Spirit challenge
-
Wow. After reading the posts here, my ignorant impression that a Spirit is a heavy duty MT has been shattered. I thought its a superior tool than the bigger SwissTool, which I read in various posts to have a tendency to have a play after heavy use.
-
@an0nemus said:
Wow. After reading the posts here, my ignorant impression that a Spirit is a heavy duty MT has been shattered. I thought its a superior tool than the bigger SwissTool, which I read in various posts to have a tendency to have a play after heavy use.It's superiour in the fact that it keeps up the high standard of the Swisstool in a more pocket-friendly package.
And to be honest, preferences may differ.
As an alarm tech I don't have any heavy duty jobs for my tools, so a Spirit would be more then enough, yet more pocket friendly.The Swisstool is simply a heavy piece of steel that might survive a nuke, while still being nice to watch at.
-
Wow. After reading the posts here, my ignorant impression that a Spirit is a heavy duty MT has been shattered. I thought its a superior tool than the bigger SwissTool, which I read in various posts to have a tendency to have a play after heavy use.
It's superiour in the fact that it keeps up the high standard of the Swisstool in a more pocket-friendly package.
And to be honest, preferences may differ.
As an alarm tech I don't have any heavy duty jobs for my tools, so a Spirit would be more then enough, yet more pocket friendly.The Swisstool is simply a heavy piece of steel that might survive a nuke, while still being nice to watch at.
Looking at them next to each other I don't even see the SwissTool being that much sturdier to be honest. Yes, the plier head is broader but the teeth are the same as is the thickness. As for the tools the SwissTool has a total of 11 fold out implements compared to the Spirits 10 (and I would argue that the job of the crate opener/large flat screwdriver on the SwissTool is picked up by the sturdier cap lifter on the Spirit). The only fold out implement that actually has more material on it is the Philips.
All in all I think that the biggest difference between the two is the size and that the SwissTool might be more suitable for people with large hands. Another possible reason to prefer the SwissTool is if you use the markings to measure stuff or the square properties of the body of the tool.
Keep up the challenge!
-
One slight hiccup I forgot to mention with my photo. The SwissTool I pictured is an older original. The newer SwissTools have significantly larger jaws. The handle frames are much much sturdier on the SwissTool as well.
The Spirit is simply not a heavy duty MT. But, it is one of the best light/medium duty tools out there. And like I said, most users will find the Spirit adequate. Just as some users can accomplish their desired tasks with a 90mm SAK.
Then some of us, particularly in manual labor, will need something designed for heavy duty work. A matter of what someone needs.
-
I must say I
all the Spirit'ed conversation (debate) going on here. When I get a chance I'll do some compairison photos with the Spirit and Swisstools side by side for each individual impliment. That being later, I do want to say that just because I see the Spirit as a medium duty MT, DOSE NOT mean it is not a quality and capable tool, IT DEFINATELY IS on BOTH counts and far more pocket friendly than any of what I consider the Heavy duty MT's. -
Day12
Wow! This is a very spirited debate :D
I like the different takes on the tools
. I can tell you this, the Spirit is continuing to impress me every time I take it out of the sheath
I used the wire cutters today at work, and the blade saved the day as the only cutting tool we had at one of the sites for cutting plastic. I have to agree with you guys in that I wouldn't try to push the pliers beyond their inteded use. I think if you put enough torque on them, they would break too. For HD work, I'd have to leave it to either a full size swisstool, my CD, or my ST300. Here's a pic of the cutters in use today, and thanks again to all of you guys following along with me on this challenge. Only 18 more to go! 

-
Nice! The cutter may be small, but they work very well! I rewired a friend's lamp with my Spirit and the small cutters with the center hard wire notch made for good wire strippers.

-
Thanks buddy!

-
@Spartan19 said:
Thanks buddy!

-
Awesome thread so far... makes me want to do the Swisstool challenge!
-
It seems my comments may have ruffled some feathers :D
I do stick by my comments based on my own previous usage and experience. If your experience and subsequent conclusions are different, that's fine
Many people have found tools more capable than I have, and vice versa. It's good to share these with other people. Suffice to say however, I wouldn't subject most multitools to harder graft than I have subjected the Spirit to. I would go in search of dedicated tools instead. Some may be better at certain tasks than others, and there is no one tool that is universally accepted as "superior", but the Spirit's durability does meet what I personally would expect from a multitool, but not what I would expect from dedicated tools.We all have different levels of expectation though, and different perspectives of what a tool is or should be capable of. For example, I think locking folding knives are a waste of time, and if there's a job I can't do with a slippy, then I need a fixed blade, not one that pretends to be but isn't. Many people disagree with that, and have a significantly higher regard for locking folders. Again, that's fine. There are very few absolutes in terms of right and wrong, the trick is to find what is right and wrong for you. My (nor anyone else's) post count, working background, exposure to and experience with different tools, or tool ownership should be taken as any form of assurance that my conclusions will be the same conclusions that you reach on your own personal journey

Keep up the good work, Spartan

-
@50ft-trad said:
It seems my comments may have ruffled some feathers :DI do stick by my comments based on my own previous usage and experience. If your experience and subsequent conclusions are different, that's fine
Many people have found tools more capable than I have, and vice versa. It's good to share these with other people. Suffice to say however, I wouldn't subject most multitools to harder graft than I have subjected the Spirit to. I would go in search of dedicated tools instead. Some may be better at certain tasks than others, and there is no one tool that is universally accepted as "superior", but the Spirit's durability does meet what I personally would expect from a multitool, but not what I would expect from dedicated tools.We all have different levels of expectation though, and different perspectives of what a tool is or should be capable of. For example, I think locking folding knives are a waste of time, and if there's a job I can't do with a slippy, then I need a fixed blade, not one that pretends to be but isn't. Many people disagree with that, and have a significantly higher regard for locking folders. Again, that's fine. There are very few absolutes in terms of right and wrong, the trick is to find what is right and wrong for you. My (nor anyone else's) post count, working background, exposure to and experience with different tools, or tool ownership should be taken as any form of assurance that my conclusions will be the same conclusions that you reach on your own personal journey

Keep up the good work, Spartan

AGREED AND WELL PUT, MY FRIEND!!!!!!!!

It's all subjective.
Kind'a like and accurate definition of "UP".
-Any thing above eye level and it is all relative depeneing on an individuals height.-

-
I'm late to this thread but have read all of the posts so far...interesting challenge!

-
DAY 13
Thanks guys!
Let's keep this party rollin'! 
-
DAY 14
-
Looking good. Even next to work boots.

-
Caught up again
I haven't been carrying a SAK since I started the Surge challenge and haven't been visiting eh Swiss forum as much as I should be
Plus work has been crazy the last while and no time for anything :ahhhGreat thread you have going here buddy

-
Thatta boy 19er!!!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
