Wool as an outer layer
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
I have several fleeces with holes burnt in the sleeves......That is an issue I have with the modern usage of the word fleece - it can be used for wool, a wool - synthetic blend and a synthetic fabric.
In regards to wool being wet and keeping you warm, easy experiment. Put on something made from wool and see if you feel warmer or colder. Stand in front of an air current (a fan can do the job on a higher setting) and record your findings. Next add water to the clothing and repeat those two steps. Would be a lot easier if one had a thermal camera so subjectivity goes out the window and slowly adds water to simulate different kinds of weather conditions and being exposed to the same (even if caught for 5 minutes in a downpour it should be no big deal)
-
I think that experiment would only confirm what everyone knows: that you will be colder wearing wet wool than dry wool. Shouldn't the comparison be between wet wool, wet other fabrics, and wet bare skin?
If I got saturated I would take off my woolens, wring them out, then put them back on as surely the wind chill would be much less than for wet bare skin.
Fleece: the old meaning is an animals coat of wool; when people use the word these days it seems they are referring to Polar Fleece, a fabric made from polyester. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polar_fleece
-
I think the point is wool can carry quite a lot of moisture without feeling wet, because of the properties mentioned above, so it can lower loss of heat even though it is wet as such. If you have enough water trapped that you get conductive heat loss through it to the outer water layer, you are basically fscked whatever fabric you are wearing. Personally, I find wool as an outer layer pretty ridiculous in a windy and/or wet climate. Yes, wool has to a certain degree been used in these parts as that too, but that was very heavy, often felted, garments, and usually with the original lanolin intact to make it repel water to some degree. That goes for many historical examples in this thread as well, it was smelly garments with the original fat intact, not nice, modern, non-smelly garments which will absorb water much quicker. A layered approach, with wool between the skin and an outer water repelling, wind proof layer, that's the good stuff. :)
Edit: Basically the short version of what 4everYoung posted, with some extra history. :D
-
Very interesting thread gents. My take on it is this; there's wool and then there's wool.
A thick knitted wool jumper/sweater will keep you warm as a mid layer or as long as it's not getting windy or wet, and I'm sorry to say I don't believe that a soaked jumper will be keeping you warm. It might be technically better than some synthetic alternatives, but not enough to make a significant difference.
On the other hand you've also got thick, tightly woven wool coats/jackets that actually aren't so warm (tiny air pockets) but are notably wind resistant and do a very good job of keeping you dry. I've got a old Swedish Army coat and an Merchant Navy greatcoat, both of which I've worn in some terrible weather without any issues. However I'd always want to be able to dry them off overnight and they're both bloody heavy.
I've also got a few wool shirts that tread a middle ground of not being heavy, being more wind resistant than a jumper and still being warm when damp, BUT are bulky to pack and certainly not what I'd consider an outer layer when the weather turns wet and nasty.
I don't think there's a magic answer here, but I do think that it's an option if you don't expect it to be all things to everyone.
-
I have an old Swiss military coat that is made of wool

They are nicknamed "Kaputt", meaning defective :D
Pro- Fairly comfortable even when the sun is burning down
- Fairly rain resistant (unless you are out and about in heavy rain for a prolonged time, you will stay dry)
- Its warm
Con
- heavy when dry, real heavy when wet
- smelly when wet
- does not breath well when wet (it really gets hot in that coat)
Now this is an old wool coat and its still a fairly good choice (especially since I can get one for less than 10$), as I have no experience with modern wool Jackets/Coats I cannot comment on those. But a modern outdoors Jacket will resist rain longer and breath better and given the choice I think modern outdoor jackets outperform a coat like this by a long margin.
-
Damn, forgot to even think about how tightly they are woven.
Well as Syncop8r said, a big test could give us all some clue. So who's in for getting drenched to the bone and standing in the wind for science?
Btw Etherealicer, really less than $10? How the hell didn't I see those shops?
-
These guys do it, I'll take their word.
-
@4everYoung said:
https://youtu.be/i9A2xpJlrJQThese guys do it, I'll take their word.
I'm sorry to say I'm not quite ready to do that. I'm just thinking out loud here so bear with me but; if it's that cold, why isn't the wet clothing freezing? The only answer I can think of (other than it isn't as cold as they are saying it is) is that it's the guy's body doing it and so it has to be taking warmth out of him. I'm concerned that he is feeling warm because of rapid blood flow to the skin and extremities, which isn't what you want at all. Even if that isn't the case then he's still using vital calories to keep that water logged clothing warm and that simply isn't sustainable over any real amount of time.
If I'm looking at this the wrong way please feel free to correct me.

-
These guys do it, I'll take their word.
I'm sorry to say I'm not quite ready to do that. I'm just thinking out loud here so bear with me but; if it's that cold, why isn't the wet clothing freezing? The only answer I can think of (other than it isn't as cold as they are saying it is) is that it's the guy's body doing it and so it has to be taking warmth out of him. I'm concerned that he is feeling warm because of rapid blood flow to the skin and extremities, which isn't what you want at all. Even if that isn't the case then he's still using vital calories to keep that water logged clothing warm and that simply isn't sustainable over any real amount of time.
If I'm looking at this the wrong way please feel free to correct me.

Here is the full video. At the beginning you can see the temperature on the thermometer.
Heat is built up from the body and because whatever type of synthetic material (I believe Aries branded) isn't hydrophilic. So it does not soak up water. There fore it does not lose the air insulating properties. The heat from his body is being trapped between the skin and the insulating layers. Just as it has been doing before they take a dunk. All the materials they are wearing are hydrophobic. So water is running off and draining due to gravity and what he expels from squeezing it. What moisture is left is warmed from the trapped body heat.
That's the short version anyway.
https://youtu.be/6Sx6SJf1hTU -
These guys do it, I'll take their word.
I'm sorry to say I'm not quite ready to do that. I'm just thinking out loud here so bear with me but; if it's that cold, why isn't the wet clothing freezing? The only answer I can think of (other than it isn't as cold as they are saying it is) is that it's the guy's body doing it and so it has to be taking warmth out of him. I'm concerned that he is feeling warm because of rapid blood flow to the skin and extremities, which isn't what you want at all. Even if that isn't the case then he's still using vital calories to keep that water logged clothing warm and that simply isn't sustainable over any real amount of time.
If I'm looking at this the wrong way please feel free to correct me.

Here is the full video. At the beginning you can see the temperature on the thermometer.
Heat is built up from the body and because whatever type of synthetic material (I believe Aries branded) isn't hydrophilic. So it does not soak up water. There fore it does not lose the air insulating properties. The heat from his body is being trapped between the skin and the insulating layers. Just as it has been doing before they take a dunk. All the materials they are wearing are hydrophobic. So water is running off and draining due to gravity and what he expels from squeezing it. What moisture is left is warmed from the trapped body heat.
That's the short version anyway.
https://youtu.be/6Sx6SJf1hTUSo that stuff is much better than wool, because you can dry it off much more easily then wool?

-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
These guys do it, I'll take their word.
I'm sorry to say I'm not quite ready to do that. I'm just thinking out loud here so bear with me but; if it's that cold, why isn't the wet clothing freezing? The only answer I can think of (other than it isn't as cold as they are saying it is) is that it's the guy's body doing it and so it has to be taking warmth out of him. I'm concerned that he is feeling warm because of rapid blood flow to the skin and extremities, which isn't what you want at all. Even if that isn't the case then he's still using vital calories to keep that water logged clothing warm and that simply isn't sustainable over any real amount of time.
If I'm looking at this the wrong way please feel free to correct me.

So that stuff is much better than wool, because you can dry it off much more easily then wool?

In one sense, yes. When comparing this to wool for the same purpose. Which in the case of the video would be taking a plunge into frozen over body of water. The wool would take much longer to recover from the effects of this than does this material. Do to the nature of the insulating fibers.
If you added an wind proof layer over the wool it would significantly increase the effect of the wool to not lose heat thru water convection if soaked. But then if you do that, that kinda defeats the purpose of this thread to begin with as that would make wool a mid layer not an outer layer. -
I so want one of those wool coats made out of a heavy military blanket, but there so freaking expensive..
JR -
These guys do it, I'll take their word.
I'm sorry to say I'm not quite ready to do that. I'm just thinking out loud here so bear with me but; if it's that cold, why isn't the wet clothing freezing? The only answer I can think of (other than it isn't as cold as they are saying it is) is that it's the guy's body doing it and so it has to be taking warmth out of him. I'm concerned that he is feeling warm because of rapid blood flow to the skin and extremities, which isn't what you want at all. Even if that isn't the case then he's still using vital calories to keep that water logged clothing warm and that simply isn't sustainable over any real amount of time.
If I'm looking at this the wrong way please feel free to correct me.

Here is the full video. At the beginning you can see the temperature on the thermometer.
Heat is built up from the body and because whatever type of synthetic material (I believe Aries branded) isn't hydrophilic. So it does not soak up water. There fore it does not lose the air insulating properties. The heat from his body is being trapped between the skin and the insulating layers. Just as it has been doing before they take a dunk. All the materials they are wearing are hydrophobic. So water is running off and draining due to gravity and what he expels from squeezing it. What moisture is left is warmed from the trapped body heat.
That's the short version anyway.
https://youtu.be/6Sx6SJf1hTUAh, so it's the extreme hydrophobic nature of the material that's in effect here, though I can't see what it's actually made of on their site. "water moves away from heat" is a statement I'm a little confused by.
I'm still not 100% convinced that a material that works when wet will also work if it's frozen, so I'd not want to use it in an overnight scenario where you want to stop moving. I'd also be interested in seeing some body thermometers and thermal cameras in use rather than relying on how things "feel" as well. Of course, the fact he doesn't appear to be dying is pretty impressive. :D -
so... no streaking?
-
Wet wool is still better than no wool, let alone cotton
-
@Aleph78 said:
Wet wool is still better than no wool, let alone cottonThis. Water saturates wool, but not to the extent that a cotton garment will. That's part of the whole "wool insulates when wet" lore. Nowadays, synthetics will dry quicker than wool because they absorb less water than wool.
I assume wool's made a resurgence because people got fed up with stinky synthetic base layers, and global trade allowing merino wool from New Zealand to be spread all over the world. Merino wool is unlike most wool of the 90s in that it's a lot finer so it's not as itchy. Icebreaker and Ibex are the larger names in the States selling merino garments.
I wouldn't consider wool to be the miracle fabric for the outdoors. Benefits are that it's more odor resistant (though there's a wet dog smell in my opinion), it doesn't melt near a fire, and DEET also won't melt it. In terms of durability, it really depends on the weave, but I'd argue synthetics are more durable because they won't generally stretch and they're also generally cheaper, so you're not as precious with them.
If you plan on being wet a lot, go with synthetics. The lanolin in wool does help it shed water (you'll see water bead on the surface), but in a downpour, it's still going to soak through.
All this being said, I love my wool socks.
-
@jzmtl said:
It's next to impossible to find any wool clothing in North America now, short of some boutique/outdoor brand (i.e. super expensive). I've tried some wool mid layer for winter sports but gravitated towards primaloft type, wool doesn't have good warmth/weight ratio in comparison. I'm sure it's much more durable though if you crawl in and out of trees all winter long.LL Bean still sells wool sweaters. Though the cheaper option is to just buy an oversized wool sweater from a thrift store if you need a cheap midlayer. But you're right, synthetics have sadly taken over much of textiles. Natural fibers will soon be luxury details in a decade or so.
-
It's next to impossible to find any wool clothing in North America now, short of some boutique/outdoor brand (i.e. super expensive). I've tried some wool mid layer for winter sports but gravitated towards primaloft type, wool doesn't have good warmth/weight ratio in comparison. I'm sure it's much more durable though if you crawl in and out of trees all winter long.
LL Bean still sells wool sweaters. Though the cheaper option is to just buy an oversized wool sweater from a thrift store if you need a cheap midlayer. But you're right, synthetics have sadly taken over much of textiles. Natural fibers will soon be luxury details in a decade or so.
This is exactly where I get my wool garments from.

-
It's next to impossible to find any wool clothing in North America now, short of some boutique/outdoor brand (i.e. super expensive). I've tried some wool mid layer for winter sports but gravitated towards primaloft type, wool doesn't have good warmth/weight ratio in comparison. I'm sure it's much more durable though if you crawl in and out of trees all winter long.
LL Bean still sells wool sweaters. Though the cheaper option is to just buy an oversized wool sweater from a thrift store if you need a cheap midlayer. But you're right, synthetics have sadly taken over much of textiles. Natural fibers will soon be luxury details in a decade or so.
REI is a good source of wool products but their stuff isn't cheap.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login