than the Solo.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
I fully understand your point. My point is that when you look at a Solo, it's a folding knife. Nothing more. So compare it to other folding knives. Folders all suck to clean up from juicy fruits.
So if I were looking for a easy clean up folder on the cheap, it would be something like a mini paraframe. It's has a very open design easy to rinse quickly and dry. This why I said the solo doesn't appeal to me.
If I'm going the SAK route with a pioneer for example, your cleaning process is still similar to the solo.Could you carry a small fixed blade for your apple needs? That would be simple to clean.
Hadn't really thought about it, but anything is possible.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
-
Personally I don't see the appeal of a solo. Without any non blade tools the SAK loses it appeal to me. Not saying anything is wrong with a Solo. But there's other single or multiple blade knives I would choose first.
A pioneer, cadet or 2 layer 91mm variation would be my minimum SAK carry as a main knife. Now I suppose if I already had a Solo I may carry it, not often nor woruld I go out of my way to purchase one.
Just my .02 on the matter.Like anything else, you have to consider it's intended use. The reason the Solo was even mentioned in this thread is because I said that I had a requirement to carve-up several apples in a daily basis.
For that, a Solo makes perfect sense, since it's a single tooled device making cleanup much easier.
I could carry one of my pocket folders to accomplish this task, but none of them are a lightweight or easy to carry than the Solo.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
I fully understand your point. My point is that when you look at a Solo, it's a folding knife. Nothing more. So compare it to other folding knives. Folders all suck to clean up from juicy fruits.
So if I were looking for a easy clean up folder on the cheap, it would be something like a mini paraframe. It's has a very open design easy to rinse quickly and dry. This why I said the solo doesn't appeal to me.
If I'm going the SAK route with a pioneer for example, your cleaning process is still similar to the solo.Could you carry a small fixed blade for your apple needs? That would be simple to clean.
I carry a dedicated Solo for apples (and other food prep). I have dozens of other pocket knives that could do the job but most of these cost 10 times as much. I won't risk damage or loss of an expensive knife when I have a cheap, but high quality alternative. And the Solo is very easy to clean with a brush and soap, so there's no argument against it there.
BTW Overhere, carrying a fixed blade is a criminal offense. -
I know that I am not on the thread topic per se but this is an EDC question. I don't get the flashlight thing. Why do so many EDC post include a Flashlight. I know I am old, 51 Yrs. I am not out late so I don't need a flashlight in my EDC list but is seems a bit weird to me. Help?
-
@pomsbz said:
Pruner blade doing the dirty work leaving the main blade clean for food use. If the blade is offset anyway on the Solo you might as well add the Pruner blade. At least until the glorious day that they resurrect the Settler. :D
I just love the Pruner Blade. It should be standard issue vs. the can opener.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login