Any Italians here?
-
I might be flying to Venice on Sunday for a few days, work trip. I know the Italian knife laws are really strict. Would I be ok carrying a SAK Rambler or is even that a potential problem?
Thanks!
No prob! If the cops stop you, just go with "no speako italiano". Then just hand them a couple of €5 and you're golden.
:D :D :D :D
-
-
Italy is part of the Schengen Agreement. Within that area you can even fly with a SAK (at least up to 91mm, I would have to check if the 93 is still legal).
There are of course buildings with restricted access (Opera etc.) and you cannot bring a SAK into the Vatican.
Our residential Italian tells me, that he always carries a SAK and never had a problem. Technically, you need a justification for carrying a SAK but that should be easy enough.So, swiss guards ok, swiss knifes prohibited?!

Smurfing racists!

With a SAK you don't need miracles. If SAK-s were allowed they'd be out of business in no time...
:D -
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@Pablo O'Brien said:
Until an Italian chimes in, how about this?
(Bladeforums) Italian Knife LawsYeah I saw that thanks, didn't seem to answer the question. Talking of which, would a Rambler be ok in Ireland due to the tiny size or is it still problematic? My dream holiday right now is a return to Ireland. I'll leave the exciting adventures for other people, I just want to stay in your wonderfully peaceful and polite country again. :)
Its about justification, you need a reason for a blade. But a SAK (non-OHO, non-locking) that should be easy enough (cutting an apple, fixing your glasses etc.). Adding to this, it is legal to carry the SAK on a plane, so that should be enough. I always recommend to take a knife that can easily be replaced though, just in case.
As for the Rambler in Ireland... I wouldn't wave it around obviously, but it should be fine. I EDC one myself as the biggest knife I feel fine with carrying in public.

But that's for in the town.
In the countryside, it's no matter. :DDo you follow vinniesdayoff on youtube? Really like his videos. So far removed from the bullschmidt chest beating of so many other knife/outdoor channels.
-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
[quote author=Pablo O'Brien link=topic=73799.msg1549611#msg1549611 date=1504705901]
Until an Italian chimes in, how about this?
(Bladeforums) Italian Knife LawsYeah I saw that thanks, didn't seem to answer the question. Talking of which, would a Rambler be ok in Ireland due to the tiny size or is it still problematic? My dream holiday right now is a return to Ireland. I'll leave the exciting adventures for other people, I just want to stay in your wonderfully peaceful and polite country again. :)
Its about justification, you need a reason for a blade. But a SAK (non-OHO, non-locking) that should be easy enough (cutting an apple, fixing your glasses etc.). Adding to this, it is legal to carry the SAK on a plane, so that should be enough. I always recommend to take a knife that can easily be replaced though, just in case.
As for the Rambler in Ireland... I wouldn't wave it around obviously, but it should be fine. I EDC one myself as the biggest knife I feel fine with carrying in public.

But that's for in the town.
In the countryside, it's no matter. :DDo you follow vinniesdayoff on youtube? Really like his videos. So far removed from the bullschmidt chest beating of so many other knife/outdoor channels.
[/quote]
Never heard of him, will check him out.
-
I'm going to Eivissa(aka Ibiza) next month.
Dublin-Ibiza, and back.
Ibiza should be bound by the Schengen Agreement, as it's under Spain's jurisdiction.
Ireland is not part of the agreement. However, this is straight from the official Dublin airport website listing prohibited items on carry on luggage:
This includes knives (with blades over 6cm)Hmm....
Anyone want to send me a classic for science? :D -
@Pablo O'Brien said:
I'm going to Eivissa(aka Ibiza) next month.
Dublin-Ibiza, and back.
Ibiza should be bound by the Schengen Agreement, as it's under Spain's jurisdiction.
Ireland is not part of the agreement. However, this is straight from the official Dublin airport website listing prohibited items on carry on luggage:
This includes knives (with blades over 6cm)Hmm....
Anyone want to send me a classic for science? :DThat's Schengen standard and allows the 91mm
. -
I've never heard of this schengen thing. Don't tell me some airlines have seen sense in an age of fear and power trips?
-
Italian graseball present!

Italian laws about knives don't make much sense in my opinion, but here it goes.
Basically, there are a few types of knives that are banned altogether (switchbalde, double edge knives), as they are considered a "white weapon". Apart from that, you are technically allowed to carry a knife only as long as you have a reasonable motive to do so. You will hear some people talking about blade lenght and telling you that it has to be less than a certain lenght (usually they'll say 4 "fingers") but that's bull.
You are also not allowed to take any knife in a sensible place, like a stadium or a street protest.That is the theory. In practice, even if they technically could, they are not going to bother you for a Swiss Army Knife. I actually asked this to a random cop a few years ago, and he told me that saks are not a problem ("because they have bottle openers and such" he said).
You're also not allowed a sak, nor any other kind of sharp object, on a plane. Which makes sense in this day and age!
-
@shadowrider said:
Italian graseball present!
Italian laws about knives don't make much sense in my opinion, but here it goes.
Basically, there are a few types of knives that are banned altogether (switchbalde, double edge knives), as they are considered a "white weapon". Apart from that, you are technically allowed to carry a knife only as long as you have a reasonable motive to do so. You will hear some people talking about blade lenght and telling you that it has to be less than a certain lenght (usually they'll say 4 "fingers") but that's bull.
You are also not allowed to take any knife in a sensible place, like a stadium or a street protest.That is the theory. In practice, even if they technically could, they are not going to bother you for a Swiss Army Knife. I actually asked this to a random cop a few years ago, and he told me that saks are not a problem ("because they have bottle openers and such" he said).
You're also not allowed a sak, nor any other kind of sharp object, on a plane. Which makes sense in this day and age!
Thanks for the info! Very useful!
-
When I lived in Napoli I carried my Fieldmaster all the time. Used it a lot too and no one minded. Not sure of the law either as well, but I have seen others using old Opinel types also with similar blades.
-
@Etherealicer said:
Italy is part of the Schengen Agreement. Within that area you can even fly with a SAK (at least up to 91mm, I would have to check if the 93 is still legal).There are of course buildings with restricted access (Opera etc.) and you cannot bring a SAK into the Vatican.
Our residential Italian tells me, that he always carries a SAK and never had a problem. Technically, you need a justification for carrying a SAK but that should be easy enough.
I did :-[ Nobody told me I couldn't 
-
@50ft-trad said:
Italy is part of the Schengen Agreement. Within that area you can even fly with a SAK (at least up to 91mm, I would have to check if the 93 is still legal).
There are of course buildings with restricted access (Opera etc.) and you cannot bring a SAK into the Vatican.
Our residential Italian tells me, that he always carries a SAK and never had a problem. Technically, you need a justification for carrying a SAK but that should be easy enough.
I did :-[ Nobody told me I couldn't 


-
@50ft-trad said:
Italy is part of the Schengen Agreement. Within that area you can even fly with a SAK (at least up to 91mm, I would have to check if the 93 is still legal).
There are of course buildings with restricted access (Opera etc.) and you cannot bring a SAK into the Vatican.
Our residential Italian tells me, that he always carries a SAK and never had a problem. Technically, you need a justification for carrying a SAK but that should be easy enough.
I did :-[ Nobody told me I couldn't 
Yeah and neither did they complain about you riding in on a horse... old man.
If they don't check you then you are always good... Problem is that metal detectors get more and more common at entrances.
-
Do NOT NOT NOT try to carry a SAK or any other knife aboard an airplane!
European airline regulations do state that a knife with a maximum blade length of under 6 cm is allowed on board of an airplane, BUT BUT BUT you are NOT allowed to pass Security with anything that resembles a knife, a weapon or even a tool !!
Before entering the plain, or the premises of the airport, security personel will X-ray your baggage and make scans of your body. If they find anything that the Security Officer considers 'unsafe' you have to hand it over and it goes into a large drum with hundreds of other 'dangerous' items. There is no legal right to appeal! It is all in the regulations, at least for Schiphol Intl Airport.
It happened to me twice...
I've seen 15 cm long AK47 toy guns, water pistols and even this 'gun mug' taken from kids hand luggage!As for the Netherlands, all pocket knives, also the OHO and locking knives, are free to carry (except double edged ones). Bali songs and stiletto's are forbidden items, even in your own home.
The problem with pocket knives in the Netherlands is, that in certain cities there are areas where any knife carrying is forbidden! For example in the inner city of Amsterdam.
You can carry a knife, but it has to be packed in such a way that "it can not easily be used". Wrapping in lots of tape will be the answer.
-
@EMZ said:
Do NOT NOT NOT try to carry a SAK or any other knife aboard an airplane!
European airline regulations do state that a knife with a maximum blade length of under 6 cm is allowed on board of an airplane, BUT BUT BUT you are NOT allowed to pass Security with anything that resembles a knife, a weapon or even a tool !!
Before entering the plain, or the premises of the airport, security personel will X-ray your baggage and make scans of your body. If they find anything that the Security Officer considers 'unsafe' you have to hand it over and it goes into a large drum with hundreds of other 'dangerous' items. There is no legal right to appeal! It is all in the regulations, at least for Schiphol Intl Airport.
It happened to me twice...
I've seen 15 cm long AK47 toy guns, water pistols and even this 'gun mug' taken from kids hand luggage!As for the Netherlands, all pocket knives, also the OHO and locking knives, are free to carry (except double edged ones). Bali songs and stiletto's are forbidden items, even in your own home.
The problem with pocket knives in the Netherlands is, that in certain cities there are areas where any knife carrying is forbidden! For example in the inner city of Amsterdam.
You can carry a knife, but it has to be packed in such a way that "it can not easily be used". Wrapping in lots of tape will be the answer.I just love all those security measures and, in some cases, the paranoia and extremes that some airport personnel incurr into and then hear about how you get metal cuttlery and glass bottles/glasses in first class, with your meals.

-
Do NOT NOT NOT try to carry a SAK or any other knife aboard an airplane!
European airline regulations do state that a knife with a maximum blade length of under 6 cm is allowed on board of an airplane, BUT BUT BUT you are NOT allowed to pass Security with anything that resembles a knife, a weapon or even a tool !!
Before entering the plain, or the premises of the airport, security personel will X-ray your baggage and make scans of your body. If they find anything that the Security Officer considers 'unsafe' you have to hand it over and it goes into a large drum with hundreds of other 'dangerous' items. There is no legal right to appeal! It is all in the regulations, at least for Schiphol Intl Airport.
It happened to me twice...
I've seen 15 cm long AK47 toy guns, water pistols and even this 'gun mug' taken from kids hand luggage!As for the Netherlands, all pocket knives, also the OHO and locking knives, are free to carry (except double edged ones). Bali songs and stiletto's are forbidden items, even in your own home.
The problem with pocket knives in the Netherlands is, that in certain cities there are areas where any knife carrying is forbidden! For example in the inner city of Amsterdam.
You can carry a knife, but it has to be packed in such a way that "it can not easily be used". Wrapping in lots of tape will be the answer.I just love all those security measures and, in some cases, the paranoia and extremes that some airport personnel incurr into and then hear about how you get metal cuttlery and glass bottles/glasses in first class, with your meals.

I guess that potential hijackers and problem causing passengers can't afford first class. :P ::)
-
For four years (2008-12) I flew 80 times a year for work, a commute of 5000 miles round trip every week. Well conversant with the nightmare of modern travel. :( I had a bunch of methods for getting through the nonsense as fast as possible. Probably forgotten most of it now or no longer relevant.
-
@50ft-trad said:
Italy is part of the Schengen Agreement. Within that area you can even fly with a SAK (at least up to 91mm, I would have to check if the 93 is still legal).
There are of course buildings with restricted access (Opera etc.) and you cannot bring a SAK into the Vatican.
Our residential Italian tells me, that he always carries a SAK and never had a problem. Technically, you need a justification for carrying a SAK but that should be easy enough.
I did :-[ Nobody told me I couldn't 
Yeah and neither did they complain about you riding in on a horse... old man.
If they don't check you then you are always good... Problem is that metal detectors get more and more common at entrances.
:D
We went in via the museum, then through the Sistine Chapel into the Basillica. I'm pretty sure they had detector gates at the museum entrance, but we were waved through as an organised group which might have been the difference (the security probably didn't want to have to wade through 30 lots of pockets and bags)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
